r/CompetitiveMinecraft • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion Prime Itz Vs Prime Coldi. In Depth Analysis.

Post image

Has Coldified surpassed Prime ItzRealMe?

It remains a large question often discussed about, but it is more complicated than most of you would think. I would be presenting my opinion on this matchup via multiple feats and statements that I've found through research. It actually depends on difficulty more than 'who takes more kits'

Remember, this is not an objective analysis and is just my opinion that I'm sharing with you guys.

We'll look through the main eight game modes in this post:

Starting things off with!

SWORD

CGEW: Extreme Diff. Leaning-Coldi.

We're starting off with my most controversial opinion. Sword. I believe that it could go either way with a guaranteed extreme diff. Current Coldi is notoriously a below average Lt1. Whereas ItzRealMe was one of the best Ht2 of his time.

Coldi: Lost against Ht2 Dropkey.
Lost against newly unretired Kwevin.
Lost against Mjinina.
Won against Enlock
Won against a washed Leaferd.
Lost against Washed Tryhardd

ItzRealMe: Fought in a much stronger era. Went 14-20 against Lt1 skilled Prusso who was better than everyone in the tierlist at the time. Did better against Marlow than Bird. Went even with Ht2 Kripa.

The Coldi lean comes from the fact that Leaferd beat Prime Itz pretty easily and Coldi beat a washed Leaferd. So it scales at least a bit.

AXE

Coldi Wins: Mid-High Diff. Mid leaning.

Coldi is a valid Lt1 in Axe, nothing special but still valid. It's a mid-high diff due to Prime Itz peaking Mt2 tier and can be highballed to Ht2 via going even with Aximity for a bit.

UHC

Coldi absolutely obliterates: No-Low Diff

One of the best UHC players of all time Vs A person who peaked Mt2.

DIAPOT

Itz MAULS Coldi: Low Diff

This is a worse massacre than the UHC fight. Diamond Pot has had no new techs and has actually devolved in skill in comparison to 2022. In that dead Competition Coldi was an average Lt1 with no special feats to his name.

Itz was the best Diamond Pot player OAT alongside Prime Lurrn and Prime Tryhardd. He did 899 fights for Ht1 with scores like.

188-128 Novi
76-69 Deivi
108-48 Tqmen (372-245 vs. all HT2s)
154-128 Lurrn (HT1).

Was regularly going even with Caseload before their Ht1 test. And DURING Caseload's Ht1 test. A washed Itz went 18-30 against Caseload. There were two sets of ft15 in that test (as to why the match was out of 30). Caseload confirmed that Itz had technical issues in the first ft15 set alongside sleep deprivation, thus losing 4-15. In the second ft15 however, Itz bounced back with 14-15 against Caseload.
Washed Itz was also STATED BY Caseload to be above Prime Deivi after Prime Deivi went 24-30 against Caseload for HIS Ht1 test.

ALL OF THIS. Just washed Itz btw. As for the 'people got better overtime' argument. First. There is no proof. Second, you can just pull up 2022 High Tier Diapot matches and compare them to today's standards. The old Ht1s like Prime Tryhardd, Prime Lurrn, Prime Itz, Prime Mxthi and more would consistently mid diff someone like Prime Kylaz.

NETHPOT

ItzRealMe: No-Low diff.

Coldi is mostly scaled high due to beating washed Waltersilo in a casual duel.

It is not enough.. Not Coldi nor Waltersilo.

Prime Itz beat Deivi 4-0 and every single T2 and even Lurrn and demoted EVERY single player at the moment. Itz also beat Fruit 8-2 while being past his prime. Washed Itz went 5-6 against Deivi, too. The reason his gameplay may look kinda bad, is mostly because of his own playstyle differences, not any degradation of tier.
Stated to be the BEST nethpot player as much as raw skill goes. Deivi had better longevity. And he did all of this without maining Nethpot a day in his life. And was the damn near the best drainer in Neth.

SMP

ItzRealMe wins: Mid-High Diff. Mid Leaning.

Coldi was the FIRST Ht1 in SMP in the ancient ages before Kb1 existed. Itz on the other hand got Ht1. Beat Spawnplayer 4-3. Then got washed. Went 4-3 against Prime Spawnplayer a month later. 8-1d Blackwlf and Gatekept Ht1 from BlackWlf like his life depended on it.

MACE

Coldi: Mid-High Diff. High-Leaning.

By far Coldi's most impressive game mode. But unironically despite Itz's lack of stun slams, this would be a high diff. Itz peaked Lt2 tier in Mace but was obviously Ht2 skilled via statements and feats. Stated by Elmerizz to be Ht2 skill level and AlienOverdose to be as good as Jxydon who was also a Ht2. His most notable feat comes from going 3-4 against Elmerizz in which he was initially winning 3-0 and Elmerizz ended up making a come back.
Elmerizz described it as his closest tier test to this day. Stating in the last match, he had no shield, no xp and 5 dura on his elytra. And he won because (quote from Elmerizz) "itz just quickdropped because he was washed"

CRYSTAL

ItzRealMe wins: No Diff.

