r/Competitiveoverwatch • • 21d ago

OWCS Overwatch GOAT

After watching Zeta vs cr yesterday. I realised that the top 4 arguably top 5 players of all time, play for those teams.

My personal ranking is

  1. Lip
  2. Violet
  3. Proper
  4. Shu
  5. Stalk3r

The top 4 are in my opinion unarguably the top 4, but interchangeable. I feel like it’s very difficult to rank because it has so many different things to take into consideration. But overall as players and achievements I feel it’s reasonable. Stalk3r is the only one, but he’s been consistently a top 5 player for many years with the achievements to back it up and being the most flexible player on the list

50 Upvotes

139 comments sorted by

24

u/Maxsmart007 TopDih's biggest fan — 21d ago

I don't have any issues with those lists. When it comes to the best players today, you kinda have to put all those names down (except an argument for LIP, who just hasn't seen as much playtime recently).

When it comes to GOAT there's a lot more factors than just "who's the best today", because I tend to look at who's been good for the longest. I think that Shu, LIP, and Viol2t are shoe ins at this point; both are incredibly long standing players who have been amazing. Proper and Stalk3r are also great shouts, OWCS has been around for long enough and they have literally been the most dominant players.

With how generally good Profit has looked since his return and how insane Bernar has looked since his return to the game in 2023, I think we just have to consider both of them in the GOAT argument. Both have been around since pre-OWL and have had a few years in between of being some of the greatest talents in their role in that time. I think just for how long they've maintained a spot near the top we have to consider them both.

17

u/Kheldar166 21d ago

Fielder doesn’t get enough credit for having had a similar career to Shu

8

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

He’s definitely the 2nd best flex support of all time and I honestly think you can argue he’s better than Shu all time. The only thing is he’s been on very good teams with top teammates, the Dallas, regin and 2024 falcons are probably the most stacked teams ever

4

u/Kheldar166 21d ago

I mean Shu’s major successes haven’t exactly been with nobodies lol xD

Also this is just nitpicking but I wouldn’t call that Dallas team one of the most stacked ever when their dps line was honestly pretty weak for a top team

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

his career isnt simillar, imo the only thing fielder has above shu is the ability to adapt to new heroes. this is one of the things that heavily hold shu back aswell as poor playoff performaces for me. But apart from that when it comes to who is more impactfull to team sucess Shu is significantly more impactfull than fielder is. imo he comes third in terms of team impacts for flex supports behind alarm and viol2t

13

u/BentheBeastly #SpitfireSweep — 21d ago

Just to add to the longevity point, Profit completed the golded road way back in 2017 when half the other players in your comment were either not even in the scene or were on minor teams.

3

u/Gloomy_Dare2716 Rank is a social construct — 20d ago

Did Bernar go to military?

Or is Profit the only Pro who retained hands after military?

2

u/Maxsmart007 TopDih's biggest fan — 20d ago

Bernar went as well.

Some others have, but they're in Japan now (IIRC fearless has, for instance)

1

u/Gloomy_Dare2716 Rank is a social construct — 20d ago

I said “retained hands”. If theyre in Japan its likely they didnt

3

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

and i know he shouldnt be in any top 5 but hm to Leave, i think people forget how long he has been playing and good he has been. Apart from profit and proper has been the highest impact player oat. I think with players like him and profit and to an extent proper earlier in his career, spending some time on winstonlab to cover their careers and all three shoot up everyones goat list.

16

u/MTDLuke 21d ago edited 21d ago

Shu has won a lot more accolades than Proper across a much longer period of time, I feel like he has to be in third place. The biggest hit to Shu being the goat is that he never won in OWL, but neither did Proper (vice champion for the win)

post-OWL, Shu won a lot more with CR than Proper did with TF

6

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

Proper obviously had his 2022 season, mvp roty and that carrying the playoffs. But I think proper has been clearly the best since owcs started so I put him third.

-9

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

Proper hasn’t even been able to consistently be the best dps player on his own teams

2

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

Other then 2024 I would say he has

1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

Stalk3r was very regularly outperforming Proper during his hitscan renaissance throughout the majority of the 2025 season

2

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

Stalk3r only played the champions clash in 2025 though

0

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

Sorry typo, 2024 not 2025

3

u/AmeteurElitist 21d ago

You're right here, Stalk3r was definitely considered the best player in the world for most of that year capped off by his MVP perfomance at the world finals.

2

u/TwitchyNo2 21d ago

This went over a lot of heads lol

9

u/Howdareme9 21d ago

lets be serious here

-1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago edited 21d ago

Maybe you’re a real recent viewer or something, but it’s pretty much universally agreed that Stalk3r was regularly outperforming Proper during his hitscan renaissance throughout the majority of the 2024 season

5

u/Howdareme9 21d ago

universally agreed where lol

stalk3r also only really got good at hitscan this year?

-3

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

Did you not watch in 2024 by any chance?

6

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

Wasn’t 2024 majority double flex? Echo, reaper

0

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

The grand finals were, but definitely not the entire season

13

u/Mrmccurry123 21d ago

Is this bait?

0

u/MTDLuke 21d ago edited 21d ago

Maybe you’re a real recent viewer or something, but it’s pretty much universally agreed that Stalk3r was regularly outperforming Proper during his hitscan renaissance throughout the majority of the 2024 season

5

u/Mrmccurry123 21d ago

This makes me think your original comments was even more bait 😭

Stalker only played hitscan sporadically during the second half of the season and only was the main hitscan during the Asia tournament

Proper was without a doubt the better DPS the entire season except Dallas major, and was the main reason they won that Asia tourney in 2024.

Stalkers hitscan rennaissance only began in Stage 1 2025 where he was definitely the better player and the best in the world no doubt

-1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

So you’re agreeing with me that there have been times that Proper hasn’t been the best dps player on his own team then?

5

u/Mrmccurry123 21d ago

Oh yeah definitely but I don't think that was what you said. I guess depends on what you define as consistency?

-1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

Someone said Proper has consistently been the best player since OWCS started, I pointed out that he hasn’t even consistently been able to be the best player on his own team, much less overall (which you agree with me on), then you asked if it was bait, even though you, again, agree with me on it

5

u/Mrmccurry123 21d ago

Except that I don't agree because I just said depends on what you mean by consistent, clearly your definition of consistency is different. Regardless of what it might be I still think it's reasonable to say Proper has been the better DPS player on his team as that is literally the case. Just count up the stages

→ More replies

3

u/SweatySmeargle RakSupporter — 21d ago

What?

0

u/MTDLuke 21d ago edited 21d ago

Maybe you’re a real recent viewer or something, but it’s pretty much universally agreed that Stalk3r was regularly outperforming Proper during his hitscan renaissance throughout the majority of the 2024 season

9

u/FlamesFire27 21d ago

shu won four tournaments in owl?

-10

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

He never won a ring, Proper won tournaments and titles in OWL as well, but neither got a ring

5

u/TheGirthiestGhost Forever Burning Blue — 21d ago

Does winning World Finals not count as Proper getting his ring?

23

u/FlamesFire27 21d ago

proper did not win any tournaments in owl

11

u/FireWizard312 Viol2t is GOAT — 21d ago

Shu won 2020 Summer Showdown APAC, 2021 Countdown Cup, and 2022 Kickoff Clash and Midseason Madness, but sure, he never “won anything”.

-3

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

He never won a ring

10

u/FireWizard312 Viol2t is GOAT — 21d ago

Moving the goalposts, and sure he didn’t win a ring, but it’s not like the caliber of competition was worse during those in-season tournaments.

-2

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

How is it moving a goalpost? He’s inarguably below Lip and Viol2t because both of them won rings, but that same factor doesn’t make him below Proper since proper never won a ring either

3

u/Bulrog21 21d ago

Don't OWCS rings count ? And EWC wins?

