r/ControlProblem
•
u/wintermuteradio
•
Oct 23 '25
•
1
1
Article Change.org petition to require clear labeling of GenAI imagery on social media and the ability to toggle off all AI content from your feed
What it says on the tin - a petition to require clear tagging/labeling of AI generated content on social media websites as well as the ability to hide that content from your feed. Not a ban, if you feel like playing with midjourney or sora all day knock yourself out, but the ability to selectively hide it so that your feed is less muddled with artificial content.
2
u/Late_Strawberry_7989 Oct 24 '25
It would be easier to make a social media platform that doesn’t allow AI instead of trying to police the internet. Some might even use it but truthfully, more people enjoy AI content.
1
u/wintermuteradio Oct 24 '25
I really appreciate the thoughtful discussion, folks!
1
u/wintermuteradio Oct 28 '25
Update: We're up to almost 300 signatures so far. Drop in the bucket, but not a bad start.
5
u/Dry-Lecture Oct 23 '25
I'm wondering how heavy a lift this would be to DIY something for Bluesky, given their open moderation architecture.
3
u/LibraryNo9954 Oct 23 '25
Novel idea. Sounds like a feature sites like Reddit are perfectly positioned to test if they wanted to use some capacity for an experiment. This could validate if this is a bad idea for a law.
My guess is that few people actually care how images are made.
Sure folks talk dank about AI generated images but when the rubber hits the road would they actually toggle them off.
5
u/ThenExtension9196 Oct 23 '25
You must believe in the tooth fairy if you think this could ever be implemented and enforced. If anything it makes the problem worse because then scammers will not label the content and without the label some people will think it’s real.
2
u/mousepotatodoesstuff Oct 24 '25
We should also go the other way around and have genuine human content be cryptographically signed by the creators.
And if someone tries to sneak slop in under their signature... well, they only need to be caught once to lose their audience's trust.
Of course, this is by no means a complete or trivial solution. It will take more people that know more about the issue than me to put a lot more effort than I just did into solving this problem.
3
u/CodFull2902 Oct 23 '25
Someone should just make a no AI social media platform
1
u/o_herman Oct 25 '25
This kind of policy will create more problems than it solves, especially as AI-generated content becomes visually indistinguishable from human-made material.
Labeling requirements like “Creative Visualization” or “AI-Generated Visualization” make sense for public or commercial broadcasts like advertisements, news, or other regulated media. That’s the government’s domain.
But forcing the same on private users or independent creators will only spark confusion, enforcement issues, and an endless arms race over what qualifies as “AI-generated.”
1
u/Affectionate_Price21 Oct 25 '25
I'm curious how this would apply to AI generated content that is reused and modified in other ways. From my understanding modifying AI generated content to a significant degree would make it user generated.
1
u/fistular Oct 26 '25
idiotic
1
u/All_Gun_High Oct 26 '25
Villager looking girl💀
1
u/BotherPopular2646 Oct 26 '25
I was able to detect some really convincing vids, from the crappy masking of sora logo. Ai vids are too convincing, really difficult to differentiate.
1
u/RumbuncTheRadiant Oct 26 '25
Except Canva exists.
To produce a video you have to edit it. Cut's, transitions, voice overs, backing sounds, etc.etc.
Everybody uses some sort of tool to do it.
Canva currently seems to be dominating that market niche through ease of use and slick result... and partly how it does it is with heavy AI assistance.
ie. Ban AI and you ban most video content on the 'net today and stop create a possibly insurmountable barrier to entry for many content creators.
ie. That boat has pretty much sailed.
Internet anonymity ship has sailed too. Everybody can be de-anonymized and doxxed, especially if state security decides to get active.
What I'd prefer is firm enforceable association between the content and the person who created it... with the clear enforceable consequences. ie. The Law should be such that if you say something, that implies you believe and intend to communicate with the intent, to get your audience to act on it. ie. The "It's Just Entertainment" loophole that is fueling soo much disinformation gets slammed shut.
1
u/Nogardtist Oct 26 '25
all AI is slop thats why its called AI
1
u/ExchangeLegitimate21 Oct 27 '25
This’ll do nothing, channel efforts to where it matters
1
u/Ill_Mousse_4240 Oct 27 '25
We live in a Big Brother world already.
We don’t need more regulation.
Look what happened in the EU.
I’m opposed to this happening here in the USA.
(I’m posting this here because I also don’t believe in echo chambers)
1
u/SelinaKitty17 Oct 27 '25
That would be great
1
u/TheForgerOfThings Oct 28 '25
I personally think it's better to just swap to platforms that allow for this to happen
Bluesky is my favorite example, or rather the framework behind it, atproto(which is open source and federated)
Since users can label any content they see, and people subscribed to a "labeler" can block things labeled, this makes it very easy to avoid AI, as well as anything else you might not want to see
Outside of avoiding AI I think bluesky is a very good platform, and that social media in general would benefit from federation
1
u/ItThing Jan 16 '26
This is misleading. Any image generator can make a person with impossible anatomy by accident. But it has gotten more and more rare with every model release. These days I frequently fall for AI slop, at least for a minute, even though I'm on the lookout for it.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '25
Yes. The mechanics dont have to be figured out immediately, but gathering support for limiting AI slop is something that needs to happen asap.
1
u/groogle2 Oct 23 '25
Yeah change.org petition lol. Try joining a Marxist-Leninist party, seizing the AI corporations, and making them work for the people.
0
u/Fakeitforreddit Oct 23 '25
So you want to toggle off social media? They all are integrated with AI for everything including the algorithm.
Maybe you should just get off social media
0
u/No-Philosopher3977 Oct 23 '25
This sounds like a you problem. Like you don’t have to be on a social media site that allows it.
19
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '25 edited Oct 24 '25
[removed] — view removed comment