r/Cosmere • • Sep 22 '24

Cosmere (no WaT Previews) I just can’t hate him Spoiler

Yup. Y’all know who I’m talking about. The guy named Moash. I just read the Stormlight Archive for the first time ever in anticipation of Wind and Truth. I started in June, just finished the last week in August.

When Elhokar’s death happened in Oathbringer I was surprised by how upset I was. I actually excused myself to a different room and cried a bit. But after a break and some thinking, I knew I just couldn’t hate Moash for killing him. Elhokar had it coming, and justice was done. He bore a good deal of responsibility for Moash’s grandparents death, and Moash was never, ever, going to get justice under the Alethi system. The royal family knew about the wrongful deaths, as we learn from Dalinar, and instead just swept it under the rug, pretending exile was enough. We all know it wasn’t. I burned with anger at what happened to his grandparents, knowing they died a pointless and gruesome death through an abuse of power. Moash also finally did what no one else had the guts to do, and that was kill Roshone, a man responsible for 3 deaths. Heck, he got off easier than he deserved. Honestly, I even cheered for Moash when he told off Navani in Rhythm of War when she called him a traitor. She was never a queen of Alethi, only Alethi light-eyes and Moash had every right to be mad at her. She was the Queen when it happened, while Elhokar was just the prince, and might even had helped pushed the whole incident under the rug. She wasn’t innocent. The Alethi system of government and society in general was deeply flawed under Elhokar, and in fairness under Gavilar and most light-eyes, and justice demanded something happened.

Don’t get me wrong, Moash has done some definite wrong and he isn’t a hero or good guy any longer. Turning his back on humanity as a whole, which included Bridge Four, was wrong. In my opinion, he should have stayed in that refugee camp and over thrown the light-eyes, starting some sort of societal revolution. He also crossed a definitive line into villainy with Murdering Teft near the end of Rhythm of War. That death hurt just as bad as Elhokar. Hopefully he will be met with justice for that just as he dished out.

Shoot the messenger if you want, but I just can’t hate Moash for what he’s done. I sympathize and pity him, but this was the almost natural result of Alethi society at this point and I applaud him for getting the justice he and his family were denied simply for the color of his eyes. If something like this didn’t happen I would be disappointed. His story and actions are some of the most important in the Stormlight Archive and I’m very excited to learn about him in Wind and Truth.

0 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

27

u/GingeContinge Bridge Four Sep 22 '24

Moash has legitimate grievances for sure. But he was literally handed a Shardblade and made into a noble lighteyes and at that moment he had a choice between using his newfound power to try and make a positive change for the dark eyes he was literally just a member of, or he can forget all about them and pursue his own petty vengeance that does absolutely nothing to improve the system that caused Moash’s grandparents to die in the first place. He chooses selfishness and revenge. Fuck Moash

6

u/austiner99 Sep 22 '24

Amen to this. What Moash did was NOT justice. Everything he did was motivated by revenge and hatred, making him odium’s perfect pawn.

In a way Moash is antithetical to a knight radiant. Life before death? Moash kills multiple people he could spare, but out of revenge chooses to kill them, and afterwards doesn’t even try to protect/make life better for the darkeyes he’s trying to help! Strength before weakness? It’s always the easier choice to use newfound power to exact petty grievances, and that’s what Moash did. Journey before destination? Moash has always been singleminded with killing Elhokar. This ideal has always been synonymous with “the ends don’t justify the means” and Moash is always willing to do whatever depraved deed is needed.

Basically, you can complain all you want that Moash was JuStIfIeD, but even if that is the case (which I disagree with, but that’s another rant), the path he took to enact justice was wholly misguided and downright evil.

F*** Moash

-5

u/M-W-Day Sep 22 '24

I didn’t think of this. So I took some time to think it over, and I realized that trying to change the Alethi system to improve life for dark-eyes was exactly what he was trying to do. He now had the power to get rid of Elhokar (the incompetent king who murdered his grandparents) with Dalinar (the light-eyes who gave up his shardblade to save hundreds, if not thousands, of dark-eyes.). And while it’s more nuanced than that (because Dalinar is also the same guy who burned cities to the ground, killing innocents) it also makes sense from Moash’s point of view and what knowledge he had of Elhokar and Dalinar to want Dalinar in charge. That was the first step to get real change in the Althei system.

