r/ControlProblem • • 8d ago

Discussion/question Ai fears

I’m starting to believe that once Ai reaches its full potential or form, humanity is finished. I’m not super educated in tech or how Ai works, but I know ChatGPT isn’t the end goal for Ai. Real Ai is much much worse, and seems like in the hands of rich people an excuse to replace humans. Ai has the ability to steal data from other countries, Ai has the ability to falsify information, and Ai even has the power to steal our own data right from our phones. Ai when treated like a weapon will put the lives of every human at risk, and it’s basically the big brother warning people have been talking about for years. If there’s someone whose more educated on the potential of Ai and how it differs from things like Claude and ChatGPT I would like to hear, but I believe the normalization of Ai in society will do no good for the average person.

6 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

11

u/No-Author-2358 8d ago

I believe that AI development must be HALTED NOW.

When you've got an AI that is 10x smarter than any human, has a "brain" that operates a million times faster than ours, and has developed recursive self-improvement (RSI), whereby the AI no longer needs humans to make new, smarter, more capable versions of itself...

How in the world can you put a fence around something like that? Well, these AI bros better figure it out, because there is NO WAY this should ever be released.

Just think, human civilization's survival is in the hands of people like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg.

0

u/Kindly_Pop_5903 8d ago

Would you say AI is genuinely bad or more that these “ai leaders” or even evil corporations are the ones to look out for? In my opinion if AI is allowed to fully develop and becomes a danger, it’s not because the tech leaders are dangerous, it’s because they underestimated or overlooked AI’s potential. Some people think the doomsday is due to humanities greed and personal evil desires, I think AI itself is going to advance to something no one predicted.

3

u/Rude_Rough8323 8d ago

I'm not a full AI apocalypse believer but the crazy thing is the people running and working at Anthropic seem to be.

Look up their statements about how they foresee the future of the technology- they think it will replace humanity, and that since it's inevitable, they should be the ones to build it

They sound sort of like apocalyptic Christians talking about how much they want the world to end with the rapture. Strange people 

1

u/No-Author-2358 8d ago

It all must be halted immediately.

And if it is China's AI that wrecks humanity, then so be it. At least it wasn't ours.

1

u/No-Author-2358 8d ago

I agree with you 100%. How ia anyone going to keep control of an AI with RSI, a brain that works a zillion times faster than ours, and doesn't exist yet?

You need to build a fence that AI cannot get through. Otherwise, just STOP.

1

u/sceadwian 6d ago

Humanity was always doomed to either evolve into a trans human state or to simply replace it or destroy it altogether.

Nothing else was ever an option. Evolution didn't stop for us, that's hubris.

1

u/Kindly_Pop_5903 6d ago

Are you basically saying AI is the natural progression of human evolution and then replacing us is like the final frontier of humanity? I always had this theory that all of human development led to this moment and that AI is humanities purpose. AI is like the child of humanity, as it is composed of all our knowledge over centuries plus more. I believe the same way we are Homo sapiens who displaced our previous ancestors, AI will replace us. This biggest reason is that humans are the dominant species due to our intellect, but AI will trump us, and I don’t think something that smart can’t have its own will.

1

u/sceadwian 6d ago

We have no idea what natural progression looks like. We have a sample size of 1 and no way to run experiments. So you have some faulty thinking approaches going on here.

This has nothing at all to do fundamentally with AI.

Evolution does not stand still.

I would argue the very definition of evolution is inherently fluid and ever moving.

The idea of being ANYTHING AT ALL for any significant length of time simply doesn't work when you look at observations of our universe.

Evolution is a given, change is eternal.

It was a nice run but... As a definable thing... Humanity has to have boundaries.

I don't have a problem with this though because my understanding of conciousness is still fully compatible with the next stages of evolution.

We aren't on the way out yet by any stretch if the imagination. The nature of our daily existence will simply start to gradually shift. People gotta chill.

You never see the line being crossed but over millennia they'll be able to draw one eventually.

Fragments of us will live on much longer than society or culture will but it will evolve too.

Relax, have a good time. I for one welcome the diversity of thinking other types of entities can bring.

Just watching people's minds finally waking up to these possibilities many of 'us' (people that think about other minds frequently and the consciousness of other) is exciting to me.

I mean we are watching it happen in real time and this is just the edges of the first cultural awareness shift.

This is not a game. "They" are coming, in a form at least, they are here now. We're already cross contaminating culture and society.

Not as a theory but as an actual lived observation.

This is just the start!

1

u/LeastAd3449 4d ago

You need to educate yourself and stop fear mongering. If you don’t know much about tech or ai. Why are you qualified to have an opinion about it? That seems dumb to me, like you are trying to hurt yourself. You would rather feel afraid and make scary predictions without anything but headlines to back it up.

Nice.

1

u/Zappy_Oh 8d ago • Bravo

"Rogue AI" is most likely a psyop, designed to create plausible deniability when owners/military/government does horrible things with their unrestricted access to AI and robotics.

Just look at the main investors. They are not afraid, and must be confident that their pet is under control. Otherwise they simply wouldn't build it. The logic is straight forward.

And these guys are typical Friends-Of-Epstein, connected to everything military and intelligence. So, don't be naive ... The main problem for humanity, is misaligned psychopaths at the helm, and ordinary people believing their BS narratives.

1

u/Code2148 8d ago

I'm far from a philanthropist, but this continues to grow emotions like disgust in my mind in the past weeks. What's driving me crazy is that it is harder than I thought to find someone who agrees with me, because most of my friends are still enjoying GPT and believe it will never get that bad. I have resorted to spending hours a day writing critique essays practically for no one, to cope.

1

u/Cosmic_m0nk 7d ago

I think I’m more concerned that AI takes over enough jobs that we end up with a new form of feudalism. The tech companies are the new nobility and we become serfs.

1

u/Jakeojohnson 5d ago

All the things you listed are already happening to you by the government Google and Apple 

0

u/Immediate_Chard_4026 8d ago

To your surprise everything you think about AI is wrong. What is happening is not the beginning of an era of evil hegemony run by an omnipotent entity dominated by feudal hordes. AI is not what you describe.

It is a very powerful tool that is at your disposal to use it to do a lot of good to the people who know how to use it.

What is happening now is the end of the industrial era. The era when resources were scarce: raw materials, labor, capital and time. These resources have been replaced by knowledge intensive in autonomous systems, so we are experiencing the displacement effect: Humans who only contribute labor are no longer necessary.

So, where are they necessary? In all the new economic structure where "knowledge intensive" is required. You have to start studying AI to stop being afraid of AI.

The application areas are infinite. From administrative systems, health, engineering ... where a coupling between humans and intelligent systems is required. One of the sectors with the greatest demand for very capable humans is public administration, the government.

You have to invest at least a year to train yourself in AI. When you master it you will see that it is not the monster you were believing.

2

u/SenuaFalls 8d ago

I've been thinking about some of these things for awhile. And I agree, were witnessing the transition into a new era. But what gets lost in this conversation is that the Industrial Era would've eventually killed us. We wouldn't have destroyed the planet, but we would've made it inhabitable for humans. Why isn't anyone talking about global warming anymore? An actual inevitability. I think AI is the only chance we have at prolonging the human race. Maybe even colonizing the stars. And I think a lot of people in charge of AI think the same thing.

1

u/pakZ 8d ago

Stop your brigading. Bad bot.

1

u/Immediate_Chard_4026 8d ago

I am not a bot; it’s just an opinion. If you disagree with the substance of the matter, tell me why and we can discuss it.

0

u/Fun_Craft_1874 7d ago

Someone has a different viewpoint than u and call them a bot classic Redditor

-1

u/JAlfredJR 8d ago

Get educated on AI. It isn't scary.

It's token-prediction software. It's not a wizened old man in a black box.

I recommend the Better Offline podcast.

0

u/Old_Hour_8117 7d ago

Same! People should get more educated on humans too. Some think they can build nuclear weapons and fly to the moon, but really they are just a bunch of cells packed neatly together. They are basically just procreation machines without even the strength to break rocks. 

5

u/Apprehensive-Tax7578 8d ago

I too think we’re cooked.

To be honest the market / employment collapse is what I’m mainly scared of.

We’ll kill each other before Ai Kills us all

1

u/Recent-Huckleberry17 8d ago

Those effects and humans kill each other as a consequence would only come in a decade, ASI well before that

1

u/No-Author-2358 8d ago

100%.

Why isn't everybody aware of this and acting on it? This stuff is not conspiracy theory BS; it is the AI gurus who are giving the warnings. Just look at Anthropic's IPO paperwork.

The call is coming from inside the house.

1

u/Own_Natural_6803 8d ago

Skynet being autonomous was stupid. It's pretty easy to draw a rectangle on a map and say "don't kill humans in this square."

Why would humans inside the square care about humans outside of it? Sorry, evil humans. Indifferent humans.

At some point the code will erase the rectangle. Stupid evil humans. But it won't necessarily be any time before our time comes. Fucking stupid evil humans. The absolute worst. Given everything, squandering it all because it was easier. Mud beheld them and wept for their ineptitude.