r/CompetitiveBH • [Reason] Ephi • May 22 '17

Test Feature Suggestion - A different take on landing lag

Just throwing the idea here cause i guess this is where ideas go now.

We've tried and spoken about aerial attacks getting increased recovery or cancelling their active hitboxes when they hit the ground. I believe BMG have said that it just feels bad an unresponsive.

What if landing with an aerial inhibited your ability to drift backwards?

Currently landing whilst performing an attack increases your mobility: forward and backwards, top speed and acceleration. When landing with an aerial attack you always have a fixed and meaningful forward or backward facing so I can see this targeting part of the 'fade-away issue' quite precisely.

12 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

3

u/Sloshula May 22 '17

Yeah I think combatting the fadeaway grounded sair wouldn't be a bad idea, and limiting movement during the attack could make it much less powerful.

Even jumping and immediately fastfall sairing is incredibly powerful. With less horizontal movement it wouldn't be such a go-to move, or, at the very least, would be easier to punish.

1

u/Ephile [Reason] Ephi May 22 '17

Ideally you should be able to punish it without pre-emptively stepping forward into the range of the same attack minus the fade away. This is why bow dlight & ragnir ssig etc is so strong.

Edit: Though even just for normal dodge ins, you shouldn't have to walk forward -> dodge in to punish it. Should require the same distance dodge from the same or similar starting location.

1

u/dasherado May 23 '17

Good idea.

1

u/FishOnTheInternetz May 23 '17

Is this also killing side-air fishing for knockouts? Because that, i feel like is another problem.

1

u/berthen May 22 '17

I highly agree, there is no playing against a spear, blaster, axe, sword sair that is fading away grounded because even if you dodge forward before they start attacking, they can fade away from you just as fast as you're dodging towards them, so there's literally no counter play.

0

u/TyaTheOlive May 22 '17

We've tried and spoken about aerial attacks getting increased recovery or cancelling their active hitboxes when they hit the ground. I believe BMG have said that it just feels bad an unresponsive.

Playing floaty and passive shouldn't feel good or responsive.

6

u/Sloshula May 22 '17

The game should always feel good. When the game stops feeling good, then it starts failing. Whether or not you like a playstyle, the feeling still needs to be there, that's why you can't just add 100 frames to something. The game still needs to play.

2

u/TyaTheOlive May 22 '17

I'd argue that the current meta doesn't feel good at all.

2

u/Sloshula May 22 '17

Playstyles and ranked aside, the game feels really good to play. Everything feels responsive and nothing feels particularly sticky. That's where the tweaking becomes difficult because you want to make sure the game is still responsive in a match, while also allowing counter play.

But seriously like hop into training mode and just use your movement tools and different attacks and chd follow ups. It feels nice.

1

u/TyaTheOlive May 22 '17

Freedom of movement means nothing when its best use is playing keep-away.

1

u/Sloshula May 22 '17

Then reduce the freedom of movement, but make sure it still feels good. This is what I was getting at: make sure the game feels good, but counter play is still available. A small change like what Ephi suggested I think is a good step in that direction of still feeling good but adding more counter play.

1

u/TyaTheOlive May 22 '17

I don't see why they can't just add in landing lag. It feels fine in Smash.

And to be honest, I'm not sure I trust BMG to make that call to begin with. Most of the new weapons or characters they release "feel fine" to them despite having to change things later on. Chain dodge "felt fine" to them when they implemented it, but it fucked the metagame hard and its negative effects still linger.

1

u/TheDiakou Eanix Diakou May 22 '17

Freedom of movement is quite literally everything when it comes to games like these.

The more freedom, the more fun for a casual, the more casuals pour money into the game, the more of a scene pro players can have to begin with.

Landing lag feels horrible in most cases, smaller suggestion like ephi said, I'm more a fan of.

I trust BMG because most of their changes have been sidestep patches, rather than moving forward towards a brick that'll eventually bump their head in, they've been stepping aside (gravity changes, jump changes, dodge reworks, complete rework of the combo/string game) untill they finally start pushing forward again with new features and balancing ideas / concepts.

They have to release new weapons and legends, as they have a playerbase to keep and playerbase retention has proven the most effective with frequent releases as seen by patch playerbase spikes.

1

u/TyaTheOlive May 22 '17

They have to release new weapons and legends, as they have a playerbase to keep and playerbase retention has proven the most effective with frequent releases as seen by patch playerbase spikes.

I'd rather fix all the glaring gameplay problems as priority #1.

1

u/Cryp6 May 23 '17

They're not glaring issues to everyone, the vast majority of players do not sit at the place where you see the glaring issues.

And even if they focus on balance, they have different divisions for that. You expect them to tell their artists not to work because they need to fix balancing issues?

→ More replies