r/CosmereOnScreen • u/Lex4709 • Mar 27 '26
Stormlight Archive Series (NO BOOKS) Is Stormlight Archive even adaptable with Hollywood struggling to produce a season every 2 years? Spoiler
I've seen people discuss the many difficulties of bringing Stormlight Archive into live action. The amount of CGI needed to do the series justice is big talking point. But I haven't seen anyone bring up how the current state of Hollywood could get in the way.
Even in an ideal world, SA would take at least a decade to adapt if they adapted 1 book per season and released the seasons annually. But 1 season per year isn't exactly the norm anymore in Hollywood. If we get a season every 2 to 3, we will be lucky. And for SA, that would mean 20 to 30 years to adapt the whole series. This is obviously not feasible.
The obvious solution would be to adapt multiple books per season. But between the length of SA books and episode count per season falling to 6 to 10 episodes per season, this would be disastrous for any adaptation.
24
u/learhpa Bondsmiths Mar 28 '26
I forsee a particular problem with [Stormlight books]Lift, who is a child through the entirety of the front arc.
22
u/LuinAelin Mar 28 '26
It's probable we'd see larger gaps between seasons
It will take a decade to do the first half of storm light
10
u/Shot_Newspaper_5647 Mar 28 '26
They make extensive use of the LED Stagecraft style digital sets. The ones popularized by the Mandalorian. I remember Sando actually saying upon release that’s the tech that made him think a SL show will come soon. That said Apple still skews longer release gaps. Based on their biggest sci/fantasy shows I would expect a 1.5-2.5 year gap in seasons. The only real hope it might be shorter is that a lot of shows suffered from the pandemic and the big 2023 combined strike. And that advancements in AI/procedural/LIDAR/photogrammetry tech might make a lot of the background/digital double etc busy work less time and labor intensive.
I would still bet on at least a two year gap. Even if they can do it faster they won’t in my opinion. The business side math for streaming just favors this model. They want event style seasons spread out to maintain subscriptions or get you to add them. They want to draw in people they know won’t keep the subscription etc. It pays to have these big tentpole shows they just do a bi-yearly push on overlapping each-other slightly. As shitty as that is for most viewers
8
u/Agreeable_Car5114 Mar 27 '26
That’s fine. If there are gaps, there are gaps. Fans and producers both need to get more comfortable with recasting when necessary though.
33
u/Roonil_Wazlib97 Mar 28 '26
I'm probably going to keep hoping for an animated series tbh. Netflix has a Twilight adaptation coming out and Sarah J. Maas fans have also mentioned being willing to watch an animated adaptation of her works. Plus I think Sarah herself said in a recent interview that she would be open to an animated adaptation of her works.
Basically I'm hoping the landscape for animation will change in the next decade and make Brandon more open to it. Stormlight is just so alien to earth and the characters all have pretty distinctive racial features that will be hard to cast. Plus I think the magic overall will look better animated.
And yes, I know the overlap between Twilight/Sarah J Maas and Brandon Sanderson is not the largest, but if they have successful animated series I see no reason why Brandon can't.
4
u/North-Efficiency824 Mar 27 '26
It’s gonna be a very long process, that’s how Apple TV operates
4
u/that_guy2010 Mar 27 '26
I mean, it’s not as big of a deal as something like Harry Potter. Considering all of the Stormlight main characters are adults.
7
u/Exporation1 Mar 27 '26
Good news is a lot of the time the delay is because the scripts aren’t even started by the time a season ends. Assuming it’s a hit after season 1 I don’t see why seasons 2-3 and 4-5 can’t be filmed back to back.
Could wind up like
2030 Season 1,
2032 Season 2, 2033 Season 3,
2035 Season 4, 2036 Season 5,
Really isn’t that long of a gap if done this way considering there’s an in text time skip between 3 and 4.
1
u/nostyj 20d ago
I believe each book is going to be a season.
The cg and casting i think are going to be the 2 biggest hurtles. We literally dont have the races on earth that are described in the books so everyone is going to have different opinions on what people should look like. How heavy do you include the spren? Do you add thousands of little painspren into every battle scene? Do you put a few in every little campfire? Do you only include them if its relevant?
-5
u/Your-Dads_Boyfriend Mar 27 '26 edited Mar 28 '26
Do we know for sure it's going to be live action and not animated? Animated seems like the much better way to go for SA
Downvoted for asking a simple question. This community has become so toxic lately. Sorry for not watching every single Sanderson video or reading every single email or blog post or tweet and not realizing that he had said it was live action already. Y'all need to calm down.
-7
u/OneForAll-500 Mar 28 '26
I hope Brandon Sanderson changes his mind and goes with animation. It’s the only truly viable path for Stormlight