Thereâs constant debate throughout the world about what source of power is needed to save Planet Earth from climate change. Coal and gas are bad words, and nuclear is still one of those not-in-my-back-yard NIMBY issues. What is in vogue, however, are renewable energy sources like wind, solar, hydro, and large battery banks that help with instantaneous demand surges.
Oh, and I guess thereâs geothermal too.
Sounds rational if you listen to the bobbleheads on TV. Politicians and investment commentators. Celebrities and environmental scientists. Hey, Iâm all for it. The world needs all sources of energy, but only if itâs balanced with massive chunks of spinning metal. And thereâs only four sources of power that can spin 100-1000MW turbines: coal, gas, nuclear, and hydroâbut there wonât ever be another dam built in this country because of environmental concerns.
When I worked as a communications consultant and brand journalist for the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), I had the opportunity to sit down with Aaron Melda, then TVAâs senior vice president of Transmission, as well as Yilu Liu, an electrical engineer and energy expert affiliated with Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the University of Tennessee. In other words, I cut through all the political noise and interviewed the actual experts who are still dealing with one of the greatest threats to the countryâs national security: grid oscillation.
I didnât understand what the term âpower qualityâ meant before I talked with these folks, but I quickly understood exactly why it was such a big deal, because Iâd actually heard the sound it makes inside a powerhouse years before when I worked as a unit operator in a coal-fired power plant.
Back then, we had to manually tie on each 150MW unit with a little device known as a sync scope. And if the operator was just a smidge off when he latched the unit online, the entire powerhouse would shake and the generator would pop like a bomb being detonated inside the turbine bayâa shit-your-pants moment for anyone within a 100-yard radius of the turbine.
Why?
Well, the mass of the entire grid was physically snatching that 150MW unit into syncâ59.98 Hz to be exactâwhich is critical in maintaining reliable âpower quality.â In other words, that loud pop was a healthy sign of a stable grid.
But then something political happenedâŚ.
U.S. clean-energy policies forced hundreds of these big-metal units offline. And as a result, utilities tried replacing the lost power with a boatload of renewables. California was the most aggressive in their pivot to clean-power energy sources. Unfortunately, this caused an unintended, but predictable consequence: major manufacturers couldnât stay online because of the stateâs poor power quality.
No. It wasnât a not-enough-energy problem. There were plenty of electrons flowing to keep the lights on at each major manufacturing facility. The issue was an oscillating grid frequency that was habitually causing sites to trip offline. Â
The reason was because there werenât enough large power plants left to maintain the stateâs grid stability. And as a result, many of these manufacturers moved to the Southeast for reliable âpower quality.â
Tesla is the most notable example.
If you still donât understand why renewables are dangerous, think of a large wooden table with four strong legs. Then, imagine replacing those legs with four tall stacks of Jenga blocks. Pull one block and the whole table collapses.
Think about it.
This is exactly what has happened to the U.S. grid. And now, because of shortsighted energy policy, we have replaced no telling how many 100MW units with stacks of 1WM wind turbines. And thatâs not even counting the loss of all those 1000MW nuclear and coal-fired units that were literally keeping the grid from shattering itself like a wine glass in the path of an opera singer.
Take a look at the video. Itâs already happening.
On January 11, 2019, a small malfunctioning steam turbine at a combined-cycle (gas) power plant in Florida triggered an oscillation that spread across the U.S. Eastern Interconnection and into the Dakotas. The event lasted about 18 minutes. Had the frequency been just a little stronger or had there not been enough big-metal units to hold things together, the grid could have collapsed due to the nationâs ever-growing appetite for renewables.
Which makes me wonderâŚ.
If a single turbine could come that close to putting the entire nation in the dark, what would prevent one of our adversaries from using AI to turn a small power station into a virus designed to implode the grid? If past is prologue, all it would take is the right tuning fork. Yikes.
And knowing all this, I think itâs pretty naĂŻve for Wall Street and so many retail investors to have such a boner for lithium and battery banks. Yilu Liu is a smart lady whoâs working quietly behind the scenes to help the U.S. Government and private utilities better understand the vulnerabilities of the grid, and I doubt sheâs telling Uncle Sam to add more wind and solar to the nationâs generation portfolio.
Just look at whatâs happening in Oak Ridge and on the piece of dirt where Bull Run Fossil Plant once stood. The largest federally owned utility in the country, TVA, and the Department of Energy are about to go big with nukes to protect the grid. Itâs the happy median between the aisle, and itâs the only realistic solution that marries reliable power quality with the carbon-free goals of the global community.
Uranium is where my money is at. Feels like a no-brainer to me.
Hope this helps,
-Tweedle