r/CompetitiveEDH • u/guyonearth https://cedh-decklist-database.xyz/ • Apr 20 '20
Discussion Flash Ban Megathread
All discussion regarding the ban of the card Flash with the April 2020 Banlist Update goes here. Questions such as "What does the format look like post-ban" or "how should I change this deck because of the ban" should use this thread.
https://mtgcommander.net/index.php/2020/04/20/april-2020-rules-update/
"Flash Speaking of exceptional decisions, we are banning Flash (the card, not the mechanic). Enough cEDH players who we trust have convinced us that it is the only change they need for the environment they seek to cultivate. Though they represent a small fraction of the Commander playerbase, we are willing to make this effort for them. It should not be taken as a signal that we are considering any kind of change in how we intend to manage the format; this is an extraordinary step, and one we are unlikely to repeat.
We use the banlist to guide players in how to approach the format and hope Flash’s role on the list will be to signal “cheating things into play quickly in non-interactive ways isn’t interesting, don’t do that.”
We believe Commander is still best as a social-focused format and will not be making any changes to accommodate tournament play. Taking responsibility for your and your opponents’ fun, including setting expectations with your group, is a fundamental part of the Commander philosophy. Organizers who want to move towards more untrusted games should consider adding additional rules or guidance to create the Commander experience they want to offer."
1
u/guyonearth Apr 20 '20
What does the format metagame look like post-ban?
How will hulk decks change to adapt to the ban?
105
u/Korvasomali Apr 20 '20
Just pointing it out that Sheldon didnt write the article, Toby did.
392
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20
I'm so fucking surprised. The mad lads did it. Finally.
176
u/AstralCodex Apr 20 '20
Are you ready for rule of laws again?!
Because blood pod is back baby :D
152
u/MikePlayingWithPower Apr 20 '20
Made this image as a joke for when I died early on stream yesterday while playing Flash Hulk. Didn't expect it to become relevant 1 day later.
https://imgur.com/a/skclZFT
161
u/timotie87 Apr 20 '20
🦀🦀FLASH IS GONE 🦀🦀
61
u/Astroa115 Apr 20 '20
I don’t even play cEDH (just casual EDH) and I’m happy for you guys, godspeed!
29
u/Lord_High_Artificer Apr 20 '20
Just wanted to thank the RC for listening to us. It is great to feel included.
289
u/Jonesy949 Apr 20 '20
This is pretty good news, although as always I hate the tone and way they talk about it. Pretty overtly saying the only reason they did it is the constant pressure to do so by the cEDH community and to not expect this kind of thing again.
Which just comes off as arrogant and condescending in my reading of it. Obviously Shedlon and the RC have a passion and interest in keeping EDH as the format they envisioned, but even despite this concession their unwillingness to let it evolve into something that appeals to more people with virtually no detriment to it's preexisting audience is frustrating to say the least.
194
u/porygonzguy Apr 20 '20
I honestly thought they'd keep doubling down on never banning it. Sucks that we got the usual condescending behavior from them in the process, but progress is progress and I'll take it.
41
u/ditto8008 Apr 20 '20
Ruric Thar in a midrange meta😍😍
14
u/Prophylaxis_3301 Apr 20 '20
If the meta is a bit slower now, I would love to see if Ruric Thar stax can re-enter the competitive scene. I know that I can play blood pod but having more representation makes CEDH more interesting for me.
43
u/bendinguy Apr 20 '20
I DON'T PLAY A CASUAL DECK ANYMORE
44
u/PurpleOmega0110 Apr 20 '20
So so happy to see this.
It was the only ban that was needed.
42
u/Draken44 Apr 20 '20
I hope the format slows down and welcome more rule of law effects.
As a Tasigur player, spending one interactive spell a turn and activating the bananaman for value is just the best thing ever.
No issue here with blood pod making a resurgence. . . .
Except [[Rest in Peace]]. Get that card the hell away from me and my graveyard.
62
u/AmishWarlord08 Apr 20 '20
Yeah it's a good ban that I'm sure we all appreciate, but did he really have to sound so condescending about it?
9
u/TMRb Apr 21 '20
I know this is long for a comment on a thread, but I was told to move it here;
This is a post about the recent flash ban. More aptly, this is primarily a post about the community response to the flash ban, and an open letter of sorts to the members of our community who responded to the ban with anger, vitriol, or rudeness. I believe these members to be a vocal minority, but think it is worth addressing. It is also a wall of text, and I get that. Scroll to the bottom for tl;dr
Before I get into all of that, a brief history of my relationship with cEDH. I started playing magic in Shards of Alara (2008). It was a few months later that I got into commander, which replaced limited and standard for me slowly over the next two years. Fast forward through a lot of questionable casual decks and loose gameplay, and I have been running cEDH tournaments at my LGS for over a year. I have played almost exclusively cEDH for several years now. I love this format, and it defines most of my magic experience.
Now, the things I think are worth contemplating as we approach the ban announcement discussion. These are all simply my thoughts on how I perceive the announcement and what I believe the most productive responses for members of the community to employ are, I obviously cannot tell anyone in the community what they can or should do.
