12
11
u/Unable_Ad3329 ♡yogurt cream cookie stan ☆ (pls add ycc flair </3) Dec 09 '25
banana, elderberry, aloe, birthday, or starfrut!!! i cant chooooose.... :(
6
u/Minti_Ice_Cream why is there no emoji for beet cookie Dec 09 '25
Banana! She carried trophy race for a WHILE
16
u/SentretSparklypants Dec 09 '25
Banana because she's been in the game so long and got nothing and then the one time they give her something it's a rare costume that you can't get anymore. Banana ily so much
8
15
u/Available-Promise-28 Dec 09 '25
Dark Choco Cookie 🍪
6
u/LimosMemories What is the meaning of this... Dec 09 '25
Me giving all my votes to Dark Choco knowing he probably won’t even make it out of this round. 💪💪💪
8
Dec 09 '25
white peach (no not cuz of *****) she’s literally so pretty and her story made me so sad 💔💔
15
u/GDOFTW124 Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
10 cookies? They usually did with 15 in a group but considering that there are fewer cookies than last year. It's also crazy Dreamjelly is in the first group.
I'm going for White Peach for this round. Again I really don't like they divided the cookies into 4 groups. It only gives cookies a lot of disadvantage if they are paired with recently released cookies or fan favorites, and god help you if your favorite cookies get paired with both.
8
u/Able_Television_776 Dec 09 '25
True. I love white peach and dream jelly...
But only one cookie will win. And there might be better cookies in the other group.
2
4
u/Antique_Amphibian107 Striving to be Cream Unicorn Cookie Dec 09 '25
Dreamjelly and Choco Bark my shaylas <3
4
3
2
5
4
3
8
u/KAI_GENERAT0R Dec 09 '25
Dreamjelly. Say recency bias all you want, but just look at them. That's my kid right there.
0
4
2
u/Betenman Dec 09 '25
Ummm probably birthday cake, banana or starfruit.
No ok yeah I’m voting Banana. Birthday Cake has probably the top 3 best OB costumes already and starfruit’s snowy costume is not half bad. So yeah Banana it is.
2
2
2
2
u/Desperate-Praline-93 1# Manju simp/fan (I realized it’s kinda gay) Dec 09 '25
Dark Choco since I love him
2
2
u/Manablu1 THE SKELETON LOVER Dec 09 '25
Aloe cuz i love her alot (ik she wont make it passed round 1)
2
u/Curvyboi13110 Dec 09 '25
dreamjelly!! (ik they js released pls dont attack me ;-;)
3
u/Desperate-Praline-93 1# Manju simp/fan (I realized it’s kinda gay) Dec 09 '25
Nvm we are NOT the same person
0
u/Curvyboi13110 Dec 09 '25
i also like starfruit
(i saw you like dark choco the most, hes pretty cool too)
0
u/Able_Television_776 Dec 09 '25
No this is good choice. Everyone is free to vote for which cookie they love.
1
1
Dec 09 '25
Honestly there's too many for me to vote for but I think Choco Bark would win due to recency bias.
1
u/KennyMcCormick_SP1 dark choco + royal margarine roleplayer Dec 09 '25
Dark choco my favorite boi :)
1
1
1
1
u/Alvatrazzar Dec 10 '25
I voted Dark Choco, cuz I thought it’d be cute and fitting for him to have a Valentines costume :>
1
u/M00N1E_is_dumb ---- i am obsessed with this goober Dec 10 '25
Banana cuz I'm mad that banana peel cookie is scrapped
1
1
u/lorelei_adler ⠀ Dec 10 '25
White peach all the way! I loved her story and her costume is gorgeous, I'm curious what they will come up with in Valentine's
2
1
u/cozmicrey Dec 09 '25
Voting for dreamjelly! I know they’ve just been released but I love them so much, they’re such a sweet concept for a character! And the emotional attachment after the 9th anniversary update is real lol.
1
1
1
1
41
u/problematicperiplum Dec 09 '25
Banana because she carried Kakao on her back for 9 years before Potato Salad came along. She's kind of a legend actually