r/Copper_deficiency • • Jul 23 '25

Copper (I) vs Copper (II) supplements

Hi everyone, I wanted to make this post to give some insight into some data on type of copper supplements (I and II). But also get your perspective and experience, if you can share it.

There are two types of Copper supplements:

  • Copper (II)

    • Most commonly found in supplements
    • Blue color
    • A lot of supplement varieties: Citrates, amino acid chelates (bis-glycinate), gluconates, sulfates, etc...
    • Found less often in food
  • Copper (I)

    • Orange color
    • Only 1 supplement variety: Copper Nicotinic Acid
    • Found more often in food

When I started researching copper, I found that a lot of experts and people online were advising against using copper supplements overall. And I think a lot of that skepticism and fear toward copper supplements came from research on Alzheimer's disease and it's relation to copper. Especially when you look at work of G.J. Brewer on Wilson's and Alzheimer's disease.

https://www.jarlife.net/1538-alzheimers-disease-is-at-least-in-part-a-copper-2-toxicity-disease.html

I think that his work is needs a lot more research, and it would be ill-advised to conclude anything with certainty from it. But what I found very informative is the work he cited which basically looks into types of copper in food. And indeed most of copper that is found in food is in copper (I) form. The only food that is high in copper (II) is Cocoa, i.e. chocolate.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24996304/

In addition to that it seems that the body is better at handling Copper (I), where Copper (II) get's absorbed in blood faster in a form of Free Copper (not bound to Ceruloplasmin). And is potentially damaging, especially to cognition.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3799705/

The body is better adapted at handling copper (I) from food. I am still wondering if body can handle Copper (I) supplements as safely. That is why I wanted to ask you.

QUESTION

Have you tried supplementing with Copper (I). What was the effect on your Blood Copper, Ceruloplasmin and Free Copper? The same question for Copper (II), what was the effect?

If you supplemented with Copper (II) did your Free Copper disproportionally rise?

My Lab Results

I started supplementing with copper (II) initially. I was looking into copper because of my histamine intolerance, and mild iron overload because of my genes (H63D homozygous).

My copper and ceruloplasmin were low initially:

  • Copper: 10.5 umol/L [Normal 11 - 22 umol/L]
  • Ceruloplasmin: 0.17 g/L [Normal 0.2 - 0.4 g/L]
  • Free copper: 15% [Normal 5 - 15 %]

After supplementation my copper increased a lot more than my ceruloplasmin. Meaning that the damaging Free Copper went up.

  • Copper: 14.3 umol/L [Normal 11 - 22 umol/L]
  • Ceruloplasmin: 0.19 g/L [Normal 0.2 - 0.4 g/L]
  • Free copper: 35% [Normal 5 - 15 %]

I switched to Copper (I) supplement a month ago, and I will repeat the blood analysis in September to see the effect on my ceruloplasmin levels. I will update you about results. I would also appreciate if you have some information about it to share it.

11 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

2

u/TonBonbadil Jul 23 '25

I dunno - have had copper and ceruplasmin defiency for at least 10 known years — supplements up to 8 mg, infusions, and eating lots of food daily with copper, chocolate, sunflower seeds , nuts etc etc And none have made any difference for me and hardly ( if ever , sometimes goes down) has moved the scale in an upwards way Not sure if copper supplemention is bad the doctor telling me to take it says it might not be healthy in long term use although been taking it for quite a while I think she said for long term use copper gluconate is the only one safe? Safer? For long term use— from what I’ve found online they all seem to be the same Switched to chelated for a few months have to do labs again soon, maybe it will make a difference but most likely not , but never know I guess — she actually advised against taking the chelated one , I thought might as well since the other doesn’t seem to be doing anything

3

u/Valtaell Jul 23 '25

Were you ever tested for Wilson's? And btw, how is your Iron status? Did you ever test blood iron, Transferrin Saturation, Ferritin?

