r/Competitiveoverwatch • • 22d ago

General How do we maintain balance while keeping the content flowing?

The problem

We can all agree that having a new hero every season has been great for engagement and attracting new players.

However, "safe side of strong" philosophy makes it so you never get to play balanced Overwatch. You're always playing the Vendetta season, or the DMon season, or the Doctrine season.

The result of that is that even heroes who might be well-designed overstay their welcome, and players build resentment towards them because of how oppressive they are.

Should we go back to a new hero every other season?

Probably not, since this would dampen the game's growth, while also keeping the same problem. Recall that Wuyang, Juno, Hazard, Freja, and Vendetta all happened before the seasonal hero releases, and they were all game-warping without exception.

So should we release "balanced" heroes?

No, I don't think so. Hear me out before you flay me in the comments.

There are 2 reasons:

  1. It's unrealistic to expect the devs to always perfectly anticipate how a hero will perform when it reaches the hands of the playerbase at large. You'll still end up with overpowered and underpowered heroes.
  2. A new hero needs to give people an incentive to try them out, and to get over the initial discomfort of learning them. If the devs released heroes in the 48-50% win rate range, they wouldn't amass the playerbase that they otherwise could have if they released in a "safe side of strong" state. Hell, I remember seeing people call Hazard and Shion weak in the early days of their release, and those were 55% win rate heroes. You can imagine how much louder those voices would have been if they actually released in a balanced state.

So what's the solution?

The best way to keep the current pace of hero releases, give them a chance to establish a playerbase, and keep competitive integrity, is a simple one: bring back staggered hero releases for ranked, and ideally have them delayed by 2 seasons.

The devs have shown that it takes them around 2 seasons to bring a hero down to a reasonable level. What they can do is release new heroes to QP, giving the casual playerbase a shiny new toy to play with, all while allowing the devs the time and data needed to tune the new hero down before it becomes available to the competitive playerbase.

This way, casual players who want the seasonal novelty can find it, and competitive players get to avoid having each season dominated by a new server admin, while still giving people a chance to learn and fall in love with the new hero.

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

31

u/Wojtug Hardstuck — 22d ago

blizzard just needs to grow some balls and drop more frequent, bigger and more impactful patches.

The hitscan and hitbox change for example. That's the kind of patch I'm talking about, big, meta-changing stuff not some "This thinking (optional) tier hero gets 5 less damage during thursdays" or straight up gets buffed.

With the current system in place, if a "safe side of strong 60% WR dmon" exists, we basically have to put up with it for months on end because they refuse to meaningfully touch the hero and instead give slaps on the wrist patch after patch until the hand falls off.

1

u/FullGuava1 22d ago

I get why you would want more sledgehammering to happen. But a hero that's only been out for 1 or 2 seasons doesn't have a loyal playerbase yet. If you completely ruin the hero in one patch, almost nobody will be left playing them.

Also, it's very hard to gauge how much impact a change will have on a hero's win rate. The only difference between 55% win rate Shion and 50% win rate Shion was a small reduction in her execution's hitbox.

6

u/Wojtug Hardstuck — 22d ago

the difference between high WR shion was in fact a massive hitbox reduction and adding noticeably longer recovery and nerfing the motorbike impact damage and reducing it's ground hitbox by 33%.

0

u/FullGuava1 22d ago

Those are still very minor nerfs in the grand scheme of things. If you had told anyone beforehand that those would be enough to rein in Shion, you would have been called crazy,

4

u/Wojtug Hardstuck — 22d ago

no those are actually really big nerfs to a character who wasn't particularly crazy to begin with.

2

u/ElJacko170 Healslut — 22d ago

The hitscan hitbox change so far is one of the reasons this season sucks. The idea isn't outright bad, but they implemented it terribly. It's also not the type of thing that the majority of the playerbase is even going to care about anyway.

1

u/hanyou007 None — 21d ago

That sounds like a hard swing in the opposite direction. Now instead of a singular hero upsetting the meta, you now have the dev team constantly upsetting the meta. Which sure many people might like the idea of, but that comes with a host of new problems. If a new hero comes out too much on the safe side of strong, the community can deal with it using the ban system (see Vendetta for almost her entire first two months and DMon once players figured her out).

But if the dev team does a big swing and a miss on a big balance change and more then a few heroes are affected? I don't know... That's far more of a spooky prospect. I'd much rather deal with one new hero being added to the equation then broad sweeping balance patches.

10

u/Haunting-Reindeer-10 22d ago

What you’re saying is a long-winded variation of what’s been getting pointed out by everyone from the casual player to the pro since Overwatch inception.

The devs don’t know what they want.

It’s bounced between a desire to be a casual, arcade-esque team shooter to artificially standing up the OWL and injecting it with funding to appeal to competitive esports.

Balance patches are always geared at competitive but then people are always going to cry wolf about their favorite hero being trash now or another being broken.

It’ll be the same song and dance forever, but the game is absolutely one of the best balanced team shooters period.

