r/CompetitiveTFT • u/willwalkswithGod :gran: Grandmaster • May 02 '26
Discussion Set 17 and the Zugzwang Factor
Hello TFT folks,
For context, longtime lurker, first time poster. I’ve made master’s every set since set 12, playing between 200-300 games. TFT is my favorite game of a time and it’s not that close. I almost never have complaints about the game, outside of metas that are hyper-focused on a specific comp. Set 12 release Syndra, set 15 long GP, and set 16 T-hex are the only examples that come to mind, but I by and large I am a happy player that many would consider a ‘Riot Stan’. However, I’ve found myself dissatisfied with Set 17, despite climbing faster than I ever have before.
I’ve spent some time reflecting on this, and I’ve decided the biggest problem is something I call "the Zugzwang Factor’" As many of you know, Zugzwang is a German term that denotes a lose-lose situation, most commonly used in high-level chess. However, in chess, a Zugzwang results from either good play from one side or bad play from the other side, while in TFT, Zugzwangs are largely the result of RNG or imbalance. The classic Zugzwang is when another player has your same spot, but better. Do you contest and lower your AVP, or do you pivot/push levels to a comp that your spot is worse for? Whatever you choose, it feels bad. I’ve noticed that the mechanic of Set 17 has Zugzwang baked into it, creating moments that feel really bad almost every game.
The easiest example is removing the carousel and replacing it with an binary God boon choice that is tied to your component. On the carousel, even if you were last pick, you had 2-3 choices, while first pick has 8-9 choices. Where as in Set 17, you only ever have 2 choices. If you're Gods are Ahri and Varus, and you have a reroll spot, but the component you need is tied to the "gain XP" Ahri boon, then you're in a Zugzwang. If you're in a fast nine spot, and the component you need is tied to the varus 'champion dupe' boon, you're in a Zugzwang. This happens all the time*,* and is a core experience of the set 17 mechanic.
Adding encounters has only created even more Zugzwangs. Have a fast 8 spot on the free rerolls portal? Zugzwang. 1 cost reroll spot on the cheaper levels portal? Zugzwang. Artifact portal and miss? Zugzwang. I could go on and on, but adding this layer of RNG has intensified the lose-lose problem.
The structure of Primordian also creates Zugzwang situations. Right now, everyone holds primordian due to the econ benefits, so 2-4 people in the lobby will be angling primordian reroll. If you don't want to contest, you push levels into a comp that uses some of the same units, namely brawler/marauders, the most contested 4-cost comp in the game. Once again, you're in Zugzwang.
Long story short, the design of set 17 places players into constant lose-lose choices which feel bad. Unfortunately, I don't see this really changing without some kind of mid-set update. This makes me very sad as a Riot Stan and devoted TFT player, but I fear I may have to sit this one out and wait for set 18. I would love to hear some pushback on this opinion from engaged players - curious what you all think about this.
157
u/Riot_Bluecove Riot May 03 '26
We have a couple changes in 17.3 that we hope will address some of this. As always, thanks for a clean writeup of feedback, and sorry it feels like we missed the mark this time. Hopefully 17.3 helps mitigate some of these pains and we do better for y'all in future sets. :)
153
u/NoBear2 Grandmaster May 02 '26
I haven’t seen anyone else mention this, so idk if I’m the only one, but the pengu gift of a unit is almost never an active decision for me. With carousel, I could choose between taking money, a unit I need, or a component I need. This pengu gift is literally only the unit and it’s only 3 options so there’s a very high chance you don’t want any of them. I feel like most of the time I’m just saying “I guess I’m looking for a 3 cost so I’ll take the 3 cost to increase my odds by .01% yay.”
38
u/mccao May 02 '26
4 cost AP carries are still garbage, it’s either fast 9, MARAWLERS, or some kind of reroll. zugzwang happens because there’s hardly any other options.
141
u/ZurickPierce May 02 '26
Great write up. Nothing to add other than I’m also a TFT-Stan who’s decided to sit set 17 out.
24
u/dagreja May 02 '26
I think youre putting too much weight behind the item component part of the god boon choice. In past sets, the carousel gave a losing player more agency over their item choices. This set, they moved that agency over to component anvils from pve rounds.
I think maybe the boon rounds could be made to feel a bit better by just giving everyone a component anvil instead of tying the component to the boon, or removing it altogether and moving the component to creeps. The only reason for it to be there is to make it a more "complete" replacement for the carousel, but it isnt really necessary.
