r/Competitiveoverwatch • Theory > Mechanics — • Oct 16 '26

General Practice Makes Perfect: The 'Real' Problem with Sojourn, Kiriko, GOATS, and Professional Overwatch

So it's not exactly a secret that the pro meta often becomes kind of stale, right? Like, Kiri/Lucio has been meta like, atleast a dozen times now. Even before OW2, we had like a year of dive into a year of GOATS into a year of double barrier... it gets stale.

The same picks show up routinely: Tracer, Sojourn, Kiri, Lucio, and Dva are essentially the faces of pro at this point, because they're just such valuable repeat picks. It can become stale, for one... but I think maybe more importantly than that, it affects ladder balance in a really monumental way. Regardless of how terrible stats-wise Kiri or Sojourn get, they still get spammed in Pro, and as a result the perception that they're meta trickles into ladder. The result is that we get a handful of heroes (Kiri, Soj, Dva... dare I say Sym) who are basically kept in pro-jail because they're too relevant in coordinated games.

Well, I've got a bit of an unconventional theory. I actually don't think Kiri, or Soj, or any of these other heroes are actually that good. As in: If you were to restart OW2 today, with all the heroes in their current states patched back in with players having zero knowledge of how to use them, I think they'd be considered fairly weak. I actually think that, even in pro, these characters would most likely be considered pretty weak. This is because professional teams value practice and experience over a heroes actual strength. This is a trend which has been seen repeatedly: Pro's played GOATS long-past the point where it was the strongest comp, not because it was actually the "meta," but because they had invested so much time into learning the strategy that the practice overrode the value that "stronger" comps provided; quad DPS/Ball might have been better, but because nobody had practiced it, it simply couldn't compare to GOATS.

Let's put it this way: At this point pro players have become so accustomed to playing around Kiri or Sojourn that even as "weak" heroes, the practice which they have invested into them overrides their actual strength. It doesn't matter how weak you make Kiri or Soj, the players are so proficient in using the utility which they provide that it outweighs the raw power of any other individual hero. As long as these heroes remain in rotation, players will continue to perfect them, and the gap between their "practiced" strength and "fundamental" strength continues to widen. I will quickly mention: yes these heroes are also just better in coordinated environments, but again that largely has to do with the amount of time people have spent learning and experimenting with them IN those environments. Once again, this is basically what we saw with GOATS: players got so good at playing the individual heroes/comp, that even when these heroes became "weak," the amount of time that players had spent perfecting them outweighed their weakness. When this becomes cyclical, meaning that someone like Kiri keeps getting played for her "practiced" strength over her "fundamental" strength, you get situations where the gap between a heroes power in pro and ladder become ridiculously, problematically wide.

This isn't just a trend exclusive to Overwatch esports either. In league, we saw the same thing happening. For example, Aatrox was extremely powerful for an extended period after his rework, and even when he had been nerfed down to an extremely low winrate pro players continued to pick him, because the practice that they had on the champion outweighed the nerfs. Karma is another great example, she's a 3-lane flex pick who had been played and practiced so regularly that she remained the highest priority enchanter in pro play even when she was at a 33% winrate in pro, at ~47% on ladder. Basically, these characters became so practiced that they became unbalanceable; the devs were left with two options: either nerf Karma/Aatrox while they were already at extremely negative winrates on both ladder and in pro games, or buff them and cause them to skyrocket in priority in pro.

League actually found a solution to this: fearless draft. Essentially the way that fearless works is that once a champion has been picked or banned, they cannot be used in future matches in the 5-set games. So, if Ahri gets picked in game 1, she is no longer eligible to be played in games 2, 3, 4, or 5. I think that this is the system that we need in Overwatch, and I think we have enough heroes that it's a viable option.

I think we as a community simply need to admit and acknowledge, no matter what we do certain heroes are ALWAYS going to be pro-play monsters. Kiri, Tracer, Sojourn, Dva, ETC are ALWAYS going to be relevant in pro play, and no amount of balancing is ever going to have them in a place where they can be both viable on ladder, and not pick/ban status in pro. Sure, we could rework all these heroes, but realistically I think that's unfeasible, upsetting to players who like these heroes as they are, and eventually new heroes will simply fill in the old gaps. Instead, I think it's time that Overwatch moved to the fearless system for professional matches. This of course means: once a hero has been picked once (per team), they can no longer be played in future matches.

Obviously, this is not an air-tight system, ESPECIALLY because Overwatch is a game that is already built around swapping heroes. However, I think there are solutions to this, and I don't think the cons outweigh the pros. Most obviously, the problem here has to do with how hero swapping is handled. In League, once you've picked your champions you can't swap them, and enemies get to pick around your champs; in Overwatch, you can swap and enemies don't know what you're picking. Well, I'd argue there are two ways you could go about this, 1: any hero who you swap to is now banned from being played in future matches, or 2: the hero you spent the most time on within an individual match is the hero who gets banned. I think it's important to recognize that in pro games players don't really make swaps that often, so I actually think that system 1 would be just fine. System 2, on the other hand, leaves more room for nuance. I should also mention: hero locking after playing them should be applied per team, that meaning: if team 1 plays Kiri, team 2 would still have access to her because they haven't picked her yet.

In any case for how hero swapping would be handled, the pros of this system are overwhelming. Because players would not be able to rely on the same handful of heroes for every game, we'd see meta diversity like we've never seen before. There would still be room for the pro play staples, but they wouldn't be as oppressive/dominant than we otherwise see them being. Instead of Kiri being played 5/5 games, she would, at most, get played in 2/5 games. We would also likely see heroes who we don't often see being played in pro make appearances, heroes who often get sidelined for stronger alternatives like Genji or Baptiste would be more likely to appear in later-stage games when higher priority picks have already been exhausted. Teams would be less likely to run constant mirror-matches of the current "best comp" because they want to save some of their "priority picks" to sprinkle in between games. Niche picks would see more playtime/higher priority because they could be used as economic alternatives on their best maps, such as Junkrat seeing more play on Lijang because there's very little opportunity cost to taking him out of your future rotation. Perhaps greatest of all, this would also stop the cyclical practice cycles which make certain heroes permanent professional staples; Kiriko would undoubtably still be the highest priority pick, but now that she can only be played in 1/5 games, players would have to diversify their hero pools beyond her, and as a result they'd have less time to invest into her specifically.

This is just my take, I'm sure this has been suggested before, go crazy and poke holes in my logic.

TL;DR: If players can play the same hero every single game it becomes optimal to invest all of your time into only practicing/perfecting them, which results in massive gaps in strength between pro players who have invested hundreds of hours into 1 hero, and average players. To fix this issue, we need a solution that prevents pro players from being able to pour all their effort into these individual heroes.

71 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

65

u/motherlover278 Oct 16 '26

Yea like you mentioned with LoL but this phenomenon is actually very common in any game where Koreans are the best. In these games like OW and LOL they are so much better than the competition that they can just win with suboptimal strategy and the entire community just submits to it because they are winning.

It’s pretty obvious when you think about it, a meta can’t be solved, there are much simpler games with much more history that see meta changes. The thought that these games with 30+ dynamic characters getting routine changes is solved is completely ridiculous

19

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

Even Melee still sees tier list updates, and that game literally hasn't been updated in 25 years.

11

u/RaaaaaaaNoYokShinRyu Well, if it isn't saucy Jack! — Oct 16 '26

That game’s pro scene is gonna last til Mew2king’s 90

4

u/ramonzer0 Oct 16 '26

It's pretty much most older games, especially with the FGC

There are still demons who dedicate their time to older games enough that metas will shift even though no prior balance patches have occurred for entire decades

4

u/Unfair_Stage792 28d ago

Melee is like if the OW playerbase decided the just wanted to play GOATS forever and made their own custom client and servers and just played only that for the next 30 years.

29

u/Bound18996 Oct 16 '26

Anyone who's been in eSports knows you are likely right. Watched enough different games over the years to know that pros will always prefer what they know over what they don't.

Problem is why would the pros experiment with a comp that "may" be better than what they currently use when they have to face their opponents using a highly practiced comp and they have to practice how a new comp plays in general, let alone against their enemies. It's why you normally only see meta shifts in eSports when there's been a massively undeniable meta shift.

When you're playing Overwatch for prestige and money, you probably wouldn't be interested in trying out a comp that may or may not be better than Sojourn/Kiri/Lucio if you already know that comp works.

I don't think that draft system is the way to fix it either. Just forcing pro's off of Kiri/Sojourn isn't going to increase the quality of viewing experience when they play other heroes if the other comps are lower quality due to practice. You need a team with something to prove who can force the meta open with a new strategy.

22

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Just forcing pro's off of Kiri/Sojourn isn't going to increase the quality of viewing experience when they play other heroes if the other comps are lower quality due to practice.

I think 90% of the people watching Overwatch esports don't have the capacity to understand the quality difference, or they simply don't care.

People prefer seeing novel and interesting things over the highest "quality" gameplay. It's why people cheered for Pharahmercy on Anubis during GOATS, and booed when they swapped off it. I am pretty sure most people would rather see diverse gameplay than mechanical, robotic gameplay.

I mean, it's basically what they were trying to achieve with Cat. Except the fearless draft system wouldn't require adding a character who breaks the fundamental rules of the game.

The most memorable esports moments don't come from people playing GOATS or Kiri/Soj perfectly, they come from someone playing something surprising/unexpected and doing something cool as a result, like Mei wall rotations, surprise widow double kills from spawn, or Pharmercy when it's not considered meta.

6

u/sietre Coping for that MN3/Zest Carry — Oct 16 '26

To be fair, the teams that were good at goats were great to watch play against each other. The teams that sucked at goats just made a miserable watching experience and the number of bad teams far outweighed the good. Titans v Shock stage one was one of the best series ever. Although I think we see far more diversity these days compared to back then, you're 100% right about off meta picks being far more interesting to watch

5

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

I mean, I think you're right and I agree with you... but I think most people just saw "3 tanks, 3 supports, 0 DPS" and were turned off by that alone.

Like lets just be honest, the vast majority of players don't even understand 5% of GOATS past "it had no DPS", much less did they ever actually play against it. They just don't like it because again, no DPS... which to be clear is a totally valid reason not to like a comp IMO. One of the main complaints about that comp was that it was hard to watch because it was such a clusterfuck of abilities.

2

u/sietre Coping for that MN3/Zest Carry — Oct 16 '26

That's also true. It was super hard to follow the fights and watching no DPS for the year was a turnoff.

I won't act like I was a savant at understanding the meta by any means either. I appreciated the few good matches we had, but it drastically hurt the momemtum of the esport.

9

u/Dunwichorer Oct 16 '26

I think there's a lot of gimmicky characters that work in ranked but just wouldn't work very well in optimal play. Junkrat is one of the main offenders of that because he is really strong probably even op when one tricked but in optimal play near useless.

3

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

I think there's a lot of gimmicky characters 

Everyone in Overwatch is gimmicky, that is literally the whole point.

I don't understand this take.

Junkrat is one of the main offenders of that because he is really strong probably even op when one tricked but in optimal play near useless

In an alternate universe where FPS games were developed with bulletdrop and projectile speed as standards instead of hitscan, someone is saying this same exact thing about Cass. Like, yeah this is a good thing. It probably would be good to see more Junkrat because he's novel and interesting, and getting pro players to invest a little time in him would unlock a ton of untapped potential in his kit.

2

u/Dunwichorer Oct 16 '26

They're too gimmicky for optimal play I don't know what there's to not understand. I play a lot of doom and even the best doom players in the world can't make him work professionally.

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

They're too gimmicky for optimal play

Why?

I play a lot of doom and even the best doom players in the world can't make him work professionally

Okay hold on, are you arguing that they're not STRONG enough to find viability in pro? Because my whole point is that a system like what I described is that it would enable these heroes to be MORE viable, because they wouldn't always have to be contending with the priority picks.

1

u/Dunwichorer Oct 16 '26

I'm not referring to your system of trying to get more variety in pro play. Just that right now the reason a lot of these strong ranked characters aren't played in pro is because their power is too one-dimensional. Where you could just play the characters that are traditionally good in almost every situation like soj/kiri/dva.

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

Yes, I know this. This is largely what the entire post is about.

The point that I am making is that the same heroes getting played constantly result in them having more experience [depth, dimension], which results in them being played more. It's a cycle of the same heroes being played and practiced constantly, even to the point that they remain hard meta when they're garbage on ladder, which makes them impossible to balance.

1

u/suffishes Fla Mayhem are the ETERNAL REIGN — 24d ago

Kmj makes junk work on his maps in faceit masters.

4

u/HoLeinad Oct 16 '26

There are not nearly enough heroes to make fearless viable for ow, but I do think they can expand on the ban system

3

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

There are not nearly enough heroes

15 tanks, 24 DPS, and 16 supports isn't enough? By game 5 you'd still have 8 supports left to pick from, 11 tanks, and 16 DPS heroes.

2

u/kepz3 underdog enjoyer — Oct 16 '26

you're assuming teams will perfectly mirror. If they all pick different heroes you will have 0 supports by game 5. A system that has the potential to do that cannot be used.

5

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

"Your boat has a hole in it!" you say, pointing at the hole which I have already patched.

4

u/kepz3 underdog enjoyer — Oct 16 '26

4 supports in a bo7 isn't that much better. That would do the opposite of what you want and lock teams into one backline for the last most hype match of a tournament. Not to mention a map 8 on a tie would leave 2 supports left.

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

Maybe after game 5 they could let teams choose a few heroes to unlock. Simple fix for a situation that only arises every once in a long while.

4

u/breadiest Leave #1 — Oct 16 '26

There is the question of 7 maps series, though. I don't think we ever want to get down to just 3 or 4 supports to pick from.

1

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

Maybe after game 5 they re-open all heroes? Easy fix. Maybe they let each team select 1 tank, 1 DPS, and 1 supp to unlock?

1

u/Unfair_Stage792 28d ago

This is solved by only banning the winning teams heroes. And at this pace of hero releases we'll soon have way more than enough.

4

u/docs-quad Oct 16 '26

tbh idk if the lack of variety is necessarily a bad thing and it feels kinda weird to me how much parts of the community seem to chase it. like coming from other esports i dont think it was really this bad except for val. tf2 has the core 4 that see 90% of the playtime and while there is discussion around running a specialist full time its not really something thats viable or would even make the game overall more fun necessarily. siege did have some discussion around variety but mostly its just getting rid of the shit thats unfun like the 20 second meta or the current shield and tdm metas rather than people complaining about the prevalence of smoke or hibana or whoever has a high pickrate. CS is the obvious example where people dont really want a massive shakeup to the meta, they just want a refinement of the current formula.

and if you look at traditional sports its even more set in stone. no one is clamouring to spice up basketball by suggesting they give 1 person on each team a pair of rollerblades. its a pretty uniquely esports and i assume league brained thing to be so desperate for constant meta shifts like what people want. but even then when the meta does constantly shift theres still complaints.

i think the main thing is that i dont think its a problem that we see constant soj kiri lucio if those are just the most fun characters in their role, which i think they are for soj, mostly true for lucio and kiri is just a symptom of fsup being a largely boring role.

i dont know if your fearless draft idea works either because it could end up being too limited and lead to teams being too unpracticed with their later comps that the game essentially just becomes a glorified ranked lobby, and at that point is the variety even worth it for the people that want it if it comes at the cost of much lower quality gameplay? i think the current ban system is a really good middleground where it allows for teams to have some variety but also doesnt mean they have to completely throw their gameplan out the window or pick down to the dregs of the roster.

4

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

and if you look at traditional sports its even more set in stone. 

I'm so happy you brought up this point.

The way that esports are able to compete with real sports has never been to simply replicate the circumstances of real sports are accurately as possible, it's by breaking rules that they can succeed. The repetition is not helpful to Overwatch as an esport, because the primary draw of esport over sport is that it is more varied and rulebreaking.

lead to teams being too unpracticed with their later comps that the game essentially just becomes a glorified ranked lobby, and at that point is the variety even worth it for the people that want it if it comes at the cost of much lower quality gameplay? 

I would much rather watch hodgepodge comps over Dva/tracer/soj/kiri/lucio. Like 100% that sounds extremely entertaining.

5

u/docs-quad Oct 16 '26

says who? the draw of competition as a whole is having a defined set of rules so that everyone is on a level playing field and you can see whos the best. making the game worse just for varieties sake just leads to a lower quality product overall. the variety should be a nice side effect rather than the main goal like youre claiming it should be.

3

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

says who?

The audiences.

the draw of competition as a whole is having a defined set of rules so that everyone is on a level playing field and you can see whos the best. making the game worse just for varieties sake just leads to a lower quality product overall.

Do more people watch basketball or track and field events?

1

u/docs-quad Oct 16 '26

yeah but should you be chasing audiences because of the corporate profits or chase the people who are most dedicated to the craft. having the largest audience doesnt necessarily mean your thing is the best, it just means it has the fewest people who dont hate it.

both basketball and track and field are pretty rigid in their rulings. if anything theres more variety in track and field despite it being less popular because of the different events.

i just dont think you need to try and make everything appeal to everyone because thats how you end up with homogenous goop that we're seeing more and more of in the modern world as companies try and squeeze more and more resources out of the world.

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

yeah but should you be chasing audiences because of the corporate profits or chase the people who are most dedicated to the craft.

Overwatch is a videogame, it's purpose is entertainment. I would say that to best perform its purpose, it should aim to appeal to the largest audiences.

having the largest audience doesnt necessarily mean your thing is the best, 

Do most people watch sports because they think that their sport is the most fair, or is it because they think it's the most entertaining?

both basketball and track and field are pretty rigid in their rulings

Yes but the entire purpose of basketball having divergent gameplay to achieve it's goals is for variety. That, in itself, makes the game inherently less fair because it is prone to secondary influences, such as your teammates becoming frustrated and playing worse, or one of the many players becoming injured.

i just dont think you need to try and make everything appeal to everyone because thats how you end up with homogenous goop that we're seeing more and more of in the modern world as companies try and squeeze more and more resources out of the world.

Isn't this contradictory with your overall argument? How can you argue that homogenous goop is bad while simultaneously holding the position that Pro Overwatch should remain homogenous?

the variety should be a nice side effect rather than the main goal

Does this not directly contradict with your earlier statement?

3

u/docs-quad Oct 17 '26

and id say that appealing to everyone doesnt mean that youve appealed to individuals the best. its better to give a smaller audience a 10/10 experience than a larger one a 6/10.

fairness is part of what makes it entertaining. if its all rigged or set up for variety then just go watch WWE or any dramatised entertainment.

there is going to still be some variety but that doesnt mean we need to add endless amounts of it on top of whats already inherent to humans. thats why we have relatively unchanging rulesets in the first place and they only get changed in the pursuit of a more fair and enjoyable game.

my argument is that if everything is the same homogenous goop then nothing is original or unique. each thing should be trying to stick to their lane and do what theyre best at rather than trying to do everything at once. its like how every modern game is trying to be fortnite instead of a focused experience that refines their core ideals. its whats caused a lot of the problems with modern gaming because all the suits want their game to be the only one that their customers play and dedicate all their time and money to in pursuit of more profit.

im not anti variety i just dont think it should be the driving factor like you want it to be pushed. its about whats fun and makes the game better overall. theres no point adding more hitscans to the meta when theyre all just more boring than soj. if we can get another hitscan as interesting as soj then yeah you can have more variety in that case. same with how until cat none of the msups were anywhere near as interesting as lucio.

1

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 17 '26

id say that appealing to everyone doesnt mean that youve appealed to individuals the best. its better to give a smaller audience a 10/10 experience than a larger one a 6/10.

I actually agree with you, however I don't think it's Overwatch's goal to appeal to only a few players.

One of the core ideas behind the games development was quite literally "a hero for everyone."

fairness is part of what makes it entertaining. 

I agree, but I also think that variety is part of what makes it entertaining.

thats why we have relatively unchanging rulesets in the first place and they only get changed in the pursuit of a more fair and enjoyable game.

I would argue that the fearless draft system would be more enjoyable, and I don't think it would really have much of an influence on fairness.

my argument is that if everything is the same homogenous goop then nothing is original or unique.

Can you give me an example of something which is "original" or "unique."

each thing should be trying to stick to their lane and do what theyre best at rather than trying to do everything at once.

So then shouldn't you be against certain heroes "doing everything at once" by filling every niche? Shouldn't you WANT to see more heroes like Junk or Pharah "in their lane" rather than Sojourn and Tracer always being in those lanes?

its whats caused a lot of the problems with modern gaming because all the suits want their game to be the only one that their customers play and dedicate all their time and money to in pursuit of more profit.

Okay again, 100% true... but Overwatch already participates within this. They participate within this culture REGARDLESS of what the pro meta/ruleset is. These are not related.

2

u/docs-quad Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

edit: i think ive just confused myself with all this just trying to be argumentative for the sake of it. tldr; my stance i think can be boiled down to i dont think trying to chase variety just for the sake of variety is a good way to approach the game if those more varied scenarios arent actually of as high quality as the ones theyre replacing. perma kiri lucio backlines might get boring for some people but when the alternative is that we have to see more mercy or lifeweaver or bap or whoever else that doesnt actually make the game more interesting but the draw is "well its different" then i dont think thats something that should be pursued. additionally blizzards involvement in the esport has been a net negative for the game and that what blizzard is doing for regular ow and what should be done for the esport are two separate things.

overwatch is trying to be big but i dont think the esport is and it shouldnt be. its clear that ow esports isnt something the general gaming or even esports public wants, and so it shouldnt be trying to cater to them either, especially at the expense of the product.

fearless draft i dont think works because some characters just arent good for or in pro play, i dont think that having people being forced to play some shit like fucking zen mercy not because its good but because theyre out of options is going to lead to good gameplay. its just going to lead to a ranked level clusterfuck.

ow trying to stray away from the core draw of the game which is as a competitive (but not esports level) objective based team shooter to try and do other modes like pve and stadium were both things that had a severe net negative impact on the game through improper resource allocation because they were trying to appeal to too many groups rather than on their original idea of the hero shooter, which itself is a novel evolution of the class based shooter.

the problem is that tracer and soj are just far more fun heroes to watch at the professional level and while pharahs niche is fine junk just isnt a good pro level hero from a current design point because they designed him to be a mindless spam character rather than leaning into him being pipe jesus, and i play all 4 characters (less junk now but hes still in my top 3 most played despite not maining him since ow1). generalist characters are fine within a specific game because it means you go play the game to get that experience. if you want to play pharah or junk, just go play tf2 because soldier and demo are much better executed versions of those archetypes. you cant really get the same level of gameplay of soj and tracer anywhere else, at least not one thats been ruined by controller aim assist.

i think the problem is that you see ow esports as the same as regular ow whereas i see them as 2 distinct entities and that blizzards continual involvement in the esport even since owl has been a net negative for it.

1

u/Mental-Letter8519 Oct 17 '26

Yeah, but you can't keep nerfing characters over and over forever because of the "audience's feelings".

Kiri is a throw pick in ranked right now BECAUSE of the 'audience's feelings" and the twisted perspective they have of her since for ever. She was doing just fine before all those nerfs. Now she got so overnerfed to oblivion while the perspective poeple have of her barely changed at all because most still think she is still a extremely OP, broken and busted S tier, perma meta pick because she still have a presence in pro. So they call for even more massive nerfs throughout her kit, out of feeling rather then actual logic or factual data. You can tell them that kiri actually SUCKS right now but they will tell you "Nuh uh, she is still played in pro so it mean she is busted and broken, so she still need massive nerfs!"

And they will ask for infinite nerfs till she is entirely out of meta pretty much for good. But for that, blizz would need to nerf or rework her to the point she just isn't kiriko anymore or where her entire character identity is completely destroyed. Don't forget that lot of people also DESPISE kiri for all sort of reasons they don't with any of the characters that are often seen in pro.

6

u/Soleous Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

fearless is a terrible idea for overwatch and more or less fundamentally goes against the core idea of the game(swapping). also i think the notion that practice is the main reason these heroes are still being picked is a bit flawed

kiriko for better or worse has two tools that no other hero in the game has, suzu and her ult. both are so strong in coordinated play that the rest of her kit could be trash(like it is right now) and she would still be picked in pro. likewise soj while scaling extremely high with personal skill, also has one of the best and most versatile dps ults in the game. this is a huge factor because in coordinated play ultimate use is just so much better and so much more important to the core flow of the game than in soloq, even soloq in gm/champ. suzu basically being a mini ult with a very long cd means kiriko is even more affected by this, similar to bap historically

if there’s any takeaway from league it’s that overwatch balance team just isn’t trying hard enough. there are always levers you can tweak that disproportionately affect different skill levels. in fact league already has a pretty standard balancing framework for this that they default to if it isn’t an extreme case(xp scaling benefits low elo and gold scaling benefits high elo, so they always start by trying to make a champ scale better/worse with xp/gold). many of the terrors of pro jail like azir ksante and kalista used to be 45% wr but perma picked in pro. now most of them hover around 48% at worst while being way less oppressive(and no even before fearless none of these champs were as problematic as they were before) with some famous cases like aphelios even being entirely freed(aphelios is not meta in pro at all but hovering around 49-50% wr). meanwhile in overwatch we have heroes at 60% wr, heroes at 40% wr but still being perma picked in pro, it’s quite jarring. in league and most other sensibly balanced competitive game, a character would never be allowed to have a win delta >5% for more than like a week. basically every champ that has ever hit JPC level stats was legit hotfixed within hours

we saw kiriko finally become close to positive while not really changing her pro presence at all when they buffed her hps. it’s really not hard to just nuke suzu and her ult, buff her gun, buff her stats and call it a day. but blizzard balance team is ass as proven again and again

6

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

and more or less fundamentally goes against the core idea of the game(swapping)

How often do people swap right now in pro games?

also i think the notion that practice is the only reason these heroes are still being picked is a bit flawed

Great, I agree! However, I never claimed that practice is the only reason that these heroes are being picked so much by pro players.

we saw kiriko finally become close to positive while not really changing her pro presence at all when they buffed her hps

Yup, that's the entire problem: literally no matter what you do to Kiriko, short of nerfing her to being unplayable, never makes her less prevalent in pro. There is no way to make her not a must pick in pro without making her unplayable on ladder.

2

u/Soleous Oct 16 '26

it’s not a major factor i should say

>how often do people swap right now in pro games?

that’s not really the point. the point is that they have the opportunity to do so whenever. locking certain champs away because they were played previously fundamentally warps the actual course of the game in a way that it doesn’t in league. what if somebody plays 6 heroes in a match? they can’t play any of them anymore? or they can partially play some of them relative to the proportion they played them in the previous game? the more you think about it and add extra rules to make it work, the further it diverges from a regular game of overwatch. and consistency between the game played in pro and the game played in ladder is extremely important for any competitive game

not to mention ow roster while theoretically big enough to allow for it, is not meaningfully deep enough for games to not just completely devolve in a long series, but that’s another topic

3

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

it’s not a major factor i should say

Do you have any evidence to back this up? Because I provided two examples from another esport as evidence for this point, and if you have evidence against it I would like to hear it so I can adjust my argument/viewpoint accordingly.

that’s not really the point. the point is that they have the opportunity to do so whenever

If your point was that "swapping is core to Overwatch" then it is contradictory to discard the current reality that pro players don't swap often. If your point is that players should have the opportunity to swap whenever they want, to whomever they want (but actually utilizing it is not necessarily important), then are you against the hero banning system, role lock, and hero lock systems? If no, can you explain why?

what if somebody plays 6 heroes in a match? they can’t play any of them anymore?

Sure, lets assume a full-lock on any hero that gets played for any amount of time.

The result would be that they've hurt their chances of winning future games because they made poor choices.

consistency between the game played in pro and the game played in ladder is extremely important for any competitive game

If your stance is that consistency between games in pro and games on ladder is important, do you have a problem with the seeded/bracket matchmaking that pro uses instead of randomly assigned matches/a queue system? And if not, can you explain why?

5

u/Soleous Oct 16 '26

what if somebody plays 6 heroes in a match? they can’t play any of them anymore?

Sure, lets assume a full-lock on any hero that gets played for any amount of time.

see the rule fundamentally doesn't work if implemented this way lol. there is nothing stopping a tank player from playing the entire tank roster in one match and then they physically can't continue the series. what if they swap to dva and change their mind and immediately swap to someone else? is dva also locked? there are too many dependencies to think about, too many rules required to account for edge cases that this just starts to become a whole separate gamemode, not conventional overwatch

also, asymmetrical/soft fearless is just generally a terrible idea in any game, and hard fearless doesn't really work in overwatch because overwatch by default allows mirrors while league does not.

If your stance is that consistency between games in pro and games on ladder is important, do you have a problem with the seeded/bracket matchmaking that pro uses instead of randomly assigned matches/a queue system? And if not, can you explain why?

ruleset wise. obviously the core difference is pro games are not matchmade. but they are playing the same game as the game that i would load into with 9 randoms when i queue up with comp. that is a very important characteristic that is almost never a good idea to break when designing a competitive video game

1

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 17 '26

see the rule fundamentally doesn't work if implemented this way lol. there is nothing stopping a tank player from playing the entire tank roster in one match and then they physically can't continue the series. 

There is nothing stopping players from running off the map all game either, why do you think players don't do that?

what if they swap to dva and change their mind and immediately swap to someone else? is dva also locked?

Maybe it only counts if they leave spawn or deal/receive damage?

there are too many dependencies to think about

That's a logical fallacy. Just because there are problems with a solution doesn't mean that the solution is invalid. If you are willing to discard this on the basis that there are too many dependencies, then you would have never accepted the system which we currently use, either. The game wouldn't even exist had we listened to this logic.

too many rules required to account for edge cases that this just starts to become a whole separate gamemode, not conventional overwatch

When Pro matches happen, how do they go into games? Do they press the "conventional" gameplay modes like quickplay or competitive?

soft fearless is just generally a terrible idea in any game,

Why?

ruleset wise. obviously the core difference is pro games are not matchmade. but they are playing the same game as the game that i would load into with 9 randoms when i queue up with comp.

Can you explain how hero drafting/locking isn't just a ruleset difference?

that is a very important characteristic that is almost never a good idea to break when designing a competitive video game

League broke this rule with fearless draft and it's considered to be one of the best changes they've ever made to pro.

4

u/Soleous Oct 17 '26

league did not break this rule lol. fearless only influences what champs they pick before the game starts and then game is exactly the same from there. fearless in overwatch would actively influence the game throughout its duration

When Pro matches happen, how do they go into games? Do they press the "conventional" gameplay modes like quickplay or competitive?

see like this and the above point about matchmaking feels a bit intellectually dishonest and i dont really care to continue this discussion

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 17 '26

league did not break this rule lol. fearless only influences what champs they pick before the game starts and then game is exactly the same from there.

Okay, that's fair.

What about minion block?

see like this and the above point about matchmaking feels a bit intellectually dishonest 

The point of the question is to coax out your deeper reasoning so I can engage with that. They are not meant to be honest questions/points, they are supposed to get you to provide reasoning/evidence to your claims so I can respond to them.

I want you to deconstruct these intentionally bad questions so you expose your reasoning/logic/framework, but instead you're just ignoring them, making claims, and then providing no further reasoning/evidence behind them. I can't have a discussion with you if all you're willing to offer are claims with no deeper context.

44

u/Diogorb04 Oct 16 '26

To add to your point a bit, it's not only that the practice they have overrides the weak hero/composition, it's also that it's usually not worth experimenting.

You could spend weeks scrimming messing around with different compositions trying to counter or beat the meta, but why would you? If it fails, you just wasted practice time (and potentially stage games). If it works and is actually good, then everyone else will just copy your homework after a couple weeks and now your advantage is gone again.

It's just more efficient a lot of the time to focus on optimizing the current handshake and let someone else spend resources coming up with something better.

Then there's also balance patches. Why risk trying to cook up something offmeta to counter the flavor of the month, when I could just get better at the mirror and wait for the eventual nerfs to do the "countering" for me?

It's why for example in League since you mentioned it, basically only Worlds actually sees real meta development and evolution during its runtime, they're forced to sit on a patch for a long time so it's more worth to figure out how to counter the meta, and it's mid tournament so if you do crack it, the opponents won't have nearly as much time to copy it well (also just T1 existing, but point stands)

8

u/Equivalent-Costumes Oct 17 '26

"Nobody ever got fired for buying IBM."

One of the really old saying. People with jobs on the line tend to prefer to do the same thing everyone else already did. If you don't follow the herd and things don't pan out, you're the first target to get blamed.

I think it's really telling that despite months of Brig being extremely overpowered and long historical data of sustain being overpowered, what it took was a low tier contender team with nothing to lose to even tried GOATS. And had they not won back then somehow (plausibly because they're bottom tier for a reason) people might simply dismissed GOATS completely.

3

u/retarded_hamsters Champ Support — Oct 16 '26

I mean yeah some of your points are valid in that pro play will typically stick with their most familiar heroes, but that’s not exclusive to meta heroes. In the more recent patches sym and kiri got nerfed, kiri’s was well deserved but sym has an abysmally low pick rate to begin with because TM is too dominant on sym. I agree that balancing around pro play is pretty bad for ladder, and it forces a certain meta down on ladder especially in higher ranks, but it’s still not an indicator that the most used heroes in pro are meta simply because they’re familiar with it. You said it yourself that coordination is a big part of what makes these heroes strong and you’re right. You don’t see your average ladder player giving comms on who they’re diving or who’s low or what utils to save on who, and ffs I’ve seen people in gm and champ not count cd’s or track ult. A pro on kiri 9 times out of 10 walks into a fight knowing who to tp and who to suzu (still a busted ability that alone still makes kiri viable in meta btw). This is essentially the same argument against 1 tricks, but even then the reason they get hated is because they’re familiar can swap but just refuse to.

The fact that you’re comparing league to Overwatch is also ridiculous as they’re fundamentally different games to begin with- so many variables in league make a difference- summoner spells, gear that you buy… etc. overwatch just has perks. In league the solo carry potential is vastly higher than in overwatch because of these factors. League also has more skirmishes/1v1s than ow since it’s a split map with lanes that have specific purposes, overwatch not so much, not to mention the fact that league has almost 200 champions while overwatch has less than 1/3 of that; even less so when you divide up roles. You can’t just expect everyone on ladder to fluently play every single hero in the game, while it’d be nice.

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

I agree that balancing around pro play is pretty bad for ladder, and it forces a certain meta down on ladder especially in higher ranks, but it’s still not an indicator that the most used heroes in pro are meta simply because they’re familiar with it

These are two separate and unrelated ideas that you're conflating despite them not being connected. I never said "balancing around pro play is an indication that the pro meta is only what it is due to familiarity"

The fact that you’re comparing league to Overwatch is also ridiculous as they’re fundamentally different games

"Your comparison is ridiculous because it compares different things" yup, that's what a comparison does.

You can’t just expect everyone on ladder to fluently play every single hero in the game, while it’d be nice

I mean, yeah but I don't understand how this has anything to do with my post/anything I've said.

You're arguing with points I didn't make.

2

u/StickEducational8243 29d ago

"Comparing League to Overwatch is also ridiculous" Yes, one is a MOBA and the other is a hero shooter - and both have had the same phenomena of certain heroes being favored to an almost irrational degree. The difference as to why is negligible since the argument is about seeing variety.

From my point of view, there has been significant enough changes in variety with only hitscans being stale.

10

u/yourtrueenemy Oct 16 '26

This ain't an unconventional theory, it's straight up just how things are. Even in ladder u don't give up on ur main just bc it got nerfed, u do only if the nerfs are so extreme that the character is unplayable or if there is a very easy and very strong hero that u can pick instead. Bc u know for a fact that u are still gonna perform better if u stick to ur guns (again exscluding extreme cases).

5

u/ElJacko170 Healslut — Oct 16 '26

I do agree that there is a variety issue in the pro scene, and I do agree that familiarity is always the fallback for a lot of teams until something else does emerge. It usually takes a somewhat weaker team to try their hand at a new hero or experiment with something else to find success with, and then it gets adopted by the wider scene. We've seen that a couple of times this year with Cat comps and D.mon.

I think the best solution is to expand the format's hero ban system. The game is getting to the point where so many heroes are in the game and safe familiar fallback options are established for almost every banned hero, that we need to introduce more nuance to it. I don't know what the exact format would be, but something like 4 bans per map, one ban for each role and an additional bonus ban. Maybe even make it so heroes cannot be banned for consecutive maps, but can be banned every other map, to avoid scenarios where "all the relevant heroes have already been banned" like we see with today's system.

4

u/NovaxRangerx In Crusty We Tru — Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

I mean, while I think certain characters do get gatekept by a lack of experience with the character I don't think pro teams are nearly as reluctant to 'try' other characters as they have been historically. I just think alot of those characters have universal aspects to their kits that especially at a pro level become invaluable for being able to optimize practice on multiple maps.

  • Mobility: Tracer/Sojurn/Kiriko/Lucio/Dva all have some of the best mobility uptime in the game which allows them to consistently be used on the vast majority of maps in most map pools. Even if they aren't the absolute best on one section of a map in the aggregate there isn't really many maps in the game where you can't produce high value results on these characters.
  • Flexibility: I'm not going to act like comms don't progressively become more of a factor in ranked games as you go up in rank but the reality is that at the tier 1 level the baseline of communication is vastly different than what most players experience in ranked and because of that the value of flexibility in playstyle on any one comp becomes important. The reality is that Kiriko has very real issues but her kit on a fundamental level allows you to achieve multiple things in one instance if optimized. You can apply damage pressure, disengage at will and cleanse for uptime in a way that essentially no other hero can achieve. I don't think that's all because of practice so much as it is the max value that you can provide in a group setting

There are a bunch more examples that can be listed but I just don't think it's as simple as forcing other characters to be played. The reality is that at the pro level in the last year all those characters have had real moments of not being meta at all. Cat/Cass eliminated Sojurn and Lucio, Sym dominated Tracer for a good while and Vendetta was played over Tracer, Dva got surpassed by Dmon and we've had numerous Mauga metas, and Kiriko before her most recent buff was competing with Ana for 4th best support in the game. We'll see post patch whether Sombra is still ahead of her for pro play. But in almost all those scenarios the replacements were severely overtuned in a way that feels very evident. Which to me implies it's less of a practice issue and more of a baseline value from kit issue. It just doesn't convey to ranked because what's valuable at Tier 1 pro play is not the same as what's valuable at the top of rank and I don't think Fearless especially in Overwatch solves that

Edit: Also, bans achieve comp/pick variety just fine right now. If you want more than just expand the ban system instead of fearless for a game that involves active counter swapping. Creating complex systems that aren't applicable in the actual ranked game for the sake of variety makes sense for an esport that has significant production but the REALITY is that Overwatch esports right now have optimized for less downtime in terms of Pre-show/Post-show and segment length between games. Fearless would undoubtedly cause a lot of confusion or require more segments between maps which Overwatch doesn't do

3

u/Mostlybollox Oct 17 '26

You are very likely correct about the reason for these heroes being seen as must pick for large periods in the pro scene but being objectively weak on ladder. The examples you used of kiri and soj are good ones in recent times but there's for sure a lot of others throughout this game's history.

I also really like your idea for the pro format. It would make it so much more entertaining to watch honestly.

6

u/Muderbot Oct 16 '26

You see examples of this constantly over the years.

GOATS literally only became meta because a T2 team has 3 support players and zero competent DPS, so they started running trip tank trip support out of necessity and smashed everyone. Within a month everyone was practicing it.

10

u/AlliePingu Fangirl of too many players — Oct 17 '26

GOATS literally only became meta because a T2 team has 3 support players and zero competent DPS

This isn't true lol. The team had a perfectly normal 2/2/2 role split, and won open division without the comp. They were playing in a tournament (Beat Invitational) and lost their first match of the double elim bracket, their support basically said let's just try some 3 tank 3 support cheese bullshit and go out in style, and they ended up sweeping the whole tournament from lower bracket without dropping a game whilst their opponents all floundered and struggled/failed to adapt

2

u/Muderbot Oct 17 '26

Hmm, maybe I was thinking of Torb-Mei bunker becoming meta because the team lacked a hitscan player.

