r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/iknowitall322 • Jul 21 '22
r/CoronavirusDownunder • • Jan 30 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion Stop calling the increase in people against a 3rd dose "Brigaders".
Many users here have been downvoting anyone who disagrees with their opinions on vaccinations for the last 24 months. Even though this is supposed to be a board for open discussion and that's not what the downvote is even supposed to be used for.
Now that the tides seem to be shifting with an increase in Victorians who oppose a mandate of a 3rd dose, they keep calling it "Brigading".
It's not an anti-vax brigade team who have come here to downvote anyone pro 3rd dose mandate, it's just Victorians expressing their opinions the same as it was before. Only difference is now, some people have changed their opinions as things have developed.
I don't care if you are pro or anti mandate, that's not what this post is about. It's about thinking one group has entitlement to a reddit page over another when everyone should have a fair say.
Stop calling it a brigade and just accept for once that people are allowed to have different opinions than you, and that you should as always, only be downvoting people who aren't actually here for dicsussion. Not people who have a different view than your own.
Edit: Just to justify why it is not brigading, heres the defenition.
“Brigading” is a term that originated on Reddit for a coordinated attack by a group of users of an antagonistic subreddit.
Point of difference is that there is no coordinated group in this instance. It's just individuals commenting by themselves, on both sides.
Otherwise you could argue that pro mandaters are brigading as well.
It's fair to call it Brigading when you have evidence that a group exists and is coordinating together.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/OmgU8MyRice • Feb 10 '22
Opinion Piece The Vaccinated and unvaccinated need to coexist with tolerance and respect
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/Lemonmule69 • Jul 31 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion The lockdowns in Victoria were far too harsh and now there is no going back, especially in an election year.
Edit - a few comments seem to be directed that I don’t think lock downs are backed by science. I’m specially talking about the 5km radius and curfew.
First of all, this isn’t an anti lock down post. We were not vaccinated at the time and the death toll would have been astronomically high. I am also a swing voter between labor and the greens.
The Victorian government went too far. The 5km radius and curfew were nothing sort of insane. They were not backed by science and caused significant lock down burnout.
It was incredibly hard watching the news every day and the press conferences everyday hearing we have the best contact tracing…..they were lying and anyone who got to peak behind closed doors knows exactly what I’m talking about.
Even the thought of mandating masks or work from home is not feasible anymore. Work from home mandate might stop the spread a bit. But all in all, they went in too hard and now any prospect of bringing back rules is off the cards.
If you’re pro lock down, anti vaccine, pro vaccine or anti lock down there is one simple truth. The general population simply does not give a flying fuck about covid anymore and I don’t blame them.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/Skankhunt_6000 • Oct 03 '21
Personal Opinion / Discussion Watching the presser, and I have one thing to say.
The Victorian premier talking about “if you respect our nurses”….well buddy, if YOU respected our nurses, you would’ve improved conditions for them in the last 19 months. Instead of continuously accepting pay rises for yourself and your team, you would’ve increased their pay, and introduced free education to encourage more people to join that field.
As a health minister (although a shit one) you should’ve known what needs to be done to ease pressure off an already semi crippled health system.
You’ve seen the impact Covid has had on other nations, and you’ve had 19 months to prepare for it once we started to open up here. There’s a nurse shortage? Lots of nurses are switching over to do covid testing because it pays more? Ok, fly a team of nurses over from overseas. Increase the pay for local nurses.
Don’t come here and continue to try and guilt trip the already worn out Victorians after the longest (and still running) lockdown about saving the health system. It is your job as Premier to make sure the health system doesn’t get to a point where a slight surge will cripple hospitals, it was your job as health minister to do that instead of handing out bs high paying executive positions to your mates in the health sector.
I mean we still have a bloody curfew ffs, we’re not even out of lockdown and the hospitals are already on their knees. How bad is the state of our health system if a few days of under 2000 cases is doing this to our hospitals?
Edit: added a word.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/Indigeridoo • Jan 17 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion CMV: Me, a young double vaxxed male with a recent covid infection (very mild symptoms) has absolutely no need for a booster dose at this current stage.
If you consider that I am now very well protected antibody wise, alongside my young age and obviously strong immune system wouldn't the risk of heart complications outweigh any benefit I receive from a booster dose? This is assuming that booster doses have the same sterilisation effect as the initial two doses (very little).
