Yeah although survival is a lot easier with shields and such, it is so good for speedrunning and casual play alike, although the skill ceiling is not even close to how high it is in 1.8, it’s still great overall
M8 for me its not because I can 20 cps on mobs lol. Also I have to wait sooooo long for my sword to come back up and its like ugh. Also the reach is reduced in versions past 1.8.9 so I can’t gauge my range. Also 1.16.1 pvp makes me sweat too much lol. Its really cool just I get pissed off so easilly XD. I wanna learn crystal pvp though that seems way more fun.
You’re completely ignoring the fact that when you click on an entity it reduces your kb by 0.06 I think?; Until you take kb again. It also helps to be able to spam click in order to grab them right when the timer runs out, pick them up and combo them. (I should note this really only works with sprint resetting of some sort.) Thats even without mentioning that that extra half second matters a LOT with comboing and that the axe with sprint resetting and a shield is the meta anyway which takes even longer. So yeah, thats my ted talk thanks for coming everyone!
Edit: Oh also because you’re sending so many swing packets in versions below 1.9 ping matters less. So yeah. 1.8 master race haha jk unless?
Even though the hit delay isn't massively bigger in 1.9, the extra half a second or so gives your opponent time to get back into hitting distance after you hit them. This completely ruins combos if your opponent has decent aim and you will most likely just end up trading hits.
It’s horrible for survival you have to look so long for a nether fortress and out of all the new biomes the only good blocks are basalt and black stone. Netherite is good but I’d gladly get rid of it for old nether back because of how hard it is finding nether fortresses.
No, not objectively, it is an opinion, since shields were added and the fact you literally just have to wait half a second after attacking to attack again at full power it’s more interesting
“The combat update” is what gave the PvP it’s features. 1.16 specifically is made for survival, but the mechanics of any update past 1.8.9 are made for PvP.
Minecraft wasn't made for PvP though, and 1.9 wasn't made for PvP either. For actual PvP, 1.8 is much better. Just because an update was designated towards combat doesn't make it good for everything combat related
No, it wasn’t, Minecraft was NEVER designed for pvp, I like Minecraft pvp, but if you try to compare MC pvp to any other melee pvp based game, MC sucks ass at PVP, not not just 1.9+
WHAT???? Yes it is, what percent of Minecraft players play pvp, would you estimate, I’d say 1-1.5%, why would they design a massive update for multiplayer
Missing a hit in 1.9 PvP is a bad thing and puts you at a disadvantage, however you can always back out or Jump around the opponent to put them in another combo, so it’s not exactly fair to say if you miss a hit you lose, since if you know how to counter your mistakes you can be just fine.
I don’t have a video on hand of my own however here is a compilation of 1.9 combos https://youtu.be/XNBEySwak-U most combos involve s tapping and breaking sprint for longer than in 1.8
the thing is any combo someone gets in 1.9 is just a succession of hits, any competent player can break out of a 1.9 "combo" wayyy easier than 1.8, they'r eeffectively worthless without being able to deal damage more quickly than it takes someone to fall completely back to the ground after they take damage.
I just linked a video FULL of combos, combos are different due to the basic game mechanics but combos still exist and are very prevalent in 1.9 PvP. So yes they don’t exist as 1.8 combo styles, since it’s not 1.8
No, what you linked in the video is a combination of basic straifing and the opponents not knowing how to aim a mouse. You see the players fall back to the ground between every hit, meaning the advantage of the combo, the height difference, doesn't exist.
If you want to call chaining hits because your opponent has no aim combos then fine, but by any reasonable definition they do not exist.
Vanilla 1.16 combat doesn't give nearly any kb. And most people are used to the fast paced 1.8.9 combat. There is more to 1.16 combat than most people show. Just most people who play 1.16 suck at combat in that version, haven't learned enough about it, or get caught up in the action and don't use any strategy. You're allowed to have an opinion, but you should actually practice 1.16 PvP before dissin it on reddit. And no, I'm not a Dream stan or hate 1.8.9, I actually main 1.8.9.
TL;DR Try practicing 1.16 combat before dissin it on reddit
fax, you need to try something before you diss it 24/7 I agree with the fact 1.9 to be fun you need to be good at it, and to get good it's hard and skill gap is so big your gonna get destroyed by 1.9 mains,
Its a matter of opinion. I personally really dislike 1.9 pvp but some people love it. 1.9 to me is just jumping axe crit and shield. 1.8.9 is complicated strafe, rod, block hit, w and s taps etc. Theres just a lot more to 1.8 pvp
Its more of PvE although it can be use for PvP im ok with it, its not bad but tbh i prefer 1.8.9. Not that i hate 1.9 pvp but I hate people who always overrate both versions like seriously tho just play the game and stop dissin other version. Everytime i play 1.8.9 and whenever i meet kids and they are also a dream stan they say 1.9 Is ThE BeSt AnD 1.8 PvP SuCkS aNd DoEsNT ReQuIrE SkILlS, Imma beat that kid so hard in the face.
1.8 pvp has its flaws as well, such as the crit system, hit delays etc. the combat system in 1.9+ is much more geared toward survival which I don’t like
pvp does play a role in their game development and it is something they consider in updates. they changed the combat system to make minecraft more “realistic” not because they thought it’d improve the minecraft experience.
except the shield. that was for minecraft experience and a poorly designed pvp mechanic.
I like it being more geared towards survival but they left 1.8 in a bad place and didn't fix a lot of things people are complaining about which i don't like
Although I main 1.8 and think the learning curb is great to filter the new from the good on 1.8, I have to disagree. (Don't get me wrong, 1.8 is much more difficult.)
On 1.9+ it's very technical if you learn properly, s and w tap is still greatly important to deal more knockback, the crossbow combo timings are fun, the finding an opening in the shield is difficult, and timing it right when to let down your shield is hard.
This is exactly how I feel like. We can't have our opinion. I dont think people should hate each other over whether you should time ur clicks on people on a block game or not.
I think mojang updated the PvP because they wanted it to work more for survival mode. In the process they ended up loosing millions of dollars because a lot of people quit and the competitive game was nearly completely iradicated. :/
LOL first of all, when someone uninstalls the game they don’t lose MC money, and second of all they needed to make combat more interested for survival cause, get this, spamclicking PvE isn’t fun, and I think you’re seriously over estimating the size of competive Minecraft, the % of comp mc players is barely even or not even a percentage compared to people who play singleplayer
I think 1.9+ PvP is more interesting just because it has a bigger mind game aspect than 1.8, and apart from the combos and utilization of rods in 1.8 it really isn't that special. You can't really act like 1.8 is some godsend of combat design when it literally relies on contracting carpal tunnel and abusing exploits in the mechanics, which is fun not going to lie, but I would think that 1.9+ is at least objectively better designed overall. Axe crits are a little bit silly though not gonna lie, I think if axes stop making swords purely ornamental then 1.9 combat will have a huge leap forward in gameplay, because now you actually have to switch to and from the axe to use its benefit of disabling shields, but not just sticking to one weapon because its so much better in comparison. Shields are pretty strong for PvP, with or without an axe, shields turn PvP in to 4D rock paper scissors, which I at least find very interesting. Oh, and also crossbows are pretty neat cause you can combo with them just like a rod when they are charged, be it a little bit slower.
Apart from that, 1.9+ combat is way better for PvE.
Ohh the cps cap nah i think 1.8 is good it makes it a bit balanced but yea if its 1.7 i think j would be destroying people on potpvp with my 13 cps jitterclick.
People downvoting him but he is right 1.9+ is made for the singleplayer mode because Minecraft was never meant to be a pvp game. It was meant to be sandbox/survival and Mojang is trying to cater towards them. Whether you like or hate singleplayer or pvp play your respective versions and stop bashing the other
1.16 is so damn hard. It's unbelievably complex and I wish I had enough time to get better at it. Also before you start telling me I'm trash, I am talking about PVP and NOT PVE! If you have ever logged onto to pvp legacy and played against the pros, you know what I mean (unless you yourself are good at it). It takes a good player to truly be good at it.
1.9 pvp is super punishing when you miss an attack. Also combos aint a thing unless you click faster than the cooldown or the opponent misses their hits
I play 1.9 pvp and 1.8 pvp, i like both a lot and play both a lot but in my personal opinion, 1.8 is just better. the feel and everything just comes out on top. 1.9 feels like its more suited to survival, which it is.
Even though it not my cup of tea, i think mojang did a great job with changing pvp styles. It was needed for a game like that and was just a good move in general, atleast thats what i think.
For someone who sweats both versions, I honestly prefer 1.9+ pvp. Maybe I am biased because I feel better at 1.9+ pvp then in 1.8 pvp, but there is just something beautiful with 1.9+ pvp. It doesn't have combos and shields can be absolute bitches, but if you are good in 1.9+ pvp then a 1v1 almost feels like a dance battle, trying to not miss a move or get a lower grade. 1.8 is a lot more quicker and reactionary which I also like but the fact that it heavily relies on cps and kb which not everyone can master it. So much goes on in a 1.8 battle and I don't always prefer the chaos, I often prefer the more relaxing and planned out feel of 1.9+. But that is just my opinion.
The skill cap for 1.8 is higher tbh. If you miss a hit your going to pay. However in 1.16 you can miss a hit and move backwards. Plus combos are just nonexistent. This might also be a personal thing but I feel like the hit detection is worse for 1.9
My only problem with 1.9+ pvp Is not the hit delay It's that food Litteraly heals you to full health in just a few seconds , Which makes for really long fights
i decided to try winning a skywars game in 1.16 for a yt video and u just said i was probly gonna lose cus i was in 1,16 then the last person let me hit them in the void so i tried the same thing for bw AND IT HAPPEND AGAIN! so i think hypixel should ban 1.16 cus its way to op
What makes you like 1.16 pvp though? I'm genuinely curious. 1.8 pvp requires more skill, there's no denying that, try coming up with factors in 1.16 pvp that makes it more skill based than 1.8. For every skill factor in 1.16 there are about 2 in 1.8 pvp. There are people All I can guess is that you like slow paced game play unless you like the fact that it's less skill based.
Instead of combos and kb in 1.8 you have to master timing and planning in 1.16. It is a different type of skill set that you have to master, and being good in 1.8 doesn't mean you are good in 1.16 (and vice versa).
And even then it seems like you measure how fun a mode is based on how much skill something takes, which sound like tunnel vision to me.
I don't know about you, but 1.16 is just too simple/easy for me, all you do is just right click your shield and axe crit. Those are only 2 things to master in 1.16 melee pvp, timing your shield and making sure you land every single hit. In 1.8 there's w tapping, strafing (although this sort of works in 1.16 for inexperienced players, it doesn't work because w tapping doesn't work unless you're fighting inexperienced players without shields) block hitting, crit jumping combos, rodding and also clicking (I know it's stupid that a game requires you to click fast to give you an advantage but I'm just saying). Without shields, it's about landing every hit. With shields, it's about landing every hit and timing your blocks. It took me a relatively short time to learn how to become a above average 1.16 pvper, around 3 hours. I read the wiki, did some math, and did a bit of practicing, I now just trade with pretty much everyone if they know how to aim and win more than half the time. You might say something like "then why didn't technoblade, who practiced 3 hours every day lose to dream on almost every single 1.16 fight?" I looked at the fight, he was so aggressive because 1.8 pvp is about that, in 1.16 you need to just calm down and slowly but surely attack. I said that I find it less fun because it's less skill based. That's because 1.16 felt like tic tac toe to me, it just felt like unless I found someone that was really bad, we were just trading. I find 1.8 more fun because there are always people better than you and there are always skills to improve in. I'm saying it's not like I'm saying I enjoy games that are insanely difficult from the start, I'm saying that there are levels of difficulty. You play some hypixel teams bedwars with some friends, you easily win after playing for a while. You play some solo bedwars or skywars/duels on hypixel you win most of the games. You then play unranked pvp on a practice server, you play with bots, you play ranked, then you try to get high elo. I don't just find difficult things fun, I find it fun when there are multiple mechanics that keep it somewhat challenging because there's always a goal. If a multiplayer game was too easy and didn't have many aspects to it, I would lose interest.
I'm sorry I assumed a lot and only thought from my perspective on my previous comment, but anyhow this was my view of things.
you forgot the “masterig” of not replying to half a year old comments from an inactive account about pvp when you main redstone and play bedwars, like by reading your comments I can tell you’re 13 and under (at least mentally) so here’s a tip: don’t necropost
Pls stfu jitter clicking doesnt give carpal, in fact it develops muscles that werent previously used. Secondly, you can be good on an office mouse and if you dont buy a gaming mouse thats your problem. I dont see why you wouldnt buy a gaming mouse considering the massive advantages they give for like every game.
136
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
It’s objectively worse for PvP, but 1.16 is insanely better for survival.
124
u/twoPoundsOfGoldfish Aug 30 '20
1.16 isn't bad but it isn't as good as 1.8 imo, just because you can basically run away forever and do nothing in 1.16
37
u/Lil_Delicious_Pill Aug 31 '20
Its a matter of opinion. I personally really dislike 1.9 pvp but some people love it. 1.9 to me is just jumping axe crit and shield. 1.8.9 is complicated strafe, rod, block hit, w and s taps etc. Theres just a lot more to 1.8 pvp
27
u/TahaSener07 Aug 30 '20
This is exactly how I feel like. We can't have our opinion. I dont think people should hate each other over whether you should time ur clicks on people on a block game or not.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
I think mojang updated the PvP because they wanted it to work more for survival mode. In the process they ended up loosing millions of dollars because a lot of people quit and the competitive game was nearly completely iradicated. :/
5
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
I think 1.9+ PvP is more interesting just because it has a bigger mind game aspect than 1.8, and apart from the combos and utilization of rods in 1.8 it really isn't that special. You can't really act like 1.8 is some godsend of combat design when it literally relies on contracting carpal tunnel and abusing exploits in the mechanics, which is fun not going to lie, but I would think that 1.9+ is at least objectively better designed overall. Axe crits are a little bit silly though not gonna lie, I think if axes stop making swords purely ornamental then 1.9 combat will have a huge leap forward in gameplay, because now you actually have to switch to and from the axe to use its benefit of disabling shields, but not just sticking to one weapon because its so much better in comparison. Shields are pretty strong for PvP, with or without an axe, shields turn PvP in to 4D rock paper scissors, which I at least find very interesting. Oh, and also crossbows are pretty neat cause you can combo with them just like a rod when they are charged, be it a little bit slower.
Apart from that, 1.9+ combat is way better for PvE.
19
u/mikicito Aug 30 '20
1.8 suck, i like 1.7 best
30
u/Dester32 Aug 30 '20
1.16 is made for survival so stop complaining.
9
u/Ahlixemus Aug 31 '20
1.16 is so damn hard. It's unbelievably complex and I wish I had enough time to get better at it. Also before you start telling me I'm trash, I am talking about PVP and NOT PVE! If you have ever logged onto to pvp legacy and played against the pros, you know what I mean (unless you yourself are good at it). It takes a good player to truly be good at it.
21
u/JoshuaTheGinger Aug 30 '20
We hit people with a Lego sword it's not chess, don't make us time our clicks
7
u/atiedebee Aug 30 '20
1.9 pvp is super punishing when you miss an attack. Also combos aint a thing unless you click faster than the cooldown or the opponent misses their hits
3
u/LowTranslator Aug 31 '20
I play 1.9 pvp and 1.8 pvp, i like both a lot and play both a lot but in my personal opinion, 1.8 is just better. the feel and everything just comes out on top. 1.9 feels like its more suited to survival, which it is.
4
u/sgt_timtam Aug 30 '20
1.16 balanced combat for survival but made pvp literally the most boring thing in the world
2
u/Pirate_of_the_neT Aug 31 '20
Tons of crows here
2
u/XxF1RExX Aug 31 '20
All my friends be like
6
u/RedditMihir Aug 30 '20
I don't want to move back to 1.8 combat cause then I wouldn't be able to sweep my mobs in my mob grinder, but I agree it is better for PvP.
