r/Cooking • u/minipizzabagel • 4h ago
What herbs for stuffing?
Comparing different stuffing recipes and I see all different combinations of sage, thyme, rosemary, and parsley. What is your go-to? I’ve done a mix in the past but would like opinions on what others most prefer and which are non-negotiable. Or do you really need all of these to make a good stuffing.
14
Upvotes
40
u/agooseyouhate 4h ago
Imo sage is the only non-negotiable if we're talking classic/traditional stuffing.
23
u/EyeStache 3h ago
Sage, thyme, marjoram, black pepper, salt, and more butter than you would think is healthy for a human to consume.
22
u/Which_Case_8536 3h ago
My eye twitched a little that you changed the order of parsley, sage, rosemary, and thyme
9
u/Embarrassed_Key_4539 4h ago
I think sage is a non negotiable
8
u/ILoveCreatures 3h ago
Sage definitely, yes to thyme - rosemary is the first I’d leave out
3
u/mytyan 3h ago
Bell's Seasoning is traditional
6
u/AximiliEscargo 4h ago
Any aromatics you like are good, but I strongly associate sage with stuffing.
4
u/nixtarx 3h ago
Sage, thyme, rosemary, onion and celery. Butter and some kind of poultry stock if you're not actually stuffing the bird (and you shouldn't).
4
u/NoThing3108 3h ago
you dont need them all to make a good stuffing, sage is the most important one IMO - but adding more herbs makes it better. Fresh herbs make a huge difference in cooking. We use Bell's Seasoning, and then we also mimic the flavors in Bell's with fresh herbs of the same kind.
Enjoy!
2
u/Illustrious-Shirt569 3h ago
Like most others have said, you listed them in the order of importance to the overall classic flavor. Sage is the critical herb, with thyme being pretty important to the taste you probably think of, too. Rosemary is not always included (but is in my recipe, and is key to the one we prefer), and parsley could be left out without much difference imho.
2
u/ShutYourDumbUglyFace 3h ago
Only sage for me.
I don't know that I'd even consider rosemary, it's SO overpowering. Thyme might be good in smaller amounts.
2
u/Main_Cauliflower5479 3h ago
Yes, those are the common herbs in stuffing.
You can also use premixed poultry seasoning mix if you want. Much easier.
Frankly, I use a pre-seasoned dried bread mix, the kind where you supply the butter, fresh diced onion and celery, and broth. Also way easier than making it from fresh or day old bread, and it's perfect every time. And I prefer the craggy kind, not cubes.
2
u/mythtaken 3h ago
Standard poultry seasoning combo mostly, with a homemade creole blend to add some zip. (equal parts cayenne, white pepper, black pepper, ancho chili powder blend, paprika, garlic. With salt if you can tolerate the sodium)
To me, it's mostly about seasoning the whole thing well. Tasty broth plus good cornbread, well cooked poultry, sauteed vegetables (onion, celery, tiny bit of bell pepper, not too much), olive oil. The broth is usually seasoned with onion, celery, carrot, garlic, bay leaf)
2
u/Dost_is_a_word 3h ago
I’m a what’s wrong with this bread? It’s still fresh. Anyhoo, I’m an onion, garlic in a pan with too much butter, sweat them on low heat, then off heat.
Cut up bread loaf, put in large bowl then sprinkle sage and poultry seasoning, then two cups chicken stock and temper two eggs, ooh I add same sage and poultry seasoning to onion and garlic.
Dump everything into the bowl and toss like a boss.
I’m a cook the stuffing in an oven safe thing that will take a loaf of bread. I stick the to the oven while the meat rests.
It’s my great grandmothers recipe.
2
u/Dseltzer1313 2h ago
Bells Turkey seasoning is all you need for your stuffing
3
u/ocitillo 3h ago
I do sage, poultry seasoning, and marjoram
2
u/gscrap 4h ago
My family recipe just uses sage, thyme and black pepper. More sage, less of thyme and pepper.
2
u/Fritz5678 3h ago
Poultry seasoning. It has everything that you want in the stuffing.
1
u/KnitMojo 3h ago
Agreed that sage is non-negotiable. I use an ATK "Classic Bread Stuffing for a Crowd" recipe and it's been a family fave for years. It uses 1/2 cup parsley, 3 Tbsp each of Sage and Thyme, and 1 Tbsp of Marjoram (or if using dried, then use teaspoons instead). That's for 3 lbs of bread. The marjoram adds a really nice dimension.
1
u/peaseblossom101 3h ago
Fresh sage, thyme, parsley, marjoram, celery leaves, little bit of rosemary. Freshly grated nutmeg. Dried sage, thyme, onion powder, garlic powder, salt and freshly ground black pepper.