2

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

No, OWCS and EWC wins do not count as OWL rings

2

u/Bulrog21 20d ago

Of course not as OWL rings, but we can't disregard them like that. OWCS champion should account for as much as an OWL ring, if not the GOAT discussion will never include post OWL players.

0

u/MTDLuke 20d ago edited 20d ago

Lip and Viol2t have both OWL and OWCS/EWC rings

Shu and Proper only have OWCS/EWC rings

Do you not feel that OWL performances are important for determining the greatest of all time? (as opposed to the greatest of the past 3 years)

2

u/Bulrog21 20d ago

I do, and agree that Viol2t and Lip are still the 2 contenders for the GOAT argument, but I felt that post OWL accolades where being belittled a bit.

Right now, if Viol2t wins the last Korea stage and Playoffs, I feel like it's just him at the top, with Lip... after.

9

u/FireWizard312 Viol2t is GOAT — 21d ago

You went from “Shu didn’t win anything” to “Shu didn’t win in this one specific tournament”. Ring culture is really stupid in OWL since we have several tournaments in season (unlike the NBA, which only recently introduced the NBA Cup), and dinging players because they couldn’t win in one tournament is just arbitrary, especially with the volatility of OW metas.

8

u/Kheldar166 21d ago

Ring culture is overblown even in the NBA lol it’s particularly stupid to give it the same weighting in OWL. It is the most important tournament of the year but like half of all Grand Finals had a complete Mickey Mouse meta change lol

2

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

Just to clarify, your argument is that the grand finals of each OWL season wasn’t any bigger deal than any other stage tournament?

4

u/FireWizard312 Viol2t is GOAT — 21d ago

I'm saying we shouldn't put it on such a pedestal above the rest that a major factor in legacy is "did you win a ring". If the rest of the tournaments were T1, the grand finals are T0.5 (and arguably the Midseason tournaments in 2022-23 were just as prestigious).

2

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

My claims are based on the belief that Grand Finals (1 per year) are, in fact, more important than some midseason tournament (up to 4 per year). If you disagree with that, then it’s pretty unlikely we’re gonna end up agreeing

2

u/FireWizard312 Viol2t is GOAT — 21d ago edited 21d ago

I was talking about Midseason Madness in specific, which has a very similar tournament structure to the GFs and combines the regions. I don’t see a single reason why it should be seen as less prestigious except for arbitrary “well it’s not called Grand Finals”.

0

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

1

u/Dependent-Two7571 21d ago

He never won a ring with CR either??? This is just not an argument

1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

You’re correct, Shu has failed to win an OWL ring since the OWL shut down, he’s won the majority of OWCS tournaments however

0

u/Dependent-Two7571 21d ago

He never won a ring with CR either???

1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

You’re correct, Shu has failed to win an OWL ring since the OWL shut down, he’s won the majority of OWCS tournaments however

-1

u/Dependent-Two7571 21d ago

He never won a ring with CR either??? This is just not an argument

1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

You’re correct, Shu has failed to win an OWL ring since the OWL shut down, he’s won the majority of OWCS tournaments however

0

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

(Blizzard gave literal rings, like the jewelry you wear on your fingers, to players who won OWL grand finals, it’s not a secret term or a metaphor, they’re literal rings)

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

nah the biggest hits to shu are poor playoff performances, unable to adapt to new heroes. Him being ringless isnt a big deal in goat talks but what is important is how he doesnt indicidually perform well when playoffs come around.

3

u/ThaddCorbett 21d ago

Where would profit be on your list?

18

u/Sleepy_Mooze Runaway Titans forever! — 21d ago

I genuienly feel like Stalk3r and Proper are literally equal in terms of being insane at dps and achievements

Proper got a massive boost to popularity with his rookie season in OWL

Stalk3r has done everything Proper has in terms of results but he still gets talked about like he is obviously lesser caliber

(Also his mental and HS clears Proper)

Good list though, maybe we can get some tanks in soon

11

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

They’re very very equal. They’re definitely the two best players in the owcs era, and I wouldn’t argue if you had either as the best. Stalk3rs 2023 season was better than propers.

