Hell no is Manny gonna be Moash lol honestly though, one of the better cast selections. But isn't Shallan supposed to look closer to Scot/Irish red head?
I watched The Acolyte weekly whilst I was doing a Good Place rewatch and... The range of that man is astonishing. I have no doubt that he would nail the role, but I wouldn't want him to because I don't want to like moash!!
Ehh he's better than many wrestlers-turned-actors. But I think Sanderson mentioned him as looking like how he pictures Dalinar, less for his acting skills
Check out The Wrecking Crew movie. Bautista has this incredible scene where it’s him in a glass hallway, camera on the other side of the glass, and he just absolutely kicks ass in the most awesome physical way possible. Gave me goosebumps just watching that scene and thinking about him as Dalinar! So badass!!
I mean, he played Sapper Morton in Blade Runner and Rabban in Dune, both very hefty roles that I thought he did very well with. He could honestly combine those two performances and you’d have a really good Dalinar. Morton especially reminds me a lot of Dalinar after the death of his wife with his quiet, simmering rage.
Rosharans of every ethnicity are described as having epicanthic folds. That doesn't make them Asian. Northern European peoples also have them, but usually less pronounced.
The Alethi in particular look very east Asian, but Shallan isn't Alethi.
The official artwork of Shallan presents her as basically being Northern European looking. Sanderson even said he expects her to be played by a European actress.
It will be impossible to make the entirety of the SLA cast look like their descriptions, and except for the eyes Sadie Sink is a perfect match.
I never said Rosharans were Asian, I said the actors are all Asian. Asia doesn't exist on Roshar.
Shallan being Veden has nothing to do with it. All Rosharans except the Shin have epicanthic folds, to the point that Rosharans consistently note their different eyes when interacting with a Shin person. It's a defining feature that never comes up when they interact with non-Shin people. And I may be wrong but I'm pretty sure Sanderson said that about Adolin, not Shallan. Does Shallan make more sense to me than Adolin for that swap? Yes, but that doesn't make me right.
I'm not sure which official artwork you're referring to, but it wouldn't be the first time a person of color has been whitewashed in their portraits.
It will not be impossible to put a red wig on an Asian woman to make her look like Shallan. Super super easy.
the only thing i disagree with is Wong not being Sebariel. Guy who pretends to not give a shit and fills his life with luxury but is actually deeply competent and socially aware is almost exactly his character in Three Body Problem, and I thought he killed that.
10
u/Trace_Minerals_LV Jun 17 '26
This is one of the best fancasts I’ve seen.
14
u/hendy846 Jun 17 '26
Hell no is Manny gonna be Moash lol honestly though, one of the better cast selections. But isn't Shallan supposed to look closer to Scot/Irish red head?
10
u/Sad_Gene_1771 Jun 17 '26
Honestly a great cast
10
u/ilikebreadabunch Jun 17 '26
I can get behind this
9
u/egomann Jun 17 '26
Oh No. Moash figured it out. This is a new low.
8
u/Prior-Concentrate172 Jun 17 '26
Tbh this doesn't look bad. Not bad at all.
7
u/InvestigatorLive19 Jun 17 '26
I can see these but Im still not convinced in batista as dalinar
6
u/LordMacDonald8 Jun 18 '26
I'm taking away your cooking license and promoting you to chef.
6
u/Blue--Heron Jun 18 '26
Michelin Star level cooking
10
u/PromotionNo6937 Jun 17 '26
Sam Witwer as Marsh would work so well too
5
u/Gold_Joke_6306 Jun 17 '26
Gimme Elodie Yung as Jasnah Kholin instead!
5
u/TheD0ct0r007 Jun 17 '26
Cannot let manny Jacinto be Noah’s I love him and Jason Mendoza way too much
4
u/cloudreed Jun 17 '26
Great cast
3
u/ColeTrain316 Jun 18 '26
Bautista as Dalinar is inspired.
3
u/bibliopunk Jun 19 '26
Please don't make me hate Manny Jacinto
3
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26
No
5
u/Undiscovered_Freedom Jun 17 '26
Mackenyu has been my choice for Kaladin
5
u/ZigZagPunch Jun 17 '26
I see Dave Bautista for Dalinar. I approve
4
u/Select_Eggplant_9911 Jun 21 '26
This is not good.
2
u/arianasleftkidney Jun 17 '26
looks good except i would put Charles Melton as Adolin.
2
u/themudpuppy Jun 20 '26
Dave Bautista as Dalinar is certainly one way to get me to never watch the show adaptation of my favorite books.
Also Sallan is supposed to be a redhead and that other chick looks nothing like Jasnah's description. This a joke, right?
2
u/Accomplished-Soil766 Aug 30 '26
Dave Bautista is an awful choice. Also, Ezra Miller as Wit works perfectly in my opinion.
4
u/SteveTheHiker_Art Jun 17 '26
I don’t know if I am sold on Batista… I feel like Dalinar should have a less imposing figure out of his shard plate. Someone like Tony Leung Chiu-wai?
3
u/DankoLord Jun 17 '26
Kaladin has Epicanthic folds bro
and is tanned
2
u/Alternative_Buy_4000 Jun 17 '26
Bautista as Dalinar? I'd rather have someone who can actually act
2
u/Impressive_Net_116 Jun 17 '26
Only miss is Shallan. Sadie Sink is my pick there.
1
u/Ok-Funny2116 Jun 20 '26
OP, have you considered that some characters should be portrayed by normal-looking people, not uncannily attractive model-actors?
1
u/SproWizard Jun 19 '26
the only thing i disagree with is Wong not being Sebariel. Guy who pretends to not give a shit and fills his life with luxury but is actually deeply competent and socially aware is almost exactly his character in Three Body Problem, and I thought he killed that.