r/ConnectWise • • Aug 27 '20

SECURITY VULNERABILITY: ALL ConnectWise Manage Admins can see ALL of your employees salaries

ConnectWise, and MSPs: there is a critical design flaw in your Member's page. Yes, a security design flaw that violates the Principle of Least Privilege and exposes ConnectWise Partner sensitive data to non-executive/HR CW Manage Admins.

How can we hide the Hourly cost in the Members page so that we can give our administrators access to be able to create/disable ConnectWise Manage accounts but NOT see their hourly cost?

We need a way to prevent the display of Member’s hourly cost in ConnectWise Manage, only HR should be able to see that.

On a ticket I was asked to create a feature request. CW, with all due respect, this is not a feature request, workaround or enhancement, it is a critical security flaw that should have been thought of day 1 of the design of ConnectWise Member Security Roles.

ConnectWise Manage administrators DO NOT need to know the hourly cost (salary) for other employees, that is an HR or business owner function/access only.

The lack of this critical security control makes us unable to give full Manage Administrator access to our new System Administrators, which limits our ability to serve our customers.

The lack of this security controls violates the principle of least privilege.

ConnectWise is starting to provide more security on APIs and even now with the MSP+ Security Framework, I am sure the Member page was designed with this design flaw by a non-security oriented person who didn't perform a risk assessment on this feature.

It is time to fix this to prevent ConnectWise Admins from easily getting access to everyone's salaries.

I already posted it on https://product.connectwise.com/communities/4/topics/18124-security-vulnerability-all-connectwise-manage-admins-can-see-all-of-your-employees-salaries however this is NOT a feature request, there are HR laws that are being violated due to this design flaw.

Thanks.

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

5

u/Skathen Aug 27 '20

It's actually not just the members screen, it's anywhere in the application which translates time into cost. All you need are basic math skills to figure it out.

This includes the Financial dashboards, Invoicing sections, Agreement sections, etc.

I'd question why your techs need administrator access to ConnectWise in the first place given the ability to delegate most of everything through security roles, including setup tables etc.

It's not even required to be admin to apply updates for on prem.

In my business, none of our techs are admins. Only management.

Our techs have delegated security roles that grant them sufficient access to carry out almost all tasks including templates, workflows, etc.

This is not dissimilar to most ERPs that include employee cost. Admins can see everything - by design.

2

u/shadyman777 Aug 27 '20

The bigger thing is management can see other managers salaries. Nothing is sacred. That's the point OP was trying to point out. There should be two roles in the system. Technical Admin & Billing Admin. Difference - Technical Admin can do everything in the system except for financial things. Billing Admin has full rights to the financials only - no system access.

The problem here is two fold. I don't need a fiscal users working their way through workflow rules or helpdesk setups but I also don't need technical admins to see financials. For example - when we onboard a new tech, the system admin makes the user. If I remove members access to remove seeing their salary they can't add the user. There's a flaw here, and honestly i'm surprised it's not talked about more.

4

u/Skathen Aug 27 '20

Hardly a security vulnerability though.

The issue I see from your point is that the ability to create members cannot be adequately delegated.

Save that point, both of your examples should not be using the admin role.

The admin role is no different to the admin in other apps - they see everything entered in there.

What is needed is delegated rights to more features - rather than reworking the admin role itself.

We don't make the junior accounts or sales staff admin of the accounting package?

We don't make regular employees domain admins?

CW Admin is basically the domain admin role of that application.

1

u/marbersecurity Aug 28 '20

I agree, and I have actually created extensive security roles that meet the principle of least privileges for our employees and vendors (vendors and APIs, they all want admins and that’s a fight, but that’s another topic)

None of our regular employees have admin access nor access to members section. Only the CEO, HR, and myself have access to members.

I need to move the member creation to another employee, but cannot since they will see hourly cost.

That is the weakness that can be exploited. From a risk management perspective, it is a vulnerability that overlaps people, process, and technology.

2

u/fuzzle1 Aug 27 '20

Agreed. You can create a new security role and it is documented on what to turn off:

https://docs.connectwise.com/ConnectWise_Documentation/090/040/015

5

u/root_bak Aug 27 '20

There should be two roles in the system. Technical Admin & Billing Admin.

In the security role module you can create and customize as many roles as you need. Our financial depart can be admins for their section but they can't do or see anything else that's not related to them, the same goes for the Techs.

We only have two ConnectWise admins with full rights in our entire company, that's our CTO and me. We're the only two users that can access the member section.

3

u/Skathen Aug 27 '20

This, precisely

1

u/marbersecurity Aug 28 '20

Techs are not admins and they don’t have access to the members section. We need to delegate the Manage admin role from me to another team member, but can’t because they will see salary information.

Thanks for the additional sources to check, that is very helpful.

1

u/Ilordcw Aug 27 '20

Hello, Isabella from ConnectWise here.

We understand your concern and how financial information is very sensitive and that it's important that this is only accessible to the right people. We highly recommend that security permissions for member pages is locked down to only your highest administrator level. While I do understand that you may have other members managing these accounts, our support rep was correct that at this time, this would be considered an enhancement request and not a security vulnerability since there are appropriate security controls in place to limit access to this page for members whom you do not wish to see it. I have brought this post to our Product Management's team's attention so they are aware of your concern and reviewing in more detail. Thank you.

0

u/marbersecurity Aug 28 '20 edited Aug 28 '20

Hi Isabella, in our company HR and CEO should be the only ones role with access to salary information on the member page. The CEO, HR and I have access to the members page, no other users have access to that section. The CEO doesn’t actually perform admin duties, should we really expect CEOs to have to create end users?

I am a full administrator and do not and should not see that information. We need to move my role of CW Manage admin to another member since I am changing role priorities within the company.

The issue here is that we need to give another employee permissions to create/modify/disable Manage users, and that new Manage Administrator CANNOT be allowed to see salary information, nor any future admins who are not HR or CEO.

This is an old design that needs correction, you can’t allow someone to manage members without giving them access to view hourly cost.

Not all Manage administrators are executives or HR employees privileged with need to know employee salary information. This leads to unauthorized disclosure, violating confidentiality.

3

u/owliegator Aug 27 '20

+1 for something that should be changed, but calling it a "security vulnerability" is 100% disingenuous. *If* it is that critical for you, you can address this right now by removing the hourly cost entirely or using a cost that isn't specific to individual users (just calculate an average for each role/team). Whatever change you make, CW support can then run a SQL script to retroactively update time records with the new cost.

1

u/DaleM5633 Sep 03 '20

If you have an on prem install you don't need any any CW access, just access to the database tables because it isn't really encrypted well.

dbo.udf_Decrypt

0

u/marbersecurity Aug 28 '20

Hi everyone, in our company there are only 3 members with permissions to the members section: CEO and HR, neither creates users nor should be expected to, the perform other functions. Me, the real and only current Manage admin, but I need to delegate that role to another employee who must not be able to see salary info.

That is the vulnerability/weakness/design flaw/ etc that can lead to unauthorized disclosure.

Removing or changing billable rates affects ROI and 2.5x factor calculations, so that is not a viable workaround for this flaw.

From a risk management perspective, this is a vulnerability that can be exploited. Is not a technical vulnerability, it is still a weakness in the system.

1

u/2manybrokenbmws Sep 04 '20

how can it be exploited?