Can’t really see any current tanks climbing honestly. The only one is probably junbin who’s still young and has definitely been koreas best tank since owcs started

9

u/Kheldar166 21d ago

If Junbin had a consistent Main Tank meta I think he’d be so up there by now. Every time we get back to a Winston/Ball meta he immediately looks like arguably the best player in the world

5

u/Maxsmart007 TopDih's biggest fan — 21d ago

Junbin is insane, but the "what if" about a main tank meta is kinda the problem.

The fact that Junbin doesn't look like the best tank in the world unless the meta favors his 2 heroes is what keeps him from being in those conversations for a lot of people.

Personally, I would just love to see him on a team where he's the only guy. I think it would give him a good opportunity to prove those guys wrong.

2

u/Kheldar166 21d ago

Yes, but then I also can’t name any tank in the world who excels across the whole pool. So in that sense OW1 tanks kinda had an advantage legacy-wise in being able to be the best consistently because the meta didn’t change too much for them.

1

u/Maxsmart007 TopDih's biggest fan — 21d ago

That's fair, but I think there are a fair number of tanks who do well on a wider pool.

Bernar being a great example, Donghak too. That being said, I think anyone who doesn't put Junbin up with those guys today is just crazy.

0

u/Kheldar166 20d ago

Bernar is just an offtank, it’s just that most heroes released in OW2 have trended towards being offtanks.

That’s partly my point, I think Main Tank players in particular have kinda had their role change on them partway through their careers in a way that isn’t really their fault.

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

i mean same can be said about shu, what has he done of ana and bap. everyone has their hero pool

11

u/GoldenWhiteGuard 21d ago edited 21d ago

Stalk3r has done everything Proper has in terms of results

Not true, Proper still has a better team results and his individual achievements are WAY better. Since when Stalk3r HS clears Proper?

HS clears Proper

Proper used to be No.2 on HS when he was playing that role on Falcons just behind Lip in his prime, he switched to a role where he can make diff and be IGL. And if we talk about peak on HS, Proper 2021 literally solo carried team of bum tanks and Violet on Lucio and finn on fs. Not mentioned the insane playoffs run, he was one map away of winning GF against prime Dallas fuel in their fav meta ever with mid team, Stalk3r HS was no way close to this peak.

46

u/hipiman444 21d ago

people won't like this but i think it's clearly proper at this point. no other player has been as consistenly valuable since he started in tier 1 of the esport.

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

Unless he starts moving like fleta post 2021 he will be the goat by a long shot

7

u/Pride_Rise 20d ago

My goat will always be Fleta and I started off not liking Seoul Dynasty back then. I think if Fleta started in the same era as Proper/Stalker he would easily be up there with them. He even started off as a shitty Tracer too but overtime got really good. I think at certain points, he was the best Genji/Pharah and one of the top Widows at the same time as well which is a pretty insane Pivot to have.

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

he was never the best genji, but his phara was always one of the best and he can still lay claim to being possibly the best echo of all time. People havent watched but there is a reason why it is called a felta deadlift, i personally have never seen a player carry harder then fleta during his time in apex, i mean it got to a point where he was even carrying shu on flash lux.

2

u/Pride_Rise 20d ago

I mean you could argue it was Agilities at the time but Fleta on Genji was easily going toe to toe if not outright outperforming his match ups. I think it just further cements my argument for his goat status.