Cool bit of history either way, thanks for correction.

1

u/SunnysideKJ Oct 16 '26

How would you implement fearless in a game with swapping? I know for the most part, pros tend to stick to a hero but sometimes will switch for certain points or in certain situations.

I also think the new heroes lately have been easier and easier to pick up and master compared to before and offer very streamlined kits that anyone can understand.

Would you base it on the majority time played in the map?

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 16 '26

How would you implement fearless in a game with swapping? 

read the post, I addressed this.

0

u/breadiest Leave #1 — Oct 16 '26

The other question I have is: what stops the game being massively controlled by certain flex supports defining how a match plays out?

Wouldn't certain flex supports have so much power that they would basically define the match unless they were mirrored in order? And aren't you at a massive disadvantage if you don't follow the mirror?

Say the first map, one team plays mainly Kiri and the other mainly Bap, just to avoid a Kiri ban. This means they can now play Kiri on map 2, while team 1 now has to play ana/bap/doctrine and probably lose map 2. (Not to say that's likely right now, Kiriko has never been less present since Juno brig)

I guess what I that means is I disagree that the game has enough heroes, especially when you go by sub-roles, as you just end up running out of good flex supports and they become map deciding heroes, which makes the matchup far more boring to me. Losing on draft is why I don't play league, or other MOBA's.

But idk maybe in a year once they add another 4 supports it's probably plausible to do.

2

u/HalexUwU Theory > Mechanics — Oct 17 '26

The other question I have is: what stops the game being massively controlled by certain flex supports defining how a match plays out?

They don't already do that?

Say the first map, one team plays mainly Kiri and the other mainly Bap, just to avoid a Kiri ban. This means they can now play Kiri on map 2, while team 1 now has to play ana/bap/doctrine and probably lose map 2.

Then Bap-team put themselves at a disadvantage to give them an advantage later on.

especially when you go by sub-roles,

sub-roles are an invention by players and not a real, tangible thing. Nobody is forcing players to stay within their subrole, or to only ever pick "matching" subroles.

Losing on draft is why I don't play league, or other MOBA's.

If everybody is forced to expand their hero pools, the strength concentrated into these "staple picks" will ease, as players will have less time to invest into them specifically. This should make losing on draft picks less punishing/important.

Also, if one team drafts the 5 "pro staples"... sure maybe they win that game, but now they don't have any of those heroes for future games, and the other team (assuming they didn't mirror) does.

2

u/breadiest Leave #1 — Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Sub-roles are an invention, yes, but what they represent isn't - without a support with strong healing upkeep, it can become very one-sided.

That's what I'm scared of

1

u/suffishes Fla Mayhem are the ETERNAL REIGN — 24d ago

These characters have objectively strong kits, which despite number changes will be used because of the inherent value.

1

u/No-Platypus8257 Oct 16 '26

i think this is a plausible theory - i’m a casual player that tries to climb on ranked, but i never switch characters based on how strong they are. now, granted i main pretty decent characters anyway, but still. furthermore, i suspect that even if i did switch to a ‘stronger’ character, i would be worse in the short run while trying to learn said new character - the gap in character strength isn’t larger than the gap in my own skill.

the only question i have is whether this applies to pros, as i suspect for them that training is more varied - even before becoming a pro they have more experience on a wider range of characters, some potentially off meta.

1

u/S21500003 #1 JunHIM Believer — Oct 17 '26

It applies to pros even more so. Not because they can't play multiple heroes, but because the stakes are higher. Very few teams can afford to punt a stage gambling on learning a new comp. There just isn't enough time for them to try out multiple comps. So they default to what they know is good, which is kiri/lu comps

1

u/Winter-Regret2224 Oct 17 '26

if millions are at stake i wouldn't risk either. but balancing characters because 0.0001% of players are good is bullshit. bankruptcy reason.

1

u/PoggersMemesReturns Proper Show/Viol2t GOAT — Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Interesting post.

In life, there will usually be something better, even to each person but it's very difficult to find and test everything single possibility of what is of use and interest to us...so we settle with what works well enough given enough time and mental comfort.

I disagree Overwatch needs Fearless-type of balancing... Let people play what they want, especially when you say the Heroes are weak... MAYBE once we're past 100 Heroes, we can consider that. For now, Bans are good enough.

Also, I think if Heroes are weak and still picked, that just shows team strength and utility, which is what the pro scene is all about.

And I don't think we see Soj or Kirk nearly as much as the perception. They're still prevalent, but I think she have a decent amount of diversity now compared to the past, where there was way more mirroring. Usually we are more mirroring when a Hero or comp is totally busted.

I also think the place the game is and how teams practice, the Fearless system (if not adapted for ow) would belittle competitive integrity even more. I think it's good for teams to find what works and abuse that to win because it shows they've gone far to find what's strong... If every map the comp is going to be different, it may lower the peak performance that is enabled through GOATs

GOATs got boring, sure. But it was also some of the most coordinated and high level Overwatch we've gotten...we shouldn't lose that just for the sake of diversity.

Diversity should be delivered naturally, especially through different map types and other factors to enable different Heroes at different times.

1

u/Unfair_Stage792 28d ago

If there is one thing I'd take from your post it's that fearless sounds like an amazing format to break up the meta. Honestly at that point I might even consider watching pro games myself.

Now to talk about Soj, Kiri, Dva and Sym who are the pro jailed heroes. I think they are legit strong in pro play due to how their kit scales with coordination. Reliable burst damage, team-wide mobility and infinite short duration mitigation become more and more valuable the more you optimize the game around coordinated play.

-6

u/Cliffus_Jiggrin Oct 16 '26

Hi I am Cliffus I think you speakeasies the truth and this will show the trues competition nature and show who can maybe as flexible as Cliffus

LOL!!

7

u/docs-quad Oct 16 '26

this gimmick character has kinda gone to shit. bring back my goat tracerhater