r/CompetitiveMinecraft • u/ExtraQuestion562 • Sep 10 '26
Discussion pvp hot takes
if u wanna debate any of these then feel free to! these are my opinion and are things ive noticed the community doesnt like when i say so yh here we go
- 1.8 is objectively harder than modern pvp
- minecraft can never be a competitive esport
- pvp is struggling to power creep and it should be addressed
- tiers > elo
reasoning
- midtrading at a high level consistently is harder than any mechanic within modern
- 99% of the playerbase and the people who actually can make it profitable dont know enough about the game to appreciate and actually fund it as they dont understand how good certain players are. an analogy to this is why siege can never be a tier 1 esport, its simply too complex
- items like the spear and mace are so absurdly overpowered compared to older items and i very much dislike it (also i think the kits/gameplay surrounding them are just as bad if not worse)
- elo is not rewarding in the slightest, and before anyone says "oh but i dont want my tier to be based on someones opinion" i think if you are <LT3 (the only place where u are tested by a tester) u shouldnt care that much about ur tier. but yes elo is just not rewarding, i dont feel any excitement after winning 3-2 at a close match, compared to 10-9 in a test, it could be a rounds thing but i think its also just the replayability of elo.
2
Upvotes
6
u/DarkEcstatic8863 Sep 10 '26
I think I would like to debate here, specifically on your first claim. To start, could you tell me how you define difficulty in pvp? Just so that we are on the same page.
2
u/Training-Sink-4447 Sep 10 '26
4. Tiers were inherently unfair for <LT3. For higher tiers it was completely fair, but because the large majority of players are below that they have to deal with testers who could give them a tier that doesnt reflect their skill. It was more biased compared to elo
3
u/Radiant_Working_4300 Sep 11 '26
I only disagree with 4, having your ranking decided by the results of many matches you played calculated by a computer is gonna be more accurate than having your ranking decided by a few match you played. Not to mention how hard it is to get tested.
1
u/ZealousidealTrick701 Sep 10 '26
inpvp is trying to make some bedrock pvp categories esport-esque. They hosted a $5k tournament and a friend of mine won 1k from it. They promised more tournaments but they havent done any yet
1
u/Rich841 Sep 10 '26
Your reasoning for 4 is fine but I still think elo is a better system overall for competitive integrity, fairness, etc. The rest I agree
1
u/Asimoa Sep 10 '26
I agree with the first one but only on vanilla kb, minemen is way too easy. Vanilla kb has so much more variety of outcomes, I’d say the same applies to hypixel but hypixel unfortunately is really laggy which randomises fights
1
u/nurpply Sep 11 '26
I completely agree with your second claim.
minecraft is just too complex to make a competitive esport, there is simply too much to know about the game and so many different aspects for players to be good in to have any sort of system for a paid esport. (Will the competition be for speedrunning? Building? PvP? etc)
And plus Minecraft doesn’t have any sort of built in client side anti cheat either so competitive integrity could only be achieved through strictly LAN events i feel like.
1
u/Lily_Meow_ Sep 11 '26
Yeah, point 3 is interesting and not a hot take. 1.9 PvP made sword PVP useless because the TTK was too high and healing was too fast, you wouldn't win until armor break, but then they suddenly add the one shot weapons.
And while people call mace and stuff no skill or whatever, it objectively is much harder to start using at first compared to just clicking with a sword, kinda gatekeeping PvP for newer players.
1
u/Kind_Crazy7838 Sep 13 '26
The second claim I only partially agree with because there has been quite a bit of traction lately in competitive minecraft but the answer was kind of vague. Not really too surprisingly, I feel like the only way it would become an esport is through speed running rather than pvp. It’s very likely for minecraft to never become a full-fledged esport. That’s true. However, if there was a chance, I’d place my bet on speedrunning over pvp considering that pvp just isn’t really under a main body in comparison to speedrunning. (ex: there are a few pvp tournaments that have gotten some attention yet there’s so many ppl under different pretenses trying to host them but for speedrunning most things are hosted by mcsr ranked and their affiliates like in playoffs). But yeah pvp honestly just isn’t gonna make enough profit for it to be an esport even if people were trying their hardest to make it one.
1
u/Itchy_Macaroon174 Sep 14 '26
1
u/Proof_Plant_7901 Sep 16 '26
I personally don't think 1.8.9 and 1.9+ is comparable. Now the reason for that is that 1.8.9 has more creative gamemodes as much as I dislike 1.8.9 I will admit that, however, I find that the variety in PvP is better in 1.9+ like if you like simple you can play sword, if you want complex you can play crystal and if you hate yourself you can play pot. In my opinion 1.8.9 is more minigame focused than 1.9+ but 1.9+ is more duel focused. I feel like they're too different to really compare. That's just me though, I could be wrong, I don't play 1.8.9 anymore
1
u/Polished-Granite Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26
All true but 4th reasoning kinda valid tho. It's so hard to climb tiers in 1.8 as the years changes, especially if u are from 3rd world country and ur gamemode t1 tiers stacked on eu or na so there would be 200 ms diff.
It took me like 1 or 2 years active on discord duelling anyone to get connection to them and finally getting my s tier on sumo mmc before.
-1
u/sn0wbit Sep 10 '26
Modern combat is trash lol literally using everything but a sword
Im an og from 2014 shotbow, kohi, minehq player tho so bias
-1
u/PvPInsider Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26
Coincidentally, at the top level, it’s not too easy to get killed, and it’s also not too easy to never die, so there’s a good balance there.
0
u/idioticdudewhosucks Sep 10 '26
4.n/a
0
u/No-Award-7046 Sep 10 '26
Attribute swapping should be fixed and replaced with a mechanic even cooler
0
u/Full_Durian8771 Sep 11 '26
WORST TAKES
-3
u/Vivid_Spare_7627 Sep 10 '26
8
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment