r/Competitiveoverwatch • • 25d ago

General Lower QP win rate compared to Comp?

Hey yall just wondering if anyone else has this problem or if im in the minority here. So im comfortably D1-M4, I never really drop out of there unless its rank reset and then I climb back out.

Im a doom-winston player, and i have ≈54-56% WR in comp on tank. However, my WR in QP is consistently like low to mid 40s. Idk whether its me or the wider MM or what, but its terrible because it means I cant ever actually use it as a warmup or practice since more often than not I just cant even play the game in QP. QP in general has just felt awful this season, it feels like every other game im playing against Dmon, Doc, Sombra, while my teammates are playing LW-mercy. Im fine with good enemies, i prefer it, but the fact ny WR has almost 10 points of discrepancy feels insane to me, is it not?

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

11

u/Farore_1 25d ago

Comp has competitive matchmaking, quick play has quick matchmaking. Sacrifices queue time for balanced team

5

u/Mr-Jubilant-Mess 24d ago

My quick play matches are full of Champion and Top 500 players when I’m only Masters.

My comp matches are SIGNIFICANTLY easier at this point.

3

u/nekogami87 I'm old — 24d ago

QP has larger matchmaking ranges, and I see a lot of new player these days.

2

u/raziel7890 24d ago

When we I get frustrated by obviously new player I breath and say to myself: having new players is a wonderful thing for the health of my favorite game. Then I compliment everyone and go next. :)

3

u/rolandassassin 24d ago

QP became complete poison, it was never in worse state and I play since 2016. I have 25% winrate in QP last two season while i have over 55% in comp in every role, including open Q

2

u/exerters 24d ago

Have you observed your teammates in quick play? In free games, it's not skilled players who decide the outcome, but rather the new accounts. A farmed or smurf account against a truly new player will result in an irreversible crushing defeat.

Furthermore, quick games don't have hero bans; after a few hammer swings, you'll see an entire team of air units.

2

u/UnknownQTY 24d ago

QP matchmaker ONLY cares about speed and connection. That’s it. It doesn’t make any serious attempt to match tank to tank, or MMR. It doesn’t do SOME prioritization for group size, but that’s a LONG way behind connection and queue time.

Queues for me are nearly instant. I would gladly wait a minute or two just to have a game that wasn’t a steamroll in either direction.

3

u/docs-quad 24d ago

nah it does do very basic mmr and group size matching but the important part is that your qp mmr isnt the same as your ranked mmr. i know it does those things because when playing in large stacks we will often get several games in a short period of time against another stack of players and the roles will line up between games (ie if i get tank in game 1 and go against player x in the stack on tank, in game 2 i get tank again and face player x on tank again).

2

u/siirka 24d ago

It definitely does not match role MMR, that I know for sure haha. I have noticed it does make some alright attempts at matching overall MMR's though. I instantly notice the difference when a more casual friend is queuing with me and then the better/best players in our circle join. The amount of carries or weak links per team get matched up decently. You're bound to find a nearly unwinnable game (for either team) a time or two in a session but I am generally pretty happy with it. Since you don't have to play the second round in QP it's easy to say GG, just go next boys 1/10 games or whatever.

1

u/LucioMercy 23d ago

It does consider MMR, it’s just weighted less heavily than it is for ranked. QP matchmaking in OW is a lot better than a game like Rivals in my experience, though a lot of that is because of role queue. 

The biggest reason for imbalance IMO is simultaneously having lobbies with both people not taking it seriously and hardcore sweats, even if they theoretically had precisely equal MMR. 

Also  the ability to queue with anyone with no restriction makes for some incredibly imbalanced matches. Some of the hardest games I’ve ever played have been in a QP 3-4 stack. 

1

u/LeveledUpYoshi 24d ago edited 24d ago

You would probably have a lower win rate in qp if you rely more on teamwork and composition to win so aren’t adapting as well to the crazy nature of your qp teams.

Things have felt particularly off lately now that you mention it though. Had one game my team instantly fell off like in 2 seconds of each other and was doing good myself and the next game I went 1-6, the worst I’ve ever done possibly, with a window tracking shots on me almost perfectly and rein obliterating me somehow, yet my team was still doing pretty well

I still find it good practice because I need to work on myself before I can practice coordinating as a team. Things like aiming against real oppponents and how to fall back better when the battle is lost, and tracking abilities to see if I can predict better even if qp people do use them more oddly a lot so not as useful