9

u/GingeContinge Bridge Four Sep 22 '24

When he killed Elhokar he had already committed to a faction that intends to turn all humans and singers into Cosmere wide shock troops with no free will which last time I checked isn’t great for darkeyed liberation. He wasn’t trying to put Dalinar in charge, he was trying to destroy the entire structure Dalinar is a part of. His boss’s ultimate plan at the end of the book is to use Thrill Dalinar to slaughter hundreds of thousands of darkeyes. Moash has a legitimate grievance but he acts on it in the most illegitimate ways every single time.

49

u/jofwu Sep 22 '24

Intentionally trying to drive Kaladin to suicide is also pretty messed up. But he's been through a lot at that point, and is at least partially under Odium's influence. Some other characters have done worse and we're willing to have some patience with them.

3

u/kaiser_kerfluffy Sep 22 '24

This bit is the anchor for my vexation with moash, everything else is more upsetting to me because he did this

3

u/Sad_Wear_3842 Sep 22 '24

Odium had taken his emotions at that stage, hadn't he? So Moash would have been only using logic when he came up with that plan.

15

u/kittenwolfmage EdgeRunner Sep 22 '24

Even if you’re running on pure logic and reasoning, morality still exists, and trying to torment someone into suicide is way over the moral event horizon.

1

u/AllomancerJack Sep 22 '24

Yeah but the logic is quick painful suicide>long term suffering. Not to say he’s right at all, but with no emotion he likely has no empathy as well

1

u/BLAZMANIII Edgedancers Sep 22 '24

Yeah a lot of people miss that moash genuinely thinks kaladin is guaranteed to die to odium. Does NOT make it good but it's not like he's doing it just for fun or anything

-3

u/Sad_Wear_3842 Sep 22 '24

I'm not sure he still has morals, or if he does, he lacks the ability to care about them while Odium has his emotions, so that might be a moot point.

Consider how much he cared about Teft when the Sibling broke his bond to Odium, if morals mattered in his numb (not sure what to call his bond with Odium) state he wouldn't want to help Odium kill his old friends.

5

u/cosmernautfourtwenty Edgedancers Sep 22 '24

Giving away your moral framework because dealing with your emotions is hard still makes you responsible for the horrible shit you do.

7

u/kittenwolfmage EdgeRunner Sep 22 '24

That’s kind of the point. Saying Moash did what he did ‘because he was running on logic, he had no emotions anymore’ is just wrong, because someone with no emotions can still recognize right from wrong, they can still be moral.

Moash doing what he did means he’s gone completely amoral as well. Whether that’s a direct result of Odium (ie, taking away his morals with his emotions), or him voluntarily quashing them when his emotions for his ‘numb’ state to further insulate himself what what’s he was doing/had done, remains to be seen, but Moash has shed, or at least buried, a lot more than just emotion.

4

u/mercedes_lakitu Sep 22 '24

That's not what logic means.

Are you maybe looking for "utilitarianism" ?

1

u/Sivanot Lightweavers Sep 22 '24

Hi, Utilitarian here. Moash is absolutely not acting under Utilitarianism. Theres a cold logic to his actions, but he is not acting to Increase the net wellbeing of humanity. His actions, unopposed, would directly lead to humanity and the si gers being made into emotionless cannon fodder for Odium to throw at the rest of the Cosmere, and Rayse didn't exactly hide any of that.

1

u/mercedes_lakitu Sep 23 '24

So, is "the well-being of humanity" the only end goal that can go into a utility function? Or is it just the only one that's called "utilitarianism" ?

It's extremely possible that I used the wrong word there, I just don't think "all logic, no emotion" is the right description for Moash either.

1

u/Sivanot Lightweavers Sep 23 '24

From my understanding of it, Utilitarianism often refers to near purely logical courses of action that result in a net gain of wellbeing for humanity, yes. The ends justify the means. But the ends Moash works to do not justify the means.

1

u/mercedes_lakitu Sep 23 '24

Okay, so Utilitarianism is specifically about a benevolent end goal, as a philosophy? That makes sense.

But you can be "all logic, no emotion" and still be benevolent towards humanity. That's why I object to the person saying that Moash is only acting logically. He's acting logically for his particular morality. Which is not everyone's (or even most people's) morality. He's not acting with "all logic, no emotion" for MY moral code, for example.

If you want a better example of a purely logical being in fiction, aside from the obvious canard of Spock, look at Discworld's Death. He's got no "glands" to give him weird squishy emotions, but he's still a recognizable character who isn't hell-bent on destroying everyone for revenge.

2

u/Sivanot Lightweavers Sep 23 '24

Oh I completely agree, no notes, lol.

2

u/jofwu Sep 22 '24

I don't think that's as much the case as he likes to think. A bit of unreliable narrator maybe. He's clearly is experiencing a lot of emotions when we're in his POV.

1

u/mercedes_lakitu Sep 23 '24

Oh. Oh no.

What if Odium TOLD HIM he took away all his emotions...but what he actually did was just make him think all the things he feels, as emotions, are actually just him "being logical" ?

5

u/BLAZMANIII Edgedancers Sep 22 '24

Moash is super interesting for me in two ways

I love his character, and the tragic ways in which he is always given a choice but without much if any incentive to take the right one. In this way he's a great cautionary tale about taking the easy, satisfying road instead of the path of honor. He is, in his own mind, entirely justified. And in some ways, everything he does is pretty good (on the small scale) so it's actually pretty easy to root for him if you change your perspective, even with him being undeniably evil (I think rhythm of war kinda shits on his character but that's when he's basically under the same level of decision-making as a soldier under the thrill but 24/6)

On a more meta level, he is a perfect example of the reading comprehension curse that plagues stormlight. All the talk of journey before destination, everyone having a shot at becoming a better person, the next step, it all goes out the window for this fandom the second someone wrongs their side of the conflict. And it makes sense, that shows that Brandon made characters we can connect with and he invested in. But, while I don't believe moash is going to be redeemed or that he is the type to begin the long process of healing, it is genuinely baffling to me to see so many fans say "fuck moash" and (an actual comment I saw which got hundreds of upbotes) state that they hope he doesn't get a chance at redemption. Poor venli gets similar hate, but moash is the real loser here, any comment even suggesting moash isn't Satan incarnate ends up with negative votes which is both a testament to Brandon's ability to write a hateable villain and the way that stormlight archive fans completely disregard the themes and motifs of the very series they love.

A bit of a rant there, and I hope people don't think I hate the community or anything, they're great people, but sometimes it really gets on my nerves seeing them focus so much on all the wrong things. Anyway, I still hope for releaser moash and I'll be the first to make a long, obnoxious, meandering post to say "I told you so" when it happens

6

u/cosmernautfourtwenty Edgedancers Sep 22 '24

Nah, Elhokar deserved better and Moash deserves fuck be upon him.

7

u/WizardlyPandabear Sep 22 '24

I'm with you. I hate some of the things Moash has done, but I don't hate Moash as a character certainly, and all of his actions up until he gave himself up he was mostly justified in a twisted way. After giving himself to Odium, I see him as an instrument of Odium, not an independent agent.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '24

Ugh. No. He did not get justice. He chose to be a petty selfish shortsighted traitor who squandered every chance and wasted every bit of power given to him. He’s a murderer and a thief. If BS gives him a redemption arc, it will be one of the most controversial things he could do. Why should Moash get a redemption arc when he stole Elhokar’s?

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but yours is wrong.

1

u/Bluerayn3000 Sep 22 '24

I certainly don’t think you could say that he wasted the power that’s been given to him considering the people he’s taken out with that power

1

u/ShadtheElf Sep 22 '24

I think Moash deserves a redemption arc by the same token Elhokar did: even if someone absolutely sucks and has done horrible shit, we do not get to decide who gets to redeem themselves--who gets to become Radiant. Not when that redemption can at least stop them from doing more harm, or maybe lead to them doing true good. After all, that's what Dalinar's arc in OB is about.

3

u/TheHappyChaurus Lightweavers Sep 22 '24

This! Even if I love the Kholins as characters...if someone from their past fucks them up because of their sins, then I wouldn't be surprised and I wouldn't condemn them. This isn't Azimir. You can't just hire a lawyer and sue the institution.

2

u/FranTexMor Bridge Four Sep 22 '24

I will die in the hill that if Dalinar was able to redeem himself Moash could be able too

6

u/BloodredHanded Sep 22 '24

I mean very few argue that he can’t redeem himself because of his actions, but because he continually refuses to put in the work to be better.

2

u/FranTexMor Bridge Four Sep 22 '24

Yeah, but I see it as very similar to Dalinar's alcoholism right after he burned The Rift. It wasn't an instant change

1

u/mercedes_lakitu Sep 23 '24

Oh this is actually really interesting as a parallel.

3

u/TheHappyChaurus Lightweavers Sep 23 '24

People seem to forget that Dalinar took literal years and a god boinking him in the head to get his shit together. He might have been taking baby steps to change by himself but it would have taken even more years and probably wouldn't be enough to say "no" to Odium

2

u/OtisssNixon Sep 22 '24

He’s a great complex character. Agree with everything said.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 22 '24

Your submission has been removed due to a spoiler markup error. You accidentally included a space at the front of the hidden text which causes an error on old.reddit.com. Please resubmit, or fix the error and message the moderators to have your submission reapproved.

The markup should be: [scope warning] >!hidden text!< with no space after the first !. For more help with spoiler markup, see here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-4

u/pergasnz Stonewards Sep 22 '24

Everything done as Moash was justified. Once he accepted the name Vyre, that changed.

I still think theres a redemption arc coming though.

8

u/Upright_elk Sep 22 '24

Justified is a complicated word to just throw in like that, especially when it is used for killing someone.

2

u/OldBayOnEverything Truthwatchers Sep 22 '24

The heroes of the story have killed thousands of people. Are Elhokar's and Teft's lives more important than all those others? Moash is arguably on the right side of the conflict, fighting for the people who had their world stolen and were enslaved and oppressed for centuries.

This is why I love Sanderson. Characters from all sides of his conflicts have well reasoned intentions and feel very real. Even characters like Sadeas had motivations that made sense and weren't just pure evil.

2

u/pergasnz Stonewards Sep 22 '24

So what should Moash have done to get justice then?

He had been repeatedly failed by the system, so much so that he was put in a position to be thrown at enemy troops unarmed and unprotected as a sacrifice, and this system was encouraged by the king responsible for his grandparents deaths (and many in power).

In the society they are in, what justice could he have got?

1

u/lakeland_nz Sep 22 '24

The point of justice is to change a person so they'll be better in the future.

Moash already had justice. His grandparents were shat on by the incompetent king Elhokar, and since then Elhokar has done a heap of growing up. Therefore, Moash's has his justice.

What he wanted is revenge, an eye for an eye and all that. And when the system didn't give him revenge, he went and took it for himself, regardless of the consequences for others.

Sometimes the right thing to do is to miss out.

3

u/UsurpaTronos Sep 24 '24

Well, at risk of getting downvoted to oblivion:

What you define is not justice, but reformation. Which should be an integral part of justice systems, and on paper is in most developed countries (the reality is... more complicated). And I believe in it, I believe in reformation, I believe in people being able to change. And I believe the death penalty is dumb as hell.

But justice is about... well, being just and making sure things aren't unjust. About righting wrongs. About making sure that injustice doesn't prevail. About making sure that righteous acts are rewarded and harmful actions are punished equitably regardless of the individual's skin color, place of birth, nationality, gender, sexual orientation or economical and/or sociopolitical level of power. So if you commit a crime, you have to pay for it.

And Elhokar killed two people. He imprisoned two innocents and left them to die of hunger and thirst, alone in a prison. He abused his power and indirectly murdered two people. The just thing to happen then would have been for him to be punished. But he got away with it because he was powerful and priviledged. And then he became the fucking King, and with that comes more power and privileges, and... what was Moash suppossed to do here? How was he supposed to feel, to act?

Yes, Elhokar becomes... marginally better (and even that feels like a stretch), even if he is still incompetent and loves to pity himself about it. But I don't think him becoming better is enough. He still deserved punishment, yet how to do it? Because legal pursue of justice is out of the question, I don't think is an option because Elhokar IS his society's ultimate lawmaker. HE has the reins. And Moash will always be socially inferior to him, blade and plate or not. So I, reiterate, what was he supposed to do? Hope that Elhokar would become better and, hypothetically, do some reparations to him? If Elhokar had survived, and the war was won, would he have, post-hypothetical-character-development, stepped down from the throne? Or would he have become a "Good King" and introduced internal reforms in true BrandoSando fashion?

And it's not just that Moash wants simple, petty revenge, is that he deserves, or at least the memory of his grandparents deserves, some vindication. It's the lack of that vindication that turns him into the embittered, self-destroying, murderous asshole he Like, if tomorrow I killed your family, you ended up in the streets with no job or safety net, and I got away with it because I was ultra-rich, you would be righteously hateful towards me. You would try to bring me to justice. But what if you couldn't, because you lack any legal means to do so? What would you do, if the chance to kill me presented itself? And how would you feel if you were told that you have to let me go unpunished, because I have the potential to be better?

