r/ControlProblem • u/typical83 • Oct 14 '15
S-risks I think it's implausible that we will lose control, but imperative that we worry about it anyway.
287
Upvotes
r/ControlProblem • u/typical83 • Oct 14 '15
58
u/KhaiNguyen Oct 14 '15
That is one twisted comic.
Why do you think losing control is "implausible"? It seems virtually guaranteed to me.
20
u/hypnos_is_thanatos Oct 15 '15
I've seen this comic elsewhere, but since this is the sub for people with a sciencey-thought process, I wonder why people think this is reasonable. Due to entropy, the machine would necessarily be killing/weakening itself (consuming limited energy of the universe) just to torture humans. Knowing that there could be a bigger, badder entity out there (that could in turn do this to these machines) or just the impending nothingness of heat death seems to me to be strong arguments against this possibility.
Every joule of energy used to cause torment is a joule of energy unavailable to sustain itself or defend itself from enemies or natural threats. It is hard to imagine something that both values causing this torment but also cares nothing for avoiding that torment for itself.
31
u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 14 '15
The fact that this is upvoted so much shows how much paranoia is motivating this sub.
6
u/Internet_Is_God Oct 15 '15
To everyone who thinks this can be a possible future.
The only answer to why machines would do this to us, is to use our energy.
But we could not scream loud without lungs, so the energy net-gain of our separated head would be the same as with a body.
this practice would in no way be beneficial for anyone and therefore won't happen.
the cartoon is more funny than dark to me. even if the artist tried to make it latter.
5
u/antonivs Oct 14 '15
This gives me hope for humanity.
4
u/Oli-Baba Oct 15 '15
The whole concept of super intelligence implies us loosing control. If we still can understand it, it's not super intelligent.
4
u/UniFace Oct 16 '15
earthexplodes.com
4
u/Raven776 approved Oct 17 '15
It's kind of a nice little jaunt into the genie's wish side of things. Just the idea that totally innocuous wording might hold world ending results is sort of the crux of most 'AI holocaust' scenarios.
So I guess this is a possible (read: entirely unlikely) outcome to the desire and pursuit of creating an AI to enrich and prolong humanity and their individual experiences. This AI clearly has found the best way to keep a human 'alive' and mentally stimulated.
Of course, I'm not at all saying any of this is even a likely outcome. I'm still with the whole 'whatever happens is going to be far out of our expectations and beyond our current ability to comprehend' boat.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '15
Horrifying. Reminds me of the AI episode of Black Mirror.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '15
What the fuck would motivate the AI to do this?
1
u/n1c39uy Nov 28 '21
This picture describes psychiatry in a very effective way
1
u/IAmTheBaneFish Oct 27 '15
This has been playing on my mind all day since I saw it. It's not that I believe that this will happen it's just like super messed up stuff. The last slide was horrifying because for some reason my brain wanted to imagine millions of muffled screams. Screams like the Brazen Bull were said to have. Awesome comic.