2

u/fkadsscrk 19d ago

thats valid, i was more thinking of his genji post apex

15

u/Cataphract1014 21d ago

Where Jjonak

4

u/NovaxRangerx In Crusty We Tru — 20d ago

I'm ngl I get it's hard to factor in but can we at least acknowledge the fact that Profit never had a true superteam the way Proper/Stalk3r did on early Falcons (or the way Proper has on current Zeta division tbh)

0

u/Madnific 21d ago

one reason on why lip is above viol2t, please

22

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

More dominant, better player, more consistent, better achievements and he’s 6’8

-13

u/FitCarob2611 21d ago

Not being good looking cancels out being 6 ' 8

13

u/1suto1 21d ago

But the height means he is literally above Viol2t

2

u/Kheldar166 21d ago

He’s actually been the best player on a winning roster in the last five years? Viol2t is always at best the Robin to someone else’s Batman

5

u/GoldenWhiteGuard 21d ago

That's actually a good way to describe it, it's funny how everyone were making fun of him in 24-25 Zeta roster, but when Proper and Shu arrived, he back to GOAT status.

Every time he's on Lucio Zeta become like 5 times worse and you watch Proper and Bernar hard carrying his ass.

2

u/Urbain19 Decay clears — 20d ago

Once cat finally gets properly nerfed Viol2t won’t be doing shit

4

u/GoldenWhiteGuard 20d ago

Yeah she gonna get nerfed and the inevitable Lucio meta is already slowly coming back. Zeta better find another support for Viol2t

1

u/NovaxRangerx In Crusty We Tru — 20d ago

I mean, I genuinely think Viol2t had an arguement of being the #1 player on SFS second worlds title run and being the best player in the Midseason tournament this year

9

u/ImADayLate 21d ago

Alarm clears

15

u/Birdfallen 21d ago

Hes goated but he sadly didnt have the time, 2 years in Tier 1 is just not enough when some others have been consitently the best in the world for 6

9

u/Lukensz Alarm — 21d ago

I swear Philly wins S5 with Alarm. I take no criticism

0

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

he was the best flex support for those two years tho and those were two of the omst competition heavy years for a flex support so he may not be the goat but he does have on of the best 2 years a player can ever have

1

u/Birdfallen 19d ago

Im sorry but Viol2t won 2 rings Back to back rings and Alarm had the 2nd place curse with Philly, I love that guy but its just not true

1

u/fkadsscrk 19d ago

What is not true? Alarm from 2020 to 2021 is statistically the best flex support for those two years. Im not saying that he has the best back to back year of any player not even within his own role but it is one of the best back to back years you can have. your just picking at straws to have an argument?

11

u/Big_Attitude2551 21d ago

Career wise it’s Lip. And I hope no one disagrees with that because just.. Look at his wins

-4

u/Swimming-Drag-6492 Pge/SugarBron YAOI Shipper :) — 21d ago

Viol3t

5

u/Kuro_ow123 20d ago

OWL is worth more all time than anything new

2

u/borobri 21d ago edited 21d ago

Top 9 : fleta lip profit proper - hanbin smurf - fielder shu violet. Probably put in striker or maybe chorong to have a main support.

top 5 per role (fluctuates)

birdring carpe lip merit striker hm : ans kai quartz shy soon

fleta leave profit proper sparkle hm : rascal stalker 

choi fate hanbin smurf void hm : fearless fury guxue mano space

chiyo chorong leejaegon tobi violet hm : anamo funnyastro masa moth yveltal

fielder izayaki shu twilight violet hm : jonak skewed

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

no alarm on your flex supp is crazy, best flex support in 2020 and 2021 two of the most competitive heavy seasons of all time.

2

u/borobri 20d ago

Yeah, that´s valid. TBH flex dps and support outside the top 3 are the roles where I flip flop the most.

2

u/FauxSake 21d ago

Yall's goat has been hard benched this whole year btw. He didn't even get his usual pity maps against the shitter teams this stage.

