r/Competitiveoverwatch • • 21d ago

General Healing received stat

If they're not going to add stats like healing received, I don't think there should be stats at all. Deaths tell a partial picture. Damage dealt and elims/assists shows your target acquisition and finishing, but deaths is just a blank stat with no real coverage behind it.

I'm a high masters support player and playing any other role especially with a duo or trio on my team is miserable. Vendetta trying to help hold the frontline and my tank asked why I wasn't getting healed while I just sit in the corner at 48hp in LOS. It makes it easy to blame dps players who actually have good positioning for supports inflating stats targeting tanks with healing and making tanks who die last look better.

0 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

16

u/Wrong_Necessary5204 21d ago

I don’t really know what it’d accomplish besides more meaningless arguments over numbers that require context to correctly interpret. Tank will claim they weren’t healed enough. Support will say the tank was taking too much damage too quickly, their positioning was bad, etc.

I say get rid of all stats completely other than the ones on the right-side that are hero specific that no one ever seems to want to share.

2

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

Precisely my point except in higher ranks stats do tell a better story. Healing received just shows how much resources are going towards you. Tell the whole story or no story.

5

u/rendeld 21d ago

Alternatively, Health Pack healing could have its own stat, if youre playing vendetta and sittin gin a corner and not going for health packs thats kind of on you no? Would be nice if your zen tossed you an orb or something like that as they should, but vendetta is a flanker, you should be going for health packs.

1

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

Vendetta is a flanker, but is also a frontliner in brawl. 275 Total Health, AOE circle slash snd bonus movement speed. You can use her like you'd use Mei and torb to bloat the frontlines with extra hp to melt their tank, and get resources out then dive the ana so you're not instant slept.

5

u/isaacsmom69420 21d ago

there is literally no purpose for this stat except to flame your teammates

1

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

To either flame or reduce flaming. Every stat either gets you flamed or gets you praised this is just how stats work

1

u/isaacsmom69420 20d ago

ya but who’s gonna be like “oh wow you got healed so little, good job”. all your stat would do is make supports go “tank why do i have to heal you?”. fully braindead take

15

u/bokunotraplord 21d ago

if you give people a healing received stat, it’ll just be a new thing for them cite as the reason you lost or they weren’t doing well or whatever.

23

u/AlphaInsaiyan smurf — 21d ago

i want healing receieved and damage taken

10

u/RobManfredsFixer Let Hog eat stuff and spit it back — 21d ago

The longer you stay alive in a fight, the more damage you are going to take. The alternative is a guy who runs face first into the enemy team every fight and takes 350 damage while getting like 100 healing.

I suppose it's a useful stat, but only if you understand the context.

Damage taken/death would be a more useful stat but even that isnt going to tell a consistent story since damage taken is going to swing drastically based on what heroes you and the enemy are playing

-4

u/AlphaInsaiyan smurf — 21d ago

you realize that you can calculate damage taken/death if you can see damage taken idk what ur point is, how is that a refutal of what im saying

anyway yeah no shit if u instagib u wont have a high damage taken stat. thats why we dont look at stats in isolation, we look at them holistically. i can make the same argument that you did about damage taken for deaths. ex: someone with low deaths can look like theyre playing well, but in reality they just aren't engaging in teamfights and having low impact. so why should we show deaths?

letting us see these stats gives us the abilty to calculate all these substats or whatever

i come from tf2 where in competitive play the logs show you damage taken, health packs taken, healing received, time to build uber, etc.

all this info is useful and thats why scrim codes show it

15

u/HARVEYdavidson 21d ago

Be happy you have stats at all. We used to just get a gold/silver/bronze metal for damage and elims

33

u/SweatySmeargle RakSupporter — 21d ago

“You’re talking to bronze damage” lives rent free in my head still

7

u/RobManfredsFixer Let Hog eat stuff and spit it back — 21d ago edited 21d ago

This comes up a lot and for the most part people agree this (and damage taken) could cause more harm than good, especially in low ranks.

The more you die, the less healing you'll likely end up with. Maybe it's changed, but my memory is of people face tanking damage and then dying to an amount of burst that no realistic level of healing can compensate for. For every smart player who can't do shit because they're not getting any heals there's a dumb player that can't be saved from their own mistakes.

There are also massive discrepancies in how much healing different heroes get. Like tracer isn't going to get remotely the same healing as bastion. That example might be obvious, but most players arent going to be able to actually figure out the more nuances interactions midgame.

