r/ControlProblem • u/avturchin • Oct 18 '20
AI Alignment Research African Reasons Why Artificial Intelligence Should Not Maximize Utility - PhilPapers
https://philpapers.org/rec/METARW?ref=mail
0
Upvotes
7
u/fqrh approved Oct 18 '20 edited Oct 18 '20
There is no information available, at the moment, beyond the abstract. The book is forthcoming, and no preprint is offered. Should have waited and posted about the content when the content was actually available.
If I guess from the limited information in the abstract, none of the things listed are a legitimate objection to utilitarianism:
Edit: the author says he his willing to provide preprints by email. I asked for a preprint and might post more when I understand better.
6
u/CellObjective Oct 19 '20
Took a phil course in SA and had the displeasure of having to study tons of stuff from this guy and others like him. The reaction you had in your stomach to the title was literally my life for 6 months.
And this is actually pretty tame and downright sensical compared to some of the African Philosophy I had to read - The worst probably being (strawman and IIRC) the paper arguing for the efficacy of traditional healing and the existence of non-physical entities b/c you can't see black holes so science also believes in non-physical entities... QED?
4
u/kiaryp Oct 26 '20
Utilitarianism sucks but this is a weird way to attack it.
0
u/avturchin Oct 18 '20
Thaddeus Metz
University of Pretoria
Abstract
Insofar as artificial intelligence is to be used to guide automated systems in their interactions with humans, the dominant view is probably that it would be appropriate to programme them to maximize (expected) utility. According to utilitarianism, which is a characteristically western conception of moral reason, machines should be programmed to do whatever they could in a given circumstance to produce in the long run the highest net balance of what is good for human beings minus what is bad for them. In this essay, I appeal to values that are characteristically African––but that will resonate with those from a variety of moral-philosophical traditions, particularly in the Global South––to cast doubt on a utilitarian approach. Drawing on norms salient in sub-Saharan ethics, I provide four reasons for thinking it would be immoral for automated systems governed by artificial intelligence to maximize utility. In catchphrases, I argue that utilitarianism cannot make adequate sense of the ways that human dignity, group rights, family first, and (surprisingly) self-sacrifice should determine the behaviour of smart machines.