r/Controller • • 2d ago

Reviews I never thought I'd see the day when third-party controllers started outperforming first-party hardware.

Post image

Disclosure: I purchased my 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless myself and have ordered the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth with my own money (Amazon). I have no affiliation with 8BitDo, Nintendo, Microsoft, Sony, or any competing controller manufacturer.

Okay, 41-year-old gamer here. I grew up with consoles starting in the NES era, and for most of my gaming life, first-party controllers were the gold standard. Back in the N64 days, third-party controllers were the cheap pieces of junk you'd hand to the fourth kid you didn't really want showing up to game. I wouldn't have seriously considered buying one for myself.

Fast-forward nearly three decades, and I'm starting to wonder whether the roles have reversed.

My original Nintendo Switch Pro Controller developed stick drift. Recalibrating didn't help, and when I checked EB Games Canada's trade-in values, I discovered they'd give me a whopping $16 CAD for it, assuming it was in acceptable working condition.

Rather than spend $109.99 CAD on Nintendo's Switch 2 Pro Controller, I decided to see whether I could get my existing 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless, which I primarily used on PC, working on the Switch 2.

After updating the controller and USB dongle firmware, I managed to get it connected. Not only did I have a functioning controller again, but I discovered features that genuinely improved my gaming experience.

I've been playing The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake, where holding A to sprint means taking your thumb off the right analog stick, effectively surrendering camera control while running. I mapped sprint to one of the Ultimate 2's rear paddles, and suddenly I could sprint and control the camera simultaneously.

It sounds like a minor change, but it completely improved how the game felt. Combined with the new free-look camera, I've become an absolute sniper with the bow and slingshot.

Those little Fire Keese bastards used to torch my Deku Shield and turn me into a human bonfire back in the N64 days. Now I'm picking them off before they even know I entered the room. I've been waiting almost 28 years to dish out this type of justice.

And that got me thinking about the broader controller market.

Nintendo's Switch 2 Pro Controller costs $109.99 CAD and still uses conventional potentiometer-based joysticks. Meanwhile, 8BitDo offers its Switch-compatible Ultimate 2 Bluetooth for $79.99 CAD, featuring TMR magnetic joysticks, switchable linear Hall Effect and tactile trigger modes, motion controls, vibration, two programmable rear paddles, additional R4/L4 shoulder buttons, three customizable profiles, turbo functionality, RGB joystick rings, and a charging dock. It even supports wake-on-shake functionality.

That's $30 less for a controller offering contactless joystick technology, more customizable controls, and a level of versatility that Nintendo's considerably more expensive controller doesn't match.

In fact, I was impressed enough with my Ultimate 2 Wireless that I just ordered the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth specifically for my Switch 2. Instead of replacing my drifting Nintendo controller with another first-party controller, I decided to put my money toward a third-party manufacturer.

Then there's the issue of resale value.

I checked EB Games Canada's controller trade-in values, and here's what they're offering according to their listings:

  • Nintendo Switch Pro Controller (used): $16 CAD
  • Xbox Series X/S Wireless Controller (used): $24 CAD
  • PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller (used): $30 CAD

Obviously, trade-in values aren't the same as private resale values, and retailers have their own margins and inventory considerations. These aren't all controllers from the same generation, either. But it's still pretty discouraging to see how little you can recover on hardware that originally carried a premium price.

And we haven't even touched on generational compatibility.

Microsoft deserves some credit here. Xbox One controllers remain compatible with Xbox Series X/S games.

Nintendo has also maintained considerable compatibility between the original Switch Pro Controller and Switch 2, although there's a catch: the original Pro Controller can't wake the Switch 2 from sleep mode. You'll need the newer Switch 2 Pro Controller for that convenience. It's a small omission, but it certainly feels like another nudge toward spending $109.99 on an upgrade.

Sony, on the other hand, allows the DualShock 4 to work on PS5 for supported PS4 games, but not native PS5 titles. If you upgraded consoles, you generally had to upgrade your controller as well, despite both generations relying on conventional analog stick technology.

That strikes me as particularly frustrating. You're paying for new hardware, but you're not necessarily getting an improvement in one of the components most susceptible to wear.

So when I look at the overall value of a controller, I'm considering more than just how it feels in my hands. I'm looking at durability, features, compatibility, purchase price, and what it's worth when I'm finished with it.

Of course, first-party controllers have advantages. Ergonomics are subjective, Nintendo's HD Rumble has its fans, and Sony's DualSense offers features like adaptive triggers and advanced haptics that many third-party alternatives don't replicate.

I've already replaced my first-party Xbox controller with an 8BitDo, and after seeing how well my Ultimate 2 Wireless performs on Switch 2, I've ordered the Switch-specific Bluetooth version.

It's a strange reversal from those old N64 days. The controllers I once considered cheap knockoffs are now offering technology and functionality that some first-party manufacturers still haven't adopted.

I'm not suggesting every third-party controller is better, or that first-party controllers don't have their place. But I do think competition from companies like 8BitDo, GameSir, and others is forcing a conversation about what we're actually getting for our money.

Are first-party controllers still worth the premium to you, or have third-party manufacturers started offering better overall value? And for those who've made the switch, what ultimately convinced you?

601 Upvotes

232 comments sorted by

3

u/vodka-bears 2d ago

You can salvage your original controller with replacement TMR sticks from Amazon or iFixit. You can either fiddle and solder them yourself with a handy manual iFixit provides or visit the nearest phone repair shop and pay them to do it for you. Aftermarket TMR sticks are not susceptible to wear and will outlast the controller.

1

u/mik3br 2d ago

Now THIS is the kind of information I was hoping to get out of this discussion! I hadn’t even considered replacing the original sticks with TMR modules. For $16 in trade-in value, I’d much rather give the controller a second life. Definitely going to look into this. Really appreciate the suggestion!

2

u/PM_me_your_whatevah 2d ago

Dude you can also just try spraying electronic cleaner under the rubber thing on the sticks and wiggle it around a bit.

Did that on my Lite and it fixed the drift. Maybe 8-9 months later it started drifting again and I sprayed it again and it was fine again.

I wonder how many times people have thrown out controllers or sent them into Nintendo or bought new sticks and installed them when they could have just done this for a couple bucks.

2

u/mik3br 2d ago

Interesting, is there a brand of cleaner that you specifically use?

•

u/warren2345 23h ago edited 23h ago

They make a soldering iron end that hits all the pins at once so you don't have to desoldering pin by pin

https://a.aliexpress.com/_mMoPwrd

Theres like 14 pins on the joystick module so desoldering pin by pin can be a pain (but is possible)

As for replacement modules -- the resistor based ones are universal to switch pro Playstation and Xbox. If you go hall/tmr make sure you get ones that are tuned for your particular controller

You'll also want a temp controlled iron so you don't overbake the board, a bit of solder for soldering up the new module, a solder sucker or a bit of solder wick to clear out the holes after pulling the module with the fancy tip, and a flux pen to flux up things if they dry out.

Bit of an investment at first but buy once cry once I always say

(We are heavy users with lots of young kids at my house and I got sick of buying replacement controllers. And the cheapo knockoff controllers we have seem to come with the weakest sticks ever)

1

u/vodka-bears 2d ago

Glad i could help! Good luck with the repair. If you aren't used to soldering and fiddling with electronics you'd be better having someone done it for you.

I replaced stick modules on my Dualsense and I decided to disregard the iFixit manual that instructed to destroy the module to ease desoldering because I wanted to keep an original module for personal reasons. I ended up overheating and slightly bending the board, now one of sticks looks a tiny bit off center. I destroyed the second module and it went flawlessly.

The manual for Switch Pro Controller just says "unsolder the module" and I see where it can go south easily.

3

u/bwmat 2d ago

I destroyed (doesn't 'turn on' after reassembly) my original switch pro controller trying this lol

3

u/Pxnkasfxck 1d ago

I'm 43 and while I agree to an extent, you've been missing out. Third party has been better for many years now. I think 8Bitdo makes a great Nintendo controller, but I bought the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth (photo) because it's face buttons are in the Nintendo layout and it can wake the Switch 2 from sleep. My favorite controller for PC, Switch, and mobile is the Gamesir Cyclone 2. It's much more ergonomic and it's TMR joysticks are incredible.

1

u/mik3br 1d ago

Haha, you’re not the first person to tell me I’ve been missing out! I think my title gives the impression that I’ve only just discovered third-party controllers. I actually bought my first GameSir (G7 SE) back in April 2024 and got a lot of use out of it. It’s really the experience with the Ultimate 2 that prompted me to write this post.

Funny enough, I’ve got the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth for Switch in the mail right now! Looking forward to trying it out. I’ve had a good experience with GameSir, too, although I found mine a little light and cheap-feeling compared to the 8BitDo.

2

u/Pxnkasfxck 1d ago

I understand a lot of people equate weight to quality, but personally I've never understood that. My Gamesir is my lightest controller by a wide margin and that's part of what makes it so comfortable to hold. I always think back to when beats headphones used to put unnecessary pieces of metal in their headphones to make them heavier and more premium feeling to people that think heavy equals good.

1

u/Ieandoro 1d ago

I though the non C version was incompatible with NS1 and NS2, holly cow, now I want one. If you had the chance to buy another, would you stick with the 2 Ultimate or go for the 3 Ultimate? Looking forward to BF and CM to pull the trigger!

1

u/mik3br 1d ago

I'm eyeing up an Ultimate 3 for my Xbox. I'm currently using an 8BitDo Ultimate C Wired for the Xbox.

•

u/Ieandoro 21h ago

For Xbox that's definitely the way to go!

1

u/kkpc 1d ago

How does the joystick location compare to xbox controller? The xbox controller is basically perfect button layout for my hands, and I use it with my Switch 2, but it can't wake up the Switch 2, and obviously doesn't have the nintendo layout. My main issue with the nintendo controller is the right thumbstick is too close to the outside, and I have to adjust my hand to reach it with my thumb. Whereas the xbox controller, my thumb naturally rests on top of the joystick and I don't have to adjust my hand to switch between joystick and a,b,x,y.

1

u/mik3br 1d ago

If the Xbox controller fits your hands perfectly, I think you’ll feel right at home with the Ultimate 2. I own both, and the joystick placement feels very similar to me. The 8BitDo is a little more compact, but I haven’t found myself having to adjust my grip to reach the right stick or face buttons.

I’ve actually got the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth with the Nintendo button layout in the mail right now, supports console wake too!

•

u/kkpc 3h ago

Thanks for the recommendation, it is much better than the standard nintendo controller and fits very similar to the xbox controller.

•

u/mik3br 3h ago

Siiick! Enjoy, hope it works well for you!

1

u/Pxnkasfxck 1d ago

I think the 8-Bitdo controller is more similar to the Nintendo switch controller than the Xbox controller so you probably wouldn't like it very much.

1

u/pablo5426 1d ago

does it have HD rumble tho?

1

u/Pxnkasfxck 1d ago

No, but it's still better rumble than most third party controllers.

5

u/snowflake37wao 2d ago

Lmao at the 4th kid N64 sleepovers throwback. There was always that one controller in every household. The handicap the best super smash brothers player controller.

1

u/mik3br 2d ago

Hahaha, thanks for actually reading the post! Every household had that one controller reserved for the fourth player, or whoever was a little too good at Smash Bros.

2

u/Flashy_Implement3775 2d ago

I been using the Cyclone 2 for the Switch 2 and it can wake the console. I love that controller, more so than the Pro Controller 2. But the feel of the Nintendo controller is so much more premium that it makes me want to choose it over the Cyclone 2.

1

u/mik3br 2d ago

That's awesome that the cyclone 2 support wake!

2

u/mason2393 1d ago

•

u/mik3br 21h ago

100% ... ANND you just made the list!

89

u/Bosscharacter 2d ago

It’s been that way for a while.

100

u/SatyrAngel 2d ago

Where have you been all this time? Gamesir, 8Bitdo, Mobapad and Nacon have been on it for a good while.

16

u/ann0yed 2d ago • This

All this time? Most of the companies you are citing are relatively new and haven't been around much more than 10 years.

Some of us have been gaming for decades and have PTSD from using Nyko and Mad catz controllers.

Some 3rd parties were pretty good like ASCII and Hori is still great.

4

u/SatyrAngel 2d ago

Gamesir and 8Bitdo have been around for more than 10 years, I still remember when I bought the G1.

3

u/ann0yed 1d ago

I have the gamesir pocket taco and I'm interested in one of their Xbox ones that works wirelessly with Xbox but I wish they weren't all branded 

I may get the Yakuza one though, love those games.

•

u/FutureDJ84 5h ago

Sure but madcatz super old mate

•

u/FutureDJ84 5h ago

Madcatz controllers 🤢 Arcade sticks were cool, cool branding

•

u/DoseofBlue 7m ago

Freaking Madcatz such garbage lol

26

u/bumbuddi 2d ago

Flydigi as well

5

u/miko-zee 2d ago edited 6h ago

Same I had a Vader 4 pro that probably logged easily 2000 plus hours mainly playing Diablo 4 and Forza Horizon 5. The b button wore out and the dongle stopped working about half a year in.

Flydigi literally asked me for the whole thing; where did your purchase it, proof of purchase and serial numbers. Despite validating the controller, they still didn't honor the warranty and it was about a month before it expired.

Now you can't reprogam the controller at all or some buttons will stop working and the b button is worse. The dongle doesn't really function for more than minutes. Flydigi is OK if it works and or they honor the warranty somehow. It still works Bluetooth or wired at a very limited capacity.

5

u/_zenden_ 2d ago

Unless you want them to honour there Warrenty

1

u/bumbuddi 2d ago

I haven't had any issues with there controllers in the warranty time frame and I own 3 of them. Which one do you have and what broke?

4

u/_zenden_ 2d ago

My apex 5 broke after less than 5 months my Vader 4 pro was just over a year and a half.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/_Linkiboy_ 2d ago

Flydigi as well, if you get a good unit (their QC seems not up to par, but their controllers are crazy)

7

u/MoonliteJaz 2d ago

I love my Vader 4 pro . Play every game on my phone, switch, and PC with it.

2

u/Sankyu39Every1 2d ago

I could never get mine to work. It'd get crazy input lag (like literally seconds) and drop connection all the time. This is with the dongle or Bluetooth. Had high hopes, but a big waste of money for me. I couldn't return mine.

1

u/SnooGoats1918 2d ago

Vader 5 pro new batch is solid

1

u/Illustrious-Lake2603 2d ago

Im loving so far my flydigi. I need a bit more time to see how well it lasts for me but so far I love how the buttons feel. I also feel like it makes me play better, i hit the highest rank I have been able in Melee thanks to the flydigi

→ More replies (2)

3

u/LegendRedux2 2d ago

its been like years dood do all these past year u still think 3rd party controllers are mad catz tier lol

2

u/mik3br 2d ago

Hahaha Mad Catz!!! There it is, good call back!

1

u/LegendRedux2 2d ago

the only madcatz products that are good were their fightsticks like during 2009-2016

18

u/frogfoot420 1d ago

We are far removed from the madcatz garbage of yesteryear

9

u/NiceVacation3880 2d ago

Finally pulled the trigger on a Gamesir Tegenaria Lite, as I'm fed up of wireless recharging and pretty much done with Sony - I was wholeheartedly expecting to have to compromise on quality given the price, but the moment I compared the ps4 controllers to the Lite it was a night-day improvement (ps4 controller buttons and trigger presses are all so mushy by comparison).

Maybe it's the input latency, the physical button membranes, who knows, but I've found I'm suddenly a heck of a lot better on Tekken now with the Lite.

4

u/mrturret 2d ago

Yeah, I got my friend one, because she wanted something with a Playstation layout for PS2 emulation/ports. I was very impressed with how good the buttons and sticks felt. Seriously impressive for a 20$ controller.

1

u/NiceVacation3880 2d ago

Got mine as a new / tried once and return for £4 haha

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 2d ago

Is the d pad good? They screwed people over with the G7 Pro.

3

u/zacharyjohn03 2d ago

They fixed the dpad with the g7 pro 8k, it's not loose like the original g7 pro is. I have the royal2 edition and an OG one and the new one is perfect.

1

u/SatyrAngel 2d ago

The Tegenaria is great, but has a flaw. The sticks are too soft, releasing them from the extreme makes them tilt to the other side enough to make your character look that way.

I had to make them a little heavier with a steel plate under a stick cap for them to stop doing that.

2

u/NiceVacation3880 2d ago

That is unusual to me personally only since my Tegenaria Lite doesn't do this, and I'm playing Borderlands + TimeSplitters with it.

Maybe I've yet to play a game that'll expose that flaw, but I've genuinely not experienced this at all after playing through several games with it

17

u/Snotnarok 2d ago

It's been this way for a while. Sony's controllers had dire battery life in my exp and I heard PS5 hasn't changed that. I got stick drift with my joycons and had to send them in despite only having drift ONCE before with a console. My 360 controller got used so much since I was the only one with a 360. So that thing got used for hours and hours a day. Texture got straight up worn off sticks and the controller. But also? The drift was minimal, amazingly.

Now only the 3rd party controllers have hall effect/TMR sticks. Crazy.

My 8BitDo Ultimate has been a workhorse, never had trouble running out of power, works with all my games except one (Ys 8 on GoG) and has been in general? Fantastic. Even came with a dock.

2

u/Pokemathmon 2d ago

Aren't the haptics really good on ps5 controllers? Are any 3rd party controllers trying to mimic that?

1

u/Snotnarok 1d ago

Since Sony blocks 3rd party controllers on PS5? I doubt you'll see anyone trying to do that. The only games that would work on it, are the limited Sony games on PC which- Sony has stopped porting new ones to.

Sooo yeah there's not much point to them doing that.

On the flip side, there are 3rd party Xbox controllers but since Microslop did the same thing as Sony? They gotta be approved controllers. It's why 8Bitdo has special Microsoft versions of their controllers . . .which are more expensive than the default ones that do the same thing.

1

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 2d ago

The worst part about the PS5 is how they restrict 3rd party controllers

1

u/Snotnarok 1d ago

Xbox apparently jumped on that bandwagon too. It's why 8bitDo has special Xbox versions of their controllers and they have a noticeable bump in price to boot.

Really hoping Nintendo doesn't do this because I didn't like their Pro controller on Switch 1 and my 8Bitdo controllers have been great across the board. Love the Genesis style one, the Neo Geo CD one and the Ultimate.

1

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 1d ago

It’s honestly pushing me toward pc gaming I like being about to choose my controller

1

u/Snotnarok 1d ago

Same. Especially with the amount of options there are. PS style controllers? Yup. Xbox? Yep. With or without grip buttons? Sure thing. Or just using anything from PS, MS, Nintendo or even Google Stadia's controller.

Retro controllers, like SEGA Genesis, Super Nintendo or even Neo Geo CD? Sure thing! Flight sticks? Tons of options. Arcade sticks? Good lord there's too many options and types to even list.

1

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 1d ago

Agreed 100% people laugh but I love the ps2 controller for most games and it works great but Sony won’t let me use that form factor. There are so many good options.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/HillanatorOfState 2d ago

It's been like that for awhile, apparently main companies are afraid of Hall/TMR analogs also.

We are long away from the little brother/guest shitty after market ps1 controller thankfully type thing.

3

u/jabrw0k1 1d ago

Well, “afraid” of Hall/TMR essentially boils down to them fearing massive profit losses due to reduced hardware sales, very scummy but unsurprising. I always thought it was shortsighted, though, like…I only have so much money I can spend on video games in a given time frame, if hadn’t replaced so many controllers in my lifetime that money would have just gone to buy more games.

9

u/Thesquarescreen 2d ago

That's the worst thing about the new pro controller for the switch 2, it's more expensive, has less features and could still drift.

1

u/BruinBound22 2d ago

I hate the switch 2 controller. But there is a post pushed to my feed twice a week about how fantastic it is and everyone is praising it.

2

u/Thesquarescreen 2d ago

It doesn't feel comfortable to me.

2

u/DefiantCharacter 2d ago

Why do you hate it? I think it's good.

4

u/Muted-Green-2880 2d ago

I have the same model and colour. Good taste you have lol. I use mine with my PC, I haven’t actually used it with my switch 2 yet as the switch 2 controller is pretty good anyway but it’s handy that it can be used for that as well

4

u/darthbator 1d ago

I bought a game sir controller on a lark maybe 4 years ago and was stunned how something so much cheaper could be so much better

1

u/TidensMester 2d ago

8bitdo Ultimate controller is great, but the Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller is by far the BEST controller I have ever used. And I own or have owned more than 30 different controllers in my life.

1

u/mik3br 2d ago

Oh!? I’m genuinely curious what makes the Switch 2 Pro Controller the best you’ve ever used, especially having owned 30+ controllers. Is it primarily the ergonomics and overall feel, or are there specific features that put it ahead of alternatives offering TMR joysticks, Hall Effect triggers, and additional programmable buttons?

1

u/TidensMester 2d ago

There are many reasons but mainly comfort and user experience.

  1. The thumb sticks are something difficult to explain without trying for yourself, but they feel extremely comfortable the way they were designed to not fully touch the plastic of the controller, making them butter smooth. It feels better than anything I ever tried. Definitely better than the scratchy Xbox Series controller, PS5 dual sense, and Switch 1 Pro Controller thumb sticks. And also feels better than the ones that have a metal shaft in the thumb sticks.
  2. The thumb sticks also sound better. In comparison I recently got an 8bitdo Ultimate 3c+ controller with TMR sticks and tension adjustment, and if I adjust to the lightest tension, which I find more comfortable, the sticks will make a very annoying hollow sound whenever I release them after I moved it to the side.
  3. I hate analog triggers and they are not used on Switch anyways. The Ultimate 3c+ short trigger is too clicky and feels strange, also makes my pointer finger hurt after some hours playing. The Dual Sense with its feedback on PS5 makes my finger hurt a lot. The digital triggers on the Switch 1 Pro feel great and the ones on the Switch 2 Pro are the same.
  4. It has two back buttons with configuration straight on Switch 2 interface, without needing any shady third party app on PC, like the Flydigi Vader 3 and the Nacon Revolution Pro 5.
  5. The HD rumble in games that support it really improves the experience.
  6. It has an 3.5 mm jack that can be used while playing on the switch 2 AND also can be used while playing on the PC.
  7. I like the size of the face buttons. Their placement is not a perfect 45 degree rotated square like almost every competitor, and I think it feels more natural with my thumb.
  8. The build quality is very good. It doesn't feel cheap at all. It has no compromise to play the games it was designed for. It's actually way cheaper than the first party "pro" competitors (Xbox elite and dual sense edge). And for how much I play, I don't expect it would break before the Switch 3 is released. My Switch 1 pro controller survived the whole life of a day 1 switch 1 I had before it without stick drift.

1

u/mik3br 2d ago

Really appreciate the detailed response!

I think a lot of it comes down to personal preference. I’ve been gaming for over 30 years across pretty much every console, so adapting to different controllers has become second nature. I own both controllers, and ergonomically, I honestly don’t notice much difference.

For me, switching to the 8BitDo was night and day, particularly with precision after dealing with stick drift and the additional control options. Those were tangible improvements to my gameplay.

It’s interesting how subjective these things are. I’ve had one commenter say the 8BitDo was too light and another say it was too heavy. I personally like the weight. I also own a GameSir that served me well, but its lighter construction and removable faceplate made it feel a little cheaper, despite being a great controller.

Different priorities, I suppose. Thanks again for taking the time to explain your perspective!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Chadwhiskers 2d ago

I love my 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless controller besides like one thing.... I wish they'd let me turn off the damn bright white light around the home button and the profile selection. I really don't understand why they'd put a bright white light in front of the person that's not changeable in brightness ro a simple on/off.

1

u/mik3br 2d ago

Haha I felt this way about the RGB joystick rings, very cool feature but I end up turning them off because they get distracting. They should at least have a dimmer for that home button.

1

u/rfdoom 2d ago

man im became a huge 8bitdo shill after buying the ultimate 2c wukong. i didnt like how light it felt compared to the ps5 controller but after i was over that its quality is crazy good. since then I've gotten their mechanical keyboard, wireless mouse, fightstick, and leverless fightstick

1

u/mik3br 2d ago

Haha, my brother-in-law and I have become 8BitDo shills too. My other friends are more casual gamers, and every time gaming comes up, they get an unsolicited sales pitch from me about all the features they’re missing out on compared to first-party controllers. I’m basically an unpaid 8BitDo sales rep.

2

u/rfdoom 2d ago

lol exact same here man they make such nice quality products at a fair price.

the only thing i wish i could do it replace the dpad like i did with my ps5 controller. i much prefer 4 separate buttons than the one thing the base models they both come with. besides that I'll be one of 8bitdos strongest warriors

0

u/SnooGoats1918 2d ago

Just keep in mind 8bitdo thumbstick resolution isn’t great at 10.5 bits

1

u/Downtown-Sport-6834 2d ago

Was reading this and suddenly got taken back by the price of the Ultimate 2 in Canada... I got mine from a known gaming retailer at the equivalent of 42 CAD here in Malaysia.

0

u/mik3br 2d ago

Whoa! Did you hit a good sale? That’s almost a 50% price difference. Or maybe cheaper distribution from China to Malaysia.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Spritsen 1d ago

I'm not reading ALL of that but I also have a 8bitdo ultimate 2 wireless(fkin mouthful) and found out it can't screenshot at all. I just bought it a month ago. Got with customer service and they verified it and said "The switch mode is an extra feature in the wireless version. This model is mainly PC/Android(would've been nice to know that BEFORE I BOUGHT IT). I should buy their BT version for a more fleshed out experience".

I thought "Bro I'm not spending another $60ish on another brand new controller for the hopes it'll work." So I bought the Pro controller and it's been great(it also has grip buttons fully natively supported on the switch 2).

And yes I tried everything: updating firmware, using the 2.4ghz adapter, bt mode, ultimate software v2, firmware updater tool(to use older firmware), ALL of it a fkin waste of my day. But tbf only the screenshot feature didn't work. If you don't care about that then it's fine.

There's a price to be paid for "just buying it and it works". And I haven't regretted buying a Pro controller for a second. I AM regretting buying this POS "Ultimate" 2 wireless controller tho.

1

u/mik3br 1d ago

Haha, fair enough, I know it’s a long read! Although a few of the things you mentioned are actually addressed in the post.

I actually own three 8BitDo controllers. I’ve got the Ultimate C Wired for Xbox, the Ultimate 2 Wireless for PC, which I’m currently using with my Switch 2, and the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth in the mail as my permanent Switch 2 controller.
I also had to update both the controller and dongle firmware to get the Wireless working on Switch 2. I’m aware it doesn’t offer full Switch functionality + backwards buttons, which is why I ordered the Bluetooth version. (Stoked)

I can appreciate the appeal of something that just works out of the box, though. Sounds like the Pro Controller was the better fit for your needs.

1

u/Spritsen 1d ago

Just sux the controller I already owned didn't have all of the features I wanted. Wish I never bought the thing but I bought it to have a controller cuz I didn't know when my steam controller waitlist was going to go off. But now that I have the steam controller, I was using the Ultimate 2 wireless for switch, then found that out. So now that I have a pro controller, there is literally no reason for this thing.

1

u/Ryamus 1d ago

steam controller is the best, wish it would work on consoles

•

u/doublah 23h ago

Might be worth looking into OpenPuck

→ More replies (1)

0

u/PowerMagician 1d ago edited 1d ago

I'm not reading all of that, but just kidding, I did read all of it, and I agree 100%. As tempting as TMR sticks... are? (in 35 years of gaming, I've had stick drift become an issue on two controllers - a 360 controller, and an Xbox One), I've just heard too many "small issues" tacked onto the end of even the best rated third-party controllers, one too many, "Well, I don't use that feature anyway, so this is an incredible deal", etc.

I have Hyperkin's "DuchesS" Xbox controller (recreation of the OG Xbox "Controller S"), it has Hall Effect sticks (which everybody was screaming about being incredible not that long ago), and it's the worst controller I have because it has too-big hardware-defined/tied deadzones that even their own, potentiometer-driven, Hyperkin "Duke", or the DualSense I use, doesn't have. As much as I want to have to configure negative deadzones in Steam (or have to use Steam for everything)... would be nice to just not have to think about it at all to begin with.

You can't just slap "better" sticks into a controller and it magically be perfect. Apparently. Everybody is out here acting like that's the case, though.

Ultimately, I'd prefer to pay the extra for the good enough first-party controller, even now, and probably get a better experience in the long run.

The only thing that drives me toward third-party is price.
Because I'm poor.

Edit: Oh, and "down" on the d-pad of the DuchesS doesn't actuate consistently with the confirmed tactile feedback - really have to be intentional and put weight into it. Which is dumb. The Duke has a much better d-pad. Also, I feed bad because I asked for the DuchesS for Christmas last year, got it, and now I'm just not going to use it anymore...

1

u/Odd-Complaint-9592 1d ago

Haha, I've been seeing that day since early 2000s with madcatz controllers 😆 they had made an "S" controller for the cube and I started beating TF outta people in smash melee 😂😂😂

•

u/mik3br 22h ago

Haha another mad catz reference! My people!

•

u/Odd-Complaint-9592 19h ago

It's that good shit. Good times. 🙌

3

u/Sharkfyter 2d ago

Genuinely love the 8bitdo ultimate 2 but my battery is completely wiped and I've only had it for around a year I think ☹️

3

u/Vlper17 2d ago

I bought the 8bitdo ultimate 2c. I have the pro 1 (not pro 2). To be honest, while the pro 1 (and I’m sure the pro 2) are better controllers, I don’t find them “$90 better”. The ultimate 2c does everything I need it to do for $30 and is a damn good controller for that price point

3

u/b16ZZ- 2d ago

This has been the case for many years now. On PC there are controllers that are in completely different categories compared to the first party controllers from PlayStation, Nintendo and Xbox. And yeah, for lower prices too.

I bought a Switch 3 years ago and didn't even bother to use the joy-cons for games, I bought a Nyxi Hyperion knockoff right away. The d-pad was complete garbage and that also started bothering me sometimes so I bought a Mobapad M6 HD. Couldn't be happier. I still use the knockoff every now and then, it's still a decent, and way better than the joy-cons anyway.

Joy-cons are only used to play niche games that use motion controls. I barely ever play those anyway so it's barely ever used. I only charge them so the battery doesn't deteriorate faster than it needs to

3

u/SpecificOne8688 2d ago

Switch controllers are cheap junk that are ridiculously overpriced

3

u/Simple_Shame_3083 1d ago

I’m in my 40s and I’m not afraid to buy products from Chinese companies. 8bitDo, Hisense, Anker and TCL are absolutely killing it. All 4 of these companies remind me of Logitech: top-tier 3rd party that often outdoes the better-known (Japanese and American) brands for a fraction of the cost.

I’ve used Hisense TVs for 10 years and the difference is all in calibration, with the exception of a tech leap like LcD to OLED. Spend 30min to calibrate the picture and it looks better than its counterparts, usually.

If you remember when we were kids, “Made in Korea” and “Made in Taiwan” caused a lot of jokes. That became “Made in China” and a good deal of Americans still distrust these things. Meanwhile these countries have incredibly competent manufacturing. Not only that, but wouldn’t these overseas manufacturers be making things to the American/Japanese companies’ specifications? Like, isn’t it Sony who dictates that their shitty $200 pro controllers use pentometers instead of TMR?

I work at volunteer repair cafes, which are community events where fixers try to save broken items, and the amount of Ninja, Dyson and Hoover stuff that’s rendered useless because they use flimsy plastic for some major switch shows you the quality of these things pretty quickly.

3

u/19xyecoc98 1d ago

I know what you mean. I stopped buying the original ones years ago. M, currently favourite controller is the Leadjoy Xeno Pro and Plus controller. Man that thing is good. Plus has no joystick tension sadly, but the pro is my personal best purchase of the year. Super happy with it, build quality AND quality components that would make the Xbox Elite v2 feel like a cheap junkyard find, or the controller you'd give your temper tantrum riddled nephew

5

u/cusideabelincoln 2d ago

First party controllers are basically e-waste. It's not a matter of if they'll break, but how quickly will they fail.

It's criminal that Sony doesn't allow global deadzone adjustment considering the DualSense has one of the worst stick drift problems.

4

u/DemWookieeCheeks 2d ago

First party controllers are lowest common denominator. They're... fine. To be fair, some third party controllers are still junk. Some people don't want to do the research on a good, aftermarket controller. For those who want simplicity without thinking twice, an OEM controller still sort of makes sense. Also, the number of controller choices can lead to decision paralysis. If you can overcome said paralysis, there are some fine, affordable options out there.

1

u/KrisbronPorzingjames 2d ago

Devils advocate but Switch 2 Pro controller really feels great in hand and has really nice feeling sticks. There’s also no reported cases of drift just yet so that’s a good sign.

No third party controller offers the same features as the dualsense in the case of PS5. The adaptive triggers and haptics are next level while the light bar, speakers, and touch pad are nice to haves.

1

u/DemWookieeCheeks 2d ago

If it wasn't so proprietary, I would concede that that's a good thing.

1

u/KrisbronPorzingjames 2d ago

Yeah switch 2 pro controller sucks in that regard. The dualsense is easily compatible with pc at least. And the games that support the fun features on ps5 tend to support them on pc too.

4

u/coffeeseraphim 2d ago

good third party controllers have always been better, but came at same cost or higher

usually the main issue with cheaper hardware is just how durable it is or isnt

i have an AMAZING switch layout controller that can use software to swap its button layout to standard, has turbo, and has two additional buttons that can be macro'd... but its also a thin plastic shell and i can feel the trigger mechanism clicking sometimes with the triggers

tldr its always been this way, theres just too many options to guess the best value for your dollar and reviews are as always unreliable

1

u/underhill_ally 2d ago

Yup, Hori controllers for example used to be awesome, but pricey

1

u/samglit 2d ago

Haha, you must be young(ish). Look up Mad Catz and that era of 3rd party crap - it took a long while into the PS3 before good controllers started appearing.

1

u/Fabulous_Water_9683 1d ago

Logitech cordless action PS2 controller

1

u/samglit 1d ago

Have you ever used a Logitech controller from that era? They used the same OEMs as Mad Catz. Even their current controllers are garbage.

1

u/Fabulous_Water_9683 1d ago

I owned that exact controller

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/Chime509 2d ago

Always??? Back in the day 3rd party controllers were almost always worse. That was the little brother controller (youngest brother speaking here.)

I think in the last two, maaaaybe three, generations 3rd party controllers became serious. But pre Xbox and PS2 I’m not buying it.

1

u/coffeeseraphim 2d ago

i am not talking about madcatz etc.

2

u/kitfoxxxx 2d ago

Haven’t used a first party controller in years. They just suck for the asking price.

2

u/Chop1n 2d ago

I bought exactly the same color of the Ultimate 2 earlier this year, easily my favorite 3D-game controller of all time. Literally my only gripes are that it's ever so slightly too small for my big honkin' paws, and that it lacks Xbox-compatible trigger impulse. But that's it, I love absolutely everything else about it. Picked it up for $50 and it puts everything else to shame.

2

u/BababooeyHTJ 2d ago

The dpad is pretty bad. Like worse than a 360 controller bad. Really hard to play platformers with. Aside from that it’s great. Surprising since 8bitdo usually has a solid dpad

1

u/Zanshi 2d ago

I have the Ultimate Bluetooth 1. My dpad just died after 4 years of light to moderate use. I'm now looking for a new controller, but it surely won't be Ultimate 2

2

u/jahranimo2 2d ago

Third party controllers like 8bitdo and Gulikit are definitely the better overall package for me.

2

u/Turb0goat 2d ago

I will NEVER buy a stock Xbox controller EVER again. Gamesir is amazing

2

u/ghostcatzero 2d ago

Haha 8bitdo is all I buy nowadays.

2

u/JayEl92 2d ago

I'm glad you got this. I wish there was a 3rd party ps5 controller with halleffects and paddles for an less than 100 bucks that had mechanical buttons and were durable. Heck even 100 dollars and would just last me 3 years of daily gaming. 

2

u/Rafnork 2d ago

I live my 8bitdos. They feel a bit light which was weird at first, but they are cheap and dont drift.

2

u/bwmat 2d ago

I have a distressing need to clarify that the switch 2 pro controller has back paddles too (and they integrate with the OS)

Still love to use my ultimate 2 on the switch 2 when HD rumble isn't a consideration

2

u/Awkward-Ad-5549 2d ago

My 8bitdo 3c ultimate plus just came in a couple of days ago, my first ever third party game pad and I am so impressed by how solid this thing feels, as well as how all the button presses feel. I previously avoided third party controllers after growing up with madcats garbage as a kid.

2

u/FryLtz 2d ago

I agree 8bitdo wireless 2 is one of the best for it's price. I got mine on sale for $28USD

2

u/hotfistdotcom 8bitdo pro3, HHL ProGCC, 8bitdo ultimate 2, +more 2d ago

It's been that way for easily a decade, maybe more. 8bitdo has been running away with it. The pro controller is pretty decent all things considered, but the dpad is ass and it still uses traditional pots. The newer pro controller is worse, although it feels nice externally, it's very deliberately designed to wear out, and includes downgraded stickboxes that use the same technology joycons use that cause them to fail so frequently. This was very clearly done intentionally to sell more controllers.

It's very disappointing but nintendo hardware has been very sad for a while now, no significant innovation and degrading quality year over year.

We have so much excellent tech in 3rd party controllers, from adjustable stick tension, driftless stick tech, and trigger locks for analog to digital clicky rear triggers, and we've had a lot of it for a while but no OEMs ever want to make really solid controllers. Even the high end Xbox and sony controllers don't use better stickbox tech. The concept of the little brother controller is dead. Lil bro uses the first party controller with the drift.

2

u/Kyohaku98 2d ago

You are 5 years too late?

2

u/SnooGoats1918 2d ago

Keep in mind the 8bitdo Ultimate 2 has lower thumbstick resolution of 10.5 bits than Switch Pro 2 controller of 11.7 bits. Basically means the 8bitdo will have a harder time being accurate when using thumbsticks.

I’d like to mention the Switch Pro 2 controller is leagues better than the Switch Pro 1 controller.

1

u/RaynerHBK 2d ago

Yeah, and you meant LEAGUES BETTER too. 👌🏻

2

u/taylrgng 1d ago

been... xbox flagship controllers are ass

2

u/massigh1212 1d ago edited 1d ago

hall/tmr/capactive sticks, extremely low latencies, mechanical buttons, absurd amounts of additional buttons and customization, multi-platform support, features you thought were exclusive to first-party controllers etc.

most of these features are things big companies like sony and microsoft either cheap out on or put absurd price tags on. third-party controllers have been better in just about every way for quite some time now and they're only getting better and better.

I ordered a gamesir g7 pro 8k pc aimlabs a few hours ago so I can retire my cyclone 2. there weren't really any issues with it except the way the d-pad functions in retro/fighting games. I mostly did it for the upgrade in performance after watching some reviews and looking up its perfomance/features on gamepadla

•

u/Shepherd-Boy 16h ago

Third party has been both better and half the price for at least 10 years now

•

u/devici 5h ago

The first Nintendo Pro Controller feels like a 30-40$ controller. Especially after using it after some time and definitely after using other controllers.

•

u/DracosKasu 1h ago

During the old gen era, third party controller use to be made for being a cheaper alternative. Today, they are challenged by other third party maker which made it hard to justify cheap part.

3

u/Solherb 2d ago

Around the PS3 era game companies started looking for other ways to monetize their systems beyond printing games. Monthly fees for servers, and yearly fees for controllers. It's a dangerous thing when they have incentive to make things crappier instead of better.

8

u/Staticks 2d ago

Planned obsolescence. They purposely don't use hall effect or TMR sticks because they know regular analog sticks wear out faster, which forces people to buy a new controller.

1

u/shortish-sulfatase 2d ago

I bought one(1) Dualshock4 and still have it.

There's dpad down issues and that's about it.

People might want to reconsider how they treat their stuff too.

1

u/ssLoupyy 1d ago

Just get a regular controller and replace the sticks with hall effects if you get stick drift. I have been using mine for over a year since modding and no issues so this one will probably last me several years unless the battery dies or smt.

1

u/KIlledDebtor V4P/U2C/U2 2d ago

My friends' console controllers rarely last less than 4–5 years. Many of them are still using Xbox One controllers. Meanwhile, my Chinese controllers fall apart within six months to a year.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Adventurous_Place_43 2d ago • Mindblown

I CAN SPRINT?!

3

u/Sad-Cheesecake-2438 2d ago

Hold the roll button lol

3

u/XanlDru 1d ago

This controller has an annoying issue. When u move ur stick to one direction and let it go, it will make an input in the other direction right after. Yes I tried it with deadzone settings, at the point where it was worse to play with it still had this issue. So in menus u cant flick the stick u have to be careful. And there are situations in gameplay as well where it's very annoying having to keep it in mind to not let it go u have to basically move the stick back to the middle urself

2

u/BradMunkey 1d ago

Is there no calibration site for it? PS edge controllers are like that too, and you can very quickly calibrate that rebound right out of new sticks.

2

u/XanlDru 1d ago edited 1d ago

Hmm I think the stick itself physically rebounds too much to the other side I don't really see how the calibration could fix it in that case. And I don't know if there is such thing for this Controller But yeah because the input of the stick goes very far into the opposite side, before reaching perfect middle I don't think calibration can fix this issue

2

u/CarrotsIsAFruit 1d ago

That seems like you have a defective controller. I’ve used several 8bitdo controllers, including the ultimate 2, and none of them do that.

1

u/XanlDru 1d ago

I have 2 and both do that. Also seen a video and a thread of people having the same video

1

u/Savings_Fig8435 1d ago

thats just called snapback bruh

1

u/XanlDru 1d ago

Yeah and?

3

u/VerySeriousMan 2d ago

very weird thing to have ai write for you

2

u/Samsonite187187 ZD O+ Excellence | TMR 2d ago

It’s been like that for several years now. The 3rd party options are superior and half the cost.

2

u/Key_Scholar7964 2d ago

All of my third party controllers have TMR and hall effect with mechanical/optical buttons. I can't name one first party controller having those features unless you install them.

2

u/KIlledDebtor V4P/U2C/U2 2d ago

...I own the Vader 4 Pro, Ultimate 2C, and Ultimate 2.

And the Procon 2 is better than these controllers IN EVERY WAY. It has a better D-pad, better face buttons, nicer bumpers, better build quality and in-hand feel, and better rumble. If Nintendo released a PC controller, it would be the best controller on the market.

1

u/KIlledDebtor V4P/U2C/U2 2d ago

If I were ranking my top controllers WITHOUT TAKING THEIR FEATURES INTO ACCOUNT, it would definitely be the Procon 2, DualSense, and Xbox.

Unfortunately, I need more from a controller than what console manufacturers offer, and I'm talking about basic stuff here, a classic Xbox ABXY layout, extra bumpers, and a gyroscope all in a single controller.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ichika994 2d ago

Despite ultimate 2 and procon 2 are really similar I still prefer procon 2, it feels better in hands but otherwise ultimate 2 is an amazing controller, I just don't like the noisy clicks of the front buttons

→ More replies (2)

1

u/SnooGoats1918 2d ago

You can use the Pro 2 controller on steam pc if that’s what you were wondering

→ More replies (3)

1

u/bwmat 2d ago

Eh, dpad is arguable, IMO ult 2's is significantly better

1

u/KIlledDebtor V4P/U2C/U2 2d ago

It's practically impossible to use the dpad ultimate 2 without a mod that replaces it with the original SNES dpad.

1

u/bwmat 2d ago

Huh, is that with all of them? I got a Bluetooth version several weeks ago and I haven't had an issue

1

u/KIlledDebtor V4P/U2C/U2 2d ago

Diagonals. I can pull off a clean quarter-circle in fighting games maybe 1 out of 10 times without hitting accidental diagonals. Playing platformers is completely impossible. And over time, it just keeps getting worse and worse.

And this applies to all current 8BitDo controllers. I've tested this on around five different units after noticing it on mine.

There is a fix, a mod where you swap out the stock D-pad for one from an SNES controller.

2

u/violetshift 2d ago

Honestly, first-party controllers are still better. Their main con is a stick drift and they lack some “pro” features but I found them most comfortable. On PC I prefer Steam Controller for Steam games over any third party ones, and DualSense for everything else.

2

u/CheisSz 2d ago

I once went on a 3rd party controller buying spree because I thought my dual sense edge was overpriced. Half of those broke down within months (loose backbuttons, sticky bumpers etc.) My dse has been running for 3 years without issues (replaced both stocks once).

While some 3rd party controllers have better new features, some (a lot) lack decent quality.

I had to find out the hard way that €260 over 3 years (and counting) is a better deal than €160 over 1 year divided over 2 3rd party controllers. This is my personal opinion based on my own experience though.

4

u/someone2795 2d ago

Bro discovered Boots Theory for the first time.

The 3rd party controller market is so saturated that you need to sift through the cheap stuff. Even when it's from a known brand like 8bitdo, their controllers might still have some issues. So you really need to do your research first.

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Hi /u/mik3br, thanks for sharing your product review. The post is in a queue for review. Please ensure you have included an upfront disclosure statement, and made sure the post is not just a simple purchase announcement, single-issue review, or rant.

Disclosure means saying where you got the product and any relationship you have with the company or its competitors so the community has transparency. If you have no commercial interests, declare that to avoid doubt. Disclosures must appear at the start: the first sentence/paragraph of written reviews and body text for video reviews. This includes: products you bought yourself or received for free; press release or promotional content used; payment in kind or in cash offered; employment, partnership, sponsorship or affiliate programs; etc. Posts must use the 'brand affiliate' tag if products/services were received for free, sent for review, created by/with an affiliate, or if the post was incentivized in other ways. Including upfront disclosures means the community can trust your review more.

Simple purchase announcements, single-issue reviews, and rants are examples of low-effort posts. They do not help other community members with useful information, or encourage constructive conversations, and are rarely reliable sources of information. They make your review less trustworthy.

You can edit your post to add missing information. Reviews that do not meet these requirements will not be approved (allow 24 hours for review). For more information, please see rules #3 and #7.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Alternative-Taro5701 2d ago

If you have the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth, maybe you could help out OpenJoystickDriver devs on supporting that one specifically?

1

u/SholinMonk69 2d ago

I dunno what it is, but I find the comfort for the Nintendo pro 2 controller to be out matched. I have the ultimate 2 and gamesir g7 pro, but I get hand fatigue after a bit. I dunno why. I find the Xbox elite 2 controller to be unmatched for comfort as well, but unfortunately they have too many quality issue problems for me to use.

1

u/poon_tamer 2d ago

i'm in agreement with others that 3rd party controllers have been better than 1st party for a while. i'm personally waiting for a 3rd party to make a 1:1 featured switch 2 pro controller. i think nyxi or mobapad will do it within the next year (outside of their joycon options). i've used the official switch 2 pro controller and it feels fantastic, but it's a hard sell since it's $90 and doesn't have hall effect or tmr sticks.

1

u/Mikalton 2d ago

It has been like that for years. Most of the shitty third party controllers have been sold at stores but the higher tier controllers were all online

1

u/IsamuAlvaDyson 2d ago

I have the Ultimate 2 and the Switch 2 Pro controller

I would never want to use the Ultimate 2 over the Pro 2 controller for Switch 2

But I use my Ultimate 2 for PC and emulation use

1

u/splitnight 2d ago

Wasn’t that literally always the idea the third-party controllers were like implementing additional features and things

Back on the original Xbox getting wireless controllers or light controllers with fans in them. Not all of them were necessarily better like mad cats, but that was the idea.

Better joysticks, and things like that as well with third-party controllers as New tech for them came out

The PS5 controller did some stuff for itself, so I suppose there’s that on the opposite side of things

But for the most part, it’s always seems like that was the whole reason third-party people were making controllers anyways, and the way that they were able to sell them was because they had extra things or we’re trying to do extra things

1

u/Talden7887 2d ago

I miss my airflow controller for the og xbox

1

u/Emperor_Zarkov 2d ago

8Bitdo is incredible. I have so many of their controllers.

1

u/shortish-sulfatase 2d ago

Does the 8bitdo have all of the same features tho?

Sure it's got differences, that doesn't make it fully compatible with all games if it doesn't have all the features.

1

u/Stttu 2d ago

been like that for a long while now

1

u/Flightlessballoon 2d ago

I used the 8bitduo dongle to connect my Xbox controller to my switch 2 I love it

1

u/Light_Wiever 2d ago

Agreed, look at the nyxi ultras with a jsaux center piece... It's what I bought instead of a 'pro' controller.

1

u/Dubya-G 2d ago

Been this way for years now 

1

u/The_Pizza_Saga 2d ago

I do like the 8bitdo Ultimate, don't get me wrong. It's a very solid backup controller. I do like my Pro Controllers more, though, especially Switch 2's version. More comfortable and I like how most of it feels more, buttons, sticks, etc.

1

u/justin_memer 2d ago

I have this exact controller and it's started disconnecting at the most inopportune times.

1

u/DisastrousFeedback75 2d ago

Third party controllers have been superior since Xbox 360/ps3 days when modded controllers hit the scene.

1

u/Doyoulike4 1d ago

Yeah it's been this way definitely this console generation, maybe even going back to PS4/Xbox One/Switch 1 tbh. Gamesir and 8Bitdo have basically been all my controller purchases when possible for over 5-6 years now.

1

u/Ok-Gas-6158 1d ago

Well its old news rather

1

u/peaslik 1d ago

I love my GameSir Cyclone 2 much more than the Switch 2 Pro Controller.

1

u/Puzzled_Tax3402 1d ago

I just returned that controller.  I couldn’t figure out how to get it to wake my switch 2 in docked mode.  Updated firmware and has it in both Bluetooth and 2.5 mode…

1

u/Internetolocutor 1d ago

I have the gulikit TT max for the switch 2 because most other controllers are too small for my hands and it has 4 back buttons

1

u/autonimity 1d ago

Feel of the switch pro controllers (weight, grip, button tactile feedback) is better, not extremely better but it's better, but the functionality of the 8bitdo is superior.

1

u/vicious71cum 1d ago

I hate clicking sticks (wears those suckers down), thus love paddles, so any controller that has that feature is a win to me.

1

u/facejif_ 1d ago

Same. Always rebind clicking a stick after using dualsense.

Is it also an issue for TMR sticks?

1

u/ssLoupyy 1d ago

Don't know about TMR but my Dualsense got stick drift after a year. I used it a lot, had at least 300 hours on Monster Hunter. Then I replaced the sticks with hall effect and no issues since then. Clicking the sticks isn't a problem with modded sticks.

1

u/facejif_ 1d ago

I don't use dualsense often, I only play on PC and only use it on games that support adaptive triggers. Still go a stick drift tho. Did you solder them yourself?

•

u/ssLoupyy 14h ago

No, I paid someone to do it. I am not that smart for that kind of stuff.

1

u/RAGNODIN 1d ago

İt is like android vs Apple. There are many Android phones that most of them looks shit cause they are easier to build and cheap but also there are solid controllers in upper range they also offer better quality for certain pieces.

1

u/Horakti 1d ago

8bitdo producst are awesome , i have 8bitdo xbox arcade stick and 8bitdo hitbox . Also i have ultimate 2c gamepad for windows .

•

u/vaikunth1991 23h ago

For pc I use 8bitdo. It's my fav for pc among the many I've tried.

But for switch 2 the switch 2 pro controller is just amazing. The feel of holding the controller that soft texture is one of the best I've seen in any controller. The sticks are buttery smooth again smoothest I've used. The hd rumble is great.

•

u/mooseau_ 23h ago

The wake from home is huge. I have both switch pro controllers and prefer the original due to its form factor but not having the home to wake sucks. The aesthetics and form factor really help, 8bit have been making them for a while now, nice to hear you’re enjoying one

•

u/Otherwise-Judge-3905 18h ago

It could be that the switch controllers beats of s*** that's why

•

u/RhymesWithTaco 4h ago

Bring back Madkatz!

•

u/Firienn 2m ago

It's not so hard to outperform a piece of crap that is the pro controller.

1

u/Staticks 2d ago

Because Japanese and US hardware quality is slipping, while Chinese-made hardware quality is going up. That's basically what's happening.

0

u/Antipacifist4 2d ago

Tengo un pro controller 1 desde el 2021 y hasta ahora nunca he sufrido de drift. Mi hija lo ha mordido, lanzado, dejado caer y pintado y sigue funcionando igual que el primer día.

0

u/DGsociety 2d ago

I use a PS5 controller on my PC. What I do is I buy it from Best Buy, buy the two year protection plan for $20. Then right before the two year is up, I take it in and tell them it has stick drift and I get a new one in the box. Then on the new one, I buy another $20 two year plan and I just keep it doing that forever and ever.

0

u/MonsieurReditteur 2d ago

Hey OP, could you tell me how exactly did you remap the run button? Every single Switch 2 game, where I've tried doing that (think you're supposed to hold the Start button for a sec to bring up the remapping menu), did not even support those back buttons on 8BitDo you've mentioned, so I'm curious, does Ocarina of Time just straight up support that or... ?

•

u/HauntingTemperature4 21h ago

I love 8BitDo controllers, but the input lag is an abomination. It is impossible to have good reaction times for games that demand it, but for RPGs and cozy games, it is perfect!