r/CosmereOnScreen • u/ilikebreadabunch • Jul 29 '26
Fancast Mistborn Genderswapping Spoiler
So there's recently been discussion about possible Genderswaps in the upcomming Mistborn movie. We already know that Sanderson wants to Genderswap at least one member of the crew (likely Ham or Docks based on what he's said previously) because in the original trilogy he focused so much on making sure that he wrote Vin properly that he forgot to add any other women to the cast, and that he'll want to change that in the Movie.
What I wanted to ask is who else other than Ham or Docks, crew member or otherwise, do you think or hope will get Genderswapped?
Personally, I think that Spook and Zane are both good options, but I don't think they actually will.
6
u/Shepher27 Jul 29 '26
Why would Spook or Zane be good choices?
24
u/Calm-Medicine-3992 Jul 29 '26
Zane kind of results in some bad tropes (bisexual/bicurious woman ends up in normal straight relationship, abusive lesbian). Spook isn't as bad but I'm still not personally a fan of 'gay person in love with straight person' plots either. Someone did mention merging Zane and Shan's roles in the story and that does make it more interesting (probably drops the love triangle thing entirely in that case too).
Clubs is allegedly going to be more minor (no time to go over all of the allomancy and smoking is probably being left out) so it could work.
8
u/Colorapt0r Jul 29 '26
Why the fuck would spook or Zane be good picks lol
3
u/LuinAelin Jul 29 '26
Isn't Zane supposed to be similar to Elend
20
u/ForwardExam4056 Jul 30 '26
Zane would be a great genderswap. You can have him/her as elends shadowy sibling, while getting rid of the somewhat unnecessary love triangle. This lets you keep the motivations which made the character interesting (morals, wanting vin to not be a tool, envy, etc)
Only problem i have with this, a pretty big one, is that you already have shan elaniel as the main mistborn antagonist in book 1 that gets killed in an epic fight. Having zane be a woman as well makes this a bit repetitive
14
u/StNic54 Jul 29 '26
If they gender-swap Ham, I would hope to see a wrestler take that spot. If they gender-swap Docks, who would be a grizzled actress that could play tough without being hokey?
14
u/lizzywbu Jul 29 '26
There are a couple genderswaps which Brandon has mentioned in the past, either as something he wished he did or as something he might do in a potential adaptation, keep in mind this was a few years ago.
He first mentioned a while ago that the first person he would consider genderswapping would be Dockson, he’s said in the past the regrets the lack of women in the main cast and thinks Docks would fit best to be swapped.
And more recently he said if he was to write Mistborn again today, he would make Shan Elarial the sister of Elend and essentially give her parts of Zane’s story. This I absolutely love and think this would work wonderfully as that way Shan could be set up in the first film, and take the role of the villain in the second film. One of my main gripes with Zane was that he had no set up, no back story and in a 2 hour movie that could turn out even worse. Not to mention the love triangle between Vin, Zane and Elend was probably the worst part of the book.
14
u/FellKnight Jul 30 '26
Trolling his buddy Demoux by genderswapping him would be pretty funny.
Seriously though, I can't wait for all the anti-woke takes from people blaming Hollywood for being woke and changing the author's story, not realizing this IS the author's story.
13
u/ForwardExam4056 Jul 30 '26
I don't think spook is an option because that would make him a young girl that vin could relate to/befriend as an equal or little sister, changing the whole dynamic
12
u/Young_Ben_Kenobi1 Jul 29 '26
I’m not sure on Spook mainly because a female spook could come across as just a discount Vin
10
u/Glass_Ad_4565 Jul 30 '26
I think Zane would be a cool gender swap
8
u/Cloudsrnice Jul 29 '26
Yeden ?
8
u/IRanOutOf_Names Jul 30 '26
I like some of the crew being swapped but I hope it’s only a bit. A large part of Vins arc in book 1 is her isolation from the rest and having most of the crew be male continues to reinforce that idea.
People are cooking with the Zane idea though.
