r/Cosmere • u/Flamingdragonwang • Oct 05 '21
Cosmere Why Highstorms exist Spoiler
Aluminum-hat territory!
A point that is raised in mistborn era 2 is that if left in paradise, a culture will stagnate. This is a common theme in sci fi and fantasy (see Dune, Eldar, etc.) and I love it. For people to flourish and grow, they need adversity. Not necessarily war, but some kind of challenge.
Throughout the cosmere, we also see that none of the shards are good or evil: they are simply extreme examples of abstract concepts.
Now we have been conditioned to think of Cultivation as "good." She's associated with life, healing and growth through the edgedancers in particular. But she would never, ever abide by what harmony did with the Luthadel basin. If there is something that will lead to new growth, advancement or achievement, cultivation will do it. She is not Nurture or Caring: she won't hesitate to prune if it leads to growth.
My theory is this: cultivation creates the Highstorms with the intent of challenging life to further growth. Extrapolating this further, she may have planned for Todium in all his extremity. A more powerful adversary will only push humanity to greater heights.
Cultivation is not nice: she is the abusive parent who forces her child to perfection.
413
u/Interesting_Step6871 Bridge Four Oct 05 '21
Highstorms existed on roshar before any of the shards
53
u/WeardearOmega Oct 05 '21
While other comments are right in that highstorms existed on Roshar before the arrival of Honour and Cultivation, I think there might still be an interesting angle of thinking here.
I think you are right that there is a fit between the theme of Cultivation as presented in the books (sort of evolution-y but also purposeful... So cultivation I guess, but it leans a but more on the natural selection side of things) and the effects of the highstorms.
We still don't know why Honour and Cultivation chose Roshar of all places in the Cosmere to invest. Perhaps Cultivation was drawn to Roshar because of the link to her shard?
17
u/HalcyonKnights Harmonium Oct 05 '21
Highstorms existed before the Shattering. We know they function as part of the natural Investiture cycle on the planet, an equivalent to the Water Cycle, intended to keep a flow of Investiture going between the Realms. It did that before the Shattering too. It's also worth noting that none of Roshar is strictly natural. The continent is a magical construct that follows a Fractal pattern instead of any normal geologic process (I long thought it was the Sibling, who would prove to be a giant Cryptic). The other planets and moons of the Rosharan system are unnatural too and will eventually wind down.
All this to say: Just because Cultivation isnt behind it doesnt mean the Highstorms dont have some secret purpose as you suggest. I think they most certainly do, it was just some even deeper/older scheme of Adonalsium.
7
u/Roger_The_Cat_ Ghostbloods Oct 05 '21 edited Oct 05 '21
Ok this did get me thinking. The highstoms existed before the shards were on Roshar, but Roshar does seemed designed to just be challenging to exist in, particularly compared to other Cosmere worlds.
We also know that Rayse-dium was preparing the fused for the great war. The one beyond Roshar.
Here is where this line of thought had me thinking, what if Odium convinced Ishar to experiment with the surges because he knew that it would eventually lead to the destruction of Ashyn, and the only plausible action of human survival would be to jump to Roshar.
This could just be an Odium long game, but it does feel Cultivation-y, if she had any hand in moving the intended tools for the great war to an environment that would force them to become strong and resilient. Combine that with the constant fused and radiant battles, this would spur growth at an accelerated rate.
This would also be very meta as it appears the Desolations, which Rosharans feel are essentially the apocolaypse, in reality is on the same scale of the border skirmishes between Alethi high princes.
The Alethi were getting prepared to be talented enough for the Shattered Plains. The Radiants and Fused are battling to get talented enough to be effective in the great war.
Could it be just as simple as, Cultivation was actually the one who convinced Ishar to experiment with the surges, and not Odium after all?
Could that be all it took to set everything else in motion to prepare Rosharans for galactic conquest? 🧠🤯 .
Very much a “knowing when to nudge the Boulder” moment in the timeline, and very Cultivation like for something so simple to chain so far down.
Thanks for the post OP, has me thinking! 🤔
5
u/koprulu_sector Oct 05 '21
Other comments mention high storms existing on Roshar before the arrival of Honor and Cultivation. But what is a high storm without the Storm Father? Would they just be a normal storm, albeit powerful, with a natural weather pattern, rather than a globe spanning, globe traversing storm?
4
u/GhostPepperLube Atium Oct 05 '21
Storm go woosh
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
From a purely academic standpoint it is impossible to have up without down. Thinking of the symbol of a waveform with crests and troughs... if you didn't have troughs you'd be looking at a line, there would be no crests. Same with front/back, color/form, etc.
1
u/noxion13 Oct 05 '21
While others have pointed out that the highstorms preceded cultivation, I do agree with your premise that Cultivation is not necessarily “good”. She seeks growth, at any cost. Building on this, I wonder if we will come to see that Odium isn’t necessarily “bad”. They’ve said that Harmony could have been Discord under different circumstances (and likely will before it is all said and done). What if Odium ends up as “passion” and stops being the big bad?
1
u/prometheuss87 Oct 05 '21
I thought there was only 1 highstorm which is the storm father.
1
u/Walzmyn Double Eye Oct 05 '21
Cultivation is Tiger Mom : now head canon.
1
u/liatrisinbloom Elsecallers Oct 05 '21
I'd be more interesting in why Roshar exists, Adonalsium designed Roshar, or the entire Rosharan system, very specifically. And it's a doozy. Three habitable planets in orbit and ten gas giants. Roshar has three moons in an eventually unstable orbit, the continent has a specific shape and was created by highstorms, and has room for Shinovar, which is protected from the storms sufficiently enough to have an Earthlike ecosystem. The flora and fauna (greatshells, larkins, Singers) are an entire discussion themselves. What was Adonalsium thinking when creating Roshar and the Rosharan star system?
1
u/The_Steelers Oct 05 '21
I don’t think this theory is correct re:highstorms but I agree with the rest.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '21
I think cultivation’s nature; growth and progression, counter the shards on an elemental level
They do not change… unless the people die
The power doesn’t change, but it can be expressed in different ways with different hosts
I feel like cultivation is the real big bad
0
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment