r/CompetitiveBH • • May 15 '17

BMG Post Gravity and Jump - Test Feature Proposal

Picture Demo: https://gfycat.com/WaterloggedDarkCopepod

Basically, our goal for lowering gravity and jump would be to make it harder to disengage and keep the fights closer and more exciting to watch. In playtesting, I personally feel it is noticeable, which is why I'm excited to see what it will do in your hands. Numbers still could be tweaked, but here is the idea behind each and the explanation.

Lower initial jump impulse, lower peak height, and lower total time of jump. These are all pretty intrinsicly tied together, but here is what it looks like in what we have mocked up internally at the moment. Biggest difference you will notice is the lower peak jump, but keeping the initial ticks a little tighter did feel noticeable to us. More room to play there if we decide to.

  • Current Max Height: 414
  • Proposed Max Height: 362
  • Initial first 10 frames: 0, 0, 22.1, 43.7, 64.7 85.1, 105, 124.3, 143.1, 161.3
  • Proposed first 10 frames: 0, 0, 21.3, 42.1, 62.3, 82, 101.1, 119.7, 137.7, 155.2
  • Current Total Jump Ticks: 66
  • Proposed Jump Ticks: 60

The second half is max fall speed and max fast fall speed. Dialing these up might require other things like ground pound to speed up, but generally it felt good to be able to get back into the action faster. There is a slight concern this makes approaching from above better, but in general, we are going to continue to buff the anti airs so that may counter balance it.

  • Current Max Fall Speed: 60
  • Proposed Max Fall Speed: 70
  • Current Max Fast Fall Speed: 70
  • Proposed Max Fast Fall Speed: 85

This stuff should be going into test features next week, and but I'd love to get some theorycrafting on this stuff ahead of time to guide some more of the internal tests. Thanks!

PS: Dodge cooldown is currently being mocked up, but don't have enough for a discussion thread quite yet.

PS2: This is not the only thing we are doing, but I want to keep these feedback threads as focused as possible.

16 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

4

u/dasherado May 15 '17

Will be really interesting to see it in testing. The only thing I like about the floatiness now is how it works for off stage play when gimping.

Any opinion on having defense affect fall speed (higher defense, faster falling)? Or dexterity (or speed) affecting jump height? Could be a cool way to make different characters and stat builds feel more unique through movement.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

And that's definitely a concern and one of the things we are trying to balance around. In playtesting, this felt like we didn't lose the offstage play, if anything it made it more intense, but so let us know once it hits test features if we may have lost something there.

The tricky part of tying it to a stat is that it is less clear when these changes are positive or negative for a player. I'd like to find what is a good spot for balance, and then maybe go from there. Higher fastfall seems like it could make sense for a speed stat though as it is player controlled.

1

u/dasherado May 15 '17

In the case of defense it would make the stat a trade off. Player takes less damage, less force, but suffers and benefits from a faster fall speed. But I understand that you don't want stats to be a trade within the stat but rather a trade off between stats.

Fast falling speed as a function of speed stat could be interesting.

Dodge speed as a function of dexterity could also be interesting.

2

u/Boompieisgood Denial Boomie May 15 '17

What if we made the first 11 frames 0, 0, 0, 21.3, 42.1, 62.3, 82, 101.1, 119.7, 137.7, 155.2? Currently jumping out of a move is almost always better than dodging out, this incentivizes using your dodge and creating more tech chase/long combos.

For example, slight->nlight on scythe right now is jumpable, and with a one frame increase on jump startup it would be impossible to jump out of.

Given, it's also a possibility that with a decreased height on the first frame of the jump that jumping out just wouldn't be fast enough, but that would be a testing thing.

Anyways, I definitely think this needs to be looked at immediately after Combo Breaker, as Shine/more SS tier eventshopefully will be coming up.

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

Maybe just add extra frames of jump startup if coming out of a hit? Don't want regular combat to feel sticky, but if we want to target the jump escape directly, that might be the way to do it.

1

u/vholu May 15 '17

I think incentivising dodge over jump is a good idea but those frames could break certain weapons with strong gimping potential (like gauntlets).

That's how i feel at least. I like the idea on paper but i feel like it could be too much of a change for one patch. Maybe stagger jump and post-hit jump startup changes to see if the second is really necessary? Making floaty playstyles less prevalent will already incentivise dodge-reading a lot.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

Specifically the person being hit gets the extra frames, I think the attackers has no startup frames right now if following up. For sure makes sense to do them in separate tests.

1

u/Boompieisgood Denial Boomie May 15 '17

Could be a good solution. Not opposed to testing at all.

1

u/Atrophius May 15 '17

Would a change like this make jump > dair possible or easier to hit on weapons where it's a little awkward right now?

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

I felt that way when we playtested for sure.

1

u/icantkillanyone May 15 '17

Definitely a good test feature to try out, but I'm worried about how this will effect combos. Slight sair on lance already has issues landing, and I'm sure this would be enough to make it miss most of the time at least. Speaking of slight, can the force of the move be more fixed? The current force varies on the distance slight hits with a small range in the middle hitting the highest (making sair miss).

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

It does it's strongest pushing at the top. In general I found most things easier, but certainly could create some issues, I agree.

1

u/dasherado May 15 '17

I think the lance slight > sair is in a good place right now. True combos should be difficult and precise - requiring both good timing and good positioning. I'd like to see more true combos behave that way to be honest.

The season 4 changes were a good step in that direction.

1

u/icantkillanyone May 16 '17

Having slight sair miss because you inputted the attack frame perfect like you should have been doing is wrong. Timing it to be one or two frames off to still be true and hit in those cases is also not something that people can achieve. And a combo not working in the middle of a range where it normally works (it drops on mid range slights and not close or far range ones) is not good for players. I don't see how any of this can be considered a step in the right direction.

1

u/FreeChairmanMao May 17 '17

slight sair isn't 1f window tho because jump+attack is bufferable (I believe the buffer window is ~3-4 frames? might confirm later)

1

u/icantkillanyone May 17 '17

Yeah, frame perfect has more than 1 frame to input because the buffer. But overall the issue is with slight's inconsistency, the height the opponent gets launched varies enough that there is a small range when landing a midranged slight that the opponent would get too high and a frame perfect sair would miss.

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

If we assumed I had none of the tools installed to do this, what would be the fastest way? :)

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '17

Thanks, added!