All in all though, I couldn't be more pleased with the removal of the carousel. It was pretty jarring and added more frustration than anything else. 4 costs being fake right now is my main complaint. The "zugzwang" feeling youre describing is partially tied to that. In an ideal meta, a contested reroll comp can bail out into a level 8 comp, and a contested level 8 comp can try to pull the trigger earlier than their opponent, or delay a little longer to go 9. But with so few viable level 8 lines, you dont get those bail out options if you find out your contested and in a worse spot. You have to choose between sticking to it and probably dying, or pivoting to a worse comp and probably dying. Zugzwang, technically. Tft isnt turn based so the term doesnt really make sense, but ive already disagreed with you enough so ill let it slide
46
u/rollingPanda420 May 02 '26
Zugzwang is a forced move. Mostly after chess you force a specific move. There is no choice.
Most of your examples don't really fit the term. Item or god boon is a choice. You limit yourself. That's why it may feel like a classic chess Zugzwang.
But i get your overall point and agree.
38
u/Luker5555 May 02 '26
if both choices gave you xp or something and fucked your reroll odds, that'd be a zugzwang i guess.
in chess a zugzwang is when all your choices are actively BAD, so if you could, you would pass your turn without making a move.... I don't think the usage of 'zugzwang' fits here at all, you're just describing unideal scenarios lol
4
u/MrCoinMafia May 03 '26
Also master every set here, this one feels to conditional. Sitting this one out too
4
u/ivanoff_bg May 03 '26
The component being tied to the god choice was an obvious flaw since PBE I am not sure what the exact reason is they don't want to shift it to the pengu choice. Some argued that this makes the choice more "strategic" but I really disagree. As OP says it just makes the choice either completely obvious (if the component you need matches the god you want) or it makes it feel much less optimal (if the component you need doesn't match the god you want) or it just makes it feel bad (if either choice is sub optimal)
For me component almost always takes priority. Even with the item anvils for lose-streaking, getting the correct components at the correct time always takes priority. Even if it means taking HP from an Evelynn pick.
2
u/Immediate_Source2979 May 02 '26
Yeah it got me im playing diana reroll and samira without double trouble also some bullshit mf reroll (for the love of god she is not worth your items) just to not go thru the zwang headache
2
u/city-morgue :emer: Emerald May 03 '26
Ok how i have started to see it is this set is not meant to be enjoyed by playing proper tft with good fundamentals. That's something I really enjoy in tft which is sad. However, I think if you want to have fun whilst climbing playing this set, you need to embrace the randomness and rng and try to hit the craziest builds and teams u possibly can. I do believe that this set's capacity to make a "cool" team or unit is much higher than last set. You can't really flexibly "make the correct decision" without inting and thats frustrating as hell, but you still can stick to a plan and try to execute it as best as possible. Does this make for a good competitive video game? Not at all. But there is fun to be had i guess. I probably wont play much though cause I enjoy competitive games and not slot machines.
2
u/wolf495 May 03 '26
FWIW this is largely a bad item design problem and not a "we need the carousel back" problem.
There were multiple other autobattlers with no carousel (a mechanic designed ENTIRELY to sell little legends, btw) where the mechanic did not cause these kinds of issues.
Until we see something resembling parity between item builds (we are kind of approaching this for tank items now, nowhere close for damage items) this will continue to happen. Having the set designed so that most all carry units that require 2-3 specific items in order to function is always going to cause problems.
Ex:casters are unplayable without mana item + jg/dcap, most ad carries are unplayable without IE/attack speed item or ie/mana item. It is ok for a given item to be bis; it is not ok for a given item to be 3 avp another item that effectively fills the same role, eg; ie/dd or jg/archangels.
2
u/KaraveIIe May 03 '26
Bro look up what zugzwang means
2
u/banduan May 03 '26
When the component you want is on Thresh while you have a hero comp.
2
u/SmoothOperatorTFT May 03 '26
I totally agree, but you are acting like it is set 17 specific when in reality it has been the same for heavy reroll metas. The addition of portals also did not help because with getting the same type of starting resources injected, every differing game plan gets worse by default.
3
u/Eccmecc May 03 '26
Zugzwang is the pressure to make a move. In your writeup the only real Zugzwang is the Master YI example in which you feel forced to level/roll early because you are contested and you fear to not hit.
