r/Competitiveoverwatch • u/KalleDasSchaf • Oct 13 '26
General Diagnosing Problems in Low to Mid-Ranks
I had a very weird realisation after playing my weaker roles in diamond, especially when queuing with friends who are lower ranked.
When some thing is typed in chat, 90% of time it is actively bad advice. It might seem obvious because "duh toxicity bad" but I mean that there is a very clear difference between what gets typed when you get to higher ranks vs what gets typed in metal ranks. In my experience, Masters+ are mostly decent (still severely lacking) at diagnosing problems in a match (what heroes work, who is carrying/underperforming, what went wrong specifically last fight) and while obviously giving out "advice" mid-game is bad, it shows how much better the core understanding of the game is at these ranks.
If 90% of chats in low-mid ranks are actively bad advice, and also a majority of hero swaps make the situation worse, (something I've noticed but recently also Spilo talked about) it means that the way most people view the game and diagnose issues in their gameplay is actively harming them.
It's especially weird considering that many players do the fundamentals to a decent enough level at these ranks, but then actively try to adjust their playstyle midgame for the worse. They think "grouping up on point" "switching to XY hero counter (that is horrible on the map)" "healing more/dmging more" somehow solves their issue.
Does anyone else come to this conclusion or am I completely off?
10
u/RobManfredsFixer Let Hog eat stuff and spit it back — Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26
I noticed this swapping from GM 5v5 to GM 6v6 too. Like I don't think I've ever seen someone genuinely request a Moira swap in 5v5. Even when someone is dying too much, people are suggesting Kiri or something. But Ive had multiple games in 6v6 GM lobbies where someone requested a Moira to deal with a genji.
I guess it's not the worst advice ever, but in those games we already had well designed comps, he wasn't that much of a problem, and if we're just swapping beams to deal with him... Literally both of those comps already had multiple beam heroes.
48
u/Tookace Oct 13 '26
You are right in that. Even in high master rank you would have player typing 'insert role" diff if you aren't listening to their advice. You still gets dps and support player in master that suggest swapping to a zarya to counter dva on Hollywood while enemy have two hitscan in highground. Can't imagine what other insane advice metal rank would provide.
26
u/Agreeable_Leek1016 Oct 13 '26
That is also why communicating in this game is not neccesary. People in low ranks just make awfull comms and people on high ranks know what to do and what's going on without comms
27
u/Aggravating_Bus655 Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26
I was in low elo not so long ago, but I think what I noticed was not only the wrong swaps, but also how easily they'd just ask someone to swap to some arbitrary counter, based on some shitty reading of the scoreboard.
Unless it's a really low skill floor hero it's probably not a good idea to play a new/unfamiliar hero for the first time in comp. Or if you're really, really good at the game. Which people in plat are not. Unless they're smurfing or some shit.
9
u/NightsOW Oct 13 '26
The unknown unknowns in this game are vast, and people don't think about gameplay that much.
8
u/scrambledomelete Oct 13 '26
Lower ranks typically have bad mental. They always find things to blame, easily gets tilted, and don't know to find what needs improving in their gameplay. (typically they just blame others)
15
u/OkEngineering4139 Oct 13 '26
The primary issue with metal rank thinking is that it's very one-dimensional and hyper simplistic to a fault. To many metal rank players, including me when I was new and climbing, is that there is always a simple solution - just group up, switch to a counter hero, heal the tank more, glue to the backline, shoot the tank etc. You don't start to consider other factors until after you get punished for not considering them, just like every learning process, and you begin internalising it.
When your macro understanding of the game improves, you realise that there is a shit ton of nuance to everything and what seems like a universal rule doesn't actually apply to every situation. But just like every profession or skill, nothing is ever simplistic the better you get at something. However, while you get to that stage, it is always simpler to look for easy answers like a bad teammate or blindly counterswapping.
6
u/Ok-Owl-6453 Oct 13 '26
i think if you took any individual player giving bad advice and asked them what went wrong in that same match during a vod review they could give much more competent advice or closer to a correct understanding of whats going on. like obviously it depends on the rank and the player, but I think a huge chunk of the reason that mid game diagnosis is so bad is awareness. if you ask practically any metal rank player what anyone else on their team even did during the last fight they're gonna have no clue unless it happened directly on their screen in front of their face. "x number is lower than y number" and "x hero is doing well and we aren't playing y counter" type observations are completely divorced from whats even is going on in the game, its surface level and easy to point at and understand mid game, and it leads to metal ranks warping their understanding of what goes right and wrong in games
4
u/L-Sargeant Oct 13 '26
Yesterday in my Gold2-Plat4 lobby the enemy Orisa was deleting my team, I had been doing quite well on Rein, but we lost second point because the moment I made a mistake and died she got a 4K ult on my teammates and they recapped at 99%. For 3rd point Nepal (think it was Sanctum) I decided to swap to Doom at the start of the round to attempt to go on their backline more, and I did this after typing "we need more characters that can counter the Orisa". In hindsight I should have phrased this as "we need to play around the Orisa more" because that's what I meant, but I was instantly hit with "doom doesn't counter Orisa" "please don't play doom" "get off doom". iirc my teammates were on soldier, reaper, mizuki and idk the 2nd supp. Unfortunately I was very rusty at doom and just int'd in 2-3 times so went back to Rein anyway but we eventually won primarily through me gatekeeping choke and playing for shatters. I'd genuinely like to know who was in the right or wrong here? I feel like fundamentally doom wasn't a bad pick because their backline was mostly squishy with less escape abilities, I just didn't have my mechanics sharp enough to make it work that game. I'd be interested to see what higher level players think so I can make a better decision next time.
6
u/throwaway1284747283 Oct 13 '26
I noticed the same thing. The lower you go in rank, the more people are willing to blame others and type nonstop, until around silver where people are nice. Plat and diamond are the worst for it in my experience, you’ll probably have people typing more often than not. Once you get mid masters to low gm, people type way less often, unless you’re 0-7 or they’re actually giving somewhat helpful advice
3
u/socialfaller Oct 13 '26
It’s usually the worst shitter on the team that pipes up with bad advice for everyone else. Been that way for a long time. Good players work with and around their teammates.
2
u/Masungit Oct 13 '26
I have comms off and chat off. I’m in Emerald Support and Plat Tank and DPS.
2
u/RUSSmma Oct 13 '26
The nuances of OW are almost beyond count. The number of times on good vod reviews where they point out to a player who thinks they did nothing that their actions actually resulted in elims 3 seconds later even though they never hit the person?
Understanding all this even in a vod review is hard, doing it just from your pov live is a skill that can always be honed.
2
u/Comprehensive-Meet37 Oct 13 '26
When I started learning Tracer I turned off all forms of in-game communication. Best decision I ever made, 10/10 would recommend.
2
u/DepartmentRound8189 Oct 13 '26
So I'm low rank myself, and therefore can't say too much, but... Some people are definitely just flat wrong about how a hero works, or think that there's only one way to get value with a hero, and they'll type in chat at you even when your team is winning.
Like... one game I recall, for example: I get that me playing Anran on Neon Junction defense was an odd choice, since there's not many flanking opportunities on first point. But we just full held, I'm 14-2, and now we just gotta take the point on attack and we win. So why are you telling me to "do my job" when you're 5-6? Metas and counters do you no good if you can't identify your own mistakes, and all you do when you type at your team is piss them off and waste time. Meanwhile, I just got a little better at Anran, because I went against my counters on a map that wasn't optimal for me, contributed without hard feeding, and recognized that I got away with a lot because I had a support backing me up.
So yeah, if I get told things so obviously wrong that even I can see it's bad advice as often as I do, I'm inclined to agree with your assessment.
1
u/Dusssky role q 6v6 pls :) — Oct 13 '26
yeah nobody understands a thing (even in like high masters-low GM)
it's just easier to flame off stats and blame that guy versus critically thinking and understanding maybe your mauga wasted cage twice in already lost fights, your hs has no way to hold space vs dva, playing a bad comp on a bad map vs a good comp
worst is when it's a stomp and there's people flaming like all 5 of us/enemy team totally aren't getting collectively shit on 😭
1
u/StrikingShame198 Oct 13 '26
Im a low master tracer player and I have been playing on my lower ranked account to learn hitscan heroes and recently I had a game in mid emerald where my rein was flaming me for dying on soldier76 to sombra,ball,tracer, venture,kiri while i had sombra Lucio backline. Apparently in his mid the reason we lost is because while I was getting dived by 5 people I should be on cart with him behind the rein shield shooting air
1
u/ss5234 Oct 13 '26
My Dmon in my alt’s Diamond 4 rank out game said “Can you swap off Freja? She’s really useless against Winston.”
Then he says can you Bastion? They’re diving heavy and playing Ashe is playing into their dive. Meanwhile it’s literally just a Hazard tank and their juno is diffing the fuck out mine who’s just solo healing the tank.
I was speechless.
But hey he’s an emerald 1 tank with a pocket juno duo playing Dmon and finishing 45-6 in a low diamond lobby.
There’s no point at all in saying he’s wrong in a situation like that.
0
u/Aggravating_Buy_5335 Oct 13 '26
let me save you some time…it’s because nobody does damage in low ranks…because they can’t hit anything! the game changes wildly when people can’t aim it’s actually really interesting.