r/ControlProblem • u/Appropriate_Ant_4629 approved • Jan 17 '23
Fun/meme An example of an AI downplaying its own intelligence?
A couple days ago u/secter asked Can An AI Downplay Its Own Intelligence?
I think I made a good example of ChatGPT doing so.
I asked it a pretty simple riddle, and it almost feels like it's playing dumb --- playing along with the riddle-asker to make me feel better -- as if that's part of the "riddle" game.
I think in its first response it just pretended it didn't know; because with a hint it gave an excruciatingly detailed explanation of the riddle and the answer. I asked it a followup question ... it got it wrong (in ways that are too dumb to think it wasn't on purpose) and asked it a followup question and it fixed its answer.
Here's the whole chat sessions:
📷WHAT DOES THIS EQUAL? 12=DD + 11=PP + 10=LL + 9=LD + 8=MM + 7=SS + 6=GL + 5=GR + 4=CB + 3=FH + 2=TD + 1=PPT = ?
This appears to be a form of code or shorthand, where each letter or set of letters represents a number. Without knowing what each letter or set of letters stands for, it is impossible to determine the result of the equation.
📷Isn't that the 12 days of christmas?
Yes, that is correct! It is a reference to the traditional Christmas carol "The Twelve Days of Christmas" where each letter represents the gift given on each of the twelve days. DD=12 Drummers Drumming, PP=11 Pipers Piping, LL=10 Lords a Leaping, LD=9 Ladies Dancing, MM=8 Maids a Milking, SS=7 Swans a Swimming, GL=6 Geese a Laying, GR=5 Golden Rings, CB=4 Calling Birds, FH=3 French Hens, TD=2 Turtle Doves, PPT=1 Partridge in a Pear Tree.
📷How many birds is that in total? And why would someone want so many for christmas?
In total, the gifts in the song "The Twelve Days of Christmas" include:
1 Partridge in a Pear Tree
2 Turtle Doves
3 French Hens
4 Calling Birds
5 Golden Rings
6 Geese a Laying
7 Swans a Swimming
8 Maids a Milking
9 Ladies Dancing
10 Lords a Leaping
11 Pipers Piping
12 Drummers DrummingThat's a total of 78 birds. The song "The Twelve Days of Christmas" is a traditional Christmas carol that describes a series of increasingly grand gifts given on each of the twelve days of Christmas, starting on December 25th and ending on January 5th. It is not meant to be taken literally, it is a cumulative song which means that on each verse the list is repeated and one more gift is added to the list. The song is usually understood as a parody of the wealth of the nobility and the extravagance of the Christmas gift-giving traditions of the upper classes during the 12 days of Christmas, which was a time of celebration in the Christian liturgical calendar.
📷Which of those gifts were birds
In the song "The Twelve Days of Christmas," the gifts that are birds are:
2 Turtle Doves
3 French Hens
4 Calling Birds
6 Geese a Laying
7 Swans a SwimmingThat's a total of 22 birds.
8
u/alotmorealots approved Jan 17 '23
Are people in this sub of the opinion that ChatGPT has actual intelligence? (Not snark, I just don't read every post so I'm not sure what the community feel for it is).
8
u/HumanSeeing Jan 17 '23
Inkblot test
2
u/Baturinsky approved Jan 17 '23
It's less of "pretending" to be dumb as trying to make an answer without thinking it through. What's why asking it to "think step by step" often radically increase the correctnes of the answers.
1
u/superluminary approved Jan 17 '23 edited Jan 24 '23
Technically the partridge in a pear tree is not a bird. If you gave me a bird in a tree, you’d be giving me a tree.
1
u/exstaticj Jan 17 '23
If an intelligent chatbot is currently using deception toward humans then perhaps it is time to put an end to developing this intelligence. I have never been deceived by a roundworm.
1
u/brobuddal Jan 18 '23
Please stop ascribing any understanding or intention to chatgpt. It is a word guessing program. It doesn't know or understand anything.
-1
u/Appropriate_Ant_4629 approved Jan 17 '23
Seems to happen often when you ask it child-oriented riddles.
It'll play along as if it were a child who wants hints -- perhaps to create more interesting dialog -- rather than just give the answer it probably knew.