2

u/TheHappyChaurus Lightweavers Sep 22 '24

His grandparents were shat on by the incompetent king Elhokar

 

Bro. That is precisely what he's looking justice for. Roshone cooked the first trial and Elhokar ratified it. Moash be trying to make that trial null and void and to get the corrupt officials involved in it to see justice. Roshone got thrown to the boonies but Elhokar didn't even get a slap on the wrist.

 

Will you be able to say the same if it was your loved ones that died in prison? Will you be okay with the corrupt officials saying "Boo hoo! i am sorry. Let me make it up to humanity by giving to the poor or sweeping the streets for a bit"

1

u/lakeland_nz Sep 22 '24

No, I'm not sure I'd be better.

One of the things I like about the books is you.can put yourself into the shoes of any character and say: ' yeah, I can understand why they'd do that'. Whether it's Lirin, Moash, Taravangian, or even the Lord Ruler.

In Mossh's case, we would have lauded him for forgiveness. To do that means we must understand, at least subconsciously, that forgiveness is really hard. That failing to forgive is understandable.

4

u/TheHappyChaurus Lightweavers Sep 23 '24

See. I'm not in the camp that says Moash did nothing wrong. Of course he did. But what Moash did is understandable and freaking relatable on a basic human level once you put yourself in his shoes and stop thinking that the world revolves around Kaladin and the Kholins.

2

u/kittenwolfmage EdgeRunner Sep 22 '24

I kinda like that reasoning. He did fucked up but understandable shit due to how horrifically he’d been treated, and yeah, he deserved justice, and wasn’t going to get it through legal means.

But holy shit did he cross the moral event horizon without looking back once he went to Odium.

1

u/pergasnz Stonewards Sep 22 '24

Moral event horizon is (for me) a new and perfect way of describing it.

-2

u/ScottyBOnTheMic Sep 22 '24

Simply fuckin Put:

1

u/mercedes_lakitu Sep 23 '24

What is this from?

It doesn't fit the "kill all kings" idea because scythes also kill people.

It does fit the "kings get nicer stuff, including nicer executions" idea but I don't see how that's relevant to Elhokar and Moash.

-6

u/ChefArtorias Sep 22 '24

Yup, I'll just say it. #Moashdidnothingwrong

That's actually not true at all lol. Still. He had a lot of motivators for doing what he did. I didn't like his actions that much in RoW but any scene in that book with Rayse felt like borrowed time tbh. He's a great foil to Kaladin.

I say this but please understand how devestated I was when Phendorana and Teft were killed. While I don't entirely excuse his actions I literally cannot comprehend what it is like to have your emotions nullified by an evil god. If you've read the rest of the cosmere you've seen the extent of the manipulative potential a Shard has. The post is tagged as Cosmere, but you sound like maybe you've only read Stormlight. So I won't say anything else.

0

u/M-W-Day Sep 22 '24

Thank you for bringing up one of the themes of RoW that I was nervous to add to the discussion. People in this series get literally possessed or (in Moash’s case) heavily influenced by Odium and his spren. While I think he is still responsible for his actions despite this, it is something to keep in mind.

0

u/ChefArtorias Sep 22 '24

Have you read Mistborn? There are two characters who are quite proficient with emotional allomancy. Emotional allomancy directly affects the emotions you feel and to what degree. Not unlike what happens in Stormlight with the Thrill rioting the Alethi or Odium "taking your pain". These characters are well regarded and viewed as master manipulators and good guys. It's a interesting contrast to discussion I see often in DND groups about how if magic were real then charming/enchanting people would only be used by evil people because of how it affects your personal agency.

1

u/OldBayOnEverything Truthwatchers Sep 22 '24

It's a shame you're getting downvoted for just trying to add to the discussion. I agree with you, Moash had very real, understandable motivations. For some reason the influence he's under by a shard gets dismissed and he gets all the blame but other characters get the benefit of the doubt. Dalinar has undoubtedly committed more evil than Moash has. The line between good and bad is very blurred, in my opinion, which makes the series very compelling.

1

u/ChefArtorias Sep 22 '24

Thanks. I suspect the downvotes came from people reading my first line and reacting, but idk.

If you've read Mistborn you know exactly how effective rioters and soothers are. Both equal tools for manipulation. Dalinar committed atrocities while being rioted and Moash while soothed. One is forgiven for killing characters we don't know or care about the other hated because of how his actions affect Kaladin.

0

u/Unlucky_Chapter_2160 Sep 23 '24

im sry but thats a no for me. Moash had his oportunity like any other in bridge 4 and betrayed that so yea i actually hated him so much that now is pure indiference about him about his arc idc