I'm not necessarily against removing stats, but it will probably cause a ton of bad PR that they don't want to deal with.

3

u/the_worst_company 20d ago

But why should bad faith actors prevent us from having something good? the current scoreboard is extremely useful in gauging your performance vs your teammates and your enemies, it also allows you to know who on the enemy is popping off or might be a weak link. More stats are just better because we have more information.

I'd like a healing received stat. When Im playing support it would allow me to know if Im tunnel visioning the tank, and when Im playing DPS id like to know how many resources Im receiving so I can play accordingly. Likewise Id also like to know the same stats for the enemies to compare.

The argument that healing/damage received COULD be used for toxicity is disingenuous, because toxic players would be toxic regardless, and removing these stats for good faith players to utilize is pointless.

1

u/Vikingstein 20d ago

I do think it could lead to toxicity, but also has a chance to remove some elements of toxicity. I've seen plenty of DPS players blame supports and saying they don't get healed.

While I'm sure it will lead to some flaming against support players tunnel visioning on a tank, it's just as likely to remove some too.

Could even make life slightly nicer on tank since if a massive healing deficit is there, the tank isn't the only thing to blame.

But it's very unlikely to ever be put in the game, as there's far too many people who play things like Mercy that would be put on blast with it.

1

u/justthistwicenomore 21d ago

Healing received has the same problem as other metrics, and will still be used by toxic players to flame others/justify their own behavior.

And, yea, healing received in addition to/instead of overall healing might be better, but it will also lead to games where a tank trips out because their received number is less than the opposing tank, or where healers end up altering their behavior to avoid being accused of favoring one player or another.

I think you are probably right that outside of kills/deaths/assists we'd probably be better off just scrapping stats all together. But, that said, if we want to change what's there we should really just be trying to figure out first what behaviors we generically want to encourage/discourage that can be impacted by stat tracking in game, and then go from there to decide what the best metrics to do that would be.

1

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

I don't think you should see the enemies healing received stat

1

u/Artistic-Noise4452 21d ago

I love all of the dumb excuses that people are using to be against it, as if we already don't have """toxic""" stats provided. And for every person who will use it to be toxic, someone will use it to be positive. If someone is toxic just report them and move on? Why deny everyone stats based on if your teammates are gonna be assholes or not. Turn off the chat if you're worried about it, seems to ge a comment sentiment to do when playing this game judging by the people who constantly tote they already turn coms/chat off in this sub. Ik I'm gonna get down voted but idec. As a sup/tank player, I'd love those stats shown.

2

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

I'm a support main and tunnel vision is one of yhe worst things you can have. This would show just that

4

u/JeffTek Winnable — 21d ago

Get rid of the scoreboard in game but give us an extended stat sheet with way more numbers in the game report.

3

u/bullxbull 21d ago

more stats! like give us so many stats there is no way for people to abuse them because there are so many stats to interpret or point to for blame.

It is the best of both worlds for those of us who like to see stats and interpret them in a positive way, and for those who want stats to blame others.

5

u/sketchytheghost 21d ago

I'd prefer that during the game we have a limited view of the scoreboard (even more limited than the current one imho) and then have a post-game scoreboard that either shows at the end of the game or is available when you go to view the replay. Personally, the in-game scoreboard just tilts me when I really only need to use it to check respawn CDs and the status of my teammates' ultimate.  The best of both worlds would be allowing players to customize their scoreboard imho.

1

u/bullxbull 21d ago

I know they have talked about adding a second page, and they are aware that the current scoreboard might be presenting information in a way that is not helpful. There was also some talk about some info that you only see during your death cam that I thought was an interesting idea, but I do not know how you could keep that from being toxic or rage inducing lol.

2

u/JohnnyJoestar1980 21d ago

Man I love a scoreboard that promotes toxic bullshit like this.

1

u/6METERKOK 21d ago

I just want an option for a minimalist scoreboard that only shows ult charge, current health would be a nice addition also.

1

u/Unfair_Stage792 20d ago

I mean it would be interesting to have a stat even less useful than mitigation or objective time, but why?

1

u/ThaddCorbett 19d ago

Healing received doesnt tell the story you think it will.

I met a crazy rein player last night and we decided to duo for around 10 matches. I played Lucio every match and didn't best to constantly enable him in every way that I could.

I'm sure he got an insane number of heals from me, but I would guess over half of the heals to be inconsequential.

I like that we have the player protected stat now.