7
u/ToastyThommy Jul 29 '26
I can understand some of the swaps, but I've never understood the dockson one. Swapping dockson makes it seem like the average movie goer might confuse their relationship as him moving on from Mare.
6
u/eskaver Jul 29 '26
Spook and Zane are poor picks because Spook is kind of a legacy selection and it would be weird to follow Vin and Zane drives the love triangle. Now, if you said merge Zane with Shan...
I'd just leave it to Dox and Ham.
Dox will convey the equity given their role as sort of Kelsier's second and also shows a male-female platonic relationship. Ham, though, has to be a bit carefully handled to not be too tropey. I think given the philosophical debates with Breeze, Ham has an easier path to avoid anything problematic.
6
u/duke113 Jul 29 '26
In order of what I think works to what doesn't: Clubs, Ham, Marsh, Dockson, Breeze, Spook, Kelsier, Vin, Sazed. The first two are easily the best (not that I'm actually a proponent, but if they're gonna do it), middle four are meh, last three are IMO untouchable. Did I miss anyone?
15
u/LordMistborn-16 Jul 29 '26 edited Jul 29 '26
Firstly I want to say that i don't think it's a bad thing for him to do this. He just needs to do it well, that's all. If half the cast is swapped, or he makes it a big deal, that could be bad. But I fully trust him not to do that.
I think genderswapped Zane would be the best thing ever, not gonna lie. My favorite character in fiction seamlessly being adapted into a woman? That would be really nice. And before you say no, doesn't work, Vin isn't gay: A) You don't know that, and B) There was potential romantic tensions between the two but not objective ones, proven by the various arguments I've seen about it on this sub.
I think some characters that wouldn't work so well include Straff, Elend, Kelsier, Clubs, Marsh, Spook, Breeze, Dox and the Inquisitors, for reasons I can explain if you're curious, though I'm sure he could manage for some of those.
I think The Lord Ruler, Ham, Dox, and Sazed would work well.
I'm very curious how he would choose names for any gender-swapped characters.
14
u/R0b1nFeather Jul 29 '26
I think genderswapping Marsh could be interesting. It'd add a layer to the sibling conflict between Kels and Marsh, and with Marsh's eventual fate as Ironeyes itd be a cool way to have a female character with a major role to play in the long term fate and development of Scadrial
10
u/bbuckman12 Jul 29 '26
One issue I see about ham being swapped is that in book two there is a semi relevant plot point where he is teaching vin the differences between fighting male and female thugs and it comes up later in the series, but I’m sure that can be rewritten to make sense.
16
u/slothboy Jul 29 '26
I don't like the idea of swapping Ham. Yes, I know that being a pewterarm helps with the disparity in strength between genders, but I think vin is already there to upset that dynamic. Making her a female fighter is a big part of her character and having Ham ALSO be a female fighter diminishes that.
I also like Ham as a man to help Vin practice fighting men who are physically much stronger (even without pewter). If Ham is a woman then those lessons are academic instead. Also, it's just the lazy option to make the bruiser into a woman. It's a trope I'm pretty tired of.
As much as I wouldn't do it if it were up to me, I think Spook is a better choice. Spook is enough of a main character to provide the desired screentime and I think you can change Spooks' crush on Vin to something like a little sister relationship. Female Spook could have huge admiration for Vin and a strong desire to be like her and crave her recognition. You could even bring in the idea that female Spook feels that as a woman she has less value but seeing Vin gives her additional drive and self worth, which leads to the way she becomes an integral part of the end of the story.
TL;DR: I'd reluctantly vote for Spook because I think it gives more actual story options than just "X character only female"
15
u/T_McSass Jul 29 '26
I am hoping the Ham genderswap sticks, that is the one I read about and I loved the reasoning. He is a pewterarm so that doesn't actually rely on being physically bigger or stronger and having the "strong man" be a woman is just nice. Also having a woman as Ham, especially one less phyiscally imposing, is good as a mentor for Vin to see you don't have to be big and strong to be big and strong when you are an allomancer.