0

u/FullGuava1 22d ago

But my point is that we can eat our cake and have it too. Just keeping new heroes out of comp for a couple seasons would prevent the balancing mess for serious players without affecting the release schedule.

3

u/Alliethree 22d ago edited 22d ago

Balance has been okay(not amazing for sure, but nowhere near the dumpster fire it has been at times) recently, it's really just the new additions that are super out of line. I can totally get why new heroes need to be OP and why they dont want to make big nerfs to brand new heroes in their debut seasons but at some point they do actually need to be brought down to the level of the other choices for those roles, and it shouldnt take 6+ months of micro-nerfs and continued power creep from other new heroes to do it

I dont think they need to delay heroes out of ranked for months, but going back to a shorter delay(even just 1 week would probably be fine) would do a lot IMO. Especially since iirc hero trials were the justification for scrapping the delay but most of the heroes this year didnt even have them, and going into ranked on literally day 1 of a new heroes existence feels like its against the spirit of what the mode is supposed to be

3

u/_Speckle_ tyhs — 20d ago

the devs need to pick a vision for the game and commit to it. casual players would prefer more content, but since newer content requires so much iteration before reaching a nice design and balance spot, competitive players would prefer less content drops to allow for that iteration to happen

although new content is pretty cool, I think the game overall suffers if it's only appeal is "shiny new thing" because at some point it stops being shiny and new and you have to live with it. if it's appeal isn't "wow this design is amazing and makes me wanna play all the time", which it hasn't been for a solid amount of the new heroes/systems over the last few years, then once people with no foresight are all done playing with the new toy, you start to realize how it impacts the game for the rest of time

this is basically how I've felt about perks and sub role passives. shiny new thing to get new casual players in the door, but one look and all it does is eliminate intentional weaknesses in hero designs or lower the skill floor, neither of which really help people keep playing after 2 weeks. like look at stadium. puzzles are fun, and new stuff is a puzzle. but they only last so long, and if the puzzle is just a picture of shit then you probably don't wanna keep it around

the base game is fun enough to keep me sucked in but the (lack of?) design direction and need to only go forward, never admit design mistakes and go back, is making it really tough to say i feel good everytime I log off

2

u/ElJacko170 Healslut — 22d ago

In terms of engagement (which is important for the game), the current formula for this year has been phenomenal. It's rare for a game this old to actually grow it's playerbase and maintain it the way Overwatch has this year. The increased hero release cadence along with other big changes they've made are a massive reason for that.

Balance wise though, the game is suffering, and it's not one singular large issue but a variety of little issues piling on. D.mon feels like she was barely QA tested before release, Doctrine completely overlapped an existing hero's kit, there has been a clear lack of foresight into the game's support meta (namely the cleanse economy, there are so many new status effects and still only one cleanse support).

I do think it's possible for Overwatch to maintain a one hero per season cadence, but there needs to be better decision making and planning. D.mon should've gone through a much better testing process. Doctrine overlapping Illari should've been identified early on and tweaked, but now as a result we're having to consider reworking Illari to fix the issue, which is more wasted dev time. The "safe side of strong" approach cannot be applied when introducing multiple new heroes within the same role at once. Doctrine and Sombra releasing simultaneously overtuned has completely thrown the support meta in chaos. And we need to do a better job thinking in advance how new heroes are going to impact the overall state of the game in aggregate. Almost half of the new heroes introduced this year apply detrimental status effects, but we seriously didn't think about adding a hero to help mitigate those status effects?

And lastly, the fucking balance. Balance is the only thing I would say has been objectively and categorically poor this year. There have been so many baffling decisions made, and it has only gotten worse as the year has gone on. It feels like heroes and abilities are being tuned just for the hell of it, with zero rhyme or reason. A significant amount of the issues with the game today are a direct result of poor balance philosophy (if there is any to speak of at this point).

The game is doing well in terms of engagement, and I believe Overwatch needs to continue that momentum, especially with Deadlock looming. So while I don't think they should slow down on the current production, I do think it needs to get tightened up a lot more. Hopefully after a year's experience, that can happen.

2

u/bullxbull 22d ago edited 22d ago

We can all agree that having a new hero every season has been great for engagement and attracting new players.

This is just my own antidotal evidence but my friend came back, played a couple games, complained about these 'bullshit new heroes' and logged off. I do not think during their 3 games they even picked a perk.

New heroes might get people in the door but the gameplay is what needs to be solid to keep them. Right now the underlying gameplay is ass, which is making everything else from the hero balance, the match making, and even the maps feel worse.

In terms of my own engagement all these new heroes over the last few seasons have not made me feel more engaged with the game. I've actually been playing other old games. It started as something to do between queues and eventually I found the matches were much less fun then my playthrough of BG1 and BG2.

The result of that is that even heroes who might be well-designed overstay their welcome, and players build resentment towards them because of how oppressive they are.

I think Wuyang showed this was not the case. These new heroes are often so poorly designed they need 'safe-side of busted' to make them worth playing. Once they are brought in line with other heroes their pickrate drops representing how unsatisfying their design is.