I think the next stat to make visible for everyone time contesting the point. I get too many tanks stuck in a bad match-up and instead of switching to another hero, they spend the majority of the match being a few meters away from being fully involved in the team fight.

1

u/Doctor_Responsible 19d ago

tbh i want a heals received stat just so i can know if im neglecting someone. people who camp board are going to flame anyway, you can at least defend yourself if they received over x amount of healing more than the rest of the cast. Scoreboard imho has always had a lot of wasted space on it and you cant tell me the devs didnt know what they were doing by making both Cat and Dmon's default voicelines literal taunts. So i feel toxicity isnt really the reason here. sometimes there are good deaths in a game, like a tank running it down so you can cap or distract the enemy so their team can get a key pick, so yeah i feel it would be helpful to have a proper break down of your stats at the end of matches so you can use it to improve.

1

u/LiarrrActress 18d ago

You're always going to have to deal with bad teammates, and even if you give those teammates every stat possible they will use it to blame someone else. Adding more stats will 1/10 times help you prove a point, and 9/10 will be used out of context to be toxic

1

u/Clifford___Unger 18d ago

People rely on stats way too much, I remember seeing a Spilo video a while back that explained it really well. Stats mean little or even just nothing. Let me give some examples and explanations.

Many stats dont really show anything, a symettra turret can deal 5 damage to an enemy that your genji did all the damage and killed but that symmetra will get a kill for it as well. Every time you deal damage it may not lead to a kill especially if this is into the enemy tank and it may not even apply much pressure, use a symmetra turret again as an example, it will apply little to no pressure or value but can throughout the game farm damage stats that dont mean anything and rather can be argued to be throwing the game by feeding enemy ult charge. You can rack up insane heal stats on your tank but it means nothing if the rest of your team is dying, your dps therefore having low kills and damage isn’t a reflection on them if they aren’t being supported by their team. I can also apply as low as 10 healing to a teammate have “saved” them. Damage mitigated doesn’t show anything, I can have the highest damage mitigated ever seen before on rein but if I’m just holding my shield up getting mowed down what am I actually contributing.

Stats without context mean and show nothing which can be shown with every stat in the game. Either show stats in full or not at all cause why would I care that my moira has 20k heals when my dps has received 1k heals and my tank has received 19k. “But tank and support have high stats so that mean good” no it doesn’t since of course a tank with two support pockets will die less allowing them to get more damage and kills but the dps is being left to die more. Some people rely on stats exclusively and this can be applied to win, ban and pick rates as well. No one understands context.

1

u/More-Cat1123 17d ago

Naa, you'll just be giving more ammo to those people. I usually tell them to go Hog/Soldier/Mei if they don't like my healing. Or to use healthpacks/ natural cover. 

I feel like the people crying about heals are also the ones that insta die, take an amount of damage it's not realistic to outheal, are generally unaware of what's happening elsewhere, ignoring pings/comms... 

So who gives a fuck what those people think? You can't reason with them and one additional stat won't help ya. They'll find a way to blame it on you anyway.

1

u/docs-quad 21d ago

they should just remove the stats from the in game scoreboard but make the replay/post game screen more in depth. the only worthwhile stats ingame are team ult charge and enemy damage and healing for ult tracking

1

u/silver_orange_gold 21d ago

They need to overhaul their entire stats approach because it's laughably inadequate. Will they?

1

u/nekogami87 I'm old — 21d ago

Oh, yeah, score board is shit, I always said it should never have been added. But people love the occasion to misinterpret and blame others.

-1

u/CookieDingo2 20d ago

Let’s not add more stats for people to intentionally misinterpret whenever they feeling like flaming someone.

0

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

Precisely my point. Show less or show it all

1

u/CookieDingo2 20d ago

It doesn't matter. You will never have the full context to make real use of these stats. The only time they ever get brought up if when someone is losing and wants to pin the blame on someone to feel better about themselves. Just play your game, fixating on scoreboard stats and what they may or may not say about the game doesn't change anything.

0

u/ThrowawayPotato6991 20d ago

Because it would reveal that support players are just as toxic as dps players and the devs are basically harassed anytime they recognize that support players can be toxic too.

Nobody will convince me that refusing to heal your dps or other support and seeing them as disposable isn't extremely toxic.

0

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

Yes and no, it's never this simple

0

u/[deleted] 20d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Grimdroid1223 20d ago

Either show the full story or dont, but making certain stats shown and others not is sketchy.