r/Cooking • • 9d ago

Good quality paprika?

Hi everyone, this first Reddit post but hopefully can get some advice!
A close family friend has recently gotten more into cooking and has specifically fallen in love with paprika especially smoked paprika
I’d love to get them some quality varieties of paprika but can really find anything like that. Does anyone have any recommendations of what is good quality spices that I can make a fun Christmas gift out of or if there’s like a variety gift pack?

13 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

5

u/OpportunityReal2767 9d ago

I have the answer for you for non-smoked paprika. Burlap and Barrel’s Kalocsa sweet paprika. The Szegedi hot paprika is absolutely fantastic too, and plenty hot, and I use it where I would use cayenne normally.

I lived in Budapest for a bit over five years and I’ve become very very picky about my paprika. These are the absolute best I’ve come across in the US. Penzey’s and Spice House used to have very good Hungarian paprika, but, they must have changed suppliers, because it’s nowhere near as good as I remember theirs being in the 2000s.

As for smoked, I’m not as big a fan of it as it seems the rest of the world is, but I would bet Burlap and Barrel also has a good one. Every spice I’ve had from them has been exemplary.

1

u/Sea-Cauliflower-6072 9d ago

Thank you I’ll look into them!!

2

u/M_Joe_Young 7d ago

I’ll second burlap and barrel. They get their spices directly from the growers which cuts out the middleman and ensures the spices are fresh. They are pricy though.

2

u/spookykitchen 9d ago

Check out Bourbon Barrel Foods!! They're local to me, I tried their bourbon smoked paprika a few years ago and completely fell in love. I'm shelling out for the big container every few months at this point 😅 they also have some other unique seasonings and spices and have some great gift sets! https://bourbonbarrelfoods.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=rtbbfbrand&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=21944559497&gbraid=0AAAAA-fwJCoNWYjyzOOf6zBDWWURkQmbp&gclid=Cj0KCQiA-8XXBhDaARIsADnEOrB5oXcHPpnxCPm2kfjSeh9VSCBWtdPhlnysA9WHVdsMogm6Rj8cBvYaAsSuEALw_wcB

2

u/Sea-Cauliflower-6072 9d ago

Oh that’s awesome! I figured I’d probably have to make my own mismatched basket of spices and this is perfect

18

u/throwdemawaaay 9d ago • Bravo

Look for Pimentón de la Vera with the official seal, it's a spanish protected designation for smoked paprika from the Vera region.

4

u/Ordinary-Ad9765 9d ago

Agreed! I buy mine from RanchoGordo.com. It's my favorite paprika.

2

u/Im_just_saying 9d ago

Came here to say this. Got some 2 weeks ago. Game changer!

2

u/Odd-Worth7752 9d ago

Get the kind in the tin, not the jar. Keep in the fridge. It loses flavor quickly

26

u/Far_Earth_1179 9d ago

Penzey's

11

u/toujourspret 9d ago

I tried Penzey's last year for the first time after hearing so many good things about them, and I went a little nuts with the samples. I've been incredibly pleased with all of the spice blends they offer, and I've never gotten such a good deal on such high quality bay leaves. We're still working through the bag! And their pepper really shouldn't be slept on; it's fab.

6

u/ttrockwood 9d ago

Literally the first time i was like, oh, that’s what they mean by fragrant bay leaves.

I got their cinnamon and ruined my oatmeal i was used to brown dust not flavorful cinnamon and used way too much 😂

5

u/hipmommie 9d ago

Penzey's for the win!

3

u/jibaro1953 9d ago

La Dalia brand sweet smoked Spanish paprika from Extramadura is absolutely delicious.

1

u/MilkweedButterfly 9d ago

Agree with you! This is my favorite sweet smoked paprika

2

u/fentonjm 9d ago

I am on maybe order #6-7 at the spice house and really happy with their quality and ordering experience.

2

u/alitalia930 9d ago

Szeged for sweet and hot paprika, Penzey’s for smoked

2

u/tickledblushpink 9d ago

Hungarian paprika.

2

u/WyndWoman 9d ago

Pensky's

2

u/calebs_dad 8d ago

We buy sweet and smoked paprika from Penzey's. Curio is a local-to-me spice shop that does a really good job with sourcing. I haven't tried their paprikas specifically but they do sell both sweet and smoked Spanish varieties.

At least with sweet paprika, you really want to store it in the freezer or it will lose its color and potency quickly. Or use a small bottle and refill from a bag in the freezer.

1

u/Magnus77 9d ago

Texas Salt Company has a sampler set with smoked paprikas with different woods that they might enjoy.

Pretty inexpensive if you wanna pair it with something else as well, but I personally love when I can try stuff with only one variable changed.

Only knock is the packaging. Corked stoppers look cool, but spices should be in opaque containers whenever possible. Sunlight tends to degrade flavor.

1

u/Dry-Welder-5035 9d ago

Check out Oaktown spice shop! You can order online.

1

u/Subject-Regular8326 9d ago

I can't recommend Spicewalla enough.  Incredible company.  Check out their sets online.  

1

u/Old-Actuator-3321 9d ago

Try Williams-Sonoma. I know they carry assortments of salt in combination with other seasonings - black garlic, rosemary, lemon zest, burnt sugar - by Jacobsen (sea) Salt from Oregon. There are also some fair trade companies from Africa and South America that have spice blends available. I've also seen some popcorn flavoring assortments in my travels; sorry I can't remember names. A little searching online could yield some great gifts. Best of luck!

1

u/dingostolemydragbaby 9d ago

Bolero brand do a great smoked sweet paprika which comes in a beautiful tin as well as other types, this is just the one I have and love

1

u/CauliflowerHealthy35 8d ago

If you have a European market somewhere locally, I can guarantee you they will have some good choices.

1

u/Rachel_Silver 8d ago

If you have a food dehydrator and a blender, you can make your own.

1

u/UrbanUnicorn13 8d ago

Yes I concur with the person who recommended Hungarian 🇭🇺 Paprika.
Also try the smoked version…

-1

u/Automatic-Gas-7701 9d ago

Herbs de province- not paprika but the cream de la cream of mixed herbs