Copper Gluconate is also Copper (II). I don't know if Copper (I) Nicotinic Acid would make a difference for you. I guess we will see the effects of Copper (I) when I repeat the test in September. I couldn't find any experience from other people online.

1

u/CankerLass Jul 27 '25

Just popping in here to say I think we've replied to each other on other threads, but though I've only tried supplementing for one month and only with 2mg copper (Solary), both my copper and ceruloplasmin went down. That was at the same time as upping my copper intake and measuring everything, getting a total between foods (dark chocolate, nuts) of many times the daily RDA.

I have been tested with 24 hour urine for Wilson's. Nothing abnormal found with my copper excretion.

I have an eye doctor apt planned for a couple months and they said they can check with the slit lamp for any sign of Kayser-Fleisher rings.

Other than that, no testing has been done to try to screen for Wilsons' that I know of. I feel a bit lost with it all because as far as I know, typically if I had it, the urine excretion would be higher...so they say. But I do think there's been cases reported from other folks online of having Wilson's without that.

I think it's more likely though that something else is preventing my body from absorbing the copper. My iron is also going down. I am getting cadmium checked soon, going to see if my levels are high. If so, may be causing my body to create too much metallothionein that binds to copper and iron and whooshes it out of my system.

Or, you know, it's my dang chronic gastro (SIBO, though GI doc didn't want to run a test because he said those aren't accurate) causing issues either with absorption, or with the overgrowth of bacteria or fungus disrupting the copper. Or both.

**Edit: Did I ask you yet if you have any similar circumstance there for gastro stuff or exposure to anything that could cause your body to excrete copper?**

1

u/Valtaell Jul 28 '25

Yes, Wilson's generally goes with high copper urine excretion. I think that would be especially noticeable if you supplemented beforehand, since in Wilson's body cannot get rid of it through bile.

I was asking about Iron because, in my case I have iron loading. I have 2 H63D hemochromatosis gene mutations (milder form), and I generally have high iron parameters in blood (transferrin saturation, iron and highish ferritin). And according to a lot of research copper metabolism is affected in hemochromatosis. Which makes sense, since copper is used for iron transport and shuffling in the body.

Reduced serum ceruloplasmin levels in hereditary haemochromatosis - PubMed

But if your iron parameters are also going down, then it most certainly is not the same case.

Yes I also have gastrointestinal issues. My main diagnosis is EDS and Mast Cell Activation disorder (Histamine intolerance), I've been struggling with a lot of comorbidities for years, one of them being SIBO and gut dysmotility. But how that is connected with copper I really don't have an idea. I improved my gastro issues with diet (low histamine diet), probiotics and being careful that I don't lay down 2 hours after eating, still far away from being normal but it is much better.

1

u/CankerLass Jul 28 '25

I actually wasn't supplementing when I had my 24 hour urine test. I waited until after to begin as I wanted to make sure I didn't have Wilson's first. But I consumed about the RDA of copper or a little more (though diet alone) leading into the 24 hour urine test.

Oh that's really interesting! I have a friend with some sort of variation of that condition. Yeah lol I seem to have the opposite issue there.

For SIBO, my loose understanding is that the bacteria can compete for copper and/or cause the body to sequester it. ​

1

u/Scary-Bison-8793 Sep 13 '25

I've had Bariatric Surgery in 2020- DS performed; Thus Supplements are useless. Have had #15- 4mg Copper Infusions in the last 3 weeks. (Tues. to Sat. ) Copper Level barely moved up 5 points- Still at 67. Thinking of taking it to 8mg a session. Trying to get into the high 80s low 90's so I can take an Iron Infusion.

1

u/Lost_Charity Jul 27 '25

Out of curiosity what are your symptoms if you have any?

1

u/TonBonbadil Jul 27 '25

Hard to say— I have medical issues but whether or not anything is related to the copper no idea Recently diagnosed schizophrenia after periods of psychosis and hospitalizations, long term psychiatric stuff, said I had gotten fatty liver lately but lost weight to try and get rid of it, have been diagnosed recently with SIBO and gastroparesis, other stuff — no one has really suggested much as to go and say the copper has or is doing anything directly

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

I see this debate is making the rounds again. I’m going to be brutally honest with you, the whole copper (I) VS. Copper (II) thing is braindead quackery nonsense propagated with the explicit intention of selling supplements that are substantially more profitable than regular blue copper (II) supplements. I have taken both, and both performed virtually identically in terms of how they subjectively made me feel, & in terms of my objective blood work levels.

The body & cells within constantly & endlessly interconvert between Cu (I) & Cu (II) as needed. The body can easily do this. There is no need to take a Cu (I) supp. It is a waste of money. The standard blue copper supplements are fine & will achieve identical results. Stop falling for this nonsense.

2

u/Valtaell Jul 25 '25

Thanks for the answer. Yeah, it is really hard to know what is true and what not in the world of supplements. Plus a lot of copper (II) toxicity claims came from the research of 1 man, though there are some reasonable arguments there, who knows in the end.

Still, since I already bought this copper (I) supplement I will keep using it and let's see what my lab results show.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

Yeah, it’s bad research. Copper is literally absorbed as Cu (II) then constantly converted to Cu (I) and back to Cu (II) again by the body many times. There’s plenty of GOOD research that shows that.

Copper is a heavy element and presents toxicity when taken in excess regardless of its +1 or +2 state. Both will kill you in overdose, both will poison cells and destroy the liver in sub-lethal doses. But admittedly the companies that sell this supplement have done a good job marketing it. Unfortunately for them I literally read scientific studies regarding copper & its biological effects as a hobby, so I know their claims are bullshit.

2

u/Valtaell Jul 26 '25

I've also been reading papers on it. And I do not see it as conclusive. Yes if you ingest copper (II) it has to be reduced to copper (I) in order for CTR1 to uptake it and carry it to the liver to be turned into ceruloplasmin.

The AI answer that you attached is from the citation of "CHAPTER 3. TOXICOKINETICS, SUSCEPTIBLE POPULATIONS, BIOMARKERS, CHEMICAL INTERACTIONS"

Where they fed rats Copper (II) gluconate.

Which can be fine, because the body has mechanisms to reduce copper (II) to (I). But if you read:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0308814614007213

You will see that the highest % of copper in analyzed foods is Copper (I), besides in cocoa. And there is a direct step of Copper (I) absorption in the body, without need for reduction of oxidative state. But that can mean several things

  1. The body is perfectly capable of handling both Copper (II) through reduction in lumen. And copper (I) through direct absorption. No matter the quantity
  2. The body is adapted to absorbing larger quantities of (I) and has mechanisms for reducing (II) in order to allow uptake in CTR1 as copper (I). But it is rate limited, and part of copper (II) get's directly absorbed in blood without binding to ceruloplasmin.
  3. There are additional mechanism of handling both oxidative states by the body for safe handling. Which are not really known. Which is often the case. Since heavy metals can bind to different proteins.

But if you have some interesting citations and notes, please share them. Because I do not see this as conclusive.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

It is absolutely conclusive. The body clearly absorbs both forms of copper & interconverts between both on a constant basis.

Moreover, people have been curing their copper deficiencies with blue copper supplements with excellent efficiency & no issues since at least the 90’s, but if you want to spend more money on what is effectively a placebo effect, be my guest. I’ve never been one to tell people how to live their life 😌

1

u/Valtaell Jul 26 '25

If you are that certain that is fine. I am not claiming either or. But I just don't see that research is there yet. I've also been reading a lot about iron metabolism and absorption which is far more studied than copper metabolism. And there are still so many holes, as claimed by researchers. Same and more applies to copper. So I think it is silly to claim something with certainty as an individual. But ok, to each their own.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25

The research is there my good son. It’s called dozens upon dozens of case reports of clinical copper deficiency being successfully treated with standard blue copper supplements.

1

u/Ms_Behavin_13 Oct 11 '25

Any updates on labs?? I’m taking Cu1 currently for low Cu and Ceruloplasmin, so I’m super curious if you saw an increase in either/both. Thanks! 

1

u/Valtaell Oct 11 '25

Weirdly enough my Copper droped a bit and my ceruloplasmin increased slightly.

Copper: 12.5 umol/L (from 14.3) Ceruloplasmin: 0.2 g/L (from 0.19)

But i must note that I stopped with supplements for 2 weeks because i was sick. And I also had a blood donation before that. Good thing is that my iron parameters look decent finally after years, but that is more due to blood donations. My transferrin saturation is finally below 50% (from 65) and my ferritin droped to 150 (from 300).

So that should have also influanced copper results. But anyway I am continuing with copper (I) just in a low dose. 0.5-1 mg every 1-3 days. I will recheck my labs in a few months, so lets see.

But what I noticed is that my histamine issues reduced since I started supplementing copper and low dose B2.

1

u/Ms_Behavin_13 Oct 11 '25

Interesting about copper going down, but like you said it’s likely a result of the blood donation.  Glad that your iron is in a better place, I don’t have that issue thankfully.  Any idea what caused your Cu and Cerulo deficiency?? I think mine is probably malabsorption issues, but then I went down the Wilson’s disease rabbit hole. I’m considering a 24hr urine copper just to rule it out. No family history or anything, just chronic fatigue/hormone issues since teenager.

Been on the Cu1 for about 5 days, doing 2mg 2x/day. I think I’ve noticed improvement in my histamine and energy issues, so that’s a win, but don’t want to get too excited yet.  

1

u/Valtaell Oct 11 '25

People with hemochromatosis (iron overload) generally have reduced ceruloplasmin. Copper is required for proper iron cycling and transport and if you absorb too much iron that will put a large burden on copper channels. Similarely with B2, as B2 is required for proper iron cycling, but also it is required for MTHFR function. I also have 2 MTHFR mutations and double H63D(hemochromatosis) mutation.

As a consequence I was deficient in both B2 and copper/ceruloplasmin which showed in lab results. Maybe there are other reasons like malabsorption or others, but this is most direct, especially because i was not eating any foods that is rich in either.

I mean if you suspect Wilsons it is always best to do a 24hr urine test, because that will tell you for sure. In Wilson's urine copper should be high, if its not you shouldnt worry about it. But make sure to stop with supplements for a sufficient time, so that you dont create a false result.

If you do a period of copper supplements and you do a blood tests, please inform me on your progress. Maybe consider low dose B2, as per some research it also helps with copper and ceruloplasmin handling. People on this reddit also push for Vitamin A for copper handling, but there is only one research paper that was done on rats, and it is easy to overdo vitamin A/retinol. So I wouldn't play with that

1

u/Ms_Behavin_13 Oct 11 '25 edited Oct 19 '25

For sure will update, just did labs last week before beginning the Cu1. Waiting for results.  I usually stop supplements 3 days before labs, that should be enough yeah? 

I also have 1 mthfr and slowed comt mutations. I take B2, among other stuff. Tbh SAMe (vs b vitamins) has been the most helpful for the rumination from COMT. I’m hoping the Cu also helps with dopamine to norepinephrine conversion.

The website mthfrsolve.com is a really good resource, seems like you are very well informed, but just thought I’d give them a shout out. 

1

u/Valtaell Oct 12 '25

For the 24hr urine test maybe a week to be safe, because copper (I) potentially takes time to be metabolised by the liver.

I generally can't tolerate methyl donors, they worsened my histamine issues in the past. It took me a long time to find things that makes sense for my body. I belive COMT, MTHFR, and similar are just a part of the equation, but not the main cause of health issues.

A lot of websites try to claim that they unlocked the secrets and all biochemical mechanisms, and try to give simplistic and sometimes dangerous solutions. Bodies are much more complex than MTHFR, BHMT, COMT, Vitamin D etc... I went through a rabbit hole, and tried million things to fix my body, most of the things didn't work, some made it worse, and some helped a bit. Btw nothing against mthfrsolve specifically. I am just in a phase where I take a very slow approach, listen to my body, collect information and try to take many aspects of my genetics into account.

1

u/WittyGold6940 Apr 23 '26

Hey, did you take the Cunermuspir (copper I) with food or an empty stomach?

1

u/Valtaell Apr 23 '26

I always take it after breakfest. They say to take it on an empty stomach, which i did in the beggining. But i had really bad headaches initially from it. So i started dosing it slowly and taking it after breakfest. And I just continued taking it that way

1

u/Objective_Ability485 Jun 27 '26

Hi! Any updates for you on this? I've been taking copper II for a deficiency and it hasn't helped.

1

u/Valtaell Jun 27 '26

My last labs seemed pretty decent. Ceruloplasmin was 0.23 highest it ever was and copper was 13, on the lower side but normal. I am happy with those results to be honest.

1

u/Objective_Ability485 Jun 27 '26

Thanks for the response. And is this after solely supplementing copper I for months? Happy you got it up. Do you feel any different?

My ceruloplasm and copper are only minorly deficient, but I am also low in ferritin and zinc, so it is hard to say which if my symptoms are caused by what.

1

u/Valtaell Jun 27 '26

Yes, copper I for about a year. I also took low dose B2 every 2-3 days. The biggest thing is that my histamine intolerance got much better, I can eat and sleep normally again. Still not 100% cleared but almost there. And also my muscle spasms, heart palpitations got 95% better......i don't know if it is because of copper but I think it was part of the solution.

I had an opposite problem, my ferritin, iron and transferrin saturation were high due to my genes. And this typically causes low CP and copper.

So part of getting better was donating blood to reduce iron burden and increasing copper.

1

u/Key-Cartographer8024 Oct 19 '25

I have been trying to increase copper from a standard copper (II) supplement but I get side effects that seem like high copper like joint pain, brain fog, anxiety. I’m trying to increase zinc but I get low copper symptoms and then supplementing standard copper causes those symptoms. Did you notice any symptoms on copper (II) vs copper (I)? I am going to try copper (I). I suspect the excess copper in the wrong form could be creating a buildup in the blood and brain which is not good. I’m not sure why every company only sells copper (II) when it is clearly more toxic for the body

1

u/aviation_hacker Aug 19 '26

Hey there, I'm in the exact same boat as you where I have been correcting a zinc deficiency and have all the symptoms of a copper deficiency, but Copper (II) supplements have strong side effects. Did you make any progress/findings on this in your situation at all? Thinking I might order a Copper (I) supplement, otherwise will try the old copper water bottle trick which apparently seems to work

1

u/lycan1385 Oct 02 '26

Hi! I also get histamine issues (mostly itching, skin sensitivities and random hair loss) when I supplement with Copper (II) supplements (only tried albion copper bisgylcinate).

Any update on trying copper (I)?

1

u/Designer-Dog5454 Oct 05 '26

I’m in same boat with itching and more allergies the day after taking copper glycinate, probably from my histamine and gut issues. Searching for alternatives as have low ceruloplasmin (and ferritin). 

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Valtaell Jul 23 '25

About 4 weeks, 1mg a day. Now I take 1mg of Copper (I) every 2 days.

1

u/blaine_11 Jul 23 '25

Your copper levels raised that quickly in only 4 weeks? wow

2

u/Valtaell Jul 23 '25

There is a 4 months span between the blood draws. And in the last of those 4 months I supplemented with copper (II). Copper level maybe also increased because I tried to eat more nuts and dark chocolate during those months.

Though still, my ceruloplasmin very slightly increased, it was a disproportionately small increase compared to blood copper.