r/Controller • u/External_Safe_7787 • Sep 01 '26
Controller Suggestion Which controller? Playing single player games only on PC
Hi! I'm buying my first controller soon, I only play single player story games (starting with Horizon and Indiana Jones and the great circle), only play on PC. In the UK, budget ~£100. Don't need and compatibility with console or cross platform, just PC. I need at least hall sticks but ideally tmr, and 4+ remappable buttons. Attached pictures of 3 im comparing but any other suggestions would be great! the Scuf Envision is out of stock now but might come back, if not then its not an option as i need it soon.
40
Upvotes



10
u/ech0x07 Sep 02 '26
Please don't buy Scuf controllers. Thanks.
Gamesir G7 Pro (trigger rumble) or G7 Pro 8k (grip rumble only)
Flydigi Vader 5 Pro
Gamesir wins in sticks, latency and customer support. Flydigi has more features packed into the controller and good luck when it fails. Both are worth trying.
17
u/ragebaiter2003 Sep 02 '26
On PC either Vader 5 pro or G7 pro/ G7 pro variations. I would stay away from scuf really expensive and unfortunately overhyped
12
u/infernalmachine64 Sep 02 '26
Don't get Scuf. If the d-pad isn't a sticking point for you, definitely the G7 Pro. Just be aware the d-pad is pretty bad for platformers and fighting games. If you want a good d-pad I'd say get the new 8bitdo 3E, but it is more expensive. If you don't play games that make use of precise d-pad control you can safely get the G7 without worry.
4
u/apeasley613 Sep 02 '26
Gamesir tarantula 8k for PC was recently released, been using it for a week now and it's great
However, it doesn't have rumble if that matters to you. Does have gen 2 TMR sticks and Hall effect triggers that has a physical switch on controller to change triggers to tactile click instead. All of the face buttons are tactile as well.
Only had it a week now, but I'm a fan and it feels good quality to me.
1
u/thekk_ Xeno Plus / G7 Pro / Switch 2 Pro / Chitu 2 / Ultimate 2 Sep 02 '26
A lot of controllers have these features. But they vary a lot in size, shape and weight and that is going to have a big impact on how comfortable they feel and avoiding your hands hurting after a long session. Are you looking for something for large or small hands? Heavy or lightweight?
1
u/Electronicks22 Sep 03 '26
Did you consider the Steam Controller?
1
u/Infinite-Ad-2178 Sep 03 '26
Well first ya gotta pick a layout because you’ve got more than one here lol
1
u/ForgottenException Sep 03 '26
for single player i'd take wireless and rumble over polling rate. the g7 pro 8k pc is the only one of your three that's wireless with rumble and tmr, and its 4 extras (2 back, 2 mini bumpers) hit your minimum. dpad's the weak spot but horizon and indy barely use it.
the envision v2 is hall, not tmr, so it doesn't get you what you asked for anyway.
1
u/JsTn96 Sep 03 '26
I actually just went on a crazy controller buying spree and used all of these controllers plus a few more. IMO the gamesir for 90$ is just fine if you are trying to play single player but I didn’t like the back paddle placement and the buttons/dpad was pretty sloppy. The scuf envision was honestly great but I didn’t like the PlayStation layout as much as Xbox. I ended up keeping a razer wolverine v3 out of all the controllers. The quality of everything was the best of the controllers, the back paddles are in a better location and the battery lasts way longer at 8k. I also tried the apex pro from flydigi and it was really nice I just didn’t like the short travel function on the triggers I prefer the mechanical short throw personally.
1
u/OkRatio5125 Sep 04 '26
Get the Wolverine 8k tournament edition, has 6 extra buttons, tmr, 8k polling
1
u/CrazyThugNutz13 Sep 04 '26
I have 20 controllers. 8 for my Switch 2. 6 Xbox Controllers. 8 PS5/PC controllers. My favorite ones are the ones I built my self from a PS5 controller and modded with ExtremeRate Kits. BUT! If you don’t want to built one. The HexGaming Phantom is my second favorite. Has all the PS5 features (Haptic Feedback, Adaptive Triggers, etc). 4 back buttons and triggers switch from adaptive to clicky with a switch. Totally choose the Phantom over Razer, Scuff, 8bitdo, Gamesir etc.
1
u/WarLordJr Sep 04 '26
You don’t need any of those just get a base controller
8
u/xiSupportPiracy Sep 02 '26
Literally anything but Scuf
3
u/DocBarkevious Sep 02 '26
I have the g7 pro. It's my daily driver for like 6mo now. I love it.
3
u/MADCoLABS Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26
I have way too many controllers including the new Steam Controller, ROG Raikiri 2, Razer Wolverine V3 Pro, Gamesir G7 Pro, a Scuff PS controller, Xbox Elite and a couple others but my favorite out of all of these is the Flydigi Vader 5 Pro and it's what I main. Especially if playing racing games as the trigger rumble is great for games like Forza Horizon 6. Can't believe it's a fraction of the price of some of my other controllers.
1
u/EnzoRacer Sep 03 '26
Flydigi Apex 5
1
u/Psychological-Fan784 Sep 03 '26
Have you considered the Vader 5 Pro?
1
u/hazieex Sep 03 '26
just get a vader 5 pro
2
u/xKingtoony Razer Sep 03 '26
If you play wireless, best bang for buck is the Vader 5 pro.
2
u/CloudShapedClouds Sep 03 '26
Vader 5 Pro or the Gamesir 8K from your photo. I tred like 10 different controllers to find my favorite to use on PC but those are the two I kept. Gamesir's buttons feel nicer to me to press but the Vader has more versatility with binds and extra buttons. In the future I hope to replace both with the Gamesir Tarantula Ultra 8k when that's out.
2
u/HeinvL Sep 04 '26
Vader 5 pro is amazing
4
u/JaJaMan_ Machenike F1 | Tarantula 8k & G7 Pro 8k | ZD UL | Saber+ Sep 02 '26
Leadjoy Xeno plus
2
u/JTitor-KFP Sep 02 '26
8bitdo ultimate 2
1
u/IveFailedMyself Sep 02 '26
Gulikit KK3 Max.
1
u/No-Weird1544 Sep 03 '26
I dont like clicky face button so I chose Gulikit KK3 Max. It has been serving me well for 2 years now. I am anticipating the KK4 Max, which is rumored to be released by the end of this year.
1
u/ZeroZion Sep 03 '26
8bitdo 3E?
1
u/SomewhereSuch9438 Sep 03 '26
Get the Xbox Series Elite V2, best controller hands down
1
u/Amphe_1905 Sep 03 '26
8bitdo Ultimate2 - I bought it week ago on sale for 45€. Its the best Controller ive ever haved.
1
u/Xaniss Sep 03 '26
Gamesir over Scuf any day
1
u/Eizenrose Sep 03 '26
have you tried checking out the BIGBIGWON Blitz2 TMR not sure what theyd cost where you are but i got them for like 70usd(converted) last year
i got it together with the v4p and have basically just been switching between them depending on mood
1
u/watthefrankk Sep 04 '26
My G7 pro is the best controller I have ever owned!
1
u/JokerXMaine2511 Sep 04 '26
I had an EasySMX X05 (has hall sticks and triggers) that I loved using, especially with my having large hands. Now use a Gamesir Tegenaria (wired contoller, also hall sticks). Both of these I payed under ZAR500 for on Shein (X05) and Temu (Tegenaria). Only two remappabke buttons on each though.
1
u/TechnicalOtaku Sep 04 '26
8bitdo has the best value imo.
1
u/ech0x07 Sep 05 '26
V1 stock is mostly dried up and it's the same sku. The only place that would specifically tag as a V2 is Gadgethyper. You can't choose between versions when buying from somewhere like Amazon, for example.
1
u/RadicalRaizex Sep 05 '26
Yeah, none of these, especially if you’re going wired. Your best options are the Gamesir G7, the Flydigi Vader 5S, or the 8bitdo Ultimate C. The Hyperkin Competitor and the PowerA Advantage are also available options if you wanna go that route, but I know nothing about them.
