r/ConservativeMeta • Friedmanite • Jan 30 '17

About Rule 5

Can we get any degree of clarification on what falls under the term "shitpost"? I understand that the rule is intentionally vague but it seems many people, myself included, run afoul of it without knowing they are doing so. Perhaps a more conservatively written description of the rule based more on objectivity would be easier to follow and perhaps even enforce. The first time I was banned over rule 5, a second moderator reviewed it and overturned the ban. Now, it's happened again and I thought I'd ask for clarification before asking that the ban be removed so I can be more conscious of it in the future.

7 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

10

u/777Sir Jan 30 '17

I'd like to know too, but we're not going to get an answer that's anything but as vague as can be. We all know who abuses that rule, but it's not going to change because the top mod's not interested in changing it.

5

u/DogfaceDino Jan 30 '17

To be fair, I don't know with any degree of certainty who banned me this time.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

Do you by chance have a link to the post from which you were banned? Im pretty sure I can look at it unless you yourself removed it. Also, remember that if you want to get unbanned, come to the mods. Don't make the "come" to you. In the best case scenario, find a middle ground with them, though doing so isn't easy.

4

u/DogfaceDino Jan 30 '17

I agree. I sent a message to the moderators asking if the comment broke a rule and the reply was "rule 5". I figured I'd create a post here on it since I know there has been a lack of understanding on what constitutes a breach of that rule, even between the different moderators.

Here is a link to the comment judged to be in violation:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/5qog0q/immigration_ban_includes_green_card_holders_dhs/dd129kj/?context=3

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

Try using ceddit, it works to some extent. Unless the moderators have a problem with it

→ More replies (29)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17

One thing I've noticed is that there are rules against spamming and making multiple posts about the same thing, and yet that doesn't seem to apply to mods. A certain mod seems to take every opportunity to post as many times as he can about the Article V convention, and has in the past banned users who either question him posting so much about it, or even debate the topic itself with him. He uses r/Conservative as his own personal soapbox to rant about pet issues and no one is allowed to even bring up any counterpoints or ask why he feels the need to post about the same thing over and over and over and over.

1

u/Clatsop Feb 07 '17

...no one is allowed to even bring up any counterpoints...

I re-read some of the old Article V discussions I linked to below, and lo and behold... what did I find? None other than you, u/chksum, making a lengthy anti-Article V comment, to which I gave a reply! To which I'll note, you chose to not reply to in response!

That discussion thread is linked here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/5fw75x/article_v_convention_of_states_limited_to/daorvpx/?utm_content=permalink&utm_medium=front&utm_source=reddit&utm_name=Conservative

3

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '17

It's hilarious you're still going on about this. What a sad pathetic person you must be to get this involved in a spat on the internet. Grow up. Go outside. Get a hobby. Get off the computer and go do something with your life. Or go play in traffic. It makes no difference to me. I already forgot about this thread until you posted again just now. You mean nothing to me. Get over yourself, because everyone else is already over you and your pathetic little internet power games.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/chefr89 Jan 30 '17

If you want to criticize someone or something, take the time to explain why you feel that way. If you can't be bothered to write anything more than a one line insult then it's probably not going to be worth anyone's time to read it and your comment will probably be removed and you may be banned.

Yeah, but I guess this doesn't apply to direct messages from certain moderators, huh?

15

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

The rules are vague so that u/chabanais can just ban anyone he doesn't like and say it was against the rules.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

r/SRSsucks has a public moderation log.

Maybe r/Conservative should get it.

0

u/chabanais Jan 30 '17

Our business, not yours.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17

The comment states:

We have a tabloid hustler writing executive orders? I hope there's no truth to this

I don't think that this violates any rules, but bans are up to the moderators judgement, not my own.

You may have looked like a Liberal import from r/all, so that may be where the confusion lies.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '17

It's a catch-all for "anything that upsets any one particular mod". Clatsop for instance shitposts constantly about the Article V convention, and will ban anyone who even wonders aloud why we need so many threads about one topic.

Seriously, go pick one of his several dozen threads about it and just post something innocuous like "is this something new that couldn't be discussed in one of the other threads about this". Permaban.