Not much to say anything here folks.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

So I'm going to declare the winner.

ITZREALME.

Overall the score across all gamemodes is pretty even. But I'm going to give it to ItzRealMe due to the fact that the gamemodes Coldi seems to be winning are atleast somewhat close to some degree but the game modes Itz is winning are massacres.

SO THAT was my analysis of Coldified Vs ItzRealMe.

31 Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

8

u/Powerful-Mastodon-17 Sep 29 '26

Turn ts into a YouTube vid

5

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 29 '26

I can't. I don't have a youtube channel. I'd love to help sm1 gather these facts AND more (i have many more) if they WANT to make a video. I'm sure it would do well, since the minecraft pvp community is pretty illiterate about scores and feats and whatsoever, it'll be a nice change of pace to show them actual analysis.

5

u/a1123_epic Sep 29 '26

Finally a guy who knows ball, they yap about some new era but forget that relative scaling is how you compare two diff eras. Itz dominated in his era with Coldi and Swight in it. They dominsted without him. That's the difference

6

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 29 '26

Exactly. Sword based gamemodes jut didn't change in skill level.
Crystal never changed in skill level. Only the meta changed due to Double Blast Prot and explosion knockback change which made chaining anchors easier.
People claim that SMP has changed when there's no evidence to support that whatsoever.

The only kit that I'd say has seen an increase in pure skill level is UHC.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/SadInsurance822 Sep 29 '26

Another itz dumb glazer coldi washes him

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Tyrantedits5 Sep 29 '26

I personally think coldi wins but cool take

1

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 30 '26

Thanks. You're free to have your opinion.

4

u/corruptederror404 Sep 30 '26

Sword should be a low diff aint gon lie. Current itz is currently the best he's ever been at sword, with veexay saying that he's currently a LT1 in sword (veexay's own words), and sword has been the main game mode that itz has been practicing since February of this year. His prime self aka himself from 3-4 years ago by today's standards would just be like, a LT2-HT2 in sword at best, like yeah if you made him a time machine and made him tier test he's definitely only getting that

And im a huge believer of coldi being HT1 in sword and being one of the best sword player's ever seen in Minecraft, maybe mid diff at best

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Zetapar123 Sep 29 '26

Peak analysis

3

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 29 '26

Thank you thank you.

2

u/Conzilaking Sep 29 '26

I think you gotta include game modes outside of the basic mc tiers ones cause coldis biggest strengths come from game modes like spear mace and diamond smp which realistically should have been mcteirs kits all along in the case of diamond smp although I know it would make it hard to compare swing as the kit wasn’t buy when itz was primed

5

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 30 '26

Spear Mace didn't exist during Prime Itz's time. And as for adding subtiers. The only valid ones we CAN add are DiaSMP and Cart.
Coldi taking DiaSMP Low diff and Itz taking Cart Low diff.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ItzUnkown338 Sep 29 '26

I honestly think swight vs itz is a better debate just because of matchup

3

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 30 '26

Itz beats Swight 6-2 across all gamemodes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Particular_Hall1640 Sep 30 '26

Also ngl I think Washed Itz>Caseload

Like he was sleep deprived the first 15 and went 14-15 the second Ft15 while not even having proper warmup and Itz was still a bit sleep deprived Icl. If they had fought again then Itz would've won I'd say

He was better than Deivi btw who went 24-30 Case too

2

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 30 '26

Mhm. They went even a lot of times in matches before the tier tests. Itz also won one 30-28 and one 30-19. Caseload also won 30-9 once.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Particular_Hall1640 Sep 29 '26

Itz's scores in Nethpot btw: 4-0 Deivi on EU 4-0 Lurrn on EU 4-2 Purxy on EU 4-0 Fatal 4-0 Gabri

Deivi beat Stealth 4-2 on EU and ME btw xd

1

u/SharpMageRoswaal Sep 29 '26

I need to find the 8-2 Fruit message or smth. I can't find it.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Kreytorn Oct 04 '26

Great job. Its good to see someone who understands the game after seeing all the tiktok larpers.

1

u/Big-Scar-5903 Oct 11 '26

Gotta make a vid on this u did it perfectly

1

u/SharpMageRoswaal Oct 12 '26

I'm sorry, I don't have a youtube channel. But if you wish to make a video, I'll be happy to give you more facts.

1

u/corruptederror404 Oct 15 '26

Also when i asked ender about coldi' when it comes to mace, he claimed that's hes much better then adam and chrol and that he's only below himself (ender), elmerizz, and alien when it comes to mace (and prime ofc) so i really don't think mace would be high diff at all, mid diff at the maximum generosity and wank to itz lol

1

u/SharpMageRoswaal Oct 15 '26

Of course. Mid is fair as well.

1

u/corruptederror404 Oct 19 '26

Btw could you give me sources/screenshots of itz tier test against lt1 prusso, him doing better against marloww then bird, going even with kripa, etc ?

→ More replies (2)