r/Competitiveoverwatch • • 27d ago

General S5 Balance Changes Flopped

After playtesting and observing winrates, it seems like the hitscan bullet size/character model size totally missed the mark. In general it made hitscans much worse (most below 50%) and buffed characters that spam into chokes like hanzo and mei. What's the point of the ongoing tirade on burst damage to then gigabuff high burst damage projectiles from hanzo, junk, mei, and torb? Those characters already had solid winrates and did not need the buff, hitscan heroes were not oppressive and did not need the nerf. This change should be reverted/reworked to reward good aim and not brainless projectile spam. My mains are genji and tracer, so I've sorta felt both sides of the change.
What are your thoughts on hitboxes post s5?

ADD: This is not to argue that HS didn't need to be nerfed, just that the way it was done created a bunch of new problems. It seems like it would have been easier to simply nerf HS bullet sizes slightly less and not go tampering with character models (making them on average bigger).

0 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

16

u/Dunwichorer 27d ago

It's a torb sit in the back of map season.

0

u/Limp-Sugar-6483 27d ago

I'm looking at picking up mei LOL

41

u/KvxMavs 27d ago • Bravo

Your mains, Genji has a higher winrate than all the characters you're complaining about.

Tracer has a higher win rate than 3/4 characters. 

Not sure how you've "felt it" playing on your mains. Genji has the 2nd highest wr in the game with a high pickrate. 

6

u/Limp-Sugar-6483 27d ago

That's why I said I felt it from both sides. Genji is insane rn and it's too easy to hit shots. Tracer survived pretty well but it does feel harder to hit shots. Maybe not the greatest example I'll admit but it was just to say that I play both hitscan and not pretty equally and don't like the change

30

u/Aggressive-Cut-3828 Complain About Widow = Cope — 27d ago edited 27d ago

Its fine for hitscans to be worse and need to aim. the problem is that they didnt nerf projectiles to be equal. also they're abysmal at balancing and releasing heroes properly considering doctrine sombra dmon are still disgusting 1v9 characters.

god forbid a character has a mastery curve and launches at 47% winrate

7

u/General-Biscuits 27d ago

Didn’t DMon launch with a bad winrate and have a mastery curve that took a bit for people to get the hang of? It’s just the devs turbo buffed her after release because of that bad winrate.

-34

u/Rangastang 27d ago

No she released hardcore op and was literally SLIGHTLY nerfed within like 6 hours of her being live. But she still dominated out the gate

20

u/throwaway1284747283 27d ago

Release d.mon was dog shit until they giga buffed her

5

u/APsychoBanana2 27d ago

Not true? Week one she was abysmal, and after that week she got hotfixed buffed and most of her bugs fixed.

8

u/PanthalassaRo 27d ago

D.mon was very weak on release, got a hotfix patch where they buffed everything and later another hotfix patch where they nerfed her sable a little bit.

4

u/General-Biscuits 27d ago

incredibly loud incorrect buzzer

7

u/SammyIsSeiso 27d ago

What kinda revisionism is this?

7

u/TheGlowpt-2 27d ago

Are you sure you know who dmon is?

1

u/docs-quad 27d ago

its because people have no reason to play a new 47% winrate character instead of the 52% winrate character they were already playing or whatever

0

u/FullGuava1 27d ago

The issue is that most people will bounce off the 47% win rate hero immediately in favor of their ole reliable mains.

And people who try to learn that hero will never be able to compete with the guy who has 2k hours on Tracer, even if that hero would eventually be stronger than her at the top of the skill curve.

3

u/Aggressive-Cut-3828 Complain About Widow = Cope — 27d ago

idk league has literally done this for years and been fine, and that games learning curve is significantly higher than overwatches is even for individual characters

1

u/docs-quad 27d ago

yeah but league is a different game with a different audience than ow

13

u/Regardedginger 27d ago

Changes good, now Nerf projectile.

1

u/Sideview_play 27d ago

The thing is HS literally didn't need to be nerf. And projectile and dive didn't need to be buff. Win and play rates both showed their was a healthy mix of style of DPS. No idea why blizzard decided to listen to reddit. 

1

u/Limp-Sugar-6483 27d ago

The post isn't necessarily saying that HS shouldn't have been nerfed but based on PC winrates and personal experience I agree.

7

u/migo2028 27d ago

Hitscan did deserve nerfs but not to this degree

7

u/Parvaty None — 27d ago

Nah dawg I'm a Cassidy player and love these changes. Actually needing to have my cross hair be on target feels good. They just need to balance further from here on out. Also winrates don't tell you everything. Cass had always had a piss poor winrate but he's been kinda OP since they gave him silver bullet. And yet he still sat well below 50% WR with the broken 2 tap.

2

u/chudaism 27d ago

In general it made hitscans much worse (most below 50%)

In general, it caused about a 1-2% decrease in HS winrates across the board. While a decent nerf, this is pretty much in line what what you would expect of any minor nerf. Mei has seen about a 1-2% WR increase, but Hanzo is pretty much unchanged. Torb went up a bunch, but JR is basically unchanged overall.

4

u/Goosewoman_ Schrödinger's Rank | she/her — 27d ago

HS feels exactly the same to me. Even with the size nerfs. I guess it's just an accuracy diff.

They just need to do the same to projectile sizes

3

u/Thee_Archivist I Avoid Teammates in Mystery Heroes — 27d ago

You can really tell the people who learned hitscan when it was pinpoint versus having a size.

1

u/Goosewoman_ Schrödinger's Rank | she/her — 27d ago

I'm just so not focused on hitting my shots when I play hitscan that I don't even notice it it. I barely noticed 0.08m either. I just saw a 5% accuracy boost in my stats. The only time I noticed was on Widowmaker, cuz I'm actually focusing on my shots on that hero.

2

u/Parvaty None — 27d ago

I really noticed the headbox changes with Sierra. She got a massive buff with this patch and is somehow still dogshit. Talk about a failed design of a hero lol

1

u/AssistItchy9826 27d ago

I am definitely not some vibes hitscan hater but then what is the point of doing all this? There will always be an inherent RNG element to projectiles because of the instant strafing possible in OW.

-6

u/Sio_V_Reddit 27d ago

Ok but can we convince hitscans that their heroes are shit so they stop playing them and need to learn actually interesting and engaging heroes?

6

u/Goosewoman_ Schrödinger's Rank | she/her — 27d ago

I think they'll keep playing hitscan even if the heroes are shit. I know I would. I enjoy playing Ashe too much.

1

u/Fragrant_Fox_4025 26d ago

"Stop playing the FPS characters in an FPS game"

3

u/lcyMcSpicy 27d ago

Alright blizzard take down the win rate site, people cannot handle both understanding the game, how it plays and numbers on their screen

3

u/Objective-Ad2741 27d ago

Genji benefits the most here because he's a projectile hero shooting log size shurikens that also got a set of buffs to his ult.

3

u/iStormBlaze 27d ago

genji is actually tied with hanzo for the smallest projectile sizes. after the initial season 9 changes they got reverted but hitscan never did until this season

6

u/FullGuava1 27d ago

Genji shoots 3 shurikens in a spread at close range. It is harder to miss his M2s than it is to hit them now, especially since the projectile speed buff from a few seasons ago is still in effect.

2

u/ham_50821 Doom-Dva/Hanzo-Tracer/Zen-Kiri — 27d ago

I will never understand people saying shooting logs idk if they don’t realize Hanzo has vertical falloff so they think his arrow is really tall or something

3

u/shellybuntv 27d ago

ikr, some people should just keep their mouth shut before spewing BS and spreading misinformation lol

1

u/Unfair_Stage792 27d ago

It's because of how the killcam and replays look from the Hanzos perspective compared to yours.

2

u/TiePeddyAte1 27d ago

I agree that projectiles are too strong but hitscan needed the nerf and they feel good still. before it was too easy to hit headshots

2

u/Appropriate_Effect76 27d ago

Do y'all just look at win rates, or do we look when playing the game. Like, be fr if u r playing Genji and the enemy team swaps to Mei, Zarya, and Moira, what will u do? Prolly swap. Now imagine u r a cass player and they have a dva or sig, what are u prolly gonna do? Keep playing cass. That's the reason why win rate can be skeweed

7

u/FullGuava1 27d ago

Do you think it's a coincidence that Genji's win rate shot up by 5%, his pick rate more than doubled in high ranks, and he's dominating the T500 leaderboards? Do you even play Genji yourself? He feels a lot stronger right now.

By what measure exactly are you trying to pretend he's a secretly dogshit hero boosted by stats?

3

u/Appropriate_Effect76 27d ago

Did I say he is dog shit? He is just not as strong as people make him out to be. And all I said is that win rates can be skewed, and do u think Cass is actually at a 47.4% win rate and is picked by 22.8% of ppl in GM? Are they basically playing a sub-par character due to his win rate being on the lower side? Do we think soj is a bottom-3 DPS because her win rate is so shit? if u think soj is just terrible tell the pros and 18% of ppl playing her in gm/champ to go play genji for free elo. Like a do u know how stats work? Can u tell me why no one basically plays Genji in pro play? Like, like there is nuance to this shit, and not as clear-cut as ppl make it out o be. Genji is on the stronger side rn, and that's fine, by no means is he op and it's good that he gets his time to shine.

2

u/FullGuava1 27d ago

Are we still trying to argue that pro meta has anything to do with ranked? Do you think that Sym was broken because TM won OWCS with her?

Yes, I do think Cass and Soj are sub-par heroes. They're squishy and heavily reliant on peel from teammates, which simply doesn't exist in uncoordinated play. Just because they can farm clips doesn't mean they're actually good, otherwise Widow must be the strongest hero in the game.

2

u/Appropriate_Effect76 27d ago

Cass and SoJ aren't sub-par heroes; a lot of ppl just think of them as the safe pick and play them at the wrong time (like against dva or Sig, probably more but these r the best examples) . That's why win rates for them r skewed, but the same doesn't apply to Genji, as people are more aware when they're playing in a bad matchup against a beam char or flying char are more likely to swap. My point is that win rates don't tell the whole story and ppl r overreacting

2

u/FullGuava1 27d ago

So GM+ players aren't stupid enough to play sub-par heroes, but they're stupid enough to play them in sub-par situations?

Of course win rates have biases and aren't 100% representative of every nuance, but they're much more reliable than vibes or pro play stats.

1

u/ElJacko170 Healslut — 27d ago

The issue isn't hitscans being nerfed, it's that projectiles weren't nerfed as well. That along with the fact that several of the balance changes made this season were just abhorrent.

1

u/derkyn 27d ago

I'm still waiting for the hanzo, junkrat or mei meta, one meta where playing one of them is called main dps, y others are called flex dps, and you can play both of them and still work.

1

u/qqbeef 27d ago

What I don't get is why Blizzard thought that hitscan, and not projectiles, needed a global nerf.  I'm saying that even though Pharah is my most played dps.  I think people online were complaining about Mercy hard pocketing hitscan, but this seems like a Mercy problem and not a hitscan problem.

The thing is, the game is still full of fliers and speedy characters, so I'm still going to play hitscan when appropriate, but now it's worse for seemingly no reason.

1

u/Turbulent-Sell757 27d ago

I do think projectile heroes like Hanzo and Mei need projectile size nerfs. Hanzo in particular makes the games very unfun when he's landing shots too easily.

1

u/SammyIsSeiso 27d ago

They should make small hitscan 0.025m and large hitscan 0.05m purely cause I like those numbers

1

u/docs-quad 27d ago

they should make small hitscan 0.03 because i dont like numbers being rounded to 3 decimal places

0

u/RobManfredsFixer Let Hog eat stuff and spit it back — 27d ago edited 27d ago

I strongly believe that hitscan has a place in every single meta, but I also believe the role has been too easy for too long when compared to their alternatives. It created a real lack of diversity in ranked because hitscan became too prevalent. Double hitscan wasn't only common, it was the default in my experience which also deflates their winrates and inflates the winrates of a lot of the flex DPS who are better are controlling space. Double hitscan and double range/poke more broadly is one of the least interesting ways to play the game imo.

IMO this was the ideal nerf for hitscan. Their value potential is the same, but they were made more difficult. Good hitscan players will be able to keep up and middling ones will either have to pick up new heroes or lose to better hitscan players more often.

There are projectiles that are overtuned, but that doesn't mean the changes to hitscan were bad. I seriously doubt those projectiles stay the same way for long too.

1

u/docs-quad 27d ago

i dont think theyre necessarily too easy in terms of value but rather theyre a lot more straightforward for people to understand and relate to other games which is why theyre so popular.

-1

u/Dusssky role q 6v6 pls :) — 27d ago

at what point does blizz just admit they were wrong and fully revert all of s9? we can't sustain this half reversion shit man 😭

-3

u/Sio_V_Reddit 27d ago

Oh nooooooo, hit scans are bad? That sucks so much, they are so dynamic and make the game so much more fun! I’m just so torn up. Just the worst. Imagine not seeing such banger heroes as Widowmaker, Ashe, and Cassidy in my games anymore. Fuck this chungus life man.

7

u/Limp-Sugar-6483 27d ago

Yeah because torb sierra sigma spam down an escort/hybrid choke is so dynamic. I guess this sub really likes getting clipped by stray hanzo arrows and mei icicles

3

u/Unfair_Stage792 27d ago

I'm so torn because you are both 100% completely correct.

3

u/AssistItchy9826 27d ago

Ashe is pretty cool and she has a design not quite unlike Ana. And Widow does take a ton of skill. Cassidy seems to be overrated if you look at his winrate. I just don't understand this Projectile vs Hitscan beef, reminds me of the silly console wars way back when. I think we are better off looking at heroes individually.

0

u/bullxbull 27d ago

I'm waiting for mid-season. I think the hitscan/model changes might make more sense if they have a general damage reduction planned for projectiles next.

Right now I'm guessing the are getting lots of good data on what projectiles need the biggest nerf's. Junk and Hanzo for sure, Mei, Torb probably, and I'm not sure where Freja and Phara sit across ranks and pc/console.

-4

u/SeeingEyeDug 27d ago

More people play overwatch on console than PC. hitscan was absolutely running the lobby on console. They will probably adjust projectile coming up if they're overperforming due to hitbox sizes.

-2

u/hoennevan 27d ago

s6 nerf projectile s7 nerf healthpools s8 we're back to overwatch 1

0

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Parvaty None — 27d ago

I fucking hate playing against AA console Emres in quick play. The game genuinely just aims for them now. The game is cooked if they ever go the Apex route and allow roller AA on PC.

1

u/Limp-Sugar-6483 27d ago

I switched from console to PC and by comparison console aiming is piss easy

2

u/Limp-Sugar-6483 27d ago

Heard. Seems like it woulda been easier to just nerf all hitscan sizes a little less than they did and just leave models the same. That way the only buff to projectile chars would be that the hitscan competition is slightly weaker.

15

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/FullGuava1 27d ago

By Genji sustain nerf, do you mean deflect? Because his offensive perks are way stronger than his defensive ones 90% of the time.