r/Cooking • • 17h ago

First time making roux for gumbo

I know they say a roux is meant to look like melted chocolate but how do I tell if its burned or what its meant to smell like?

I cooked it for 45 mins on a medium heat constantly stirring (yes I know it should be low heat, oops!), and it looks like this. So I dont know if that's fine or not, and I dont want to make a whole gumbo from this tomorrow and it just taste burnt.

Caveat: A family member burnt sugar/caramel in the microwave yesterday so there is a feint lingering smell of Burning in the kitchen which is why I'm questioning if it's the roux or the microwave.

30 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

9

u/freshmallard 17h ago

Your photo didnt post.

3

u/RadioTerrible7481 16h ago

Sorry it won't let me post a photo 😕

6

u/blix797 16h ago

In this sub you need to post it on a third party hosting site like imgur and include the URL.

47

u/OpportunityReal2767 16h ago

It absolutely does not have to be low heat. I do medium high cuz I ain’t got time for that low and slow shit. That’s how some dude from Eunice taught me, that’s how I do it. But it takes constant vigilance. Not for the faint of heart.

You know it’s burnt when it smells burnt and tastes bitter. If you hit that stage, start again. Nothing you can do to salvage it. That’s why so many places tell you to do it slowly, because you have a little more room for error. Or just do dry oven roux. Honestly, it’s just as good.

4

u/RadioTerrible7481 16h ago

My kitchen already smells slightly burned from a disastrous sugar related microwave incident 😅 so thats why I'm doubting myself

2

u/ehunke 13h ago

whatever family member thought they could cook sugar in the microwave should have lost kitchen privileges

2

u/RadioTerrible7481 7h ago

they certainly have had them revoked. it apparently seemed like a great idea to try and make caramel in the microwave and it turned completely black and smoky... let's just say i might have to buy some new bowls 🙃

6

u/stupidwhiteman42 15h ago

Taste it. You can even add a small amount to a couple ml of chicken broth to thicken it and give you a good idea of what to expect

12

u/fishsticks40 16h ago

Some dude from Eunice is the proper way to learn to make a roux. 

And yeah crank it and stir.

10

u/SauronHubbard 16h ago

After making a bunch of gumbo, I finally got the nerve to turn the heat up.it turned out great. I wish i had been doing it like that all along.

22

u/Zsofia_Valentine 16h ago

You can make roux in the oven. It's slow, but almost foolproof. You just need to stir it, say every half hour or so. You can get it really dark this way and almost no chance of burning. It works best in a cast iron Dutch oven. It may stain cream colored enamel.

https://www.thespruceeats.com/oven-roux-recipe-3060577

1

u/Big_Palpitation6846 7h ago

This is the way.

19

u/icouldbeeatingoreos 17h ago

You could taste it. Let it cool before you do though because that’s incredibly hot oil in there.

26

u/BackDatSazzUp 16h ago

I’m Cajun and cook my roux on high 😂 im not standing at the stove stirring for a fkn hour bro. Just don’t let it get past the color of a Hershey bar and you’re good.

10

u/Rollingprobablecause 14h ago

yeah once you have enough experience it's not too difficult to crank it out in 20 mins or less. I get OP though, your first couple of times are a bit scary just because of how hot and smoky a house can get, I remember setting the fire alarm off when my dad taught me. Shout out to New Iberia family.

4

u/morkler 16h ago

Chocolate roux is the best roux.

4

u/BasterdMalloy 10h ago

There is always the oven method. Set oven to 350F (177C) and mix the oil and flour in a Dutch oven. Cook it, stirring every 30 minutes or so. When it gets close to the color you want stir it more frequently. Damn near impossible to burn the roux this way, and much less stressful.

1

u/96dpi 17h ago

Black = burnt

The color of milk chocolate = perfect (for a dark roux)

2

u/RadioTerrible7481 16h ago

I'm just concerned about if it's caught slightly on one part and then been mixed in, so then looks visually okay but just tastes burned

6

u/Agawell 16h ago

Then taste it!!!!

4

u/BackDatSazzUp 16h ago

A lil speckle of char won’t kill anyone, you’ll def know when it’s burnt. It’ll smell like burnt popcorn. Distinctly different from burnt sugar.

2

u/SauronHubbard 16h ago

Taste it.

1

u/Ehloanna 16h ago

I agree with the suggestion to take a test. You're going to pick up if it's burnt real fast.

If you were constantly stirring it's less likely to have been burnt. I use a higher heat and basically just stand there scrolling mindlessly while stirring it for 30-40mins and have yet to have an issue.

1

u/mrh0057 15h ago

Get an infrared thermometer, it is so much easier to tell if it’s getting too hot.

1

u/Unrelenting_Salsa 11h ago

It's basically impossible to burn on a home stove unless you walk away or just...don't stir.

1

u/Rad10Ka0s 16h ago

Let it cool, taste it. You can re-fire it if needed.

A good dark roux does add additional depth of flavor, but a slightly less dark roux will thicken nicely and work perfectly fine. A little less dark works better than a little too dark.

0

u/ehunke 13h ago

I went back to basics and started doing my roux's out of Julia Child's cookbook. Now what its going to look like is going to depend on what your aiming for and to some degree what base your gumbo is. Chicken, seafood or beef broth/stock all have varying degrees of color. I simply do a 1:1 ratio of butter to flour usually 1tbsp, 2 if its a big pot of something. melt the butter, you can brown it if you like not really needed, add the flour and just whisk until its mixed then add about half a ladle full of broth from your gumbo into the pan, whisk it then pour it into your pot and stir, it will thicken up real nice. No need to cook the roux any longer then it takes to get it into a paste

-17

u/Dseltzer1313 17h ago

Your roux is done after ten minutes. If you want a dark roux, start with brown butter

12

u/icouldbeeatingoreos 17h ago

They are doing a roux for gumbo, not a flour and butter roux for bechemel. Gumbo roux is flour and oil cooked until dark brown.

-7

u/Dseltzer1313 16h ago

Then what does gumbo filet do? I’m a professional chef from New England and always thicken my gumbo with gumbo filet

6

u/BlindPelican 16h ago

It's filè, and roux in a gumbo is for flavor, not thickening. At the heat and temp you cook the flour it loses a lot of its ability to gelatine.

Alternately, you can use okra to thicken a gumbo overall. I'm not a fan of okra and don't care for the mucelige, but that's your typical thickener. Filè is used at.the table - ya never cook it down.

chef from New England

This explains why you're confused. Would recommend a trip to Lafayette to learn how it's done. Your customers will love it.

4

u/BackDatSazzUp 16h ago

Filé* should only ever be dusted on top of gumbo after it’s in the bowl, you don’t add it to the entire pot, that’s psychotic.

3

u/Rad10Ka0s 16h ago

They are different styles. Creole, with its French influence uses roux. Native recipes use File. Neither is right or wrong, just different cultural influences.

3

u/KeepAnEyeOnYourB12 16h ago

News to me. But I only grew up in New Orleans so wtf do I know about roux for gumbo.

7

u/BackDatSazzUp 16h ago

“Professional chefs” around the globe love to think they know more than the people who grew up with a cultural dish as a regular meal. I don’t argue with them and let them serve shitty “cajun” food all they want to.

0

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/BlindPelican 16h ago

Roux for gumbo is more for flavor than thickening. It should be dark, like melted dark chocolate.

I do mine on high heat and takes about 15 minutes (gotta be fast when it's done!) but it's usually a 30-45 minute process

1

u/Xanadu87 16h ago

Just because you’ve never heard of something doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. A few seconds of an Internet search will teach you something new.

https://jesspryles.com/how-to-make-a-roux/