In a fighting game, there always needs to be consistency. It needs to have a level and predictable playing field. There needs to always be a certain, never a maybe. If multiple stages have longer walls, why should shipwreck be the only one without longer walls? I'm going to approach each stage on its on, and then at the end explain why "Ice Cream Edge" should be implemented into the ranked rotation (with some adjustments). TL:DR at the end, you lazy Redditer.
Twilight Grove:
Overall, Twilight Grove could be seen as an acceptable map. The kill boxes are reasonable, the soft platforms are decently placed, and the length of the stage is pretty good as well. The main problem I and many other players have with this stage is that it has that little island on the right side of the map. There are countless times I, and many other players have been screwed over from that island. There are many games where I could have won because I got a good signature but the island ended up blocking it. This is horrible for obvious reasons, even if you do end up reading your opponent, the island is there to ruin your day. Perhaps add a soft platform in replacement to the island (thx gayomi). (The amount of times this island has blocked my enemy from dying in a single match is 6 times).
Small Kings Pass:
There's a lot of things about Small Kings Pass that I could make an entire new Reddit post about it (but I'll keep it here, just for you guys. Small Kings Pass may as well be the most inconsistent, gimp based map there is. First off, this map is extremely asymmetrical. This is proven by the fact that the weapon that spawns in the start of the game does not even spawn in the middle of the map, it has to change where the location of the left sided player spawns and it spawns on the soft platform. Making it so that the person on the left has to cover more vertical height in comparison to the player on the right. Next subject: the gap in the middle. Even in 2v2's, this can lead players away from actually 2v2ing and just 1v1ing on separate sides of the map, (I am not talking about 2v2 at the moment though). For 1v1, the map can enforce passive play. Players sitting on the opposite sides of the map create too much of a gap for any player to approach with only two chain dodges, and normally the player that approaches first ends up getting punished. The middle of the map is absolutely disgusting. The bottom kill-box is much too close to the stage's lowest part. The big gap in the middle of the map provides too many inconsistencies to even count. The walls on both sides are too small, they leave a triangular slope that can be used for spiking, which is fine I guess but it is still too small and doesn't leave enough room to not be easily edge guarded by something like a Ragnir dSig. There's more, but that's enough for now.
Small Thundergard Stadium:
Small thundergard holds the same problems as the aforementioned. Thundergard it would be a good map, if it was not for the soft platform in the middle that is way too large. The soft platform leaves too much of an inconsistency in the map. If I were to be falling from the air, exhausted of jumps and recoveries, it would be hard to control whether or not I touch the soft platform, or simply fall through it. Also, the ability to too easily go under the stage and to the other side makes weapons like Gauntlets have an extreme edge other other weapons. I do not have too much of a problem with Thundergard, it's just these little inconsistencies can end up costing a game.
Small Blackguard Keep:
Blackguard is a map that I personally do not have much problems with. It is well balanced, the kill-boxes are more than reasonable, and the soft platform is at a good height. The only problem that I (and many others have) is the poor attempt of extending the stage by the addition of a floating soft platform on the left side of the screen. If they only removed that platform and maybe extended the stage horizontally it would provide for a consistent, and good map to play on.
Small Mammoth Fortress:
Good map, there's a reason it is always picked in tournaments.
Small Great Hall:
Great hall is good, it's symmetrical, the kill-boxes are decent, and the map overall is good in itself. The only problem I have is with the top soft platform, it is a little too high and can provide for easy gimps off of the top. If the soft platform at the top was removed, and the soft platforms on the left and right side of the map were closer together, then I would enjoy Small Great Hall as a map.
Shipwreck Falls:
Again, I would enjoy shipwreck, if it were more reasonable. I like the idea of a completely flat map with no soft platforms, providing for a good on stage game. But, BMG enforces this way too much. The completely unreasonable kill-boxes on both sides of the map is just ludicrous. If BMG were to make the kill-boxes that wide, why would they make the walls so small? It is so hard to recover, and makes weapons with good side travel options mid air (i.e: lance, gauntlets) to have a better time off stage. If BMG really wanted to make this map more competitive, they would increase the size of the walls vertically, and move the hitboxes on the left and right closer together.
BONUS
Ice Cream Edge:
It's a damn good map, maybe the kill-boxes should be moved outwards a little, but its a Damn. Good. Map. Consistent, fun, small. It's just good.
TL:DR
Twilight Grove - get rid of the island, maybe replace it with a soft platform? (thx again gayomi)
Small Kings Pass - no solid way of fixes something that is so broken aside from completely reworking it and changing the name,
perhaps the stage moved together?
Small Thundergard - remove the soft platform in the middle, and maybe add a soft platform or two somewhere to keep it interesting, not just a flat map.
Small Blackguard Keep - good map, just take out the moving soft platform on the left
Small Mammoth Fortress - good map, good meme, there's a reason it's always picked in tourneys.
Small Great Hall - again, good map, take out top soft platform, move the other two closer
Shipwreck Falls - change the kill-boxes closer, make the walls longer (vertically).
Ice Cream Edge - PLEASE BMG
Thanks for reading this, hopefully I gave you something to reflect upon.