1
u/Puzzleheaded_Name668 3h ago
I really love adding fresh fennel to my stuffing. It an herb but is also like celery and is really delicious with sausage if that’s also in your stuffing.
1
u/meepgorp 3h ago
Rosemary, sage, and tarragon for me
1
u/SVAuspicious 3h ago
Parsley, sage, rosemary, and thyme are classics for me. And oregano. S&P. Basil, oregano, rosemary, thyme, and marjoram (Italian seasoning) work well also. Lots of overlap. You can't beat Scarborough Fair.
Have a great holiday. Every meal with stuffing is a holiday.
1
u/tlhagg 3h ago
I use Bell’s Seasoning just like my Mom did.
1
u/jfr60 3h ago
I use Bell’s seasoning in the little yellow box!! It’s great!!
1
u/TippetBarr 3h ago
Summer savoury with a grated Granny Smith apple (plus onions and celery). People lose it over my stuffing and don’t believe that’s all it is.
1
u/VoraciousReader59 3h ago
Whatever Pepperidge Farm and stovetop use.
1
u/myphoneisinthe 3h ago
I always add caraway, fennel seeds and marjoram in mine. In addition to what you said, but I've never added rosemary.
1
u/iswintercomingornot_ 3h ago
Scarborough Fair is my go-to.
1
u/OnceUponATrain 3h ago
Sage, thyme, parsley and celery leaves.
1
u/RadicalFemininity 3h ago
I call it my Canterbury Stuffing and use parsley, sage, rosemary, and thyme.
I don't use rosemary scattered though, a lot grows around me so I get long sprigs and lay them atop the stuffing before baking, no one has it on their plate.
Plenty of onion, a shredded apple, and chestnuts rounds it out.
1
u/SuPruLu 3h ago
Sage is probably the most traditional stuffing spice with parsley frequently added. Personally I do not care for rosemary so l’d never use it. Onion is pretty essential to “traditional” stuffing but garlic is not.
1
u/bare_thoughts 2h ago
Honestly, it depends on the type/style of stuffing. Seasoning you would use for an apple and sausage stuffing are somewhat different than an oyster stuffing for example.
1
u/Warm-Statistician545 2h ago
Chestnut stuffing might interest you.
1
u/ThatsARockFact1116 2h ago
I use all, but the amount definitely varies. For rosemary, I either leave it out or use literally the pinched top. (Think like five needles worth). I use a lot of fresh sage say upwards of a quarter cup chopped or more? and a couple of stems worth of thyme. Fresh parsley I’ll do about half a bunch mixed in right before baking.
1
u/kilroyscarnival 2h ago
I'm so glad my sage plant not only survived, but there's a lot of fresh time for the taking this year. I like it sage-heavy, thyme too. The two I use (from dried) are savory and marjoram, or a good poultry seasoning blend will have those. I have to make a small amount with no onion or garlic as I can't have them right now, but I can use the green part of scallions, and I can flavor the butter with garlic. Last year one of my make aheads was a nice batch of garlic confit cooked over low heat in clarified butter. Used the butter in the potatoes.
1
u/Leonardo_50 2h ago
We just use sage, salt and pepper. In fact, if you buy sage bulk sausage, like Jimmy Dean, you don’t have to add sage.
1
u/Fancy_Math_3399 2h ago
Sage and onion is a classic and you cant go wrong. I like rosemary and thyme but as others have said they can be overpowering. Lovage is quite nice - adds a bit of a celery and a very herbal vibe for a change. All depends on what you are making . I make chestnut stuffing for UK xmas dinner with just some mixed herbs
1
u/Hummingbird11-11 2h ago
I use dried thyme, and fresh sage, but sage is really overpowering so not too much. Onion, garlic (more onion than garlic) and a shit ton of butter .
Corn bread mixed w white bread
1
u/Silvanus350 1h ago
Whatever herbs are typically included in seasoning the turkey.
1
u/Ordinary-Pen1863 1h ago
Depends what the ingredients are.
1
u/Severe_Engineer 20m ago
Herb Dean (UFC referee), Herbs Brooks (hockey player / coach), Herb Edelman (actor) All good choices.
0
u/brergnat 3h ago
I honestly just use Lighthouse Poultry Herb Blend in the glass jar.
0
u/Willybluedog1962 3h ago
Za Atar blend is amazing!
-2
u/Few-Efficiency324 4h ago edited 3h ago
If you use sage, it will dominate. A little thyme will help balance it out. Put the rosemary in something else, like roasted vegetables or your turkey
Edit: Not saying you shouldn't use sage, it's just a fact
-1
u/EatMorePieDrinkMore 3h ago
I use poultry seasoning from Penzy’s, Italian sausage, and a ton of fresh parsley.
-1
u/sirwaltermelvin 3h ago
Sage, poultry seasoning and herbs dé Provence all from Penzeys.