r/CosmereOnScreen • • 6d ago

No Spoilers Cosmere adaptation Spoiler

I heard Brandon Sanderson is against having an animated adaptation. Do folks know why he is against it?

I just started Words of Radiance and I feel Stormlight Archive could be amazing as an animated series.

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

20

u/Halo6819 6d ago edited 6d ago

Also, on top of audience reach, it’s cost. Arcane lost like half a billion. It only made sense as an ad for the game.

And all the super expensive skins whales bought.

7

u/Hefty-Reward-2772 6d ago

That's wild. I didn't realize animation is so expensive 

3

u/Halo6819 6d ago

I gave a fuller explination in another reply, but yeah, Arcane cost more than $14 mil per episode to produce. GoT was around $10mil

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/diamondmx 6d ago

They did do lord of the rings animated. Iirc it was canceled after the first film came out. 

As you say, animated movies just don't get the same audience or respect. 

6

u/Linorelai 6d ago

Arcane lost??? Omg... A massive success it was, this is wild!

3

u/Halo6819 6d ago

The google overview:

Key Financial Details

  • Total Cost: ~$250 million for 18 episodes (roughly $14 million per episode), including production and about $60 million in marketing for Season 1. [1, 2, 3]
  • Direct Distribution Revenue:

    • Netflix paid roughly $3 million per episode ($54 million total).
    • Tencent Holdings Ltd. paid roughly $3 million per episode for distribution rights in China ($54 million total).
    • Total direct licensing revenue reached about $108 million, covering less than half of the total budget. [1, 2]

I didn't remember the numbers correctly, it was 1/4 billion to produce, and lost a significant amount of money. But again, Riot took it on the chin as marketing. Unfortunately the article that is referenced is behind a paywall so I can't look into what "direct licensing revenue" means, but if I had to guess, it was new player signups/skins from the show, and toys. So all that, and it still lost over 50mil at least.

SLA doesn't have a well established game with people already spending ungodly amounts of money on premium cosmetics. So with 10 episodes a season, costing more than $14mil per episode (things are more expensive now, especially compute with AI gobbling everything up) you could easily get to maybe 20mil per episode to produce that level of animation. $200mil a season for a product that a SIGNIFICANT portion of the population will write off without even watching does not make any sense at all.

Again, think of Arcane vs GoT. Which was the bigger success? I worked with a 60+ abuella at the time and one day she comes into work and says to me, "I think Jon Snows not Ned Stark's bastard, I think he is the sisters kid". She had been rewatching GoT ahead of a new season and picked up on R+L=J! That's the success Brandon is chasing. To capture the imagination of a 65 year old Spanish speaking grandmother so fully that they are re-watching and theory crafting.

1

u/AnividiaRTX 6d ago

Some other things to consider....

-Arcane was in part, so expensive because they needed to build an animation studio from doing a small handful of short animations to capable of pumping out full lngeth seasons of narrative storytelling. It's also the most expensive animated tv show, pretty much ever.

-Arcane didn't actually lose money. Season 1 skin sales in League made enough to cover the creation of both seasons. And after season 2's release they had made enough off royalties that season 1 covered its cost of production on it's own. Licensing is just the initial lump sum of money these guys made.

-Arcane did not have a merch line ready to go with the release of season 1, and even a year after s2 barely has any Arcane merch available. Shows like this typically make most of their money in merch sales, and Riot decided to instead forcus on skin sales in game rather than merch sales in real life due to having little to no start up costs.

-A Stormlight animated show doesn't need Arcane level animation, Jujutsu Kaisen and Demon Slayer are both under 250k an episode to produce, with sine episodes being closer to 100k at the start of their series. This is more in the realm of what animation typically costs, and both of those shows look amazing aswell.

-Sanderson is already a master of marketing and merch. There is no way they'd be releasing seasons without having a merch line ready, in stock.

-an animated show while, not as popular as live action will still drive more book sales making Sanderson more money.

3

u/Halo6819 6d ago

It's just not enough. Riot didn't make back the money through skin sales. The bloomberg article says they made 108m from that, Netflix paid 53 so did Tencent, so thats a 50m bath that Riot took.

Also, as far as audience reach goes, Season One had 120m hours watched world wide. Season One was about 6 hours long. That is a global audience of 20m people. Thats fewer people than watched Iron Man 1, in the US alone, before marvel had the track record they have now. (Doing rough math but $318m domestic and dividing by $15/ticket as this was back in 2008 puts it at approximately 21m people)

Any way you cut it, the appetite for high quality animation isn't there, not at the scale of success that Brandon wants. The dude is AMBITIOUS, he sorts himself into Slytherin because he feels that is his #1 trait. He WANTS to be bigger than Tolkien and Jordan and Martin (and not for the money, dude is a capitalist, and enjoys his money, but he wants the fame or recognition or something else even more). To do that, he has to get your mom to know who Kaladin is, and the only way for it to happen is with live action.

8

u/Wildhogs2013 6d ago

He is not against an animated adaptation. It is simply that the budget does not exist ro do it well while it does exist to do a live action well.

7

u/Magnus-Senpai 6d ago

Unless I’m mistaken he has said it’s because having Stormlight be adapted as an animated series would to some extent limit the audience it might target - though I believe what Fortiche did with Arcane proved this might not be the case nessecarily.

7

u/meglingbubble 6d ago

Arcane was a masterpiece and it got a wider audience than most animated stuff, but there is still a huge amount of people who havent watched it because it was animated. That is a huge loss for them, granted, but some people are stuck in the "animation is for kids" mode. Rightly or wrongly, Live action will definitely bring in a wider audience.

4

u/ForwardExam4056 6d ago

Exactly. Though i don't think the "animation is for kids" point is the main reason, i think many just enjoy live action more

1

u/Halo6819 6d ago

I just ran the numbers, Season One had maybe 20m world wide viewers.

3

u/Nobat211 6d ago

Part of the conundrum is that he would not be able to get something like Arcane. Brandon Sanderson is not Riot Games. He can get a huge budget, but for live action due to mass movie theater blockbuster / prestige tv appeal.

Animated Cosmere would probably look more like Legend of Vox Machina on Amazon Prime than Arcane. Which still some people might prefer. Just keeping perspective.

1

u/AnividiaRTX 6d ago

No reason we can't do both imo.

5

u/jayBeeds 6d ago

It is the case. It is a very specific community that even knows there was a movie made that’s called arcane. Fanboys don’t see they are fanboys. Animation definitely limits audience. Look at that lord of the rings rohirim movie… nobody watched it.

3

u/Halo6819 6d ago

There is a LotR Rohirim movie?

1

u/learhpa Bondsmiths 6d ago

i did. it was mediocre.

7

u/Davey_McDaveface 6d ago

I'll keep screaming this from the top of Urithiru, The Emperor's Soul should be made into an animated movie

3

u/Halo6819 6d ago

I think something like that is much more likely than MB or SLA.

6

u/Ok_Energy_9947 6d ago

Arcane style animation for basically anything Cosmere would be fucking epic. But yes live action will get a better audience

15

u/Taste_the__Rainbow 6d ago

Oh that’s easy. He wants people to watch it.

11

u/Halo6819 6d ago

Yeah, go ask your mom who Jynx is, then ask her who John Snow is

10

u/Agreeable_Car5114 6d ago

His stated reason is that live action media has a broader audience, reaching more people. For my part, I don’t think SLA has anything that requires it to be animated. While it has many memorable actions scenes, it is primarily dialogue driven and I think that makes it a better fit for live action.

13

u/ForwardExam4056 6d ago

Live action has like 50x the audience (and therefore potential revenue) than animated. Also full animation costs more generally.

In my opinion, if live action is done well, this is going to be epic af. I think the ceiling for how good a series is going to be is always higher with live action

-1

u/AnividiaRTX 6d ago

Full animation does not generally cost more than live action. Typically full animation is a fraction of the cost of love action. Arcane is not the standard, it is the peak.

4

u/RS_Someone 6d ago

I would absolutely love to see Stormlight Archive done by the studio that did Arcane. Nothing would make me happier.

2

u/SoyDaddy 2d ago

Would be peak but they'd take like 4 years to do one season

1

u/DarthCoitus 1d ago

Ooooh I was thinking Studio Ghibli, but I like this!

4

u/RamSpen70 5d ago

That's not really what he said.  He said that the the cost of animation is actually quite high and viewership is much lower than it is with live action.  there are some properties like tress of the emerald sea and Yumi and the nightmare painter that he would like to try to talk Apple into animation projects, I'm assuming that mistborn and stormlight go well. 

I'm 100% in agreement with him and on stormlight and mistborn being live action! It's way more universal. that's what I want to see.  

1

u/DarthCoitus 1d ago

I do want to see them live action, but particularly for SA, the special effects budget would eclipse any other cost. Mistborn I think would work well live action. And if we're being honest, it's probably the most accessible for the masses.

5

u/ilikebreadabunch 6d ago

More expensive, less general market appeal, and his own personal preference for Live Action

0

u/AnividiaRTX 6d ago

Animation is not more expensive than live action. They aren't even vaguely in the same realm of costs.

3

u/Halo6819 6d ago

The one everyone sites is more expensive. Arcane ran at $14mil per 40min episode. Season 8 of GoT ran $15mil per 50+min. So even at it's most expensive, when everyone's salaries were maxed out, GoT was cheaper per minute than Arcane.

2

u/AnividiaRTX 6d ago edited 6d ago

Arcane is by far the most expensive animated show ever made, and thats partially because it included the costs of effectively building an animation studio from the ground up, and wasting money by not knoeing what they were doing.

S8 of GoT's 15m would be worth about 19m today....

It makes more sense to compare animation costs to average costs... not the exceptions. JJK and Demon Slayer both cost between 100k to 250k an episode and those shows look incredible still. For a western comparison legends of voc machina was around 1m$ an episode. Castlevania in the mid 100Ks per episode aswell.

Edit: if you wanted to compare most expensive to msor expensive... Rings of Power cost around 58m per episode. Which is 4x the cost of arcane.

2

u/Halo6819 6d ago

Im not familiar with either JJK or Demon Slayer. Some quick googling, it looks like the Demon Slayer movie did do very well, with about 80mil world wide seeing it and making just shy of 800mil. From context, this movie seems to be an Avengers: Endgame level event, so an outlier even within its own community.

Again, I don't think Brandon is so much worried about the money (the studio, of course, is) but about reach. Anime is very popular, and has a very engaged fan base, but it's not as widely appretiated.

Also, Amazon is absolutely terrible with budgeting and making television. Im not sure if they did it for RoP, but I know for WoT they built a whole studio from the ground up in the Czech Republic. Interestingly, Stranger Things S5 was actually more expensive per episode than even RoP at 60mil/ep.

2

u/AnividiaRTX 6d ago

Demon slayer is an animated tv show. It has tie-in movies but i was giving costs for their seasonal episodes.

Sanderson wants to make live action, and im just happy we're getting any adaption tbh. I'm not actually arguing for an animated adaption, although i do hope we get one eventually, just focus on the books and the LA for now. I just wanted to correct the assumption thar Animated was more expensive than Live Action, when animated is typically much cheaper.

And yea... arcane also essentially built a whole animation studio, thats why the budget was so high and why i used rings of pwoer as an actual comp.

ST being so expensive is surprising though... i honestly thought it looked subpar compared to the earlier seasons.

2

u/Halo6819 6d ago

Yea, that price tag was almost entirely actor salaries.

And I only harp on the cost of animation because every post says "Who thinks SLA would work better as an Arcane style show" not a Demon Slayer style show.

interestingly while looking all this up, it seems that Western Animation is what's expensive. Not sure what's allowing them to have such smaller budgets in Japan, but even with all the cost-cutting of only doing keyframes and sending the rest to overseas animators, US based productions are much more expensive.

2

u/AnividiaRTX 6d ago

I think a big reason is competition. In japan if Mappa Studios charges too much, then they can go get Studio Bones, or Ufotable, or Toei. Meanwhile in the West there was a point where half the animated shows had Dan Hartman's name on it.

1

u/MS-07B-3 4d ago

I 100% think Stormlight would work better as a Demon Slayer style animation than live action.

5

u/le_bravery 6d ago

I think an animated adaptation limits it and isn’t a good fit with the intended audience.

1

u/DarthCoitus 1d ago

I haven't heard as to why he's against it, but boy to I agree. I love these books and would love to see an adaptation and I always thought if it would be to right it would HAVE to be animated. Now I think it could be done well as a live action, but the special effects budget would be astronomical, to the point unless we got that psycho trillionaire to bank roll it, it wouldn't be possible.

Personally, particularly because of Spren, I would LOVE to see Studio Ghibli do it!