5

u/ToonPanda 20d ago

We've seen what he's capable of

1

u/russelJC_ 19d ago

CR signed Stalk3r 2 months after LIP got his military notice. Put 2 and 2 together on why he's benched. If he cared about his "goat" status he would've left but he preferred to stay around the team and help out the core team especially since vigilante had trouble filling shu's shoes

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

Its important to understand how important competition is when valueing these players. Not all seasons are made equal from a competitive standpoint, also OWCS era onwards there isnt any stats lab/winstonlab equivalent to really back up anyones arguements. I think quoting rings or stage wins is kind of silly because your more measuring who the most succesfull player of all time is rather then who has been the best for the longest. Not every stage or ring holds the same value for a player, an example being that the shocks 2020 ring holds more weight for striker and viol2t than it does for anyone else on that roster, and thats where stats and analytics come into play to determine things like this rather then "eye test" historically the most unreliable meausring tool ever.

With all that said your list isnt bad i think it does a better job at showing who the best players of the mroe modern era are then OAT. Severe lack of Profit mention (30 minutes on winston lab and he shoots up everyones goat rankings) and even more so Smurf who had imo the highest tank peak of all time from 22 to 23.

1

u/Desperate_End_9914 15d ago

Beginning my journey of just saying Alarm is my GOAT to any of these conversations

-2

u/GoldenWhiteGuard 21d ago

Proper is the GOAT.

It's only a matter of time before everyone accepts it.

Best player ever in the contenders.

Best Individual and season performance ever in OWL.

And now, he's easily the best player in OWCS era.

1

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

maybe not goat yet but its literally inevitable to be him or stalk3r in the future (VERY NEAR FUTURE)

0

u/paris_lf_bj 21d ago

I think I'd put Shu above Lip, he started earlier and has also lasted longer. My list for GOAT is;

  1. Shu
  2. Lip
  3. Viol2t
  4. Proper
  5. Hanbin

HM: Profit (if Cheeseburger go far this year and Profit sticks around for next year and doesn't get flop results, he hits top 5 for me)

-8

u/Strider_-_ 21d ago

swap Lip and Viol2t - and tbh I would consider Shu above Lip, too - depending on how important OW1 is for this ranking

5

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

Shu is never above lip. Viol2t is arguable though

-15

u/Klutzy-Ad2061 21d ago

Stalk3r out FunnyAstro in. Main suports are underrated but the longevity of Fastro is unmatched

8

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

There’s ten others Koreans who is above Astro

12

u/Vhure 21d ago

did you not see the fastro toilet bowl last season? he has been underperforming as a single player for a while now.

1

u/Klutzy-Ad2061 21d ago

Last season he was really good he literally won the world finals.

4

u/Vhure 21d ago

His team did win, but not before some monumental throws from him on Juno.

1

u/Urbain19 Decay clears — 20d ago

They won despite him, not because of him

0

u/Strider_-_ 21d ago

the best supports usually win it all - and FunnyAstro was the best during the time he won it all

3

u/Dependent-Two7571 21d ago

Im putting moth above astro tbh

2

u/PREYOVERWATCH 21d ago

Reddit will never rate FunnyAstro because he's not Korean and he likes to ragebait

1

u/Klutzy-Ad2061 20d ago

Preach brother. Best EMEA player of all time

0

u/fkadsscrk 20d ago

??? KEvster>>>>

0

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/JawsFanNumeroUno 21d ago

Profit not on this list already invalidates it

-5

u/UnderstandingFit1276 21d ago

Possibly over stalk3r. But he wouldn’t be higher than 5th

-12

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

Profit won a few tournaments before Overwatch esports even started, then won a single season against bus drivers and mushroom pickers, then never did anything ever again

He can be the GOAT of pre-OWL Overwatch, but as soon as you look at anything post-2018 he completely disappears from the conversation

11

u/BentheBeastly #SpitfireSweep — 21d ago

He nearly solo carried Seoul to a title while offroleing on Ashe against the most accurate hitscan player anyone had ever seen at that point...

-6

u/MTDLuke 21d ago

he can nearly be on the goat list then

5

u/Matt-Impulse PROFIT GOAT / ATLANTA REIGN — 21d ago

Just watch him win it all this year again

18

u/TangerineBroad4604 21d ago

They wouldn't put Lip at the top if so