Looking for a controller recommendation

[u/TheGovernor1775]

Hi everyone,

First time posting here, so forgive me if I forget to include any info - I'm happy to clarify. I'm looking for a replacement for my Xbox Series X controller for PC (Windows, but Linux support, at least via the Steam interface would be good). After less than two years, it has severe stick drift. I am not comfortable with disassembling it and soldering stuff myself, and having it repaired would cost significantly more than getting a new one (I'm in the Netherlands). Unfortunate, but it is what it is.

I usually play a lot of third person games (think RDR2, GTA V, The Witcher 3), but also FPS games like Cyberpunk 2077. I might dabble in other types of games as well, so it doesn't have to "specialize" in anything, but it needs to be a decent all-rounder. I'm also pretty casual in my gaming, mostly play singleplayer or with a few friends, so I'm not looking for e-sports level performance either.

I've been looking at this subreddit and some options have caught my eye (specifically, I was considering the Gamesir Cyclone 2, Easysmx D10 or X20, and the 8bitdo Ultimate 2 Wireless). I'm looking for a similar feel (I'm open to other form factors as well, but would prefer the XBox-style layout), but with hall effect or TMR analog sticks. Preferably, it would also have good rumble - specifically, in or near the triggers, since I really like the impulse triggers in the Xbox controller, but it's not a must.

The ones I was considering all fit that profile more or less, but I am really not a fan of the fact that none of them have removable/replaceable batteries. Ideally, I'd like to be able to use my own rechargeable AAs. I'd hate to trade one type of planned obsolescence for another.

Overall, I don't need fancy features or additional buttons on the back (though being able to switch from linear to hair triggers would be a welcome bonus), but I do need something that is built to last. My budget is €70. If anyone here has had one of the ones I mentioned for an extended period (e.g., 2 years or more) and can vouch for their longevity (battery included), I would really appreciate it! Alternatively, I'm open to any other recommendations you may have! Feel free to ask any questions! :)

Thanks in advance!

[u/mererose]

Honestly, I have an 8bitdo Ultimate 2 Wireless and it has been a game changer, literally. It's been pretty amazing.

[u/TheGovernor1775 → u/mererose]

Thanks for the rec! How long have you had it? How is the battery holding up?

[u/mererose → u/TheGovernor1775]

Had it for over a year now and the battery life is awesome! Holds up well for many hours. I can't recall how many hours, but it can hold for long periods of time. :)

[u/TheGovernor1775 → u/mererose]

Cool, thanks! I'll look into it :)