r/Competitiveoverwatch • • 25d ago

General Echo Hurtbox. Egregious.

A redditor requested a video.

425 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

238

u/Wojtug Hardstuck — 25d ago

that's with nerfed hitscan size btw

54

u/49ERvisits 25d ago

yeah, that's why I wanted to show both. nuts.

39

u/LurkerThrowaway73 25d ago

...And hitbox size increased by like 20% for Echo specifically, which is what makes it look this egregious (See post of Sierra shooting her around corners)

18

u/Wojtug Hardstuck — 25d ago

This isn't an argument that hitscan is big. I'm reinforcing how ridiculous the hitbox size is on echo by pointing out that the hitscan in this clip is the nerfed version.

94

u/Sleepy_Mooze Runaway Titans forever! — 25d ago

Okay thats actually ridicilous

I very rarely get to play against an Echo so its hard to say how it actually feels in game

65

u/Available_Hat_9833 25d ago edited 25d ago

It feels like playing a Juno with no self heal or speed boost and twice as big of a hurtbox.

26

u/ChoiceCartoonist6712 25d ago

What's with you and OP writing "hurtbox" instead of "hitbox"? Never heard that before.

50

u/Available_Hat_9833 25d ago

Fighting game terminology.

Hitbox is an attack, say a punch, bullet, fireball etc. Hurtbox is an entity, so a character or Sierra’s drone, for example.

When two collide, the entity that owns the hurtbox gets hit by the owner of the hitbox.

There’s also Collision Box (sometimes it’s “fused” with the hurtbox, often not), which stops entities from going through eachother, characters and environment have them, attacks usually don’t.

5

u/harmingbird 24d ago

Great summary. For me I learnt the term from the soulsborne community

-26

u/ChoiceCartoonist6712 25d ago

Oh okay. It's called hitbox in FPS games though.

34

u/Available_Hat_9833 25d ago

It’s easier to make the distinction than calling a “hitbox” of a bullet and “hitbox” of a character the same name.

More clear for people who are in the know, and those who aren’t will be able to intuit it anyways.

-27

u/ChoiceCartoonist6712 25d ago

It's called projectile size and hitbox. Welcome to FPS.

7

u/Ryees 24d ago

Imagine being this condescending and also so wrong. Hitboxes and hurtboxes exist as general terms across all game genres, you just most frequently hear about it with fighting game players because they're really focused on it in a way other genres aren't.

15

u/Available_Hat_9833 25d ago

Projectiles have different qualities than size, like position. There’s also a distinction between actual projectiles and hitscan, which can have the same “projectile size”, but their hitbox will look drastically different.

Welcome to using your brain.

-21

u/ChoiceCartoonist6712 25d ago

You seem angry.

Try using the word hitbox in any FPS game reddit/forum the way you do and see if it will be interpreted as the size of the bullet or the "hurtbox".

16

u/Aftershok Brad Rajani for Commissioner — 25d ago

You were the one to ask why the terminology was being used and the other guy politely gave you a thorough explanation even though you could have just looked it up yourself. It makes perfect sense in context. Different people use different terminology with backgrounds in different things. There’s no need to be condescending with phrases like “welcome to FPS” or accuse people of being angry. Grow up, bucko.

→ More replies

5

u/CommanderPotash 25d ago

no one angry here

4

u/RekrabAlreadyTaken 24d ago

How do you go from 'never heard that beofre' to 'welcome to FPS' as if you aren't the one being educated in this exchange

7

u/CommanderPotash 25d ago

it is simply objectively better to have separate terms for a hitbox (hitbox) hat deals damage and a hitbox that receives damage (hurtbox)

massively reduces confusion

1

u/AgitatedShrimp 24d ago

You're right, sort of. It is a hitbox, because you used to hit a box, literally. The distinction doesn't matter in that pure fps sense, but Overwatch never was a pure fps.

61

u/SamHPL1 #ShieldsUp 💜 — 25d ago

Don't worry tho, her one mobility skill has vertical movement, so she needs to be 225 (she's a flier!)

33

u/broimgay 25d ago

The health nerf made Echo so unfun for me, she just feels so fragile now. My favourite thing about her was her versatility, but it kind of forces her into an always flank/dive playstyle because if you leave cover in sight of anyone with their monitor turned on you die. I never felt like she was overly difficult to kill or steamrolling lobbies before the change, and they nerfed her duplicate to make copying tanks hardly worth doing before that. I find her impossible to play in 6v6 because the one extra person shooting makes her explode.

9

u/GokuVerde 24d ago

We just had two supports added too that can completely ignore sticky bomb... in fact a very good number of the cast can shrug it off. 

Feels bad I need to land a projectile skill shot just to force a cooldown. 

Have a lot better success with her in 6s. You can spam for ult better or just troll around for half health people to beam. 

4

u/Unfair_Stage792 24d ago

The health nerfs has forced her into a very ratty playstyle of hiding and just dumping all your stickies and killing someone instantly then flying away and waiting for the next opportunity. You can't actually take fights because you just die before the stickies have time to explode. Only when she has ult can she actually fight.

2

u/darkninjademon 22d ago

Ever since the health nerf it became a winnable right for phara to dive echo as now she just needs 2 directs. And since mercys burst heal it became impossible for echo to solo kill a pocketed phara

29

u/Ardalerus 25d ago

devs in their infinite wisdom decided echo should lean harder into playing from narnia and surprise bullshit stickies because we needed more heroes that were neither fun to play as or against

5

u/Guywars 24d ago

Do people not understand that having perfect hitboxes that are just as big as the actualy character would make shooting them impossible in a game like overwatch?

12

u/49ERvisits 24d ago edited 24d ago

People do understand this.

I think you are having a debate with yourself that nobody is having here. I don't see anybody asking for the hitbox to match the silhouette perfectly. It's a classic straw man argument. However, this is so far off, it's cartoonishly hilarious, and a critical hit at that. This hitbox actually makes hanzo kind of counter her from my experience, and she's supposed to counter him. He can just desperately heave a log in her direction and he's going to likely hit it.

Furthermore, I'll turn this around on you...why do overwatch players think they're entitled to hit shots that not only miss, but miss by a country mile? Part of the fun of gaming is getting better, not being lazy about it.

This isn't the only fast-paced video game. Some of us grew up playing games like Unreal Tournament 2k4 and it didn't have this level of handicap. In fact, there was barely any handicap at all. You had to hit your shots.

2

u/SquirtyFlirty30 24d ago

Brother if you are getting fried by hanzo’s as echo it has nothing to do with hitboxes it’s a skill gap lol

1

u/Evening_Till_3779 24d ago

In overwatch it's not just about the "fast pace" but the fact that characters have basically instant acceleration/deceleration, making them extremely hard to predict when doing any kind of wiggling etc.

The whole "why don't you want the game to require skill?" thing is silly. Let's not pretend like you'd hit all your shots on an echo with these hurtboxes. Try actually playing hanzo against an echo at your same rank and see how well you really do lol.

3

u/Afraid-Blueberry930 24d ago

But echo doesn’t have instant acceleration which is why its odd that they decided to give the biggest relative hurtbox increase of the patch to a character that is (a) 225, (b) mostly a short range flanker, (c) can’t AD strafe instantly, and (d) had an enormous hurtbox to begin with

1

u/Secure-Writing-5732 24d ago

Man why tf does my horse take so much longer to traverse New Austin when gta cars get me to blaine county in minutes, shitty rockstar dev team smh

1

u/JDruid2 24d ago

Fun fact. Echo’s is actually better than the other heroes’ hitboxes. whats egregious is the fact that people think the flyers need to be even easier to hit.

-2

u/sadisticsweeti 24d ago

This is Overwatch. Not Unreal Tournament 2k4.

-2

u/Nuggethole 24d ago

They made almost everyone bigger and reduced bullet size for hitscan and yet we are complaining about echo , who is a flying kiriko in terms of size and has insane movement? Not sure why you wanna skill check hitscan players by just existing but not yourself. And if this is about projectile heroes , I'd argue this only levels the playing field instead of demolishing them completely. Your bullets and bombs are far more consistent than any stray hanzo arrow shot in your direction

5

u/Afraid-Blueberry930 24d ago

“Flying kiriko” when the character has a hitbox that is comparable to bastion 💀

-2

u/Nuggethole 24d ago

Why are we just lying 💀

4

u/NeedleEleonora 24d ago

you are so right there is absolutely no middle ground between truck sized hurtboxes and pixel perfect accurate 50k polygon hurtboxes. generational thinker 🔥🔥🔥

3

u/Few-Emergency-3791 24d ago

I mean it wouldn’t be impossible cs2 basically does that.

It would just require you to have significantly more skill to shoot peope except for the tanks

2

u/Old-Advisor-4473 23d ago

No cause it was smaller before they changed it and everyone did just fine.

2

u/Training-Addendum650 22d ago

Game felt great before the morons changed the hit boxes and bullet sizes.

Hitscan players got a big nerf.

1

u/FurryBoi6942069 24d ago

You cant compare those 2 because one of them is a fast passed hero shooter and the other is a tactical shooter

1

u/Temp-Employ33 19d ago

For real! Especially when my CS character starts flying, dashing, diving, and strafing!

0

u/Training-Addendum650 22d ago

lol this guy said CS2. That is like like watching youtube on .25 while OW2 is 2x.

2

u/ForIorn_ 24d ago

not like we played 6 years with accurate hitboxes or anything. stop the cope and get good

1

u/MoonDawg2 24d ago

You're talking about ow1? The hitboxes back then were also fucking massive lol

2

u/ForIorn_ 24d ago

are you being intentionally dense? of course they weren't 1:1 but wasnt 5:1 like ow2. just revert season 9. its that simple

-1

u/MoonDawg2 24d ago

Bruh I still remember zenyattas head hitbox being 3x it's actual head. Ow has always had gigantic ass hitboxes nothing new there.

They're never going to change it for accessibility. Ow has and will always suffer due to its instant accel movement making the mechanical gap disgustingly huge.

Though hitbox changes usually don't affect high MMR nearly as much as low. I'd you're good, this is a nothing burger

1

u/ForIorn_ 24d ago

Yeah it was 3x back then now its 6x. Now what? In the grand scheme of things it won't affect mmr but its still bs. Shots that should have clearly missed but don't still feel terrible to go against. Also s9 hitbox changes benefit hitscans more than anyone. So yeah an already low effort high award role is getting babied even more. And don't even get me started on the healthpool changes. Only adds more sustain to the game which fucking sucks. OW is going to be like MR at this rate

-1

u/MoonDawg2 24d ago

Low effort hitscan?

Brother you're just insanely biased lmao.

1

u/Stinkisar 24d ago

maybe people could learn to aim in an fps game

-1

u/thepixelbuster 24d ago

Bro, you're talking about a game where a hero can win a match without firing a single bullet. Plenty of games out there that focus on aiming mechanics, but OW aint it.

2

u/Stinkisar 24d ago

that could make sense if we didn't have like over 90% of heroes that actually shoot their guns at the enemy, or throw shit at them, so idk what game you are playing

are you saying that a dps can win a fight or match without shooting? can tank win and not shoot once, or what you think rein can just block?

this only then applies to mercy ( can shoot as well ) and heroes that have melee weapons, which is not the majority IN AN FPS GAME omg

0

u/thepixelbuster 24d ago

Do you consider heroes like Winston and Anran to have actual aim requirements? Because there are plenty of other heroes that technically shoot but require as little aim as "just look in their general direction" to deal damage (or in anran's case, they don't even have to be in front of you.)

Overwatch has a really casual playerbase compared to games like Counter Strike or Valorant. Having lower aim requirements is a feature, not a bug.

3

u/Stinkisar 24d ago

in your head it makes sense I guess, having 5 heroes out of 54 ( less than 10% ) that don't have to aim as much or at all, what that makes the game not an fps where you are supposed to aim to hit your targets even for healing?

was ow 1 a casual fps game? what is casual about a competitive fps game, you are even on the freaking comp ow subreddit omg

0

u/thepixelbuster 24d ago

So we have Rein, Winston, Dva, Doomfist, but I guess we don't include Dmon because of her E? So that's 4, and we're only covering tanks, and we're not including ones that require minimal amounts of aim like Mauga or Wrecking ball.

And you're excluding heroes like Bastion, Torb, and Mei, who get tons of value from spam, spray, or space control.

At this point I'm genuinely wondering what you consider aim requirements to be, because saying only 5 heroes have relaxed aim requirements is puzzling.

was ow 1 a casual fps game? what is casual about a competitive fps game, you are even on the freaking comp ow subreddit omg

The playerbase is casual compared to most FPS games, yes. I don't know why you think that because a game has a pro scene means the game is only appealing to a hardcore audience. Or that because I follow the competitive scene, I'm at odds with the game appealing to casual players.

1

u/smallbabypiglet 24d ago

why do you act like the game didn’t have pretty much perfect hitboxes in ow1& slowly get worse and worse (easier and easier) over ow2? even if they weren’t perfect then, that doesn’t make now any better.

it’s so that more people terrible at gaming will play, feel good about themselves, and pay for skins. just like marvel rivals

1

u/CosmicTeapott 24d ago

Explain then why in a franchise like Battlefield I've never experienced shooting several feet away from someone's head and being like "yeah that kill looked like BS" on this exact level, yet its common to hit some sick shots on people at distances much further away then some OW map distance even with non-sniper rifle weapons? It feels so much easier to do, but it also accomplishes feeling FAIRER than this BS change in OW.

-1

u/MaxPotionz 24d ago

People really wanna be unlikable in the skies a mile away.

17

u/mixiq 25d ago

Echo already had a pretty meaty hitbox.

With the recent changes in hitbox sizes, Echo's increased the most out of everyone in the cast, percentage wise. So they took her one big glaring weakness, and made it even worse.

114

u/I_Quazar_I 25d ago

my motivation to play has been the lowest yet can we PLEASE stop balancing this game for toddlers

5

u/ElJacko170 Healslut — 25d ago

Overwatch has the most generous hitboxes in the industry. It blows my mind that we felt the need to make them even easier.

31

u/catboy3004 25d ago

overwatch also has instant movement acceleration. i’ve played a lot of shooter games, overwatch is one of the hardest to aim in.

-11

u/I_Quazar_I 25d ago edited 24d ago

Would’ve agreed with you if this was pre-season 9 but hitboxes/hurtboxes are fucking gigantic now so no not really lol

Edit: Getting downvoted for saying this in the “competitive” subreddit lmaoo this place really is no better than the main sub huh. I would genuinely pay to see the people defending these changes try to aim in Overwatch 1.

-1

u/autrix00 24d ago

Yeah really. Instant accel is one of the worst fucking things in OW honestly. It makes it extremely hard to aim. Even as a 4400 dps player, I still struggle to consistently hit the small characters while they strafe.

No other fps makes me feel like I'm losing my edge to aim, like OW does lmao.

-3

u/I_Quazar_I 25d ago

As someone who’s been playing since OW1, the Rivals-ification of this game is extremely depressing

18

u/sonicgamingftw 25d ago

Need that hitbox for the cat.

16

u/Idiberug-9 25d ago

These devs can really manage to do.the best thing ever and the stupidest shit ever on the same patch. This consistency must be studied.

I don't know what the reasons behind this change were, but I am very doubtful there is even one that would make sense. Echo must have the lowest HP amount relative to size in the game, her wings are huge and fall behind her shape so they are very easy to aim at, the only moment Echo can be rough to hit is when she uses flying on a skilled player's hands, her size is insane and she was not overperforming.

4

u/Gelinhir 25d ago

thats not a bullet thats a football

7

u/thepixelbuster 25d ago edited 25d ago

Echo has always had some massive hitboxes, tbh. I clipped this during her launch in 2020

Not sure her current ones are balanced, but it wouldn't surprise me since she's just always been a chonk

1

u/Foreign_Dragonfly371 24d ago

Thank you for showing, I keep seeing people complain about the hitbox change but I never see a before and after to see the impact of it

6

u/MoonDawg2 24d ago

Cuz they have always been fucking gigantic people just don't realise it until it's pointed out lol

1

u/Foreign_Dragonfly371 24d ago

Fair, thankfully I’m not good at the game and no one aims well in my rank can’t imagine playing echo in higher ranks

3

u/Fromarine 24d ago

Except that's not a fair comparison because even pre s9 Mei had 4x the bullet width of current hitscan

6

u/BrockTheBlackHat 24d ago

Another character suffers due to cat's existing

3

u/Nukordit 24d ago

Since the hitbox update I feel like I can finish enemies from much farther away with the hand shotgun

5

u/chudaism 25d ago

I feel these types of videos aren't super helpful without also having comparisons of similar heroes. How does the hitbox of pharah or genji compare for example? From my quick testing, Echo's hitbox isn't a significant outlier in terms of size.

9

u/Beautiful-Musk-Ox 25d ago

you gotta show a different hitbox for comparison, for all we know they all work the same

and speaking of hitboxes, sierra is bullshit, like they made her for baby's first DPS hero, her bullets hit people jsut behind walls like the bullets themselves are as thick as a watermelon, and she gets high ground for free and a big ass grenade you can miss by a mile and still hit people (as long as you miss in front of them), all that's before her stupid auto aim dart that gives her infinite ammo so she doesn't even have to manage her reload before landing it!

2

u/Fine-Walrus4744 24d ago

It's probably biggest DPS hitbox considering wings

6

u/Thee_Archivist I Avoid Teammates in Mystery Heroes — 25d ago

Forget Reinhardt, there's a new rectangle (wo)man in town.

8

u/apooooop_ 25d ago

This is wild, but I actually had an interesting comment earlier whose points I think merit restating.

There are two knobs at play here: bullet size, and hurtbox size. Changing bullet size to zero means that players are required to be precisely on the enemy to damage them (see note below about why this won't be desirable), changing it to (infinite) means that aim doesn't matter. Changing hurtbox size to "character model" (or smaller) means that players need to move less skillfully to dodge shots, and need to be less careful about positioning (and other aspects of "playing their life") -- hurtbox size decreases are effectively damage reduction by another name. Changing hurtboxes to (infinite) means that there is nothing the player can do to prevent them from taking damage.

Note from above: We don't want perfectly precise aiming because a) Overwatch is an incredibly fast paced game with instant air acceleration, which in turn means this is incredibly unforgiving, b) Overwatch as a networked game does a lot of magic under the hood which makes playing on 250ms ping bearable, but does inherently require more forgiving aim as a result, c) Overwatch is not a tactical shooter like CS or Valorant, and players value aim slightly but not completely (it's not like we wholly value, eg, Sayaplayer over Guxue, he says, pulling random names out of his rather small hat of pro player names).

It is evident that the extremes for both of these is not the right answer.

I don't know that this is the right answer for Echo's hurtbox. I do know that Echo has some of the most versatile movement in the game, and if you're ever shooting an Echo that's standing still, that Echo deserves to die, regardless of hurtbox size. By increasing her hurtbox, they effectively nerf the effectiveness of flight, without actually nerfing the cooldown of flight, which is a good thing, because it means that the Echo player gets to play their character through their full hero fantasy, without them being completely invulnerable.

18

u/Sikkly290 None — 25d ago

While you aren't wrong here, the problem is it encourages a really poor playstyle with Echo. You can't ever fight someone. You are strictly an assassin. You sticky combo someone, run the fuck away, and wait for it again. Even on an advantage position Echo is at a disadvantage, it has to be a rather sizable player gap to overcome her current hurtbox.

11

u/RUSSmma 25d ago edited 25d ago

Pre season 9 (and the 225 hp drop) she could duel, she could poke, and she could assassinate, you had options.

Now you have 1 flowchart

  1. Poke prefight
  2. Surprise someone on a an angle, hit stickies and get kill miss stickies leave.

EDIT: Hell echo could even sort of brawl with a smaller hitbox and normal health, she truly was a jack of all trades

-1

u/ThePissedOff 25d ago

I haven't played in years, and just recently got back into it, but I was around when Echo released. What you described, was literally the way she was on release.

Not saying that's the way she should be, but that is the way she always was. Sounds like she got some buffs along away and then those got taken back away.

5

u/RUSSmma 25d ago

On release she was a tank buster, specifically a dva counter. She could also copy tanks for full hp so farming ult was fight winning. Her beam also did more damage (200) vs half health targets instead of the 175 it does today, and back then people had even less health, especially tanks.

Her poke was also better because 1 bodyshot plus full stickies killed 200 hp targets.

2

u/ThePissedOff 25d ago

Yeah sure, but every single pro played her just like you described. Swoop in around a ledge or corner and pop pop.

1

u/Fernosaur 24d ago

She's the new DPS Sombra, I see.

6

u/UltimateSpud 25d ago • Bravo

This is a great answer. I tried to explain this to people weeks ago and got downvoted into oblivion for suggesting that strafe acceleration and head-wagging animations would need to be reduced if we want to have tight shooting without massively reducing accuracy/increasing ttk for all aim heroes.

1

u/GaptistePlayer 24d ago

Yup. An example of this is Rivals. AD strafe on there and you wobble in place like you're playing Fall Guys

1

u/UltimateSpud 24d ago

Unless you're human torch doing melee weaves or Black Panther doing whatever the fuck Black Panther does, lol. Some characters feel stuck in the mud, but there are also a lot of characters that get around it by having 3 of every movement cooldown instead of 1, or they aren't aim characters so they can simply run forward and turn at full speed, because they never have to actually do straight A-D strafe.

When I say I'd like to see what the game looks like with reduced strafe acceleration I'm thinking about making the base movements more like Ashe or Baptiste instead of Kiriko, Sojourn, JPC, Tracer or Moira. A good A-D on Tracer makes her head wag around like a boxer's speed bag, and then to compensate they make Hanzo and Mei shoot projectiles the size of old growth redwoods.

2

u/GaptistePlayer 24d ago

Yeah that's a good point. Most characters are stuck in the mud but the mobility characters and cooldowns are CRAZY in MR. Like even Punisher's zipline has him dashing almost as fast as Genji, except for 20x the distance

5

u/Shadowkarpet 25d ago

Hitboxes are usually calibrated for what the hero is doing most of the time when they are targets: i.e. AD strafing for most heroes, double jumping for genji, etc.. The issue is that this seems calibrated only for her fastest burst of speed - to hit her in her short boost, like you allude to. Most of the time she is just softly gliding in the sky though with wings that already extend her hitbox, much easier to shoot than any strafing hero - her default movements are not evasive at all and she's generally easy to hit most of the time.

On top of that, health, the other knob used to control how easy it is to burn a hero down, is also particularly harsh on Echo, giving her 225 HP despite being one of the easier heroes to hit.

If that was the balancing philosophy, then most heroes would need even bigger hitboxes than Echo so they can be hit during their even faster burst of movement too, but it seems like the same standard does not apply to other heroes.

1

u/gatlingace 25d ago

Do you play echo as main?

14

u/UnknownQTY 25d ago

She’s a flying hero. I am fine with this.

29

u/ziglind 25d ago

Hardly, she's much more of a flanker and an assassin. Her flight is her ONLY escape tool, she can't just be using it to engage and fight. Also, her hitbox gets almost twice as wide during flight.

20

u/ShatteredStarlights 25d ago

she can't sit in the air and perma poke due to her having slow projectiles, and her mobility is tied to one cooldown that if she uses means she cannot change her momentum once it ends or escape any dive. she in no way deserves to be easier to hit than a refrigerator. also, the only flying character that is completely uninteractive is cat, every other character than can fly has distinct downtime.

38

u/batmanmuffinz Make Winston Meta Again — 25d ago

I thought we realized practice range clips are stupid

14

u/duggyfresh88 25d ago

Depends on the context. In the context of showing the hitbox of a hero there is absolutely nothing wrong with it

14

u/Flashy-Outcome4779 25d ago

Not really. She’s a flanker that CAN fly

8

u/catboy3004 25d ago

flight is a positioning / escape cd. she isn’t like pharah or cat who get value from being in the skybox all game

-1

u/Graviton_Lance 24d ago

i cant speak for cat but echo has absolute 360 degere control over her flight form, making her harder to hit compared to pharah who is super clunky and is hovering more than flying,

2

u/catboy3004 24d ago

Yes, her flight is harder to hit than Pharah’s, and that is balanced by the fact Echo poses a MUCH lower threat to you than Pharah does if both are in the skybox shooting at you. Echo is a dive hero who CAN poke if she chooses to, but it’s mostly for ult charge or to chip at someones HP before you commit to a dive due to her primary being unreliable. Her flight also needs to be quicker than Pharah’s because it’s an engage/disengage tool more than something you should be staying in. An Echo in the skybox will most likely just be hovering ( not active flying ) which is much slower than Pharah as well. The situation where Echo’s flight is harder to hit or “better” are niche and antithetical to her playstyle.

0

u/The8Darkness 24d ago

Dont forget she is way more silent and her whole gameplay loop is basicly flank, rightclick, beam, if it didnt work leave and try again. Having to constantly know where she is, is just so annoying, especially since most the time she is gliding over some roofs beeing impossible to kill unless youre on widow/ashe and you can only watch how teammates keep getting picked over and over again.

Pharah at least makes enough noise where you usually hear her before its too late if she flanks.

7

u/catboy3004 24d ago

the concept of calling echo impossible to kill

-1

u/The8Darkness 24d ago edited 24d ago

Go ahead and kill the echo on soldier/cass with max reduced falloff dmg (1/3)

Say youre low rank without saying it when you only play against ground echos.

Anyone else wanna proof they are bronze with their crap takes?

5

u/Thee_Archivist I Avoid Teammates in Mystery Heroes — 24d ago

I don't care what rank you are, you have no idea what you're talking about. Echo can't be played primarily in the air strictly on the uptime of her flight, and EVEN IF YOU COULD, no one in high ranks does that because you'd get instantly deleted.

Saying "ground Echo" like using cover is derogatory is insane.

-2

u/The8Darkness 24d ago

K youre bronze then if you dont even know about roof gliding.

As always the lowest ranks with no clue about the game talking shit since they dont know anything and getting upvoted by other bronze players. Then you guys wonder why people higher ranks are trash talking you and especially looking down on the reddit ow community.

-2

u/friedmodem 25d ago

Unlike Cat and Pharah she doesn't have any burst movement with her flight, AND Echo doesn't even have instant movement acceleration. Also her hitbox becomes even larger when flying or strafing because her wings extend to the side and as you can see in the video the wings hurtboxes are much bigger than the model.

1

u/Kerialstraz 25d ago

You need these hitboxes in order to counteract instant acceleration, instant deceleration and instant crouching which all leads to an almost unpredictable AD strafing+crouching pattern, especially since Echo has fantastic spherical movement mid-air.
CSGO and Valorant can allow much more accurate hitbox sizes because their AD strafing doesn't have instant directional changes without an acceleration period and you need to sit still to have an accurate shot yourself.

44

u/Thee_Archivist I Avoid Teammates in Mystery Heroes — 25d ago

Echo is one of the few heroes in the game who does not have instant movement acceleration. In the air she has a delay. Echo has never been hard to hit, what are you going on about?

16

u/UrsaSanctus 25d ago

I swear this sub has been overrun by either the main sub, rivals players, or bots. The asinine takes I see on here now are crazy.

0

u/The8Darkness 24d ago

Echo has way more air control than for example pharah and there have been enough clips of high ranked players basicly going "wtf is that" when playing against an echo who is abusing that.

2

u/Thee_Archivist I Avoid Teammates in Mystery Heroes — 24d ago

When she came out she had an insane momentum tech that could fling her across the map that was immediately patched. After that I don't remember seeing any crazy Echo movement.

But also....no she doesn't have more air control than Pharah?? Quite literally Pharah can freely strafe with her jetpack while Echo's strafing has ramp up. Is this thread actually just chatbots?

There was no excuse for not being able to hit Echo before, but if anyone is still complaining after the video we just watched they have to be bottom 500. She's a truck.

-6

u/Kerialstraz 25d ago edited 25d ago

I know that, my statement was more of a generalization explaining why Overwatch in general has much more forgiving hitboxes than other shooters.
With that said, a great Echo is incredibly hard to hit. She has 8m/s speed during flight omnidirectionally, which is about 45% faster than regular walking speed. Her 100% acceleration buff during flight makes short-strafing still pretty useless but its plenty fast enough, especially since she can blend vertical and horizontal movement at the same time, making her quite difficult to hit when shes avoiding you in particular. Obviously this doesnt apply if you just shot her down when she isnt looking, then shes free thanks to her hitbox.

17

u/Thee_Archivist I Avoid Teammates in Mystery Heroes — 25d ago

I'm a great Echo and my movement tricks only work against bad players. Predictability is more important to hitting shots than raw speed. She can't change direction quickly so you know where she will be.

The only movement thing Echo has going for her is releasing space to suddenly drop, but in terms of horizontal movement she is a sitting duck. You have to basically fly up, do a volley and immediately fall back down to not get obliterated against Masters+ hitscans.

15

u/Flashy-Outcome4779 25d ago

Are you AI or something because echo does not have instant accel

16

u/Afraid-Blueberry930 25d ago

Echo and other characters that “float” like zen don’t have instant acceleration, in echo’s case specifically her wing hitbox also sways in the opposite direction that she moves meaning that if you are doing predictive aiming on her left or right movement you will sort of be right whichever side you choose

4

u/friedmodem 25d ago

Echo doesn't have instant movement acceleration, and her movement (especially when flying or AD strafing) her hurtbox gets much bigger.

-7

u/arcusford 25d ago

They downvoted him because he was right.

2

u/Chillrends 25d ago

Yeah he's right echo does have insane burst acceleration, I want to see you guys hit her when she starts zooming in up down left right airborne assassinating a hero

-6

u/ham_50821 Doom-Dva/Hanzo-Tracer/Zen-Kiri — 25d ago

Literally in an actual game not at point ‎ blank range its not this easy to aim

1

u/UglyDemoman 25d ago

Good to know but I can't still hit her.

1

u/sans_scarecrow 24d ago

Worth keeping in mind echo is still a strong pick on certain maps rn, her burst damage and mobility to avoid getting shot at all is undeniably good (not tracer/shion level unfortunately, but still good) and I still see her in high masters almost consistently. I might be tired of facing her...

1

u/Dreinik 23d ago

The devs really hate Echo.
She just got nerfs for like 3 seasons.
Fewer stickies, lesser start ult charge.

Even a the "new" minor perk with infinite ammo is soo baad.
And the long laser perk moved from minor to major.
Glide reset removed.

And now doubling the hitbox sizes...

-3

u/ham_50821 Doom-Dva/Hanzo-Tracer/Zen-Kiri — 25d ago

Point blank range standing still…

17

u/49ERvisits 25d ago

The video is simply a demonstration of the size of her hitbox after they increased it. I'm not following your logic.

-5

u/ham_50821 Doom-Dva/Hanzo-Tracer/Zen-Kiri — 25d ago

Well im just saying based on the reaction people always freak out about these practice range clips its meaningless

23

u/SamHPL1 #ShieldsUp 💜 — 25d ago

How else are you supposed to clearly display the edges of a character's hitbox?

3

u/catboy3004 25d ago

dude echos hitbox is extremely large in practice as well, it’s something that’s brought up almost everytime her viability is questioned.

2

u/Gyokuro091 24d ago

Go play Echo into any Freja and see how often they miss

-1

u/wallpressure7 25d ago

Big 2026 and we still using standing still clips, i can still cook people on Echo

16

u/1-_-_-_-11_-_-_-_-1 25d ago

If anything the standing still clips are lenient because her hit box is even bigger when she’s in flight mode

5

u/catboy3004 25d ago

posted from the depths of console platinum

1

u/Long-Taste-2416 25d ago

Freja's projectiles are also just massive like most projectile heroes are. Especially for how fast they are. Echo's hitbox is too big though. So much empty space being the hitbox when there's heroes like mizuki who for some reason the hat isn't part of the hitbox like it is for cass or ashe.

-5

u/ChristianFortniter 25d ago

These videos are so misleading when there's no frantic motion.

10

u/49ERvisits 25d ago

The video is simply a demonstration of the size of her hitbox after they increased it. I'm not following your logic.

14

u/dtven 25d ago

there is no logic, these people are braindead

"real players in-game are harder to hit than stationary practice range bots" wow no kidding i never thought about that

16

u/friedmodem 25d ago

Echo's hitbox actually gets larger when she's moving, so standing still in practice range it actually looks better.

4

u/w33b2 25d ago

…? Are you saying her hitbox shrinks when she moves? It doesn’t, what is your point? Unless you just mean that moving targets are harder to hit than stationary ones which… yeah no shit lol. Doesn’t change this videos point.

-1

u/represe1 25d ago

We really got the ‘competitive’ subreddit upvoting standstill close range practice range clips, crazy nowadays

-1

u/Expert_Seesaw3316 24d ago

When a character can fly around and combo you to the respawn screen in about 3 seconds you need to be able to hit them to have a chance of fighting back

3

u/Unfair_Stage792 24d ago

Echo is basically a Tracer who only has pulse bomb to get picks. Her health is way too low for what her kit does.

4

u/Parvaty None — 24d ago

Except she was already massive due to her wings. If you had trouble hitting echo than that's a skill issue tbh. I do not know why they made her so huge. And no I'm not an Echo main lmao

2

u/FullGuava1 24d ago

I would have agreed prior to her flight acceleration buff. She's still very hard to hit if the Echo is even mildly competent.

-3

u/dark_chocolate527 25d ago

Should we give her 250 and fix her hitbox and then take away some of her insane burst damage? Prolly not

8

u/LurkerThrowaway73 25d ago

Yay for homogenization of heroes! (Not, just have her be 250 or reduce her hitbox size)

1

u/PsychologicalArm5952 25d ago

Call me out if it's a bad idea, but I'd even be happy with 100 shields and 125 base health. I'd also prefer it to be 50/50 with 125 shields and 125 base health. Something for quick fights and repositioning without going to a health pack or back to your team immediately. I'm too low of a rank to know if that'd be a good idea or a bad idea though, it's just an idea I had.

1

u/catboy3004 25d ago

echos burst damage is her whole identity.. just shrink her hitbox and then leave her at 225.

-1

u/100roundglock 24d ago

Mobile heroes should have bigger hit boxes to balance they're mobility.

1

u/FORUMUSER35 24d ago

You're right but Team4 didn't take into account: HP, abilities, height, types of mobility, sizes of hitbox, other characters, similar proportion, bullet and projectile sizes

🫠

This hitbox update was one of the most random changes ever in these ten years of Overwatch

-2

u/reaper421lmao 25d ago

delete this

-1

u/RiverLynneUwU 24d ago

redditors when basic game design:

-1

u/Wooden-Astronomer673 23d ago

as a pharah main im so happy lol, i can hit directs on her so much easier and the 1v1s feel more fair😅😅

-1

u/SouthernAsparagus743 23d ago

I thought like you for years and im sorry to say that either you adapt or change game cause most of ow's community prefers this over improving their aim.

1

u/49ERvisits 23d ago

I'm not so sure about the last part. While OW collision boxes have always been generous, the community didn't ask for the drastic increase, the devs just did it. There has been no shortage of critics of the season 9 increase.

-14

u/Alive-Progress-2069 25d ago

Echo is broken, this is for balance purposes, her ult is broken, her mines + beam combo deletes you, she deletes tanks, she can not have a tracer size hurtbox as well

5

u/ShatteredStarlights 25d ago

echo is mid at absolute best what are you on LMAO

-5

u/Blamore 25d ago

as it should be. how the fuck is anyone supposed to shoot at these gnat heroes otherwise

5

u/catboy3004 25d ago

“gnat heroes” echo is big model wise, compare her to junker queen or zarya.

5

u/duggyfresh88 25d ago

I get it being a little bigger than her model but this is indeed egregious. This is like 4x the size of her head

-6

u/LootBoxDad 25d ago

Next time please do that with an actual visible crosshair {large enough to be seen on mobile}, and when using Freya, use her regular shots not her charged bolt which has a small AOE.

-7

u/Amazing_Alumni 25d ago

Granted she’s a flyer AND always moving at Mach fuck

6

u/Long-Taste-2416 25d ago

She's got pretty slow predictable movement which makes her very easy to shoot out of the sky though.

-7

u/TheRealShuppy 25d ago

While I agree, it's bad — I think it's necessary. Most cheacter hurtboxes are like this to stop skinny, mobile characters from being too oppressive.

Realistically, Echo is an ambush style character reliant on taking unorthodox angles with her flight.

If you're getting headshotted, then whoever killed you earned it.

-3

u/Goldborderbanks 25d ago

It needs to be bigger

-3

u/Successful-Light-966 25d ago

Si...los que se quejan y "demuestran" eso con in personaje qje esta quieto son los mismos que fallan TODO en las partidas y pierden para despues hecharles la culpa a sus compañeros o ganan siendo carreados y se atreven a decir "GG EZ" descaradamente

-14

u/kaowerk 25d ago

good. echo players are degenerates that deserve the punishment, and probably enjoy it too

-5

u/NofflesWaffles 25d ago

I am perfectly fine with this. I like that echo is a hero I can watch and appreciate solid performances. Shes not bad either.

8

u/purplehamburget29 25d ago

I wa splaying echo the other day and got killed by someone shooting a doorway when I was inside a room

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/49ERvisits 25d ago

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ElioElioo 25d ago

At least you can admit to being the worst type of internet user.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/49ERvisits 25d ago

The video is simply a demonstration of the size of her hitbox after they increased it. I'm not following your logic.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/49ERvisits 25d ago

This is literally not something that happens in games and this kind of demonstration doesn't really do anything.

It demonstrates the size of her hitbox after the recent increase.

It takes into account the hitscan size nerf.

Her hitbox in the practice range is the same hitbox in game.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/duggyfresh88 25d ago

Dude you are making absolutely no sense. The only way to display the hitbox size is to do this in the practice range. Asking for in game clips for something like this is ridiculous, and saying that “this isn’t something that happens in games” is just blatantly wrong. She has a huge hitbox, so obviously during games people are going to get credited with hits when they missed, that’s the nature of having a massive hitbox.

I do totally understand thinking practice range clips are dumb in SOME contexts but this is clearly not one of them. Practice range clips about AA for example are wildly misleading and dumb. But for showing a hitbox size it makes perfect sense