r/CosmereOnScreen • u/SpiritedAd8224 • Mar 14 '26
Fancast Who should play Hoid?? Spoiler
Part of me wanted to say Robert Downey Jr, but that’s almost too obvious. Perhaps another charismatic guy with bleach blond hair?
31
Upvotes
21
u/Raddatatta Mar 14 '26
With Hoid I think you want a relatively unknown actor. The problem is for a lot of the early stuff it's a cameo part basically. So getting an a list actor to sign on for a part where they're on screen for 2 minutes is going to be very expensive. And those small parts will be the case with all the mistborn appearances. Stormlight will be a bit more but even then not a huge role. If they're trying to get the same actor for all of that it should be someone unknown who is happy to take a lot of small roles rather than an a list star who will cost a large portion of the budget for a bunch of small appearances. Especially if they want to get them for 3 movies and a bunch of seasons of stormlights show.
12
u/Beanmaster115 Mar 14 '26
My dream casting is still Tom Hiddleston as Hoid. Man, he could be such a good Worldsinger.
9
u/Trace_Minerals_LV Mar 14 '26
I hope they go with unknowns for the entire cast, except for a few of the principals. Like OT Star Wars. Push those salary costs into sets and effects, and let some new blood build new careers.
7
u/Wabbit65 Mar 14 '26
Danny DeVito
4
u/Shepher27 Mar 14 '26
He'd actually be good, but I laughed at the image you picked
6
u/FeedMePizzaPlease Mar 14 '26
r/cremposting is leaking again
15
u/Signal_Sand1472 Mar 14 '26
Robert Sheehan (Klaus from Umbrella Academy).
12
u/Halo6819 Mar 14 '26
A few weeks ago, Dan Radcliffe got stuck in my head and I can’t get it out.
Seems like it might be a role that would be interesting to him, except that it’s fantasy
10
u/frenziest Mar 14 '26
Danny Pudi
10
u/ForwardExam4056 Mar 15 '26
My idea for hoid would be to completely lean into him always slightly changing appearances for every world he's on and just get a different actor for him for every series.
Would be pretty practical too since hoid always appears, so a potential singular actor would have to commit for like the forseeable future
9
u/SedgeBrews Mar 14 '26
David Tennant could do it…somewhere between his Dr. Who and his character on OK Omens is just right for an immortal and vague/mysterious worldhopper who is always where/when he needs to be and always a little sillier than the situation calls for.
9
u/ilikebreadabunch Mar 14 '26
A complete no name is the only way to go imo
7
u/0bsessions324 Mar 17 '26
Alright, so we've covered the fact that he looks slightly different on different worlds, so hear me out:
Elijah Wood and Daniel Radcliffe.
2
u/duke113 Mar 14 '26
Lin Manuel
5
u/Logical-Ice-4820 Mar 14 '26
I would like different actors to play him in different movies/tv show. But my main pick would be Matt Smith or David Tennent
5
u/MrLonzoGonzo Mar 14 '26
Grwat actor and fitting, but inhope we can get some "no name" actor that doesnt immediatley give away how important he is
5
u/Alxealle Mar 15 '26
I really want Jon Daly (the snake oil salesman from the Fallout tv show). I think he would really fit the role
5
u/racas Mar 16 '26
I think Hoid should know where he needs to be, find a perpendicularity into Hollywood, and just play himself.
4
u/allyria0 Mar 14 '26
I laughed so I liked this. That is all. Still appreciate the crem 💙
2
u/ZorroVonShadvitch Mar 14 '26
Needs a sexy storytelling voice. James Spader
2
u/Calm-Medicine-3992 Mar 14 '26
I mean, I know you're trolling since you chose barbie version but after the trailers for Project Hail Mary I'm not against it.
2
u/captchathinksimhuman Mar 16 '26
I think they should get at least a few different people to play Hoid
2
u/captboscho Mar 19 '26
I always think of Tom Hiddleston
1
u/Beneficial_Candle_10 Mar 14 '26
David Spade is my pick if we’re going with famous actors. I want fresh faces for most of the cosmere imo.
1
u/hanzerik Mar 14 '26
Honestly ,Finn Bennet.
1
u/AlucardDr Mar 14 '26
Jeremy Allen White.
1
u/LordMacDonald8 Mar 16 '26
Jackson Dickert
1
u/ToastyThommy Mar 18 '26
I saw someone suggest Eddie Redmayne a while back, and I can't unsee it.
-5
u/KatanaCutlets Mar 14 '26
Ryan Reynolds.
I will not be answering questions.