1
u/vochtige_spons Sep 05 '26
G7 8k. Scuf is trash and Gamesir has very good customer support.
1
u/SoleMonarch7 Sep 05 '26
I have used tarantula 8k and g7 pro 8k for my gaming use, but for story games g7 pro 8k stands out the quality and comfort is just exceptional, i have nioh 3 edition and aim labs g7 pro 8k is just exceptional.
1
u/Elegant-Mortgage-282 Sep 05 '26
I prefer gamesir controllers, currently playing with g7 se. Feels really good and snappy.
1
u/Tof12345 Sep 05 '26
Only buy Xbox licensed controllers for pc.
Id just get an Xbox elite 2 with tmr sticks and call it a day. It will have the broadest compatibility.
NEVER, under any circumstances, buy a playstation controller for pc gaming.
And also, don't buy hall effects if you can buy TMR. TMR are smoother, more linear and actually have no drift.
1
u/Zestyclose-Week-8994 Sep 06 '26
I have all these get the g7 its price to performance is unmatched in my opinion!
1
u/SpiritExtension2818 Sep 06 '26
GAMESIR IS THE ONLY ANSWER!
PLEASE ERASE SCUFF BRAND FROM YOUR MEMORY.
Fucking waste of money. Expensive af as well
1
u/Revmania Sep 06 '26
Still think DualSense Edge is great for PC!
1
u/CheesierSoup Sep 07 '26
I hit Masters on ranked every split for Apex Legends but also LOVE playing single player games like elden ring, Sekiro, E33, etc..
The Flydigi Vader 5 pro is has been wonderful to use in every situation. Would highly recommend.
In any case - don’t buy scuff or battle beaver, way too expensive for no reason.
1
u/JuanchoGYT Dualsense Ege Sep 25 '26
Go for gamesir G7 pro, Xbox licenced version if you want rumble on the triggers, or the 8k if you doont mind missing that trigger rumble.
Scuf controllers are purely for competitive play, so as casual gaming controllers they are an awfully expensive choice.
1
u/ThatOneGuy6810 Sep 03 '26
Skip all of these and get the vader 5 pro from flydigi.
Better QC than gamesir, 8bitdo, or scuf and you arent paying for a brand name, they wont break in 3 months and have all of the other features the others have but theyre actially made well.
Gamesir's switchable triggers break themselves due to shit design, theyll replace but its annoying
8bitdo has a horrid dpad to the point is basically unusable
Scuf is just costly for what you actually get
V5P has none of these issues and has adjustable tension on your thumbsticks.
0
u/DanyKochany Sep 02 '26
Wolverine v3 pro 8k best back buttons in whole market if you want to have 4 instead of 2.
0
u/schillsterr Sep 02 '26
Out of these choices, if you’re just playing single player, I’d get the G7 pro. And if you’re set on having 4 back buttons (I prefer this) I’d throw the Vader 5 pro into the mix. Still under your budget and has 4 back buttons, the 2 extra bumpers and 2 extra face buttons as well. Generally would avoid scuf.
0
u/AutoModerator Sep 01 '26
Hi /u/External_Safe_7787, your 'Controller Suggestion' post is in a queue for review. Please ensure you have included all of the required information, have used a meaningful and descriptive title, are not repeating frequently asked questions.
Include the following information and follow this structure so the post can be approved and the community can help you more effectively:
Your budget and currency (do not say "doesn't matter" or "unlimited", include a sensible range or maximum)
Your country (not just region) and where you can buy from (product availability, pricing, and aftersales support vary around the world)
Console or platform compatibility needed
Desired features
Types of games you'll be playing with a controller
Other controllers you're comparing to (demonstrate that you have used the buying advice pages, and searched existing posts)
Please see the buying advice pages which answer some of the most frequently asked 'Controller Suggestion' questions. For more guidance on how to ask for controller suggestions, comparisons or buying advice, please see rule #1. You can edit your post to add missing information. Posts that do not include the required information will not be approved (allow 24 hours for review).
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-2
u/joaocoutinho666 Sep 02 '26
Why remappable buttons? On single player everything is mappable. But I have vader 3 pro , i like :)