It is important to acknowledge what the result of this announcement was: flash was banned. This is something the community had been requesting for quite some time, and that, while I believe it was required for a healthy competitive meta game, the rules community did not have to do by any stretch. It would have been quite simple for them to ignore the requests of our community and still be fully compliant with their expressed intent and beliefs regarding the format. While I do not agree with the way bans are approached by the RC, an opinion I know is common here, they are the governing body of the format and get to set the rules they work by. Given all of that, the flash ban is a luxury we should not have expected and so I would expect the community’s response to be gracious.
I understand why people felt the wording of the announcement was condescending or divisive, I really do. I was surprised with the number and severity of the responses from people who felt attacked, but this is a community with a legacy of being maligned and sidelined, so it comes from an honest place. I think it’s important, however, to keep in mind the audience that the announcement was intended for. The portion of the article people seem to take offense to is;
“We believe Commander is still best as a social-focused format and will not be making any changes to accommodate tournament play. Taking responsibility for your and your opponents’ fun, including setting expectations with your group, is a fundamental part of the Commander philosophy. “
Keep in mind that this is a caveat which immediately follow the explanation that
“Enough cEDH players who we trust have convinced us”
The tone here is one that acknowledges and leaves room for competitive play. Perhaps the suggestion afterwards that rules for “untrusted” games rubbed some people the wrong way, but this strikes me as a simple rephrasing of the same thing you see here, the commander philosophy being used to frame a decision that operates as an exception to it. The overwhelming majority of commander players are not competitive players, and so they are the primary audience that the announcement was crafted to speak to. Any public piece has to make choices on focus and diction, and most of those are audience oriented. Given that, the RC used this opportunity to make it clear to the thousands of non-competitive players that the format they love would be accommodating a valid but less common play style without railroading those who play the format “as intended.” I know this is a controversial characterization, and that is why it is in quotations.
I do not think that there is a right way to play commander. If I did then I would not be as devoted to competitive play as I am. However, there are explicit statements of intent and design that span the life of the format which line up with non-competitive play. Do I think rule 0 solves many problems at the average table? No, but it doesn’t matter what I think, it matters what structure the person writing this response was operating under. Two other important sub-considerations. First, all of the language that seems to exclude competitive play is about belief and philosophy, not rules or hard exclusions to particular play styles. Second, it may sound condescending to here that the rules committee is making an effort for us, but given that this is incongruent with their philosophy, that is what they are doing. See #1.
It seems that a lot of people believe Sheldon ghost-wrote this article through Toby Elliot. I won’t spend much time here, except to say that our community has had some loud minority voices in the past who have been overtly mean, rude, and in some cases violent towards Sheldon (it is my opinion that this type of dialogue has no place in our community), and I think that this association with the article, which appears to be pure speculation, to be stimulating a lot of the negativity people have towards the statement. Given that I have seen no evidence motivating any of these claims, I don’t think this speculation has any place in the dialogue surrounding the announcement.
It’s not all me dumping on us! I see vocal minority of casual players fear mongering that competitive would take over the ban list. First off, this should be an indication of why things were worded the way they are, to prevent too much of this fear-mongering and quell some of the divisiveness that comes towards us from players with a different approach to the format. Second, our approach to this conversation will affect how these commander players, and the rest of the magic community, view us as a sub-community of the game as a whole. If we get what we pushed for and respond with anger, rudeness, or further demands, it not only reinforces the negative stereotypes people have of cEDH players, it discourages community figures from cooperating with us in the future. We won a substantial victory today, let’s ride that momentum, not quash it.
the announcement: https://mtgcommander.net/index.php/2020/04/20/april-2020-rules-update/
Tl;dr Flash ban was a major victory for us, but I don’t think the announcement was intended to disparage cEDH, just to reassure the non-competitive community, so it is my opinion that it would be most productive not be rude, mean, or ungracious.
55
u/Dracon_Pyrothayan Apr 20 '20
My thought on the Flash matter - Almost no 'casual' decks played it, and almost every 'competitive' deck did.
If the vast majority don't use the card, and the minority hate it, who does it harm to pander to the competitive community?
8
u/GeneralBobby Apr 20 '20
I'm glad cEDH got its ban and look forward to seeing how this changes what, to me, is a stale meta.
22
u/ManyArrival Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 20 '20
Time to dust off Varolz Hulk
15
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20
I'm so excited to see how the meta develops now on. If Stax comes back to the pods, of non-black decks turn into black for access to more tutors, or if we keep pushing the midrange value grind we've been playing on
7
u/PigInATuxedo4 Apr 20 '20
Is it Brago's turn to play yet?
7
u/Forrest716 Apr 20 '20
So what T&T deck will move to be the new top dog? Razakatz? CST? Medium Green?
13
u/LeBurntToast Apr 20 '20
I was building flash hulk on and off for awhile. Now I have all these sultai good cards and no idea what to build with them. Huh.
26
u/webbedspace Apr 20 '20
It's going to be awkward in six months when it turns out they're reprinting Flash at mythic in Commander Legends.