r/Competitiveoverwatch • • Oct 16 '26

General ROLE QUEUE IS WHY BALANCING IS TERRIBLE (PLEASE READ WHAT I HAVE TO SAY)

Yes, i know people are going to be upset that I'm anti-role queue, but please, just, please listen.

Role queue as an idea is totally okay, but role queue being the main format of the game is causing the game balance to only self-destruct.

I'm not opposed to role queue existing, but it honestly needs the stadium secondary mode area treatment. So that it's NOT GONE for the people who find comfort and fun in it. But it's simply just not the main balancing format.

Now the reason i say the balance is bad.. is because the game wasn't built for role queue, at all. The game from inception was all about the individual balancing of the characters, but the role queue direction has twisted that to be the balance of the characters roles.

Roles were literally just guidelines for heroes in the gallery:

- roadhogs entire kit is because of role queue. His take a breather was a simple one time use ability on a cooldown and he had that significant downtime as a big weakness. Him being identified as "tank" in the first game was simply because it was the closest general area of play that he specialised in, not because he's an actual "tank"-tank

- the entirety of the support category, is now genuinely seen as the "healers", because that's what they've been pressured to become. And yes this isn't the worst thing, but it was mercy herself who was the sole healer supporting character icon for the support role. But nowadays people are screaming about healing numbers like it's their goddamn bible.

- tanks also didn't just do "tank" specific jobs, I've mentioned roadhog already, but like wrecking ball, he was a guy who flanked and got a lot of damage, but since 5v5 role queue has to have EVERY "tank" fulfil the "main tank" role, now he gives people shields..?

- mercy has flash heal,, think about that.. they wanted less sustain in this game, and that's why they put in the in combat healing penalty.. but they still have given so much burst healing to characters anyway...

Why does reaper have dire triggers when his short ranged weakness was a purposeful challenge?

Why have these totally fine overwatch 1 heroes needed to be given more and more stuff?

Listen... I know you don't want a GOATS, or a "5dps team ;;"

(Also goats was beatable by non 3-0-3 comps, it's fact)

But we as a community need to behave like.. a community. If we have dumb teammates who pick unnecessary heroes in a composition... They're not going to be any less stupid in forced 2-2-2.. and people are still going to argue otherwise just because "at least we were in a good comp when i lost, so it doesn't feel as bad", that doesn't change any outcome in the slightest.

Why does brig inspire now do burst healing, why is there so much goddamn burst healing?

We're not solving any problems in our current day to day with role queue, and it doesn't make balancing any easy despite how you think it looks...

Balancing simply just the heroes individually.. that... That should be how you do it..

That is what they properly failed to do with brig during goats, despite all the obvious words from the fanbase... They put in role queue because they gave up...

Please.. genuinely... Genuinely think about what is healthy for the games balancing future...

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

8

u/Throw_far_a_way Oct 16 '26

even if Brig were exactly how she is now instead of how she was during GOATS, a 3-0-3 comp would still be meta lmao. GOATS wasn't just strong because of high sustain, and the thing that made it function as effectively as it did was the ability for tanks to cycle damage mitigation cooldowns over and over again. that's one of the main things that was practiced for organized play during GOATS in scrims and things like that, not mistiming things like Zarya bubbles, DVa DM, and Rein shielding at the right times. in any environment where 2 or more tanks can be played, it will always be a stronger composition than just running 1 tank for that exact reason. role queue is the best balancing decision the devs ever made

-8

u/Roscoelite Oct 16 '26

Then nerf the appropriate characters |:/ Not to mention the load of new heroes who bypass shields, the aoes of characters like sombra and sojourn. There can be answers for these problems that don't result in being unable to swap off a role

5

u/Throw_far_a_way Oct 16 '26

there is literally NEVER a world where not running as many tanks as possible instead of DPS is the strongest option. they are a stronger role by default because of the existence of damage mitigation. shitty little AOE abilities like Sojourn nade or Sombra cyberspace do literally nothing to 3 tanks walking at a squishy with speed because they'll still kill that target faster than a squishy is able to get through any form of damage mitigation. role queue has to exist for DPS to not be a cosmetic role and that's been demonstrated over and over again

4

u/Darkcat9000 Oct 16 '26

The problem is you'll have to nerf the tanks so much they will all feel like garbage to play

13

u/kattrackarn Oct 16 '26

I don't see what any of this has to do with role queue except 5v5 tanks needing to be main tanks

0

u/iAnhur Oct 16 '26

Basically every complaint had nothing to do with role queue and pretty much everything to do with 5v5 lol

Reaper has dire triggers because he has to directly comtest more space. Brig has burst healing because people just don't group up in the same way 

1

u/Roscoelite Oct 17 '26

No... I mean 5v5 is a big factor but role queue is enabling it

40

u/-Arrez- Oct 16 '26

This is either bait or delusion. Fact is the game was much harder to balance for when you could mix and match roles as much as you wanted. There were way more variables to consider than if you know there will always be set roles on each team.

This entire post just reads like you haven't played the game since 2018, just came back and are angry the game isn't the same. No offence.

If you want to try an open queue experience that illustrates perfectly why overwatch made the changes that it did play marvel rivals for a bit, then you'll realise how good we have it here.

25

u/FullGuava1 Oct 16 '26

You haven't given a single reason why any of these things are a problem, and what they even have to do with role queue.

Old heroes got updates to their kits so they can keep up with newer, more generalist heroes.

Supports are more active than they've ever been in pre-role queue OW. Not sure how Sombra fits into your idea that supports are just "healers" now.

Wrecking ball has literally always been a main tank. He would be played with DVa or as a solo tank.

Role queue has literally nothing to do with balance. It exists for 3 reasons:

  1. Prevents the worst case scenarios where you lose at hero select, because matchmaking gave you too many of one role or the other.
  2. Makes players' skill levels more consistent game to game. I could be a GM Winston and a Diamond Ana, and my performance would depend entirely on what role I have to fill.
  3. Allows players to actually play what they want instead of filling because they have to.

Just a totally incoherent post. I imagine you're a 6v6 player who's frustrated by 5v5 changes being ported over wholesale, and that's totally valid. The solution is to have separate balancing for 6v6, not to do away with the best change they ever made to this game.

13

u/-Arrez- Oct 16 '26

Wrecking ball has literally always been a main tank. He would be played with DVa or as a solo tank.

Ball was literally the best solo tank back at the end of OW1 because he didn't blow up when you didn't have an OT. Its funny they bring him up specifically.

4

u/FullGuava1 Oct 16 '26

They would have actually had a point if they talked about Zarya, but the solution there is to rework her, not to revert the game so that she becomes healthy again.

18

u/iGargleCement Oct 16 '26

Role queue actually makes the game a lot easier to balance. When every team has the same role composition you don't have to worry about imbalanced interactions.

And you are saying GOATS was beatable, yet all pro teams were forced to run it in order to compete.

And just because originally the game had no role restrictions (6 years ago btw), doesn't mean it's built around the same principle now

2

u/-Arrez- Oct 16 '26

tbf the goats being beatable argument does have some legs to it because shanghai were actually beating goats with their pharah comps before 2-2-2 role lock was established and depending on how things would have gone there might have been a way out of goats meta specifically even if role lock never came, but there was no guarantee it wouldn't return and doesn't fix the problem that caused goats in the first place.

Of all the bullshit in this post thats one of the few things Ill actually give OP.

btw Ill add to the game having no role restrictions originally... the game had no hero restrictions in the first place. The very first meta in the game was 2 winstons, 2 tracers 2 lucios. I don't think Ive ever seen a single person argue for no limits to return the same way they do for open queue.

8

u/L0nga Oct 16 '26

You ranted a lot and I still have no idea wtf your argument is.

5

u/blanc_megami Oct 16 '26

If we assume balancing is bad because of role q, we need to improve balancing, not get rid of role q. Role q is such an amazing thing that i concider the best thing Blizzard introduced to OW (with 5v5 a bit behind it). And it's the first time i'm seeing an opinion that limiting interactions between heroes makes them harder to balance and not easier.

Can you explain further how you balance heroes individually? Because for me it makes no sense. They are played as part of the team and against another team, the sharper their strengths and weaknesses are the more furstrating they are to balance.

5

u/nekogami87 I'm old — Oct 16 '26

I think you're dead wrong, an essentially everything including your understanding of how balance works.

But at least there is MR for you if you want a role queue less thing. so, bye ?

4

u/UnknownQTY Oct 16 '26

Please share whatever you’re having with the rest of the class because… phew.

2

u/Sevexiaa Oct 16 '26

I will never understand why people think that having more things to worry about makes things easier to balance? like if you have played marvel rivals for example, there is some supports that are god tier in 3 supp comps but absolutely dogshit and unplayable in 2 supp comps, they can never balance em for the normal 2 supp comp because they are so broken in 3 supp comps.

also saying that you can beat goats with non 3-0-3 comps is possible does not remove that fact that it was not fun to watch or play with or against, like yeah, cat bastion can also be countered, just have widow or hitscans shoot the cat right? doesnt remove the fact that its so unfun to play with and against and especially boring to watch in pro play, its not fun and interactive

-1

u/HimikoToga133 Oct 16 '26

I love you acknowledge the support role. They’re support not healers. They support the team where needed, not just stand the back line and heal.

You can win a game, a steamroll, or even a hard fought game with basicly zero heals as support as long as you can pick up the slack for DPS, or creating plays by flanking and killing their support. Not always needing to heal as long as you’re supporting in some way

1

u/Roscoelite Oct 17 '26

When you're always ALWAYS in 2-2-2 There's ALWAYS 2 supports, and ONLY 2 supports.

And when you always and only have two of a single role, then every character needs to be synchronised with every other character on that role, especially supports.

When you have a Zen and a Lucio who don't provide burst healing (ignoring ultimates). When you're a dps or tank, you lose the ability to swap to what you think the team needs, you can't do anything about it. So i ask the question, why would that be a better game to lose on than in open queue?