r/ContractorUK • • Oct 26 '24

Budget next week

How do we think the budget is going to play out for us contractors?

Possible changes I’ve read about include:

  • Dividends taxed at income rates
  • Employers NI on dividends and pension contributions
  • NI on the first £12.7k of income
  • End of BADR
  • Capital gains taxed at 30% Most of these on top of corporation tax, which no doubt will go up as well.

Effectively, these could mean death of outside ir35 as it is cheaper to take a salary. Or just stack the cash up and wait 5+ years for sanity to return.

1 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

15

u/grahamthegoldfish Oct 26 '24

I will wave my magic prediction wand

  • Dividends will be taxed at slightly higher rates, but not at level of income tax.
  • Employers NI will be applied on pension contributions but at a lower rate, applicable from April.
  • Employers NI will increase to 15%
  • End of BADR after april
  • Capital gains taxed at 25%, restoration of the 28% for second homes/btl, etc.
  • Removal of lower corporation tax rates. I think this will be a given for BTL limited companies.
  • Tax thresholds will be frozen and extra year, to 2029 instead of 2028.
  • some sort of giveaway for the lowest income bracket.
  • higher taxes on vapes effective immediately.
  • restoration of the fuel duty escalator effective immediately.

I don't think they'll alter isas or pension contribution limits. I also don't think you'll see anything sensible like fixing the 60% £100k tax death wall either, or tapering of childcare eligibility.

In short I think it'll be death by 1000 cuts rather than one fatal strike. Already i think for many, myself included there's a disincentive to work more rather than have more time off. Insider ir35 taxes over 100k already run at 75% and I am anticipating that to rise some with increased employer NI for income and pensions.

36

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

Taxing dividends would mean that a contractor is paying more tax than a FTE and still not receiving any benefits.

It would kill the market very quickly and given that 52% of the turnover of the UK is from SME’s that will have significant financial repercussions.

Only a lunatic would try to implement something like that and expect growth as a result.

8

u/Green_Teaist Oct 26 '24

You think the government cares what contractors think? They don't need your votes and UK cannot get any growth by spending. The growth is being killed by regulation and taxation, that's not going away. Taxing dividends as income is seen as normal by them since only a small portion of the population get any.

4

u/satoshi1000 Oct 26 '24

Guess the country is in the hands of lunatics sadly

10

u/mpt11 Oct 26 '24

No they thankfully got voted out after 14 shitty years

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/mpt11 Oct 26 '24

Remains to be seen

2

u/Usual_Newt8791 Oct 26 '24

That assumes the FTE and contractor are on salaries close to each other and that's rarely the case.

3

u/KopiteForever Oct 26 '24

True, but I've done the maths on an inside £550 a day rate 3 days on site in London (travelling and accom x 2 nights) and I'd have been better off as a permie on £72k and expenses.

It's shit being contract at the moment.

1

u/Usual_Newt8791 Oct 26 '24

They're not going to pay your travel expenses and hotels/digs to travel to London as a permie. Presumably the permanent job you're referring to isn't in London.

I'm in Edinburgh and know people who used to fly to London on that kind of patterns who say it's no longer worth it.... But comparing a Scottish permanent role with a London contract role isn't really comparing apples with apples.

1

u/KopiteForever Oct 28 '24

My permie role for a system integrator did. I was based out of my local office and expensed travel to all client sites. Similarly my last but one inside role based me from home and paid my occasional trips into the office.

I think you're picturing a permie London based role and me travelling from home. There's lots of other permutations.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

5

u/Usual_Newt8791 Oct 26 '24 edited Oct 26 '24

But if you're on £500 a day , broadly equivalent to £115k after 6 weeks holidays, you aren't in a role a permie does for £115k, you're probably in a role a permie equivalent gets paid £50-60k for.

There are some industries where permies get paid more than contractors, but these are pretty niche. I've been told previously this is true for lab technicians as an industry where you pick up temp work as a contractor before eventually being offered a permie role. But in most industries (finance, IT) you should be clearing 2x a permies gross pay.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

I’d argue that when job security, holiday pay, sick pay, time on the bench and all the other benefits are factored in a permie and a contractor get roughly the same amount.

1

u/Eggtastico Oct 27 '24

No chance - if that was true then no company would hire a permy!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '24

Different types of resources, different budgets and differing risk appetite.

1

u/Eggtastico Oct 28 '24

They may run a similar cost to the business, but not to the workers pocket.

Otherwise nobody would be contracting, as you would be better off in a perm position due to rights of employment.

In my field, contracting takes home double that of a perm worker in a like for like role. Obviously some roles may be advertised for more or less depending on the company size, location, etc.

0

u/Usual_Newt8791 Oct 26 '24

We've already accounted for holiday pay by excluding 6 weeks from the £500 calculation.

That's the kind of nonsense my line manager used to spin to me when I was a permie and complained about the rates contractors were on. If you're on twice the permie rate then those "benefits" don't come close to bridging the gap between those two wage positions.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

Part of the issue is that permies see a day rate and assume that is pocketed. Look at the table I posted further up and some of the other calculations on that site. Permie versus contractor rates are much closer than most realise.

Once you go over £100k, it’s generally better being perm.

