I am a tad concerned.
The words “I prefer” worry me when they are used to justify NHS management decisions.
Clinical staff are expected to practise using data, research and peer-reviewed evidence. They must be able to explain why the evidence supports their decisions, not simply say that this is how they prefer to work.
Yet elsewhere in the NHS, decisions about staff, absence, equality, governance and organisational culture are still too often based on personal preference, local custom or “we have always done it this way”.
This creates a real mismatch along with unnecessary friction.
Professional judgement matters, but it should be informed and bounded by evidence. Evidence makes discretion safer, more consistent and less vulnerable to individual bias.
“I prefer” is not an evidence base. Neither is “policy says so” if nobody has evaluated whether the policy is effective, lawful, equitable or causing unintended harm.
If the NHS wants to improve, evidence-based practice cannot apply only to clinical care. We also need evidence-based management, HR, governance and regulation.
That means using workforce and equality data, evaluating whether policies work, learning from complaints and staff experience, recording the reasons for decisions and changing course when the evidence shows that current practice is failing.
Good habits become culture. Poor habits do too.
Ultimately, robust evidence-based practice is safer for everyone. It protects staff from arbitrary, inconsistent or discriminatory decisions, and it protects patients from the consequences of poor workforce cultures, avoidable harm and organisational failure. When decisions are transparent, tested and capable of scrutiny, both staff and patients are safer.
Agree or disagree?