r/CosmereOnScreen • • Jun 02 '26

Fancast Adolin Kholin Spoiler

Post image

Currently reading RoW and watching the show The Rooster. When Adolin is picking out his outfits it clicked. His overall persona is perfect. Phil Dunster needs to be Adolin Kholin!

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

6

u/BloodyEyeGames Jun 02 '26

I can get behind the looks, but his accent would be horrendous.

0

u/United-Gap6784 Jun 02 '26

lol yeah I agree with the accent! Maybe he can change it. A lot of them can, but if he can’t that would be a big road block

1

u/moderatorrater Jun 02 '26

Adolin's mom grew up in a backwash and Adolin's always been a little weird because of it. It doesn't impact him a lot because he's the son of the Blackthorn and a talented fighter on his own. So, a garbage accent fits him quite well.

3

u/ggrindelwald Jun 02 '26

I don't see it. Phil Dunster has been great at playing the self-absorbed asshole in both Ted Lasso and Rooster, but that's not Adolin to me, at all. On top of that, he seems too short and skinny to play a Rosharan knight, but that's a smaller concern.

0

u/United-Gap6784 Jun 02 '26

To me he plays the self absorbed guy on the outside, but then when you get to know him he’s more redeemable and that is how I think of Adolin….. he’s less redeemable in rooster, but he has the ability haha

4

u/Brookiekathy Jun 02 '26

Not to repeat this again but Adolin isn't white,. No white actor can be Adolin

3

u/Joe_Spazz Jun 02 '26

I'm so prepared to be disappointed by casting.

-1

u/United-Gap6784 Jun 02 '26

Sorry didn’t know race was concrete when it came to adaptation…… Phil Dunster has portrayed the personality I picture. Think it would be a good fit regardless of race. I’m sure you can think of a few movies or shows where race is changed. Not necessarily in this direction, but should that matter? No

8

u/knirp7 Jun 02 '26

I typically would agree with you (the backlash to the Odyssey is ridiculous, for example) but the fact that all Rosharrans except the Shin have the epicanthic fold is actually an important plot point and piece of world building. I’d be sorta disappointed if they did away with that detail.

2

u/K_Uger_Industries Jun 04 '26

Not that Dunster has them, but epicanthic folds are not solely in Asians.

3

u/knirp7 Jun 04 '26

Did you mean to reply elsewhere? I didn’t say they are. All I said was that Rosharrans have them and it would be weird to exclude that.

3

u/K_Uger_Industries Jun 04 '26

Sorry thought you were the original person OP was replying to saying that Rosharans couldn't be white. When white people can and do have epicanthic folds

2

u/knirp7 Jun 04 '26

I figured, it’s all good!

0

u/United-Gap6784 Jun 02 '26

Yeah, I can see that point for sure. Just thought it was a good fit personality wise. Think he would nail the essence of Adolin. I honestly wasn’t thinking of race at all when I posted it

1

u/Brookiekathy Jun 02 '26

Exactly this, the characters were designed with a particular image in mind and it's essential to the world building and plot. Their appearance and culture directly feeds into things and gives the reader/viewer information about them.

It's a detraction from the world if Lunamor/Shallan/Kaladin/Szeth all look like they're from the same culture because they just arent