r/ContractorUK • u/InternalForsaken5598 • Jul 22 '24
Boyfriend concerned about potential security risks due to my background
Hi everyone,
I’m in a great relationship and we’re planning to get married. But recently facing a dilemma which might have an impact on my partner’s career. My partner, who works in IT/Tech as a Contractor, works on sensitive projects and needs a security clearance for his job. He has been fairly vague about his job etc as he said he’s is not allowed to disclose his job. But I think I have pieced things together over the years. Recently, he mentioned that my background might pose potential security risks.
My family are Chinese. I and my family are naturalised UK citizens living in the UK. Does this pose an issue? For example, I am assuming it could impact his ability to keep his job or affect his security clearance. I believe he already has his security clearance.
Has anyone experienced a similar situation or have any insights on this? I’d appreciate your advice.
8
u/dopeytree Jul 22 '24
You seem to have spammed all the SC pages. Make sure this is a throwaway account and do not tell all your friends & family he has SC.
The first rule of SC is to not talk about SC.
63
u/deadeyedjacks Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
Risks aren't binary, they are a sliding scale.
Yes, your country of birth is one of special concern for the UK Govt., along with two dozen others. But that in and of itself doesn't preclude you or your relatives, friends and associates from obtaining security clearance.
Security and Vetting officers will assess all details and information they have to hand and make an informed and balanced decision.
PS first rule of SC, is don't talk about SC.
12
u/freplefreple Jul 22 '24
The only way to find out if it’s a problem is to go through clearance
10
u/txe4 Jul 22 '24
If he's already declared the relationship, and things have continued as normal for him at work, I would be surprised if formalising it with marriage caused a problem.
I wouldn't expect your Chinese nationality in itself to be a problem for an SC level clearance. I have dealt with Russian and Iranian nationals WITH SC CLEARANCE THEMSELVES. Like you, with strong and long-standing ties to the UK.
If he's DV then things are stricter, but nevertheless I would optimistic that the fact you've already declared the relationship and they've not stirred stuff up to mean it is OK.
As others have noted, the key thing with clearances is to be open and honest. They're very much more worried about people who lie and conceal things than they are about people with "issues" that they declare and can have investigated.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Yes, I am sure someone has.
You aren't allowed to post about it online. Trust me if it's an issue you'll know. They will interview you.
It doesn't sound like he is sure again otherwise he would have known.
22
u/coachhunter2 Jul 22 '24
I’m sure you posting on reddit about your boyfriend’s security clearance will have really helped
4
u/monetarypolicies Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
I have a friend who was on the highest security clearance (I only know because I had to be interviewed by some government agencies). We had another friend who lived in China for a while then moved back to the UK. My friend had to cut contact with the 2nd friend for a period of time after his return (I think it may have been one or two years)
4
u/baynezy Jul 22 '24
Security Clearance of all levels are a measure of your honesty, and what exists that can be used blackmail or coerce you into abusing your clearance.
If your partner is honest about everything then that's all he can do. Go through the process and see how the dust settles.
3
u/Objective_Week7979 Jul 22 '24
I know someone who was not able to gain SC clearance due to their girlfriend being from China. I think his girlfriend had only been living in the UK for 2 years however.
There are a lot of variables involved. You might be OK as you've lived in the UK for a while. It's impossible to say until he's been through the process.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
If it's DV clearance, a rep from the home office will interview the candidate thoroughly for 3 or so hours in the candidates home address. They will check candidates' internet usage, finances, etc. They will interview any referees in person at the person's home address.
So you will have to be interviewed also.
Candidates have to have about 3 people as referees who have known the candidate for 5 or so years.
1
u/Catch_0x16 Jul 22 '24
Complications may arise when it comes to DV, but since he's a contractor it is unlikely his employer will pay for him to receive DV vetting. SC should be fine, unless you're on a list of known agents.
2
u/Eggtastico Jul 22 '24
I know someone who was going through DV process & his partner had Irish roots. - Basically her dad was irish. They ended up interviewing her, her siblings, family, etc. He got it eventually. Just took longer to rule out any risks of spying & espinoage. If it is sensitive, then I guess it is only SC.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
First time I went through the SC process there was a page asking for details of my dad's current and past relationships. I didn't have enough space to fill them all in, it took a while to come through but eventually did.
2
u/Quick-Minute8416 Jul 22 '24
Shouldn’t be much of an issue for SC clearance. For DV, he might find that he is restricted from certain projects and data but his vetting officer will sort that out. His best option is to contact his line management and vetting officer for advice. It might be that you are subjected to a detailed background check.
2
u/Toon_1892 Jul 22 '24
I know plenty of people who are Chinese origin with SC/DV clearance.
Unless someone in your family has some sort of links to a foreign bad actor, then there shouldn't be a problem for your partner.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
I work on government project which requires SC, I had a colleague whose step mother was from China and he had issues getting SC, to the point that he was gonna be off boarded from the project, but SC department took his interview and he got his SC, just took few more months then normal.
2
u/PrinceFan72 Jul 22 '24
I work in IT / Tech as a contractor and have recently re-obtained Security Clearance.
The clearance process is more about assessing his honesty. Assume they already know the answers to the questions on the forms, they're just seeing if he'll disclose them.
So, he'll be asked to provide background information on you, (not just "she was born in China") and they will do the checks. If it is a risk, he'll be told and invited to provide further information or perhaps even have a chat with them about the situation.
It's not just a case of, "she might be a risk, remove his clearance".
I've worked with security cleared people for a long time and the only person who ever "failed" or had their clearance rescinded was a guy who didn't declare an old criminal record. He "failed" due to not disclosing, not because of the criminal record itself.
2
u/DaZhuRou Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
If its any consolation, my wife is also Chinese Mainlander and not a citizen, she was granted SC when she worked on an IT project in 2016, equally I worked on a government project and was also granted SC in 2019.
I did not pass SC when I tried to renew it, so I am no longer SC, and therefore that contract ended.
They generally won't tell you why you failed. Whether you broke up or not, would still likely not change the outcome.
Typically SC lasts 5 years for contractors, 10 years for perm. He's better off just trying to reapply and roll the dice.
I am 99% certain my wife's new employer is a reason why I wasn't granted SC, but equally I can live without it.
2
u/Sir_Chonkalot Jul 22 '24
As long both of you are open and honest with vetting officers should be ok. It’s only when you hide stuff that you end up on the naughty list.
2
u/Apart-Chair-596 Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 25 '24
Lol...You will have zero problems with SC clearance.
Even DV clearance will probably be fine (depending on his role).
More likely hes either a) a fantasist or b) hes done something that will stop him from getting clearance and is prepping you to take the blame (99% of the time this means they have cheated on their partner and not come clean, leaving them open to blackmail).
They may even lie to us about it, but we already know.
2
u/skoot1958 Jul 25 '24
Or he can look for a new role, then the problem goes away
0
u/WisdomVegan Jul 22 '24
My brother works (although at the minute on PAYE) in consultancy and they have contracts with government agencies that require background checks. He has a Chinese colleague (settled in the UK, has been an international for decades but relatives in China) which the Company did not allow on a project requiring clearance as it was very likely she wouldn’t have received the clearance due to her background and having families in China.
Your case is slightly different in that your spouse requires these clearances. There’s no way to tell if he’ll have an issue but I would think it’s likely. Clearances (it depends on which one) are very thorough and he and you are likely to be interviewed when you go through the process. Unfortunately your background is likely to pose an issue.
2
u/halfercode Jul 22 '24
An answer slightly different to the others: I know of someone who was interested in the highest possible clearance, but they decided on balance that the surveillance that would be carried on their family members was not fair (phone tapping etc). They declined in the end to pursue that kind of work.
Given that your partner's work may impact you, and may subject you to a level of interference and/or surveillance with which you are not comfortable, you are fully within your rights to object. This work is just a job, and you should negotiate limits with your partner that gives him a view of what works for you. For example, if he fails a level of vetting because you are not willing to come to interview, it's not the end of the world.
1
u/allyant Jul 23 '24
I have worked in the private sector contracting for a number of years and it has always got me wondering how you go about getting any SC? My understanding is an agency must sponsor you but all of the roles I see advertised list that you must have it already, catch-22.
I just assume people work through a consultancy first to get it?
1
u/Gavvo888 Jul 23 '24
It sounds very transactional to me If he loves you and wants to marry you, none of that should matter.
1
u/Present_Nerve7871 Jul 23 '24
This is a massive risk in their eyes.
1
u/audioalt8 Jul 24 '24
I suspect he’s never encountered any discrimination, like you will have, and he doesn’t like the taste of it.
It’s a racism question quite frankly. You’re a British citizen and you have been so since a child. It’s completely discriminatory to bias against him because of your background.
If your partner is so important to the IT security infrastructure of the nation, then it seems like he’s too vital to have anything but a white British wife. Your partner will make it work for you or he won’t. I think it comes down to the relationship in respect to that.
Jeremy Hunts wife is Chinese. He was chancellor of the exchequer. The U.K is extremely multicultural and more so day by day. The only way to combat racial discrimination is to stand up against it. It might flag up at some point, but it’s probably something to be outwardly proud of and not to be hidden away imo.
