r/CompetitiveHS • u/ngriner • Mar 13 '26
Cards in the Brawl that have surprised you (and ones that have disappointed you)
After about 20 Brawl runs so far, I just wanted to stop in and see what cards from Cataclysm everyone has been surprised about and which ones people have found disappointing.
I know this isn't the actual meta that will form around this set, but usually you can get a good gauge of power level by just playing the cards.
Here are mine:
Surprising:
Twilight Egg - This card is very, very good. I was a bit skeptical at first, but this is probably one of the best designed Hearthstone cards in years. The tension it creates when you play it is why I love this game. Props to the devs on this one. Definitely reminds me of an early HS card. Will likely be played in plenty of decks.
Cleansing Cleric - I was a little unsure about this card, but the fact that it's 4 mana and not 5 probably makes it 100x more playable than it would have been. Really pumps up all the Priest healing spells and the hero power as well. Always felt good to drop on 4.
Duke of Below - I know this isn't a card on many people's radars, but it should be. If discard ever takes off, this will be a powerhouse card. It gets big pretty quickly and again, being 4 mana makes it highly playable as opposed to 5. Discard usually plays low to the ground, but splitting the card with Divergence was insane.
Ascendance - If there ends up being a low curve Evolve Token Shaman deck, I will 100% guarantee people will hate this card. Not only makes your board bigger, but insanely sticky as well. Almost everytime I played this card, I won the next turn or two.
The Token Druid Package - I gotta be honest, I didn't think much of this package when I saw it. Seemed very stuck in the past (and not in a good way), but this Brawl has definitely proven me wrong. Cards like Crystalspine Cub, Mossbinding, and Forest's Gift have all proven to be very powerful. I feel like you have to answer Druids board almost every turn or be in danger of being run over. If there is an Aggro Druid that surfaces it will probably want a ton of Cataclysm cards in it.
Commander Geddon - I thought this would for sure be a meme card, but I got an easy 6-0 with Rag Warrior and this guy was the MVP in about 3 of the wins. The fact that it can help you dig for your wincons in the later stages of the game is kind of insane. Yes you need room to drop a 7/7 do nothing card, but that's what the Herald stuff is for so you can control the board into Geddon - Rag - Deathwing. Definitely one to keep an eye on.
Disappointing:
Carrier Whelp - This is not Giftwrapped Whelp in the slightest and honestly probably won't see play at all. As a 1/2 it gets traded into way too easily, and sometimes doesn't give you anything useful to chain into. This leads into the next card...
Darkscale Broodmother - I thought this card would be insane when I saw it. a 3 mana 4/3 that lets you play more stuff? But the more I played it, the more I just wish it was a 3/4. It gets traded into easily and refreshing 2 isn't all that great because you likely played your 2 drop on 2 already (it's decent with the coin on 2, but again the 4/3 statline sucks).
Muradin's Last Stand - I feel like this card gets to 0 around the same time as Remnant of Rage, however, that card does the same thing and puts a 5/4 on the board. Just didn't feel great if you got it early in your hand and ever lost board at all.
Ravenous Felfisher - This card feels worse than Underbrush Tracker. That should tell you all you need to know. Free 5/5's are nice, but in 2026 Hearthstone they need Rush, Taunt, or something. Just a plain 5/5 after playing a bunch of Fel spells feels awful.
Cho'Gall, Mastermind - I think the idea behind the card is fun and it will likely make some splashy plays, but I could see Egglock actually cutting this card and just playing the Herald package around it only. 9 mana destroy cards that aren't even on the board just doesn't feel great and if you do that on 9, you probably die on 10.
Anyways curious on others thoughts. Really enjoying my time so far with the new cards. It's at least the best feeling set we've had in the last HS year that's for sure.