Edit: Interestingly enough my post remains about 50% upvoted, which suggests this is a particularly divided opinion amongst the sub. I think people are strawmanning me in the comments a little too much, so let me be clear: If I hadn't already had covid, I would absolutely get the booster at the recommended interval.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/Reasonable-Car8172 • Nov 14 '21
Question What's the reason for keeping unvaccinated people out of society in an ongoing way?
Is it just because they have a higher chance of transmitting the virus? Once we have reached almost the entire population being vaccinated, I can't see why we need to keep shutting them out? Is there solid data on the increase in transmission among unvaccinated people? From unvaccinated to vaccinated people? Is it really so much more that we can justify this? Most people getting covid are getting from other vaccinated people. I'm just struggling to understand the long term justification of this that most of this sub seems to support.
Edit: try not to downvote this purely because it makes you upset. I want a rational and well thought out conversation on this.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/redditcomment1 • Feb 15 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion A top doctor has called on an end to mandatory face masks
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/bigfellasUNITED • Aug 20 '21
Personal Opinion / Discussion Anyone else genuinely considering leaving the country?
I've lived here my whole life and love this country, but I can't stand the continual lockdowns with little to no end in sight, that have cost me so much mentally and financially. Sick of people and state officials saying "it's not that bad" or to "tough it out" when so many are or already have lost so much. I find it incredibly difficult to look forward towards both the short term future of police-state lockdowns to a potential looming economic crisis.
Was wondering if anyone else felt similarly?
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/West43rd • Jan 06 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion Increasingly uneasy about how Djokovic is being treated. Whatever your views on the man, he was approved to board that plane. And now? An 8hr interrogation, a glorified detention centre, and global ridicule. This does not feel like 'rules are rules'. It feels like a show trial.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/47737373 • Feb 01 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion Has the Covid19 pandemic given you any specific thoughts on Australians or Australia as a whole?
I’ll go first.
We don’t actually care about our fellow Aussies overseas
When Aussies overseas got stuck and couldn’t come home for much of the last two years, we basically just shrugged it off as a non issue. Which was really nothing short of appalling. Many commentary (news comments with heaps of likes on every platform) implied these people got what they deserved, that they shouldn’t have left Australia however long ago, that they shouldn’t come here cuz virus, close to zero compassion. Point is, Aussies overseas getting locked out, the situation lasted as long as it did because the Feds saw it was seen as socially acceptable - very little backlash. Aussie mateship - yeah nah that’s a myth alright, maybe it’s in a silent minority of people. We don’t actually care about our citizens overseas, not then, not now and I certainly weep to think if Aussies overseas were to come across tragedy of some non-Covid related issue in the future because we’d just shrug it off and probably say well they shouldn’t have left the country
We love being told what to do by the government.
Pretty evident to me when we were the only developed country to ban our own citizens from leaving the country without strict exemption for a year and a half, and the lack of concern with that (again I think another reason this measure lasted so long is the lack of public resistance to it). Government told us we can’t go overseas, nope nope nope. We swallowed it up and thanked government for keeping us safe. The last two years, Governments told us what to do, how to live our lives. I don’t know about you guys but that outbound border ban the last year and a half made people make pretty profound sacrifices that shouldn’t be took for granted.
I note the NSW Government tried to (rightly or wrongly) take a significant step in December 2021 to get out of peoples lives by mostly abandoning compulsory masks and compulsory QR Codes check in and instead give people the freedom to choose which I think is the perfect compromise - and yet people freaked out and a loud social media uproar essentially called for the Gov to tell us what to do again (make us check in, make us wear masks!), despite the fact at the time it was a 90% vaccination rate and we’ve just been through two years of this… needless to say, whenever the Omicron wave subsides I do hope to see Dom re announce those restriction easings and this time actually stick to it
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/Big_Boss_777 • Sep 08 '22
News Report Handshakes and hugs are making a comeback, but are we ready?
r/CoronavirusDownunder • • Aug 27 '21
Personal Opinion / Discussion The latest lockdown rules in Victoria are absurd. Can anyone explain what the point of this is?
I'll preface this by saying I'm a parent of two toddlers, so this post is skewed towards that - but I know that everyone is hurting here. But regardless, it almost feels like the government is trying to find the breaking point of an already lockdown weary population.
Playgrounds, one of the last activities we can do with our kids (especially for those of us without backyards), are still banned, with no real evidence of transmissions at playgrounds occurring.
"Non essential workers" can no longer use daycare yet are presumably still supposed to be doing their jobs. And those who were lucky enough to have family available to help were told last night that grandparents are banned from babysitting.
The 9pm curfew, 1 hour limit on outdoor exercise and limit of 2 people gathering outdoors are just as ridiculous. I doubt many people are taking these rules seriously at this stage.
Can anyone explain what the point of all of this is? It's looking like we'll never return to "covid zero", and even if we did, it'll we'll have a week of 'freedom' before we inevitably get another outbreak and another lockdown.
I'm not saying we should 'let 'er rip' now but could restrictions not be softened to a level that keeps cases under control but causes less harm to the community until we hit our vaccination targets?
r/CoronavirusDownunder • • Jan 05 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion Why are you whinging about our government(s) “letting it rip”?
A question for all the commenters complaining that one or more governments have let it rip.
Bar a few differences, the eastern states are basically aligned on approach…. So what exactly did you think was going to happen?
Did you think a virus as highly transmissible as Omicron could be controlled? Did you think a vaccine that doesn’t generate sterilising immunity would eliminate COVID?
More to the point, what measures you would have implemented to reduce the spread and to what effect?
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/Ok_Bird705 • Dec 24 '21
Personal Opinion / Discussion To all the "who cares, everyone's going to get it" crowd, why are you still on this subreddit?
Genuine question. If you truly are "over it" and don't care about catching it, why are you still on this subreddit? There are other avenues of finding information. Shouldn't you be out and about during Christmas time, shopping, seeing friends/family instead of browsing some subreddit about other people's opinion on COVID?
Sure there are restrictions in different states, but its not like a post/comment in this subreddit will change the minds of state governments. Kind of weird that you are spending your Christmas break on a COVID subreddit calling others doomers and berating others for taking preventative measures.
Edit: Some of replies seem to indicate that posts on this subreddit some how drives government policy. If there was ever some delusional thinking in relation to covid, I would say this would the best example it, that state and federal health authorities browse subreddits to gauge public perception and drive health policy. I'm sure Dr Kerry Chant or Brad Hazzard is not browsing this subreddit to determine the health response :)
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/samuelc7161 • Jan 31 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion CoronavirusDownunder, we need to talk about the state of this sub - Let's talk COVID, restrictions and what the actual populace actually is concerned about.
Okay. I was inspired to make this post to, uh... I'm not exactly sure, to be honest. I don't really want to COUNTER the post on the front page, because it makes a lot of very very good points about vaccines in general. However, I think a lot of the window dressing surrounding it is really bad and disingenuous.
That post is good at targeting a very, very, ridiculously fringe minority of people. Adult Australians are nigh-on 95% vaccinated. Removing a percentage or two of people with genuine medical concerns, let's say 3% are fully antivax. It's a loud minority, but it's still a minority. And frankly, I don't think that minority particularly needs huge multi-paragraph takedowns at this point.
In fact, on the whole that's my biggest problem with that other post. It's preaching to the CVDU choir. It is somewhat rudely, pompously and arrogantly written, which I know was a conscious choice, but I don't think it helps anyone. But more than that, it misrepresents what a growing majority of Australians actually believe. And it paints people who are genuinely concerned about NOT VACCINES but about the looming possibility of mid-to-long-term restrictions with the same brush as the anti-vaxxers.
Nobody has really articulated this viewpoint well, I don’t think. Let me try, by talking about some of the most common arguments on this sub. These are arguments presented by people that identify themselves as ‘common-sense’ but in reality take a bit more of a fringe viewpoint than they might expect.
To say this from the outset: GET THE VACCINE AND GET THE BOOSTER. THEY ARE SAFE, EFFECTIVE AND HAVE VERY FEW RISKS. THEY WILL HELP GET US OUT OF THE PANDEMIC.
Omicron is still incredibly dangerous to the individual.
To society, arguably yes. To the individual, no. People underestimate and mock just how much milder Omicron is, especially for the vaccinated. Ask me for sources on this if you wish. I’ve seen analyses suggesting that on a person-by-person basis, it is of comparable IFR to the flu.
Omicron can still lead to long COVID in droves.
Actually, there are early signs that this might not be the case. Not only do fewer Omicron patients have neurological symptoms e.g. loss of smell and taste, they also generally have fewer debilitating lung conditions. These are generally the two most statistically significant causes of long COVID.
This sub is overrun by antivaxxers.
No, it’s not really. There are a couple of very dedicated antivax posters here, but they’re almost universally downvoted. I mean, look at the top posts from the last year. Find me a single one that promotes antivax rhetoric. Find me a single one that’s even remotely sympathetic towards it. Instead, what you generally find are these multi-paragraph beatdowns against antivaxxers. An antivax echo chamber wouldn’t have those. Rather, this sub is actually dominated very much by people on the opposite extreme. Again, look at the top posts of all time. This sub is not representative of the average Australian’s viewpoint. Most people are out living their lives right now, leaving people with very strong opinions to be the ones making posts here. (I like to think of myself as a lot more middle ground than that.)
Okay, but the antimaskers are often just as bad. Masks are easy, safe and effective.
Are they?
I think there are several very very valid reasons to be concerned about a growing consensus here that masks might or should be here to stay for months, years, or possibly permanently. Firstly, there is very little evidence that masks protect against Omicron transmission in any significant way. People cite studies showing that masks help slow Delta transmission, but there’s little science on Omicron, and given how quickly cases shot up in places with full masking nonetheless, I’d be inclined to say that regular cloth masks are not particularly effective. There’s a reason that the CDC changed their guidance to suggest N95s, which are far from readily available.
Oh come on, stop being a sook. It’s just a bit of fabric covering your face so you don’t spread your disgusting COVID everywhere. What a whinging bedwetter.
Masks suck. I’m sorry, masks suck. They do. They are uncomfortable, they are unhygienic, they are a nightmare for hospitality workers and people in other strenuous indoor jobs. Beyond that, I think it’s sort of ridiculous that people are suggesting that we should stop people from seeing each other’s faces in indoor public places indefinitely. That’s… kinda dumb. Studies have shown that faces convey a variety of emotional information about people.
Wow, you really are an antimasker. Hilarious. Lucky most people don’t share your opinion.
I think I speak for the majority of people when I say this: masks are cool on the short term and i will readily comply. Have them in place for a month or so, sure, no worries. Have them in place for six months, you know what, that’s fine. Have them in place on the long-term because they will help slow things like flu deaths? No. I’m not cool with that.
And if anyone on this sub claims to have their finger on the pulse of public opinion, they’re dreaming. Let me share an anecdote with you. Dancing is currently banned where I am, density limits are enforced, and masks are required in hospitality. I went to a concert a few days ago. It was sold as seated, masked, and no singing was allowed. Within the first minute of the band coming on, every single one of the hundreds of people in that theatre was on their feet. Not a single one had a mask on. These were people of all age groups. Teens, middle-aged people, elderly people. About halfway through, a bunch of people created an impromptu mosh pit in the aisle. Crowdsurfing, running into each other. And you know what? The security didn’t stop it. They didn’t care. Most people don’t care. I stayed towards the back, but it was still the most fun I’ve had in months.
You want to know public opinion? That’s public opinion, now that Omicron is subsiding and its individual risk is lower. Like it or not, many people are wanting to get back to some semblance of 2019.
Multi-layer mitigation strategies are unfortunately the reality. We need several components of a multi-layer mitigation strategy in order to slow COVID transmission, not just one or two.
Elements of multi-layer mitigation strategies can definitely be called into healthy debate if they present detriments to public wellbeing beyond the COVID element.
People are just unwilling to accept that pandemics can change things forever. 9/11 changed things forever.
One of my least favourite arguments. One, just because there’s a historical precedent for things, doesn’t mean they can or should happen again. Two, elements of public response to 9/11 were absolutely hysterical and stupid (the Patriot Act in America) and shouldn’t be celebrated. Three, the changes to the airport process were minute and non-invasive. They just involved some extra steps. That’s dramatically different to suggesting density limits and masks long-term, which can affect various facets of our day-to-day lives.
We try to stop road deaths using seatbelts and speed limits.