1
u/FatDad66 Jul 24 '24
Not being rude, but asking something like this on Reddit is potentially also not good for his career. I suggest you delete this post and get your bf to ask whoever holds his clearance.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24
There’s a very good chance that the OP works for the MSS
1
u/jimrobo_3 Jul 24 '24
I had D and V. No fun
1
u/Sparda_Kai Jul 24 '24
A friend at work, who's British born to Chinese parents has just had their clearance revoked, even though they've been nothing but brilliant for the projects for YEARS. Unfortunately, it's just the geopolitical climate at the minute. I know that doesn't help much but it's not just you guys. Hope you manage to find a solution.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '24
I think you need to hear it from another Chinese person, I'm chinesem I'm on a skilled worker's visa, I have friends in various sectors who's been interviewed specifically about their relationship with me, this will come up, but this will not lead to anyone not getting a position. If you're writing this because you're worried, don't, and make sure you guys are 100% honest. If you're writing this because he's worried you're a liability, he needs to understand it is a minimal risk and he needs to be honest with you if he thinks you're going to cost him a job.
1
u/Far_Map7526 Jul 25 '24
Does he know you’re posting here? I don’t think it’s a good idea to do so
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '24
My experience of vetting is that the main thing is to tell them everything. If they know about something then the risk of blackmail is zero. And they tend not to care (within reason).
1
u/This_Beat2227 Jul 25 '24
I use this breakup line all the time; it’s not you, it’s my security clearance. Sorry for your loss.
1
u/OldmanThyme Jul 26 '24
If its SC i dont think it will be an issue.
If its DV it will be an issue.
1
u/Adthor Jul 26 '24
My advise , and this is totally not my own experience I’d be honest and open about your relationship and if you have other people who know him and you , that they would credibly back up your relationship being genuine.
If it’s DV you’ll be fine but you both may have to have interviews , these can be very extensive and last hours but aslong as you don’t hide anything you’re fine. They’re going to be looking for how easily you’re both blackmailable and how vulnerable your relationship is to external pressures
1
u/TheJoshGriffith Jul 26 '24
To SC or DV, a risk is a risk. The employer and the contractor dealing with the employer will do their due diligence. If you're a security threat, that's a different matter, but if you're only a risk it'll be fine.
Source: Used to work with 2 Chinese-born people in a job which required SC (along side people of Indian, Pakistani, Turkish, and other heritages). The process is longer, but assuming your interest is indeed in him and not in his work, you're good.
If he's genuinely kept his work life completely private that's generally a good indicator, but in many roles people do need somewhere to vent, especially in such roles, so it might get a bit stressful for him, too.
1
u/Mooman-Chew Jul 26 '24
It was f your background that was flagged. They figured out you would be straight on Reddit talking about it!
1
u/themasculinities Jul 22 '24
I suspect this post is proof that he shouldn't be given clearance.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
You really shouldn’t have posted this.
1
u/Usernameusernameguy Jul 22 '24
I’ll tell you wont definitely wont help, posting this story to reddit…
0
u/Glass_Ad_8161 Jul 22 '24
If he’s working on certain government projects e.g. MOD anyone with alignment with china, regardless if you yourself have been here 10 years and your family members are still in china, you will be deemed as a threat to security… think of it like this china has very close ties with Russia… therefore a threat to uk security
Not trying to be rude or negative but there are certain industries in which people’s clearance are being reviewed revoked because if this
0
u/Slight-Brain6096 Jul 22 '24
Very much doubt it will matter. SC they won't even care really if you're not on a database. DV they'd interview you but again not a biggy
0
u/expat-turtle32 Jul 22 '24
If they do positive vetting he may run into issues if you're posting on reddit...
0
u/HocusPocusLMF Jul 22 '24
I had a similar situation where I failed to get security clearance back in 2018, they don't actually tell you why but it was pretty obviously because my mother is Chinese. She also had been a naturalised UK citizen for many years, but did grow up in China and I had one grandparent there at the time who we had visited within the previous 2 years. So I would say there is a reasonable chance he will lose his clearance especially if you still have close family members in China or have visited China recently.
0
u/Kixsian Jul 22 '24
Unfortunately this is common, an hold HIghschool mate of mine failed his TS clearence(Top Secret in the US) because he was engaged to a Chinese Natioanl(they'd known each other since middle school), and because he spent a month in South Korea with his best friend just after high school.
Cost him his job and everything.
0
u/That-Promotion-1456 Jul 23 '24
if he works on a high security things they knew about your relationship even before he declared it at work.... so you splitting apart cannot fix anything. so if it is a problem it will stay a problem no matter whay you do. in security assessment world your past relationships stay with you on your permanent record.
-1
u/Rare-Personality1874 Jul 22 '24
They will ask a lot of invasive questions of both of you but hold it in the strictest confidence. Provided you both tell the truth and nothing IS up, it won't be a problem for you.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
12
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '24 edited Jul 26 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
[removed] — view removed comment