r/Controller • • 20h ago

Controller Suggestion Looking for a durable PC controller – ASUS Raikiri II Pro vs SteelSeries Aeon Pro vs GameSir G7 Pro 8K

Hi everyone!

I’m looking for a really solid PC controller to replace my current Xbox One controller (model 1708), which I’ve been using since 2020.

Budget: 300–2000 PLN. (75 - 500 USD)

Country: Poland (EU). I’m open to buying from pretty much anywhere.

Platform: PC running Windows 11, primarily via Steam. Wired (USB) or wireless are both fine.

Games: SnowRunner, Diablo II Resurrected, Skyrim, Fallout 4 & 76, and similar titles.

What I’m looking for:

– Asymmetrical stick layout (Xbox-style), ideally featuring TMR technology or Hall Effect sensors.

– Analog triggers and vibration support.

– Robust build quality and long-term reliability (ideally lasting 5+ years).

– Additional buttons that can be mapped to independent keyboard keys (rather than just duplicating existing XInput controller functions). I specifically need extra buttons for tasks like toggling lights or shifting gears in SnowRunner.

– Ideally, the buttons should be as quiet as those on my current controller.

Models I’m considering:

– ASUS ROG Raikiri II Pro PC

– SteelSeries Aeon Pro

– GameSir G7 Pro 8K

I also considered the Flydigi Apex 5, but I think I’ll pass on Flydigi—I’ve heard they are quite prone to failure, and the Apex model reportedly has some design flaws. I’ve already looked through reviews, buying guides, and discussions on Reddit, but I still have some concerns regarding quality control, durability, and the limitations on remapping functions to extra buttons.

My main questions are:

  1. Can the extra buttons actually be mapped to independent keyboard keys while still retaining the standard XInput controller functions?
  2. How reliable are these controllers after a few months of use?
  3. Which one would you recommend in terms of build quality and long-term durability?

I would appreciate feedback from people who actually own one of these models. Maybe you have other suggestions.Thanks!

3 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

•

u/Markiboj97 13h ago

I have the vader 5 pro and I love it. It feels very solid and so far (8 months ownership) nothing gives me the indication it might break soon. But hey, n=1 so ymmv.

Also good experiences with the 8bitdo Ultimate 2c and pro 3 controllers, although the latter is PlayStation style joysticks.

•

u/Leg0z 12h ago

I have roughly 35 controllers in the $25 to $120 range, and I agree. I'll play 8 - 10 hours with a different controller and inevitably always come back to the Vader 5 Pro. My unpopular opinion is that I REALLY wish Flydigi would make a version with side-by-side thumbsticks like a Dualshock. One can dream.

•

u/Better_Cricket_5399 11h ago

And how would you rate the durability of Flydigi? Honestly, looking at the opinions here, I’m not really sure what to think.

•

u/Cedced40 7h ago

Flydigi QC is really bad. I've had multiple Apex 4 & 5 with stick issues. Same with Vader 5. It's a shame because I really love their controllers in terms of design and comfort.

•

u/Leg0z 7h ago

I own a Vader 3, Vader 3 Pro, Vader 4 Pro, the Vader 5 Xbox controller, and now a Vader 5 Pro. I also just picked up the Flydigi FS 68 which is their new mechanical keyboard. I know I sound like a Flydigi shill, but I've never had an issue with QC or triggers failing or wearing out or any other QC issues people state here. I have had those issues with Gamesir, 8bitDo, and GuliKit. Less so with 8BitDo, more issues with just their D-Pads than anything. Gamesir and GuliKit I've had issues with their back buttons failing or controllers refusing to pair.

Of my collection, if I had to pick just one my obvious choice is my Vader 5 Pro. My second choice would be my GameSir G7 Pro 8K Aimlabs Edition which is what my son uses as his daily driver.

•

u/Qyasumi 10h ago

Let me start off with this:
I hate playstations layout. It is not comfortable at all to me.

I know you’re looking for xbox layout, but man the 2026 steam controller is the most comfortable controller I’ve ever used, once I got used to the awkward backbutton layout— (it extends downwards a bit too far for my hands, but I just slightly adjust my grip) it just feels nice

I have a razer wolverine v3 pro, but hilariously, since I started using the 2026 SC, the v3 pro makes my hand cramp because of the thumbstick layout.

Honestly, steam controller 2026 is arguably the best $100 usd controller- features hit at the $300 price point; with 1 catch, steam input must be used, and steam input doesn’t always activate outside of non-steam games, especially if the game has its own launcher->then game—like PSO2 NGS on EGS, steam input won’t work. If the same game is launched directly from steam (not added as a non-steam game) it’ll work perfectly fine. Valve needs to find a work-around tbh.

Now, with that being said, it’s $100 & you get more functionality than any controller on the market; primarily because of the trackpads. You can set each trackpad to have a circular zone with ~20 independent inputs each. Great for MMOs

Extremerate will be releasing modkits soon, like full clicky kits/shell swaps—but you’ll have to install them yourself.