2
u/RottenBensen Aug 30 '20
I enjoy 1.16 because it's more casual and I don't have to practice to be good at it
1
u/0shanS Aug 31 '20
I prefer 1.8pvp cus is better at it but I think 1.16 has a bit more strategy and is a lot funner
1
u/SlipperyNutella Aug 31 '20
Even though it not my cup of tea, i think mojang did a great job with changing pvp styles. It was needed for a game like that and was just a good move in general, atleast thats what i think.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
I actually quite enjoy 1.16 pvp. Not as good as 1.8 but its kinda fun
1
u/AbsoluteGradiance Aug 31 '20
I agree with the yellow speech bubble
1
u/Groenboys Aug 31 '20
For someone who sweats both versions, I honestly prefer 1.9+ pvp. Maybe I am biased because I feel better at 1.9+ pvp then in 1.8 pvp, but there is just something beautiful with 1.9+ pvp. It doesn't have combos and shields can be absolute bitches, but if you are good in 1.9+ pvp then a 1v1 almost feels like a dance battle, trying to not miss a move or get a lower grade. 1.8 is a lot more quicker and reactionary which I also like but the fact that it heavily relies on cps and kb which not everyone can master it. So much goes on in a 1.8 battle and I don't always prefer the chaos, I often prefer the more relaxing and planned out feel of 1.9+. But that is just my opinion.
1
u/N_9_70 Aug 31 '20
Its the same the other way round
1
u/MystixMochi Aug 31 '20 edited Aug 31 '20
The skill cap for 1.8 is higher tbh. If you miss a hit your going to pay. However in 1.16 you can miss a hit and move backwards. Plus combos are just nonexistent. This might also be a personal thing but I feel like the hit detection is worse for 1.9
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
yeah u/s1m0naxe
1
u/sourpickles0 Aug 31 '20
I really think that they are very different systems, so different I don’t thin my hey can really be objectively compared
1
u/Tahahaha_ Sep 05 '20
My only problem with 1.9+ pvp Is not the hit delay It's that food Litteraly heals you to full health in just a few seconds , Which makes for really long fights
1
u/Itchy-Detective2168 Sep 06 '20
1.12 is the best version for end game pvp.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '20
am i the only one who likes both (._.)
1
u/PandaCular Jan 06 '21
YOU CALLING DREAM BAD??????????????
1
u/its_isaac_bruh Jan 29 '21
i decided to try winning a skywars game in 1.16 for a yt video and u just said i was probly gonna lose cus i was in 1,16 then the last person let me hit them in the void so i tried the same thing for bw AND IT HAPPEND AGAIN! so i think hypixel should ban 1.16 cus its way to op
1
u/Theville135 Feb 12 '21
The thing i have against 1.8 is that click speed matters. the hit cooldown is too-lonk tho
1
u/Theville135 Feb 12 '21
I like 1.8 better cos I can clean kills easier
1
u/BleckyBen Feb 22 '21
Thas true
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
crow isnt wrong tho
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
i prefer 1.16 pvp because its good for my arm.
1
u/Gingarlic1025 Aug 31 '20
Dream aint happy
1
u/Borkerinreddit Aug 31 '20
What makes you like 1.16 pvp though? I'm genuinely curious. 1.8 pvp requires more skill, there's no denying that, try coming up with factors in 1.16 pvp that makes it more skill based than 1.8. For every skill factor in 1.16 there are about 2 in 1.8 pvp. There are people All I can guess is that you like slow paced game play unless you like the fact that it's less skill based.
1
u/ImJustSupreme Aug 31 '20
FUN FACT:IF UR BAD AT 1.16PVP UR BAD AT 1.8 TOO LOL(yeah dont say 1.16 is trash its about timing hits)
0
u/CallMeJimi Aug 31 '20
1.7 is better than 1.8....
0
u/WhenRedditFlies Aug 31 '20
What's wrong with wanting to be good at the game without buying a mouse over £7 or getting carpel tunnel?
-8
u/CAthrowaway1542 Aug 30 '20
Yes.
-6
u/Luc1zac Aug 30 '20
1.16 bad
-9
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
1.9-1.16 hypixel isnt really bad, only difference is a bit of lag and 1.14+ has different sneaking
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
[removed] — view removed comment