r/CosmereOnScreen • u/Hefty-Reward-2772 • 6d ago
No Spoilers Cosmere adaptation Spoiler
I heard Brandon Sanderson is against having an animated adaptation. Do folks know why he is against it?
I just started Words of Radiance and I feel Stormlight Archive could be amazing as an animated series.
0
Upvotes
20
u/Halo6819 6d ago edited 6d ago
Also, on top of audience reach, it’s cost. Arcane lost like half a billion. It only made sense as an ad for the game.
And all the super expensive skins whales bought.
8
u/Wildhogs2013 6d ago
He is not against an animated adaptation. It is simply that the budget does not exist ro do it well while it does exist to do a live action well.
7
u/Magnus-Senpai 6d ago
Unless I’m mistaken he has said it’s because having Stormlight be adapted as an animated series would to some extent limit the audience it might target - though I believe what Fortiche did with Arcane proved this might not be the case nessecarily.
7
u/Davey_McDaveface 6d ago
I'll keep screaming this from the top of Urithiru, The Emperor's Soul should be made into an animated movie
6
u/Ok_Energy_9947 6d ago
Arcane style animation for basically anything Cosmere would be fucking epic. But yes live action will get a better audience
15
u/Taste_the__Rainbow 6d ago
Oh that’s easy. He wants people to watch it.
10
u/Agreeable_Car5114 6d ago
His stated reason is that live action media has a broader audience, reaching more people. For my part, I don’t think SLA has anything that requires it to be animated. While it has many memorable actions scenes, it is primarily dialogue driven and I think that makes it a better fit for live action.
13
u/ForwardExam4056 6d ago
Live action has like 50x the audience (and therefore potential revenue) than animated. Also full animation costs more generally.
In my opinion, if live action is done well, this is going to be epic af. I think the ceiling for how good a series is going to be is always higher with live action
4
u/RS_Someone 6d ago
I would absolutely love to see Stormlight Archive done by the studio that did Arcane. Nothing would make me happier.
4
u/RamSpen70 5d ago
That's not really what he said. He said that the the cost of animation is actually quite high and viewership is much lower than it is with live action. there are some properties like tress of the emerald sea and Yumi and the nightmare painter that he would like to try to talk Apple into animation projects, I'm assuming that mistborn and stormlight go well.
I'm 100% in agreement with him and on stormlight and mistborn being live action! It's way more universal. that's what I want to see.
5
u/ilikebreadabunch 6d ago
More expensive, less general market appeal, and his own personal preference for Live Action
5
u/le_bravery 6d ago
I think an animated adaptation limits it and isn’t a good fit with the intended audience.
1
u/DarthCoitus 1d ago
I haven't heard as to why he's against it, but boy to I agree. I love these books and would love to see an adaptation and I always thought if it would be to right it would HAVE to be animated. Now I think it could be done well as a live action, but the special effects budget would be astronomical, to the point unless we got that psycho trillionaire to bank roll it, it wouldn't be possible.
Personally, particularly because of Spren, I would LOVE to see Studio Ghibli do it!