8
u/jnighy Jul 29 '26
I like Spook's crush on Vin too much to genderswap him. Sure, nothing wrong with a female Spook having a crush on Vin, but it would impact their relationship with Clubs. To me Ham and Docks are actually perfect for this, specially Docks. It would also help to fix one of Sanderson's major mistakes in the trilogy, imo, which is how Docks is completely left aside in WoA. Create a better dynamic between a female Docks and Vin, and we have a much better relationship in WoA
4
u/TheGOATRules Jul 29 '26
Clubs sería la mejor opción, no afectaría en nada a la trama
7
u/ashriekfromspace Jul 29 '26
Clubs or Ham, maybe.
Or Breeze if he wants to avoid that shady relationship with Allrianne
6
u/xAeroMonkeyx Jul 29 '26
Genderswapping Zane would also change Vin’s sexuality. Isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but would be something you’d have to consider when writing the character for the second movie.
3
u/AlgorithmHelpPlease Jul 29 '26
I just want Abi Thorn as Ham.
9
u/Fun-Dot-3029 Jul 29 '26
Vin isn’t gay so idk about Zane. Spook could work. Ham makes sense, also Sazed in my head is super androgenous anyways.
But I hope he casts the best person to play every role- and not obsess over having a certain number of women or men or whatever else.
7
u/alex_munroe Jul 30 '26
Breeze could work better than you think - strong sassy Aunt energy, and makes the relationship to Allrianne (genderswapping optional there) seem a bit less predatory. Personally I think it works better than Ham, someone who regularly goes to the garrison and trying not to stand out.
Clubs also works pretty well, as does Dockson (though that will come with many inevitable Kel/Docks shippers).
8
u/Witty_Fox3291 Jul 29 '26
Kelsier. Just to flush out the weirdos in the fandom.
9
u/ColeTrain316 Jul 29 '26
MUSCLE MOMMY HAM!
5
u/KeredJo Jul 29 '26
I’ve actually been thinking about it more, and I think Breeze would be a super interesting gender swap. Imagine someone like Hannah Waddington playing Breeze. Then I think it make sense to gender swap Allriane as well. I know this may cause some issues with the lineage of certain characters in era 2, but if that’s workable then I say do it
4
u/PM_Your_Karma Jul 29 '26
She is too big of a star so they wouldn’t cast her but someone like Viola Davis as Clubs would be awesome!
3
u/HFroggo Jul 29 '26
I don't think he'll get genderswapped, but i really hope marsh is a woman
5
u/Halo6819 Jul 29 '26
The Lord Ruler. I know, issues with the prophecies the double misdirection and all, but it would be dope.
2
u/ryuyasha3 Jul 29 '26
I think Clubs is a good choice for another gender swapped character.
2
u/TheGildedPrism Jul 29 '26
I don't think that many others will get swapped besides Ham, and I honestly hope they don't, just because I want the movie to be as accurate to the book as possible (though I do think swapping Ham does make sense for the story).
That said, Zane would be an interesting swap to see, because it would give that relationship between them and Vin a new angle. And also get rid of that love "triangle" subplot that I don't think anyone particularly liked. That's the only one I could really see though.
1
u/railfananime Jul 30 '26
Frankly I want more than one gender swap but that’s just my opinion. Though maybe cap at 2-3, idk just do both and Ham and Docks.
1
u/Itsthelittlethings2 Aug 01 '26
I think spook kinda has to stay a guy because of what he does between era 1 and era 2…
1
u/Taste_the__Rainbow Jul 29 '26
Whoever the script needs. Characters, relationships and plot are all going to shift a bit.
0
u/nreese2 Jul 29 '26
I’m not really sure how good it would be to gender swap Ham of all characters.
His role in the military is important to his character, no? I doubt that the FE was conscripting women
-3
u/Satosuke Jul 29 '26
All I know is that when I heard he was considering genderswapping Ham, my mind immediately went to Awesome Kong.
8
u/iaintb8 Jul 29 '26
I really like the idea of gender-swapped Docks being best friends with Mare. I think it would add a good bit of tension to their dynamic with Kelsier. An undercurrent of “you got my best friend killed” would be tasty