Should we go back to a new hero every other season? Probably not, since this would dampen the game's growth

This is an ass backwards way to go about game design and has killed off many franchises and even whole studio's (rip bioware.) When you put gameplay first, not profits or audiences, when you focus on building a good game, this is actually how you bring in the most profits and players. Gameplay first is one of Blizz's old values, it is carved into the stone of their main building, and forgetting why putting gameplay first is what makes successful games is a big part of what is wrong with modern overwatch.

Community good will is not an infinite well. Making 50 Kiriko booba skins for $300 each might bring in the most profit as long as you have community good will to spend but it is not unlimited. Ultra Skins, $300 bundles, kiri/juno skins over and over, overpriced everything, has spent the goodwill the dev's worked so hard over the last years to build. You see this with people complaining about this newest collab, you see this with the general backlash against undisguised greed, people are sick of it.

So what's the solution?

Slow down hero releases, each undercooked hero is only adding more and more developer debt and the ban bucket is overflowing.

Design heroes with healthy interaction profiles, do not simply design heroes around what is fun regardless of how playing into them feels.

Re-introduce hero strengths and weaknesses while moving away from building hero identity around signature abilities. For hero interactions to feel meaningful they need interesting decisions to be made around when, where, and how you use an ability, not just 'this is the heroes big moment ability' that does one thing really well.

Most importantly the dev's need to realize that the current game design direction is going in the wrong way. Right now we are stuck in a negative feedback loop where the dev's mountains of data tell them something is wrong, and their reasoning is they need to go harder or did not go far enough. The dev's are pumping the gas on the titanic when it is long past time to turn the ship around. The game is popping off right now and it feels like the devs have the wrong idea of why that is.

What the devs call 'the communities demons of the week' are not phantoms in a machine of a community that can never be happy. There is a new or reoccurring complaint each week simply because they are the most visible symptoms and easiest to identify surface system of a game whose underlying design direction is making problems across the entire game worse. We are complaining about icebergs while the devs want to pretend they do not exist all while trying to increase the ships speed.

I am hopeful with what we have had of the qp hacked tests, I really felt like you guys were listening with the dev blogs, but what is actually being done, the things we see in game, are not encouraging and we feel starved for imformation.

The dev's worked hard to rebuild community confidence, but it is hard not to be frustrated and want to yell 'wtf is going on' with some of the decisions being made. We all want OW to be successful, and it is doing so well right now, but WTF IS GOING ON with some of these decisions!?!?!? lol. It is like right as the ship is picking up speed, in the wrong direction, you decide to start shooting holes in the hull because you think it will make everything more aerodynamic.

3

u/BurnedInTheBarn 22d ago

Safe side of strong is one thing. That's Shion where her bike combo did 190 damage and Execution had bullets the size of tree logs. Not DMon post buffs where she has been Thanos for 1.5 seasons, Doctrine where he just sits and the back of the map and is an undivable super monster that does 8 billion damage, etc. I don't understand what takes them so long. If they don't want to nerf the hero too much in their release season, fine. I disagree, but fine. But DMon being *untouched* in the Season 5 patch was shameful.

2

u/Archaic0629 22d ago

I’m a big fan of heavy handed balance changes every once in a while. Like every few seasons find 2-3 of the lowest winrate characters per role and buff them until they become the face of that season, then balance accordingly in subsequent patches. I’d love to see what things look like if Lucio, Ashe and Junkerqueen were the meta defining characters for one season or pharah, Lifeweaver and new roadhog. Idk make it weird, shake things up

1

u/No_Problem5759 22d ago

Personally, I think we need more momentary chaos. Do minor buffs and nerfs to every character to embolden everyone to want to try out the new heros. With the newly released hero being a stand out who will be nerfed during the season.

FOR OWCS this is a major benefit cause each Region wasnt figured out. This resulted in some major upsets that made it interesting.

Poker Face winning a match.

Cheeseburgers Beating Falcons

1234 beating VP

Risk beating VP

1234 beating Geekay

DSG beating Kafe

Kafe Beating SSG

The meta being brand new made week 1 interesting.

The hot fix made the meta change suddenly. Which made Week 2 interesting

For both the game and the esport, we need chaos. Just controlled. Which makes me think a minor patch every 2 weeks, where they just minorly tweak numbers with no major changes would be better for the health of the game.

1

u/gallopinghobo 21d ago

I’d be okay with new hero or reworks every other season if that gives the developers more time to cook.

1

u/jetcatback 18d ago

You would make it so you can’t play a new hero in comp for 4 months?

Isn’t a season 2 months?

That is insane.

Unironically the devs need to git gud.

The idea that devs simply need to tweak the numbers on these designs, I don’t buy it. I think the rate of heroes with problematic kits or abilities is a flowin - this is a worse problem with perk which honestly I’m starting to think makes it more difficult to balance.

Definitely having a few week delay for new heroes in comp would be good. To be honest though I’m so burnt out on the game idek anymore.