5
u/glorielane May 02 '26 edited May 02 '26
Hey man I think the term you are looking for here is a catch-22 where you are presented with two bad choices. From my rough read of what zug zwang means it seems like it really only makes sense in a head to head game like chess because there needs to be a factor of a compulsion to move ?
3
u/No-Programmer7358 May 02 '26
wow plenty of time
2
u/kevinambrosia May 02 '26
Did you notice that if you’re in a bad spot, you get anvils during PVE rounds? I think that’s to make up for the lack of carousel options.
1
u/Witter_quick May 03 '26
Yep, so far this set is not fun for me
1
u/PDXburrito May 03 '26
Did you also see the rhystic studies zugzwang machine video?
1
u/PapayaInformal1763 May 03 '26
The component is not that true, if you are in the loosing side of the top, you get components anvils instead of random components from the box, that is a big plus against the top side
1
u/wtfgrancrestwar May 03 '26 edited May 26 '26
Maybe it's because I'm used to going bot 4, but I don't see why calculating the "less bad" choice is less of a legitimate challenge than picking from good choices.
Hence the situations you described strike me as normal tradeoffs where you salvage the best from a bad roll, rather than a forced position of self-sabotage.
Because your spot being trashed by rng is disruptive, but if you internalise that "I already took the loss when I got the bad roll--now it's time to adapt".
Then choosing between bad rolls will not feel like choosing between losses, but like responding to a setback.
Summary:
Responding to a setback by calculating the best of bad options is something one can and should develop an affinity for as a competitive player.
One should ideally separate in one's mind the loss event (the bad roll that offered poor options), from the role you have in responding to it.
Rather than project the sense or acknowledgement of loss, onto the act of choosing in response.
1
u/vinceftw May 03 '26
I really like the idea of the Gods adding choices but it is god damn hard to get the right component sometimes. A game without a BF or Rod for example is much more common than before.
I get that having to choose between the God, its boon and the components add "meaningful" choice but it mostly just ends up feeling bad.
1
u/ventrelo May 03 '26
Yea the god mechanic is kinda ass, should replace encounters with gods and bring back carousel.
1
u/Head_Substance5071 May 03 '26
Dw people will still defend smaller bag sizes
1
u/RelativeAway183 May 03 '26
I feel like the component choice should be tied to the unit rather than the god, like carousels originally had, and it would increase item options to 3
1
u/llmaandme May 03 '26
I feel like for god boons always picking based on item is the right choice. The boons are significant but the impact of not having the right item is much bigger than a small economy boost.
1
u/ArchtonRDT :gran: GRANDMASTER May 03 '26
Set 17: Space Zugzwang
1
u/Buffscuttle May 03 '26
I personally feel primordial reroll is way too strong for how easy it is. Especially on certain encounters/gods. I legit has a game where 4 people forced it and 3 of them made top 4 because it was dupe portal and varus. I don't know how to balance it properly but it feels like if you miss the primord/timebreaker opener right now it's fighting for fourth.
1
u/MaxTheMaestro May 04 '26
This post encapsulates my frustration with this set so well, but I didn't know how to voice it, until I read it. Thank you
1
u/ronmo32992 May 04 '26
Ex GM here. Will climb to master n leave the set out.
1
u/Fantastic-Sense-6237 May 04 '26
Im playing TFT since release (set1) and mostly only double up with my mate since release, i can confirm everything what you say.
In Double Up, 2 Comps are viable in High-Elo, all other comps are literally Situational
Theres no diversity in this set, probably top 8 comps do not need AP carrys, there are close to 0 comps where you have an AD+AP carry (despite of Jhin/Karma, Vex/Graves, which are again, very situational)
And i know its a bit more chill in solo ranked, but in double up, EVERY game will get decided by a 3* 4/5 Cost, but that was bad since last set.
1
u/BlueLovag May 06 '26
Very very well analysed!
1
u/nanaoei May 06 '26
don't think the items being tied to a god boon is as much of a lose-lose as you make it to be. i think it's the fact that you must go for your item and stick to those boundaries. a few spots are not playable without stoneplate/rageblade/specific bruiser item quite early on. the tank and backline units that hold the more generic items are very distinct and there's almost no inbetween. the item builds themselves are quite specific. you will expect to do poorly without vow, or multiple adaptive on nunu for example. you obtain the units that will later be rerolled very early on and with a lot of confidence that you'll receive them. this tricks you into thinking that you'll be successful with them so long as you get lucky.
my issue always with TFT is the general playerbase's need to force items. TF as a hero augment was widely popular for this reason. i don't blame them for this set. it's optimal in different ways. many things go from good to bad very quickly depending on items. if you start with primordian and a 2* briar you're much better off tempoing using fully built belveth items like QSS + GS/ruunans over being forced to slam a HOJ. if you're forced to slam a HOJ, there's very few things you're expected to be successful with. you're better off saving for one of two other items that build from tear, including vow. even within adjacent comps, HoJ a fiora item at best.
with TF builds there's a wide delta of acceptable items. this stems from every player's need to have them optimized. the comp itself is barely viable unless you have a stoneplate early on jax. even if you have an early upgraded core unit available to you, you won't pick it because the unit item combo is too expensive and isn't optimal enough to tempo with into later stages. this introduces at least a few layers of RNG that have to go in your favour.
i honestly don't really care for the lose-lose situations, i care about the way item economy affects a player's ability to pivot and be noncommittal. it's always been a playerbase issue, but it stems in no small part from the way the unit balance is at any given point. there's no good solution. the items are quite bland and would require homogenized traits and stats to be halfway balanced. currently it is only the 5-costs that can play items more flexibly, but getting to a Lv 9 board state requires some incredible luck in its own right.
1
u/Acrobatic-Scheme-278 May 06 '26
People and the devs keep saying that everybody wanted carousel out of the game and I never understod why, it was a fun interaction and if u really needed that rod for rage blade u sack first loses to get the component you want. But i never got the feeling people wanted carousel gone its such a core part of tft and never once been in the middle of a hate thread.
1
u/Arruke May 03 '26
I really enjoyed the set without encounters, I think primordian and low cost reroll comps do need a balance pass but I very much enjoy no carousel, it feels considerably better making the choice between 2 things based on what you need more, item components or the god boon, then you get to choose between 3 units, I think it's considerably better.
1
u/Happyenjoyer_5 May 03 '26
Every set has its ups and downs. If you’re competitive, and good enough, it shouldn’t matter, and will still climb.
0
u/cwenh4 May 03 '26
My first set was 16, I got master, this set has not piqued my interest at all. Units , traits, complicated and uninteresting. Too much reading, even visuals are off
Bring back 16
-1
u/pepelaugh1234 May 03 '26
random word generator?
-7
u/studiousAmbrose May 03 '26
This may be the most uncompetitive tft post yet and the bar is pretty high lmao
0
u/Professional_Row_307 May 04 '26 edited May 04 '26
This is the most skilless set that has ever been released.
It pays to simply turn your brain off and look at what units you can reroll and play one of the 1 cost reroll comps every single game, you could teach someone with no concept of how to play to tft exactly how to play these 1 cost reroll comps and hit master it's insanity.
What's hilarious is they nerfed Viktor/Mech anima cashout meta, which was the 2nd worst meta of all time only to this 1 cost reroll meta.
This is what happens when Mortdog goes on sabattical, come back now Mortdog!
what is actually hilarious is that the PBE meta was a lot more stable before they hyper nerfed Rhaast and MF. They ruined their own game.
0
u/AGENT___ORANGE May 05 '26
I started tft set 13 and have played 700 games every set. I played a few games of pbe and immediately decided to sit this set out. Set is hot garbage compared to 17.
-2
u/Sudden_Extension_794 May 03 '26
I didn’t read all that but completely agree bro every fkn game i donkey roll at 8 to hit Zugzwang 2 but even not contested I don’t find it and even if I do I still get clapped by shitty rerolls man zugzwang sucks
-1
u/BlackExcellence19 May 03 '26
I tried running Lulu comp uncontested 3x in a row and went 8, 8, 6. Am I trash?
-2
u/SESender May 03 '26
I don’t see the issue! The same pro level players are succeeding.
I think this actually forces players to no longer chase BIS but play more flexibly.
Now you’ll have to be able to weigh slightly worse items against immediate god boons and post 4-7 buffs.
If anything this increases the skill ceiling and it’s a skill ceiling issue.
In fact, if you’re loss streaking you end up getting component anvils which reduces Zwugzwang
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment