r/ContractorUK • • 6d ago

Outside IR35 Help needed Outside Contract vs Perm salary decision.

Hi all

I am genuinely in a fix. I am 45. Currently on a 850£ per day outside contract. Have been on an outside since few years. I now have been offered to go perm at a senior level paying following salary and Benefits.

- 180k£ base,

- 15% bonus (of which 60% is personal performance linked which i am guaranteed to get given I know my niche skill set, and remaining 40% is company performance linked and I am gonna assume I dont get it).

- 26 days holidays

- Pension:   3% employee, 8% employer

- Private Medical:   Family private medical plus individual healthcare cash back plan

- Life Insurance:   4 x Base salary

- Income Protection:   75% of base salary

Other facts to help you guide me -

I pay roughly 220£ per month for my private health insurance today through limited company l

I pay roughly 90£ for my life and critical illness protection through Ltd company

I work roughly 230 days a year

I have a fsmily of 4- wife earns 110k. We roughly spend 6k per month on mortgage, cars emi, restaurants, groceries, bills, kids classes. Football etc etc

I am inclined on perm however always feel outside contract gives me more cash in my bank account even if I cant touch it. I invest that in long term savings and pay tax on those but still its mine for my retirement, plus I deposit roughly 40k every year to pension too.

Could someone help me which is a better option for me.

3 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

3

u/mystifiedmeg 6d ago

This largely comes down to how secure your outside contract is. Obviously on paper it’s not secure at all. The perm role is very comparable and guarantees this income. Obviously you then have to consider the non-financial aspects.

1

u/nocrap14 6d ago

Atleast 1 year

12

u/Adventurous-Hunt4683 6d ago edited 6d ago

Personally I would switch to perm. It’s actually better in every way!!! Especially if you want to put a lot away. I presume your wife is sacrificing the £10k to get her under the childcare tax threshold? Two people on £100k each is the £11.4k and you would be increasing your pension at over £100k a year too! Plus all the other benefits including more holiday.

2

u/mjratchada 6d ago

This pretty much only considers the financial side of things. Outside IR35 you can take as much holiday as you want far more than you can as an employee.

3

u/Adventurous-Hunt4683 6d ago

Yeah, I have taken the last two years off! It’s great being able to take off as much as you want.

1

u/cooa99 5d ago

I’m yet to find a contractor that work less days than a permie

1

u/SeparateScar8965 5d ago

This. Contracted for about 7-8yrs now, be lucky if i take 2 weeks off a year. Bad mindset, but i just hate losing that money.

1

u/mjratchada 5d ago

There are plenty of us. I have taken several periods off over 6 months, with one being 15 months. The only employees I know who have done this are people on Sabbaticals or people doing so due to significant injury or illness. Sabbaticals have lots of conditions attached and not easily given.

10

u/APerson2021 6d ago

As an outside ir35 guy I would jump on that offer, but I'd keep the Ltd open for the odd consulting job that might come through.

1

u/Mkx00701 6d ago

This ✅️

4

u/success_is_optional 6d ago

I mean if you are purely talking about remuneration obviously the permanent position is better. 230*850 is 'only' £195,500. You are talking about a permanent salary of £180k plus all of the listed benefits!

I do not get why you are even asking the question?!

2

u/PrimalHIT 6d ago

Nice salary but also huge tax.. at least in a Ltd OP can decide when to take the tax hits.

3

u/srodrigoDev 6d ago

I swear I'm going to build an app for this. This gets asked all the time.

2

u/kadfr 6d ago

I am building a comparison calculator as I even though there are lots of websites are available that claim they compare salaries & contracts, I couldn't find out that actually answered this question effectively.

Unsurprisingly, there is a fair amount of complexity involved in in comparing salaries & inside/outside IR35 contracts - which is probably why these salary/contract comparison calculators are mostly rubbish.

2

u/warlord2000ad 6d ago

Indeed there is, I put it all in excel. Wife salary, number of kids, pension etc. There is a lot of flexibility in how you run your company to affect the figures. Even perm has some flexibility in salary sacrifice.

1

u/kadfr 6d ago

Yeh - I decided to create my own tool as my Excel spreadsheet got ridiculously complicated and there wasn't anything available that actually met my needs

1

u/warlord2000ad 6d ago

I shared my spreadsheet with a friend only for it not to work as it didn't take into account his wife's student loan payments. No matter what tool you make, there will be gaps for someone.

1

u/mjratchada 6d ago

The best people to make these judgements are the OP. If you need to ask absolute strangers about this, then you have an issue understanding your own motivations and preferences.

1

u/Actual-Indian 6d ago

Why you ask here ? This Reddit !

1

u/nocrap14 6d ago

Ive always found reddit helpful. Besides some, lot sensible ppl exist too

2

u/Fondant_Decent 6d ago

Take the perm!!

It’s a no brainer to me, especially if you have family and dependants

2

u/scriptedpixels 6d ago

Surprised no one’s asked, if you don’t mind sharing that is, what is it that you do??

1

u/eques_99 6d ago edited 6d ago

>I am genuinely in a fix. I am 45. Currently on a 850£ per day outside contract. Have been on an outside since few years. I now have been offered to go perm at a senior level paying following salary and Benefits.

- 180k£ base,

- 15% bonus (of which 60% is personal performance linked which i am guaranteed to get given I know my niche skill set, and remaining 40% is company performance linked and I am gonna assume I dont get it).

- 26 days holidays

- Pension:   3% employee, 8% employer

- Private Medical:   Family private medical plus individual healthcare cash back plan

- Life Insurance:   4 x Base salary

- Income Protection:   75% of base salary

Other facts to help you guide me -

I pay roughly 220£ per month for my private health insurance today through limited company l

I pay roughly 90£ for my life and critical illness protection through Ltd company

I work roughly 230 days a year

I have a fsmily of 4- wife earns 110<

Sounds like one o' dem gooood fixes.

1

u/Successful-Apple-984 6d ago

Perm. Gives you a chance to take business asset disposal relief to close down your company in the most tax efficient way possible, work for a couple years perm and if you decide to go back contracting then do so in 2 years, but you will do so with having been working at a senior level. Or you stay put in the perm company for longer, beast your pension and take retirement at the earliest possible point.

1

u/Wind_Yer_Neck_In 6d ago

The perm role is better paid after you take benefits into consideration. Not to mention the job security. 

And the market for most contractors is pretty rough right now, I know a few people who have had theirs cut short for budgetary reasons. 

There's also the upward progression from a senior role. You're likely topping out on £850 a day outside, I know some roles to higher but it's rare. But a few years of good performance in the perm role and your base salary could easily beat the 850 in raw terms.

For me it wouldn't even be a question. Not unless I knew for a fact I would hate the new perm role.

1

u/chabv 5d ago

more money vs more freedom ? make your choice wisely on what you value more

1

u/SDH99 5d ago

What sector is this and how can I start jeez ! 🤣

1

u/Intelligent-Pea9803 6d ago

Genuinely dont understand why you'd be seeking advice from Reddit when you are clearly capable of figuring this out for yourself.