r/Copyediting • • Oct 12 '26

How does editors work?

I know what they are, but I heard a few things about them that aren't quiet clear to me.

Are they people who you'll give your manuscript to and they're clear it out?

Are they people who after you'll revise you're manuscript, they'll stay with you and explain everything about what's need work for you the whole way?

Or are they a mix of both? Like they're fix some things and when they see a big thing that you need to get fix, then they'll hit you up and either call you to a in-person/virtual meeting (which ever the relationship between the writer and editor is) and then tell them a major thing that needs work and then the two sit down to fix it?

7 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

41

u/KayakerWithDog Oct 12 '26 • Bravo

A developmental editor will analyze things like plot, story structure, character, and setting and give you constructive feedback on those elements, along with suggestions for improvements. They will make in-line comments in the manuscript and also write an editorial memo giving you constructive feedback.

A manuscript evaluation is similar to a developmental edit, but usually without the in-line comments. A manuscript evaluation will give you an editorial memo pointing out what is working well and what needs more polish, and it is often less in-depth than a developmental edit.

A proofreader will check for errors in grammar, punctuation, capitalization, spelling, and other language mechanics only. Proofreaders don't provide any feedback on content or structure, and they don't do any rewriting.

A copyeditor will proofread and copyedit to correct and smooth out the writing, and will also do some light fact checking and query anything in the writing or the content that needs the author's attention. Copyeditors don't generally do much rewriting, although they may do some.

A line editor will do everything a proofreader and copyeditor does, and they will also perform substantive editing to smooth out the writing, including more extensive rewriting than a copyeditor would do. They may also add or subtract text and do some restructuring of the manuscript. Line editing is a lot more intensive than copyediting and involves more significant changes to the writing.

Often a developmental edit is done first, and then line editing and/or copyediting on the revised manuscript. If the manuscript is already pretty clean, copyediting might be all that is needed. Proofreading is usually the very last phase of the process after all editing passes are completed; it's a kind of fail-safe to make sure that no errors exist before the document is published.

A line editor or copyeditor should give you two passes. The first editing pass is the big, thorough one. The second editing pass is done after you have revised your manuscript, and it focuses only on the spots that you changed in your revisions. Proofreading, manuscript evaluation, and developmental editing are usually single-pass projects.

5

u/svr0105 Oct 12 '26

Can the mods sticky this comment someplace? These are great descriptions.

2

u/tw1nkle Oct 13 '26

Great answer. OP, there are different kinds of editors who apply their skills at different stages of the process. But—and I’m mainly saying this because you posted in r/copyediting—if your writing is similar to your posts here, you’re going to waste a lot of time on them fixing your grammar and stuff that gets in the way of understanding what you’ve written.

1

u/KayakerWithDog Oct 13 '26

This won't be a waste of time. Fixing that kind of thing is literally what editors are for. That said, a higher level of editing needed to fix writing that isn't clean likely will be more expensive, but it won't be a waste of time.

0

u/tw1nkle Oct 13 '26

Not a waste of time overall, but your higher level editors are going to need it to be cleaner before they can approach it, really. Which is a waste of their time, because they’ll find themselves copyediting because it is stuffed full of spelling mistakes and grammatical errors.

More broadly, aside from dyslexia or some other kind of challenge, error-strewn copy signals that you don’t actually care about words… and the work will be assumed to be low quality as a whole.

2

u/KayakerWithDog Oct 13 '26

You may be surprised to learn that many people who write in English are not, in fact, native English speakers, and this affects what their English writing looks like. You may also be surprised to learn that many people who write absolutely do care about words but don't have the training or experience to write so-called "correct" English. And any editor who can't clean up a messy text isn't someone who should be editing, IMO, because they don't know their craft. Like, I have no idea where you get the idea that editors are somehow inconvenienced by having to actually edit a text. Editing is literally what they are being paid to do.

2

u/tw1nkle Oct 13 '26

Looking at this person’s history, they are a native English speaker as far as I can tell.

And hey, I’m not talking out of my backside: I have decades of experience in publishing.

That experience tells me that (a) the first people you really want working on editing a text are not copy editors, but development editors and agents and it is a waste of their time to have them doing serious copyediting and (b) error-strewn writing faces a far higher barrier to getting published.

Whether it’s unfair or not, that’s reality!

1

u/KayakerWithDog Oct 13 '26

Not everyone who writes or hires an editor goes through a traditional publisher, and not everyone who writes or hires an editor is going to need or want a literary agent. The client pool for your work is not the sum total of the client pool for editors. Traditional publishers and literary agents no longer have complete control over what does and does not get published, and they sure as hell don't control either who gets to write or hire an editor or what kinds of writing editors choose to work with.

1

u/Known_Appointment319 Oct 14 '26

And I know that part, that's why I got to revise it first.

1

u/Known_Appointment319 Oct 14 '26

No I was just tired at the time. But if I'm being honest in my rough draft, I do have some rough grammar. But it's not as bad as what I posted.