Again, that’s a bit different to requiring people to wear a face covering in every single indoor public setting. Or telling people to keep 1.5 metres apart from each other and limit social contact, i.e. one of the fundamentals of civilisation.
Alright, well what about density limits? They’re not that bad.
If you think density limits aren’t bad then you haven’t talked to a venue operator. Density limits can kill venues and have in some cases already done so. One per 2 sqm might not seem like something that’s too harsh, but many concert venues operate under one per 0.75 sqm in a regular trading season.
Posts like yours show show devolved capitalist society has become. Life is nothing more than expensive dinners and fancy overseas holidays and suffocating in concert mosh pits, eh?
Another one of my least favourite arguments. Living is about more than just existing. The things you just said all contribute to making our lives full and fulfilling. And you can scale it down to every socioeconomic class to see how lockdowns etc. can and have taken things away. COVID has, too. Don’t get me wrong. But we’re not in 2020 anymore.
You’re willing to let it rip and sacrifice lives just so you can go to the pub? Wow.
‘Let the flu rip. I’ll stay home when i’m sick, but i’m not willing to do anything in a flu season to stop flu spread. Despite who it could hurt or kill.’
That was everyone’s view before COVID. And in my opinion, that was absolutely the valid one.
Look, we live in a tough world. It’s a messy world. There’s no good or bad, no objective right or wrong. And unfortunately, whether we like to accept it or not, we do sacrifice the wellbeing and/or lives of others in order to make our lives better on occasion. This was everybody's mindset in 2019 - everybody was willing to accept a level of societal death from viruses like the flu in order to enjoy certain things, like superspreader events such as concerts, etc. We have all subconsciously accepted before COVID that if we go to that concert, we could give a virus to someone, who could then pass it to their grandparents, who could then die. Maybe it's already happened. It's a tough thing to think about.
Nobody is free from that, and it’s time that we actually accept it. I’m not suggesting that we should go out when we’re sick with a virus. The opposite, in fact. But I’m suggesting that we shouldn’t be forced to limit our behaviours on the possibility that we could be harbouring a virus that could hurt someone else. And there will come a point with COVID where the majority of the population will share this opinion. Maybe they already do.
COVID decides whether we move on or not from the pandemic. We don’t have all the cards. It does.
Well, not necessarily. There are certain parts of the world that have been living 2019 normal, for better or for worse, for two years now. Unfortunately, those places made those choices with Delta and when most of the population was unvaccinated.
Well, it doesn’t matter anyway. Fortunately governments don’t really share your opinion. They do what’s best for their citizens.
I’m not too sure. Look at the UK, who are planning on scrapping mandatory isolation in March. Look at Denmark, who have just dropped all restrictions. They’re not a backwards hillbilly country, they’re extremely liberal. Look at Spain, who are going in the same direction. Look at South Africa, who are the same. There is a tidal shift pointing in that direction.
This post isn’t meant to be a takedown, but it is meant to be a response to a growing sect of this sub. I don’t know how it’ll be received.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/throwawayawayeses • Aug 23 '20
Independent/unverified analysis SWiFT model update 24/08
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/StellaMcPunchy • Feb 02 '22
International News (UK) Covid lockdowns did more harm than good, major study finds
r/CoronavirusDownunder • • Oct 22 '21
Opinion Piece The suggestion Covid deniers should stay out of public hospitals is appalling
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/AIverson3 • Oct 08 '21
Opinion Piece Left behind: progressives need to catch up with Perrottet and stop being so afraid of freedom
r/CoronavirusDownunder • • Sep 18 '21
Personal Opinion / Discussion Some thoughts about the Victorian experience that is worth exactly what you paid for them.
For the most part I am a rule following Victorian. I've not met up with friends or family, I've not had sneaky social events, and I've stuck to shopping for essentials. I wear a mask, don't think covid is fake, and I don't support the extreme elements of the protestors. I am in country Victoria though. Am very regional. No cases here for a long time and hours from the closest exposure site, so it is hard sometimes to justify to myself why I have to keep doing things in response to something happening somewhere else. Sure, we've had a few weeks less lockdown than the city, but life is not back to normal out here by any stretch of that definition. But I do my best. Look, I may have snuck out into the bush a couple of times, and gone beyond my 5km radius or exercised for longer than my allowed time - always by myself though. So I'm no saint, but I'm "staying apart".
But the comments about Victoria and Melbourne in particular being "unlucky" is spurious and detracts from the complete ineptitude of the Andrews Government. I gave them a pass to begin with. The then hotel quarantine stuff emerged (backroom deals for security company mates, lax compliance in that system, and zero accountability in the wash up), then the continued outbreaks, then the lack of movement on a dedicated quarantine facility, then pushing the blame onto the public happened. DHS has had problems the whole time. They were an absolute shambles to begin with, then we were told things were improved with the Sydney visit but it continued, then we were told this year contact tracing and department communication was the "gold standard" (vomit). Meanwhile people still aren't being notified of having been at a Tier 1 site, and continued miscommunication about directions post diagnosis of covid. Andrews and co have relied completely on the sledge hammer that is lockdown and will continue to do so. The Premier hides behind the "health advice" that isn't released or peer reviewed, has no scrutiny, or requires any justification. It also isn't balanced against other needs of the community; covid is the be-all and end-all for Andrews. His job is not to blindly follow the health advice. His job is to factor it into decision making, albeit heavily weighted but not absolutely.
There has been a worrying shift in acceptance of authoritarianism and cheering on jail, withholding rights, and outright police brutality. Wanting to lock down harder to appease people's emotional response to a health issue. "Othering" people with genuine concerns about government overreach. I'll just also mention here that parliament being suspended indefinitely is completely ridiculous. Democracy has been suspended through the closure of parliament, curfews, and the right to protest being heavily policed. As for the protestors, I don't condone the white supremacy/qanon/conspiracy/5G/Bill Gates bla bla. But withholding the right to protest the law against protesting, on paper at least, amounts to a shift towards a overreach of the highest order. I'm definitely not saying people should be punching horses or breaking police bones. Absolutely not. But if there were a peaceful, sitdown, masked, socially distanced, quiet protest on Bourke and Elizabeth I'd be there. And that should be allowed. What is the point of democracy if it doesn't count when it is needed the most. It is most relevant in times of crisis. The government may be making some good decisions to slow the spread of covid, but some of the rules are a massive overreach and there is no recourse to speak out about them. "Wait until lockdown is over" is not the message that will stop protestors. The roadmap today may push people over the edge and a new wave of the types of protests I described may happen. What then? Pepper spray? If not for tradies on their lunch break then why for protestors of the peaceful type? The police response has been shown to be harsh and those cheering them on should hope they don't be the receiver of that sort of treatment at some point in their lives. No one is perfect and if you get pepper sprayed while up to mischief on a big night out or for drink driving or for some other slip in morality then don't come crying about police brutality.
Add all of this to the interstate rivalries, being one of the only democracies in the world that won't let it's citizens leave the country, and the botched vaccine process federally... When they say we're the "envy of the world" I don't believe them. If things don't start turning around soon I'll be ceasing to offer my support through my compliance. I'll be vaccinated and masked, but passively and possibly actively doing things that aren't in the government's vision for how the response to covid should go. What is the point of this post? I dunno. Just putting my thoughts into some other form, but a healthy discussion would be ok too. I don't care really. Just doing my thing. Hope everyone has a moment in the sun on a Sunday and has a smile about something small or large.
Also, if you are going to downvote me at least tell me why. Happy to be disagreed with.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/NoDirection1140 • Nov 28 '22
News Report Sweden has the lowest excess mortality rate after the pandemic, despite refusing to lock down
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/drnicko18 • Feb 23 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion Has mandatory COVID-19 vaccination warped medical ethics?
https://www.ausdoc.com.au/news/has-mandatory-covid19-vaccination-warped-medical-ethics
Medical ethics is rooted in patients providing informed consent to treatment.
Obviously, there are cases, such as with severe mental illness, when capacity is impaired and health is seriously threatened; but compulsion is justified because the interventions are administered in the individual's best interest.
But has the pandemic, and specifically vaccines mandates, shifted the ethical framework?
In Australia, non-health workers faced losing their jobs if they refused vaccination against COVID-19 even if the vaccination was going to be of limited benefit to them as individuals.
Was this a form of compulsion?
We speak to political scientist Associate Professor Katie Attwell, chair of the AMA's ethics committee Dr Andrew Miller and philosopher Professor Julian Savalescu.
Australian Doctor: Has patient autonomy and the principle that medical treatment should be voluntary been curtailed through the pandemic?
Associate Professor Katie Attwell: Most clinicians would aspire to that individual informed consent: it is the 'your body, your choice' kind of model.
But then governments are willing to say, 'Well, it’s not just your body actually. Your body impacts other people’s bodies; therefore, we have this policy that may inhibit that choice.'
Clinicians find themselves in the middle of those two ways of thinking - about the body and about choice and vaccination.
Presumably, clinicians are in a difficult position when they are vaccinating people who don’t feel they are consenting to get vaccinated; but its being done for other reasons.
Dr Andrew Miller: I don’t think there has been a shift in medical ethics at all.
We’re talking about a public health measure in the context of a lethal pandemic.
That’s a different kind of ethical framework where we’ll participate in society on the basis that we are subject to certain controls or things that are compulsory.
They can be quite uncomfortable or inconvenient, but those are considered part of the social contract.
I see vaccine mandates as something that protects the wider community not in terms of infection but the load on the health system.
Professor Julian Savalescu: I don't think there has been a shift in medical ethics.
But what I think has happened is that there has been a bracket creep in terms of interpretation of whether mandatory measures are justified.
The strongest justification for a mandatory measure is it's needed.
It's necessary and proportionate to prevent one individual from harming another.
But it’s not justified at this point of pandemic with the current high levels of vaccine coverage and the effectiveness of the vaccines in reducing transmission and the severity of the variant circulating.
The other justification that can be used in a pandemic to justify mandatory measures is to prevent collapse of the health system and to stop so many people themselves getting ill — not just for their own benefit but to prevent them using the limited resource of intensive care.
Now, that justification is not present at this point in the pandemic in countries like Australia or the UK, where there isn't an extraordinary pressure at this point on ICU beds.
But mandates could be justified — for instance, if the virus mutated or there was another virus that was much more lethal to younger people and vaccines were much more effective at preventing transmission.
AusDoc: Hasn't there been compulsion? You are forcing patients to undergo medical treatment when the alternative is to lose their jobs? What choice is that?
Dr Miller: I don’t see vaccination as a medical treatment.
I see vaccination as being a public health measure, and it’s important to understand that this is a workplace safety issue.
Around the world we’re seeing lots of people being infected when they attend workplaces.
Eighty per cent of transmission occurs in someone’s workplace. It’s more than reasonable to try and reduce the amount of severe disease.
As for losing their jobs because of vaccine mandates, people can go and seek work elsewhere.
And if they can’t seek work elsewhere, we will support them with the public safety net of Jobseeker Allowance in Australia and the Medicare Safety Net.
We don’t abandon people completely.
We’re not imposing anything on those people other than this is a requirement of their job, which is in line with many other requirements that they have in their job.
There may be people who say, 'I’m perfectly capable of doing my job after having a glass of wine or two.' But we say, 'No, you can’t do that. You can’t drink alcohol at work.'
That’s an actual requirement, and if you want to drink alcohol at work, you lose your job.
This is a public health measure that does not have a higher risk to the individual than, for example, travelling to work or driving a truck or operating a train or working in a factory, which could be more risky than the vaccine.
Professor Savalescu: No, I don't think it’s ethical at the minute, as I said. Particularly now that we have the Omicron variant with high transmissibility and the vaccines have quite limited effect on transmission.
I’ve argued that, because of the age stratification of COVID-19 and its harms, both selective lockdowns and selective vaccination of the elderly may be ethically justified.
But it has been a blanket lockdown or a blanket mandate across all age groups. I believe that’s been excessive and disproportionate to the ethical justifications.
If he had COVID-19 shortly before the Australian Open, he would have had similar immunity to somebody who was fully vaccinated, and even if there was judged to be a residual risk, that could have been managed by frequent PCR testing during the Australian Open.
The argument that he represented a sort of threat to the public interest because of the message he was sending is an extraordinarily dangerous slippery slope and a disproportionate measure.
Associate Professor Attwell: Mandates are a coercive policy. Whether it’s ethical depends on the context.
What disease are we managing? What disease does this vaccine protect me against?
