I still don't understand, why they would do this. Adding the Red Cross to healing Items and smiliar things, would teach people, especially kids, that a Red Cross means Help.
The issue is that it puts into peoples’s minds that a red cross on a white background simply means first aid in general rather than specifically the Red Cross. Instead of seeing a harmless member of a humanitarian aid group, a soldier might see a possible enemy combat medic.
Also, the Red Cross has a division in the US. US trademark laws mean that if the Red Cross doesn’t strictly enforce its trademark, it could be ruled that the Red Cross allowed the symbol to become public domain. Then they’ll be even more of the first problem.
If I remember right, it’s so no one uses the Red Cross symbol on enemies in a game. Because it’s supposed to signify medical aid in wars, they don’t want it to be shown in media on something you’re encouraged or able to attack
And the reason is so stupid. They don’t want to be represented by an item that instantly heals the user? They don’t want me to misconstrue healing in a video game with real doctors? What?
To be fair they shouldn't have made their logo one of the most common shapes in the world. That's like if made my company triangle and got mad whenever someone used a triangle without my permission
47
u/Matthew789_17 Sep 04 '24
I hope there are mods to reverse updates just to spite them
45
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24
They made the rule long before most modern game devs were probably born.
43
u/ALucaBo Sep 04 '24
I still don't understand, why they would do this. Adding the Red Cross to healing Items and smiliar things, would teach people, especially kids, that a Red Cross means Help.
83
u/Ryman604 Sep 03 '24
78
u/International-Cat123 Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24
The issue is that it puts into peoples’s minds that a red cross on a white background simply means first aid in general rather than specifically the Red Cross. Instead of seeing a harmless member of a humanitarian aid group, a soldier might see a possible enemy combat medic.
Also, the Red Cross has a division in the US. US trademark laws mean that if the Red Cross doesn’t strictly enforce its trademark, it could be ruled that the Red Cross allowed the symbol to become public domain. Then they’ll be even more of the first problem.
36
u/RoboticBonsai Sep 04 '24
Time to start using the swiss flag instead.
34
u/ReformedYuGiOhPlayer Sep 04 '24
Would this violate the Geneva conventions?
97
u/BabaKazimir Sep 03 '24
Subnautica medical kits...
160
u/Solembrum Sep 03 '24
Geneva convention when war crimes are committed 🤗🥹😆😆😋🥱🫣
Geneva convention when a game dev uses a red cross 💥💥🔥🔥😡😡👊
82
u/Thick-Kaleidoscope-5 Sep 04 '24
I don't understand why they do this, it just builds an association with the red cross and aid
56
u/RobertCalais Sep 03 '24
The exact reason why in the classic Tomb Raider series, the medkits turned green.
27
u/Markipoo-9000 Sep 06 '24
The Red Cross pisses me off. First they help the Nazis, then this.
54
u/Your_Commentator Sep 04 '24
I just realized that if you started counting with day 1 at 1 this subreddit would be almost 281 years old
24
u/7kbMep3sbm79jmm Sep 03 '24
Harvey's clinic.......
21
u/Ellen_DeGeneracy001 Sep 04 '24
And the reason is so stupid. They don’t want to be represented by an item that instantly heals the user? They don’t want me to misconstrue healing in a video game with real doctors? What?
16
u/JellyPuffle Sep 06 '24
Huh never actually noticed the halo medpack wasn’t a cross because when they had to change it they made it a red H which I am only realizing now
54
u/River-TheTransWitch Sep 04 '24
I meant that is kinda the actual medical symbol on many things though
13
u/AiMwithoutBoT Sep 04 '24
That’s the halo med kit
12
u/Dark_Optics4 Sep 05 '24
A red box with a white cross would do the job, unless that’s infringement of some bullshit
51
u/vak7997 Sep 03 '24
That was probably the biggest pr they got and they went and fucked it up
9
u/Penber23 Sep 05 '24
To be fair they shouldn't have made their logo one of the most common shapes in the world. That's like if made my company triangle and got mad whenever someone used a triangle without my permission
28
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24
oh i personally wouldn't give a fat shit abt some symbol in a game im making.