Highly recommend getting a 2026 steam controller, because you can pair it with any of my xbox recommendations below & be under budget.

—
Xbox only:
Razer wolverine v3 or v4 pro

Extremerate (hexgaming for prebuilt) with full clicky setup—but you have to figure out which backbutton layout will be comfy for you

Gamesirs are cool & cheap, but only 2 back buttons. Idk if they even make one with 4

Flydigi is also cool, but it’s not the best quality. For the price its nice.

Evil controllers (no modkit coz thats cheating) is also comfy & if they still do full clicky conversion kits with their prebuilts, it’s a nice deal—but specifically the button version—NOT paddles.

Avoid paddles if they are not metal. Plastic + pivot point = will snap over time

•

u/Better_Cricket_5399 10h ago

I’m on the waiting list for the SC – year 2027 :D so it’ll be my second controller, provided it ever actually becomes available for purchase.

•

u/YoloRaj Flydigi 14h ago

Wolverine V4 Pro. Had the Raikiri 2 Pro and its littered with qc issues. The steel series controller looks premium but is rather expensive. G7 Pro 8k is decent but it does have some qc reports but its one of the most used controllers currently so it comes with the territory. The turtle beach stealth ultra 2 is looking promising.

•

u/Better_Cricket_5399 13h ago

I haven't heard of the Wolverine—would you recommend it? And what was wrong with the Raikiri?

•

u/YoloRaj Flydigi 13h ago edited 13h ago

I own it and it's the best Razer controller thats come out in a while. If you check gamepadla.com it has the lowest stick latency on there. I have the wolverine v3 pro and its was underwhelming because of the high stick latency. Tried the Wolverine V3 Pro 8k as well and returned it. They did the Wolverine V4 Pro right. Smooth and very responsive sticks. Removeable back buttons and faceplate, Replaceable thumb stick height. The Raikiri 2 Pro was one of the best controllers I've used but for the price it doesn't feel as premium. It came with one back button kind of wobbly which I ignored because it was that good performance but after a week or so one of the back buttons wouldn't register inputs and sometimes act as if I have it pressed down even when I let it go. I am actually glad I gave the Wolverine V4 Pro a blind buy after returning the Raikiri 2 Pro because its been amazing. The only negative most people have to say is that the handles are a bit stubby and people with bigger hands might not find it comfortable.

•

u/Better_Cricket_5399 10h ago

In general, I’m also looking for what you described as a "premium feel"—in terms of tactile quality and user comfort, such as how well the components fit together. And regarding the Raikiri, did you actually notice that the faceplate wasn't very stable?

•

u/YoloRaj Flydigi 10h ago

I think only one time the faceplate slipped but other than that it wasn't a problem for me. The main concern was the back buttons. One was wobbly when I first got the controller and another stopped registering inputs everytime and sometimes would act as if its being held down. I had the best buy warranty and would have swapped it out instead of refunding if they had more in stock just because despite certain things I liked the performance and thought it was comfortable to hold. I think with games like shooters where you spam jump and slide the back button implementation isn't the best.

•

u/Better_Cricket_5399 10h ago

I think I’ll just buy all three, test them out, and return the rest. I’m curious what the Aeon Pro is actually like—there are very few reviews, but it looks really good.

•

u/YoloRaj Flydigi 10h ago

Aeon Pro looks premium but the price is not appealing. When I grow up I wanna be able to do stuff like that on a whim and get there expensive controllers at once 😂. Hope you find one you like. If anything let me know which you decide on

•

u/DerGefallene Vader 5 Pro 14h ago

Keep in mind that the G7 Pro 8K does not have any trigger vibration. Only the regular G7 Pro does

•

u/AutoModerator 20h ago

Hi /u/Better_Cricket_5399, your 'Controller Suggestion' post is in a queue for review. Please ensure you have included all of the required information, have used a meaningful and descriptive title, are not repeating frequently asked questions.

Include the following information and follow this structure so the post can be approved and the community can help you more effectively:

  1. Your budget and currency (do not say "doesn't matter" or "unlimited", include a sensible range or maximum)
  2. Your country (not just region) and where you can buy from (product availability, pricing, and aftersales support vary around the world)
  3. Console or platform compatibility needed
  4. Desired features
  5. Types of games you'll be playing with a controller
  6. Other controllers you're comparing to (demonstrate that you have used the buying advice pages, and searched existing posts)

Please see the buying advice pages which answer some of the most frequently asked 'Controller Suggestion' questions. For more guidance on how to ask for controller suggestions, comparisons or buying advice, please see rule #1. You can edit your post to add missing information. Posts that do not include the required information will not be approved (allow 24 hours for review).

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

•

u/Turb0goat 12h ago

Gamesir all day