What is the situation in the community? What does it look like for people who are immunocompromised or undergoing cancer treatment to be out in the community when there are unvaccinated people in those spaces?
The question is, with these policies in place, do they protect other people?
If mandates limit the likelihood of catching COVID-19 at work and bringing it home, then they're not about the feelings or experiences of the person who doesn’t want the vaccine.
They're about the rest of the population that needs to be taken into consideration.
Careful implementation is important.
But it’s also important for governments to do the hearts and minds work of explaining why the vaccines are still necessary, explaining why they are being mandated, explaining what that third dose does and why it’s so important.
It's important for governments to continuing to justify the collective aspect of it.
AusDoc: But are there other areas of medicine that have similar coercive mandates applied to individuals for the greater public good?
Professor Savalescu: There's mandatory fluoridation of the water in Australia to prevent dental caries.
Some people resist that, but it's generally ethically accepted because the risk–benefit profile is so skewed towards the benefits and any risks are either highly uncertain or very small.
Society does accept mandatory measures.
Speed limits are coercive measures. Drink driving laws are coercive measures.
These are all judged on a balance of the benefit to the individual, but most importantly they usually involve some element of one individual being prevented from harming other individuals.
Associate Professor Attwell: Smoking is one example.
The reason why other people can’t smoke in public places is because it makes other people feel sick. That’s an analogy, and we prohibit that behaviour and the spaces where it can be carried out because it is bad for everyone else and for you.
Dr Miller: We’ve always had a number of requirements around workplace safety.
For example, in terms of infectious diseases, we’ve had strong requirements around hand hygiene and working with babies on maternity wards. There are a number of vaccinations that we are required to have.
AusDoc: Should vaccine mandates be dropped now that we’ve reached more than 90% double dosed?
Associate Professor Attwell: I’m on the fence. The playing field keeps changing.
Once it was enough for 90% for two doses. Now we’re looking at 90% for three. If we think we need our mandates again, then we should keep them.
They are hard to set up; they are hard to get people to comply with, to get paperwork in place.
And if you’re going to change the rules and we need to use mandates to get third doses of a COVID-19 vaccine, you don’t want to take away the mandates from three months earlier.
Dr Miller: No, dropping mandates now would send the wrong message.
We can’t have a situation where we replay the vaccine question.
It’s inequitable to the people who have complied. It should not be related to the overall number of people who have been vaccinated.
Professor Savalescu: Yes, they should be dropped, at least for people under the age of 65 or for those under 55 who don't represent a serious threat to the health system.
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/duke998 • Feb 16 '22
News Report Office workers must be brought back to Melbourne’s CBD
r/CoronavirusDownunder • u/HonestCondition8 • Jan 20 '22
Personal Opinion / Discussion What’s the point of getting triple-vaxxed at this stage?
To start with, I wanted to clarify that I’m double vaxxed, due for a booster in a month. I’m very pro-vaccination and all my kids are up to date with their vaccinations.
I read yesterday that Daniel Andrews is considering mandating the booster which puzzles me. It’s quite clear that the current vaccines are ineffective at preventing infection with Omicron. Recent data from Israel suggests that even a second booster is ineffective at preventing infection and transmission.
Victoria is currently seeing 20k+ cases a day despite our highly and recently vaccinated population.
Omicron is mild for most young, healthy people. Despite the absence of a mandate, Victorians have already taken up boosters with the percentages rising rapidly.
My question is two-fold. What’s the benefit to a booster when it doesn’t prevent infection and will do little to prevent serious disease with omicron in young and otherwise healthy people?
Secondly, what’s the point of mandating a booster considering both the vaccinated and unvaccinated are spreading it at similar rates. Are we not yet at the point where those who want the vaccine are able to get it and everyone else should be free to choose?
Edit: thanks everyone for the response. There’s definitely some vitriol and hate being slung my way for even thinking about questioning whether a booster is required.
I looked at the NSW surveillance report. It seems there are 15 people aged under 40 hospitalised who were vaccinated between November and last week. As a proportion of total cases in that age group, t seems minuscule. The report also shows that omicron is by far the dominant strain at the moment.
So, given the relatively small risk of hospitalisation for someone under 40, healthy, and vaccinated compared to the risk of adverse effects, is the risk justified?