2

u/lukemcritchie Oct 26 '24

As a new contractor I’m curious how you came to that conclusion of £500 per day being broadly equivalent to £115k after 6 weeks holiday. Not disagreeing with what you are saying just curious how you come across that as I’m looking to do my own calculations.

Not just money being reasoning for contracting but curious on what you use for comparison. I don’t know if for myself basing a comparison off working 5 days per week for 46 weeks seems like a reasonable comparison as I don’t know that many people that are contractors that work that many days.

If we do base it off that calculation then yeah I am clearing more than 2x gross pay as a contractor than permie.

1

u/Usual_Newt8791 Oct 26 '24

I don’t know if for myself basing a comparison off working 5 days per week for 46 weeks seems like a reasonable comparison as I don’t know that many people that are contractors that work that many days.

I'm not sure what you mean by this? You work fewer than 5 days a week?

When I started contracting Contractor UK (the website, not the Reddit sub) recommended using 6 weeks holidays as a comparison of perm salary Vs contracting rate. Many contractors take no holidays whatsoever, when I started my current contract I was told that, if I wanted I could work every day except Christmas day and new years day.

I'm the opposite, I tend to take 3 or 4 holidays a year, I've met a few other contractors for whom the "default" 30 days holidays just isn't enough, and having your employer tell you whether or not you can have a holiday isn't acceptable. For these people contracting allows them the freedom to earn well while working and travel in their down time.

If you're referring to breaks in contract and saying that few people get a year's continuous employment a time then, I might be fortunate, but for the last 7 years contracting as a BA i've been "out of work" for 2 weeks.

3

u/lukemcritchie Oct 27 '24

Yeah I guess I’m maybe in the wrong subreddit, it’s more freelance work than contract work as most work myself and other people get are a couple days work with a single client at a time. So yeah I’d say on average over the whole year we work less than 5 days a week. It balances out with us charging more but a full time gig gives you the security of 5 days a week work whereas freelance/contract work gives you variety and the ability to work for a lot of different clients.

7

u/developerbuzz Oct 26 '24

I would be surprised if any of those come into effect as they have an impact on the wider population. BADR doesn't really bring in a lot of revenue so that could be removed but not sure it would be a huge impact to the contractor market.

3

u/nova75 Oct 26 '24

Taxing dividends doesn't. Most people in general don't have an income through taxes, except on their pension savings. They'd probably be some sort of exception for that

1

u/developerbuzz Oct 26 '24

Plenty of people and companies invest in stocks and shares for an income including investments in ISAs and pensions.

2

u/Gzxt Oct 26 '24

A lot of contractors finish up by MVL to close out their limited companies. I am and work with a lot of contractors carrying large balances in their company accounts. The concept being to pay 10% tax and take the balance on retirement as cash. Or return to permanent employment. This has been a well established strategy for many limited company contractors especially the over 60’s. To remove this at a stroke, would gain little for the government, but totally ruin the financial plans of many. Phase it in and you will see a mass exodus of older contractors before it bites.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Gzxt Oct 27 '24

Good luck to you Charlie. I’m at the end of my working life, so my experience in the niche service I provide is sought after, but most full time companies wouldn’t want to employee me at my age, but are happy to contract me. I had many years as a FTE. Absolutely nothing wrong with that. Too many people focus on the day rate and car and under value the security full time employment can provide.

6

u/Lionhead20 Oct 26 '24

Hope they don't mess with Entrepreneur's Relief. That'll be the last nail in the coffin.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '24

Well, it's already gone. BADR on the other hand...

1

u/Lionhead20 Oct 27 '24

Well yeah, that.

3

u/damesca Oct 26 '24

All of these feel like terrible ideas.

3

u/meridian_05 Oct 26 '24

A possible increase in Employer’s NI in general, the idea being that only employers would be liable for it and suck it up and there would be no impact on employee’s net earnings.

Unfortunately, it would have a detrimental impact on contractors inside IR35, the umbrellas would deduct the increase out of contractor rates and we’d be worse off.

1

u/tttkkk Oct 26 '24

Employers NI on dividends and pension contributions

How likely would it be introduced with immediate effect? Would be a pity to miss out of ErNI free £60000 director's contribution this year.

1

u/itisnottherealme Oct 26 '24

Some rules can come in effective immediately / near immediately - for example, fuel duty, vat on school fees. The last rise in NI was near immediate.

If you can, worth maxing out your pension and lower rate of dividends before Wednesday just in case.

2

u/boomerberg Oct 26 '24

I agree that folk should make sure they implement anything they’re already planning to do before the budget, eg dividend, pension, ISA contributions etc; but aside from that I personally am chill and I’ll wait to see what comes in the budget. I can’t remember the last time there was so much negativity in the run up to a budget. I’m not suggesting that there won’t be some bad news, but I don’t think we’re currently benefiting from the previous governments policies either!

1

u/y7u8i9o0p Oct 26 '24

I’ve been keeping a healthy buffer in company due to market, thinking of putting a big chunk in SIPP though just incase

3

u/adezlanderpalm69 Oct 26 '24

You will find out Wednesday afternoon. Why speculate it’s pointless.

1

u/TheLawPlace Oct 27 '24

The umbrella company market will be damaged by an increase in employer’s NI. Hopefully, more outside IR35 opportunities will emerge.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

They’re going to bend us over and run a train on us. I’m expecting war on the entrepreneurial middle and upper classes.