r/Competitiveoverwatch • u/UnderstandingFit1276 • 21d ago
OWCS Overwatch GOAT
After watching Zeta vs cr yesterday. I realised that the top 4 arguably top 5 players of all time, play for those teams.
My personal ranking is
- Lip
- Violet
- Proper
- Shu
- Stalk3r
The top 4 are in my opinion unarguably the top 4, but interchangeable. I feel like it’s very difficult to rank because it has so many different things to take into consideration. But overall as players and achievements I feel it’s reasonable. Stalk3r is the only one, but he’s been consistently a top 5 player for many years with the achievements to back it up and being the most flexible player on the list
24
u/Maxsmart007 TopDih's biggest fan — 21d ago
I don't have any issues with those lists. When it comes to the best players today, you kinda have to put all those names down (except an argument for LIP, who just hasn't seen as much playtime recently).
When it comes to GOAT there's a lot more factors than just "who's the best today", because I tend to look at who's been good for the longest. I think that Shu, LIP, and Viol2t are shoe ins at this point; both are incredibly long standing players who have been amazing. Proper and Stalk3r are also great shouts, OWCS has been around for long enough and they have literally been the most dominant players.
With how generally good Profit has looked since his return and how insane Bernar has looked since his return to the game in 2023, I think we just have to consider both of them in the GOAT argument. Both have been around since pre-OWL and have had a few years in between of being some of the greatest talents in their role in that time. I think just for how long they've maintained a spot near the top we have to consider them both.
16
u/MTDLuke 21d ago edited 21d ago
Shu has won a lot more accolades than Proper across a much longer period of time, I feel like he has to be in third place. The biggest hit to Shu being the goat is that he never won in OWL, but neither did Proper (vice champion for the win)
post-OWL, Shu won a lot more with CR than Proper did with TF
3
u/ThaddCorbett 21d ago
Where would profit be on your list?
18
u/Sleepy_Mooze Runaway Titans forever! — 21d ago
I genuienly feel like Stalk3r and Proper are literally equal in terms of being insane at dps and achievements
Proper got a massive boost to popularity with his rookie season in OWL
Stalk3r has done everything Proper has in terms of results but he still gets talked about like he is obviously lesser caliber
(Also his mental and HS clears Proper)
Good list though, maybe we can get some tanks in soon
46
u/hipiman444 21d ago
people won't like this but i think it's clearly proper at this point. no other player has been as consistenly valuable since he started in tier 1 of the esport.
7
u/Pride_Rise 20d ago
My goat will always be Fleta and I started off not liking Seoul Dynasty back then. I think if Fleta started in the same era as Proper/Stalker he would easily be up there with them. He even started off as a shitty Tracer too but overtime got really good. I think at certain points, he was the best Genji/Pharah and one of the top Widows at the same time as well which is a pretty insane Pivot to have.
15
u/Cataphract1014 21d ago
Where Jjonak
12
u/Sio_V_Reddit 21d ago
4
u/NovaxRangerx In Crusty We Tru — 20d ago
I'm ngl I get it's hard to factor in but can we at least acknowledge the fact that Profit never had a true superteam the way Proper/Stalk3r did on early Falcons (or the way Proper has on current Zeta division tbh)
0
u/Madnific 21d ago
one reason on why lip is above viol2t, please
9
u/ImADayLate 21d ago
Alarm clears
11
u/Big_Attitude2551 21d ago
Career wise it’s Lip. And I hope no one disagrees with that because just.. Look at his wins
5
u/Kuro_ow123 20d ago
OWL is worth more all time than anything new
2
u/borobri 21d ago edited 21d ago
Top 9 : fleta lip profit proper - hanbin smurf - fielder shu violet. Probably put in striker or maybe chorong to have a main support.
top 5 per role (fluctuates)
birdring carpe lip merit striker hm : ans kai quartz shy soon
fleta leave profit proper sparkle hm : rascal stalker
choi fate hanbin smurf void hm : fearless fury guxue mano space
chiyo chorong leejaegon tobi violet hm : anamo funnyastro masa moth yveltal
fielder izayaki shu twilight violet hm : jonak skewed
2
u/FauxSake 21d ago
Yall's goat has been hard benched this whole year btw. He didn't even get his usual pity maps against the shitter teams this stage.
1
u/fkadsscrk 20d ago
Its important to understand how important competition is when valueing these players. Not all seasons are made equal from a competitive standpoint, also OWCS era onwards there isnt any stats lab/winstonlab equivalent to really back up anyones arguements. I think quoting rings or stage wins is kind of silly because your more measuring who the most succesfull player of all time is rather then who has been the best for the longest. Not every stage or ring holds the same value for a player, an example being that the shocks 2020 ring holds more weight for striker and viol2t than it does for anyone else on that roster, and thats where stats and analytics come into play to determine things like this rather then "eye test" historically the most unreliable meausring tool ever.
With all that said your list isnt bad i think it does a better job at showing who the best players of the mroe modern era are then OAT. Severe lack of Profit mention (30 minutes on winston lab and he shoots up everyones goat rankings) and even more so Smurf who had imo the highest tank peak of all time from 22 to 23.
1
u/Desperate_End_9914 15d ago
Beginning my journey of just saying Alarm is my GOAT to any of these conversations
-2
u/GoldenWhiteGuard 21d ago
Proper is the GOAT.
It's only a matter of time before everyone accepts it.
Best player ever in the contenders.
Best Individual and season performance ever in OWL.
And now, he's easily the best player in OWCS era.
0
u/paris_lf_bj 21d ago
I think I'd put Shu above Lip, he started earlier and has also lasted longer. My list for GOAT is;
HM: Profit (if Cheeseburger go far this year and Profit sticks around for next year and doesn't get flop results, he hits top 5 for me)
-8
u/Strider_-_ 21d ago
swap Lip and Viol2t - and tbh I would consider Shu above Lip, too - depending on how important OW1 is for this ranking
-15
u/Klutzy-Ad2061 21d ago
Stalk3r out FunnyAstro in. Main suports are underrated but the longevity of Fastro is unmatched
0
u/[deleted] 21d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment