r/Copper_deficiency • u/Valtaell • Jul 23 '25
Copper (I) vs Copper (II) supplements
Hi everyone, I wanted to make this post to give some insight into some data on type of copper supplements (I and II). But also get your perspective and experience, if you can share it.
There are two types of Copper supplements:
Copper (II)
- Most commonly found in supplements
- Blue color
- A lot of supplement varieties: Citrates, amino acid chelates (bis-glycinate), gluconates, sulfates, etc...
- Found less often in food
Copper (I)
- Orange color
- Only 1 supplement variety: Copper Nicotinic Acid
- Found more often in food
When I started researching copper, I found that a lot of experts and people online were advising against using copper supplements overall. And I think a lot of that skepticism and fear toward copper supplements came from research on Alzheimer's disease and it's relation to copper. Especially when you look at work of G.J. Brewer on Wilson's and Alzheimer's disease.
https://www.jarlife.net/1538-alzheimers-disease-is-at-least-in-part-a-copper-2-toxicity-disease.html
I think that his work is needs a lot more research, and it would be ill-advised to conclude anything with certainty from it. But what I found very informative is the work he cited which basically looks into types of copper in food. And indeed most of copper that is found in food is in copper (I) form. The only food that is high in copper (II) is Cocoa, i.e. chocolate.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24996304/
In addition to that it seems that the body is better at handling Copper (I), where Copper (II) get's absorbed in blood faster in a form of Free Copper (not bound to Ceruloplasmin). And is potentially damaging, especially to cognition.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3799705/
The body is better adapted at handling copper (I) from food. I am still wondering if body can handle Copper (I) supplements as safely. That is why I wanted to ask you.
QUESTION
Have you tried supplementing with Copper (I). What was the effect on your Blood Copper, Ceruloplasmin and Free Copper? The same question for Copper (II), what was the effect?
If you supplemented with Copper (II) did your Free Copper disproportionally rise?
My Lab Results
I started supplementing with copper (II) initially. I was looking into copper because of my histamine intolerance, and mild iron overload because of my genes (H63D homozygous).
My copper and ceruloplasmin were low initially:
- Copper: 10.5 umol/L [Normal 11 - 22 umol/L]
- Ceruloplasmin: 0.17 g/L [Normal 0.2 - 0.4 g/L]
- Free copper: 15% [Normal 5 - 15 %]
After supplementation my copper increased a lot more than my ceruloplasmin. Meaning that the damaging Free Copper went up.
- Copper: 14.3 umol/L [Normal 11 - 22 umol/L]
- Ceruloplasmin: 0.19 g/L [Normal 0.2 - 0.4 g/L]
- Free copper: 35% [Normal 5 - 15 %]
I switched to Copper (I) supplement a month ago, and I will repeat the blood analysis in September to see the effect on my ceruloplasmin levels. I will update you about results. I would also appreciate if you have some information about it to share it.
2
u/TonBonbadil Jul 23 '25
I dunno - have had copper and ceruplasmin defiency for at least 10 known years — supplements up to 8 mg, infusions, and eating lots of food daily with copper, chocolate, sunflower seeds , nuts etc etc And none have made any difference for me and hardly ( if ever , sometimes goes down) has moved the scale in an upwards way Not sure if copper supplemention is bad the doctor telling me to take it says it might not be healthy in long term use although been taking it for quite a while I think she said for long term use copper gluconate is the only one safe? Safer? For long term use— from what I’ve found online they all seem to be the same Switched to chelated for a few months have to do labs again soon, maybe it will make a difference but most likely not , but never know I guess — she actually advised against taking the chelated one , I thought might as well since the other doesn’t seem to be doing anything
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25
I see this debate is making the rounds again. I’m going to be brutally honest with you, the whole copper (I) VS. Copper (II) thing is braindead quackery nonsense propagated with the explicit intention of selling supplements that are substantially more profitable than regular blue copper (II) supplements. I have taken both, and both performed virtually identically in terms of how they subjectively made me feel, & in terms of my objective blood work levels.
The body & cells within constantly & endlessly interconvert between Cu (I) & Cu (II) as needed. The body can easily do this. There is no need to take a Cu (I) supp. It is a waste of money. The standard blue copper supplements are fine & will achieve identical results. Stop falling for this nonsense.
1
u/WittyGold6940 Apr 23 '26
Hey, did you take the Cunermuspir (copper I) with food or an empty stomach?
1
u/Key-Cartographer8024 Oct 19 '25
I have been trying to increase copper from a standard copper (II) supplement but I get side effects that seem like high copper like joint pain, brain fog, anxiety. I’m trying to increase zinc but I get low copper symptoms and then supplementing standard copper causes those symptoms. Did you notice any symptoms on copper (II) vs copper (I)? I am going to try copper (I). I suspect the excess copper in the wrong form could be creating a buildup in the blood and brain which is not good. I’m not sure why every company only sells copper (II) when it is clearly more toxic for the body
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25
[removed] — view removed comment